Jimmy's Neighborhood Restaurant in Tarpon Springs - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Absolutely great food, service and atmosphere. Mena was amazing. Will return many times over. The chicken Parm with angel hair to die for. Sauce taste like home.

The best cheesecake I have had outside of New York City. The best turkey cheese sandwich I have ever had.

Food is good, love that it's a neighborhood place. Phone lines get a little busy sometimes is all

I seen some reviews of this place that looked promising, so I gave it a shot today. First thing I noticed when I sat down was the amount of fly's, my server came over and I asked for a water with lemon, she brought it out and went on her way, I took one sip and it tasted like sewage water. I tried to get her attention but she was busy gabbing with some friends. When she came back over I asked her to please get me a seltzer water with lemon as this water tasted horrible. She then told me she knows, there have been a lot of complaints about it, that should have been my sign to bolt but I already put my food order in. So, you know the water is tainted and gross, yet u still served it to me? Seltzer comes and u can still taste it as it all come out of that same soda handle. Anyway the food arrives and I only went there to try the Grilled Octopus, it is my favorite Greek Food. Long story short, it was chewy like rubber and a big disappointment! Been down in FL since 1993 and I have eaten at Hellas in Tarpon for as many years as I have been here, and never disappointing. I always like to try different eateries but this one will be avoided at all cost.

Picked up dinner on the way home and was blown away with the taste of the food! Great portion sizes a well!

We have been here multiple times and never disappointed. The food is awesome and staff is so friendly. If you love clam chowder, they have the best.

I can't say enough good things about this place! Freshest seafood in town.

Great Waitress, Good and Fresh Food, Tasty, Affordable

The food was absolutely awesome at a very reasonable price. The service was impeccable and the atmosphere was very nice..

We went on a Saturday evening, around 5:30p. Didn't have to wait for a table. It's cozy. Small neighborhood gem. Had a nice Greek salad and spinach pizza. Really good. We'll go back.

Gyro was delicious and the fries were crispy crunchy.

Food was delicious and service was excellent. A great local spot in Tarpon Springs....

Food was excellent, sercice was exemplary. I had the stuffed grouper, one of the best fish dishes I have had.

Our favorite place to eat. Lasagna is so good. Everything we have had here is yummy

We have had so many great meals here, but I love their pizza the most! Great staff too!!

Jimmy’s is may favorite local restaurant. Great food and service.

Feels like home, but with better food and better service.

Server was great, very friendly. I did not care for their red sauce. Shrimp Alfredo very good. If we go there again, I'll be happy to try something else.

I have had a lot of pizzas from here, can it get any better, seem like it, loved tonight's pie. Thank you so much

The food is average good for a local restaurant, and the portions are smaller than a typical restaurant. We are locals so we know the tricks most of the restaurants in the area use for tourists! We ordered calamari, mussels, shrimps, smells and a side of lemon potatoes. This was my 5th order since we moved in the area. I was surprised that after ordering all this for to go, they didn’t put even a slice of bread! Last time when I ordered, I think they put some pickled peppers! When we ordered from anywhere else they put a side of rice or anything from the house. Moreover, if we go to any restaurant around, that is a good place, as an entry they give you bread and olive oil, at least! And I am fit, but I still need my food! I needed my 2 slices of bread, at the end of the day! 😄Nevertheless, we ordered because I was tired of cooking tonight, so I was expecting some good food and some bread or anything that I don’t have to worry about doing it! And I cook better than most of the restaurants here, of course, although I am not a chef! I love food! Thats it! What I wanted to say, please be more conscious about your business and how you treat the locals! 2 slices of bread is 0.25cents, which will brighten their day/night! Don’t be cheap! Be wise! This is my 25cents.☝️

The service was good. The food was yummy 😋. We had the margherita pizza. We saw a ton of to go orders so I'm sure the other food is good too. The restaurant was full of customers. I would recommend

Jimmy's is one of those local secrets that's hiding in plain sight

Best spot in town. We love this place!

Excellent food & friendly service.

Fish & Chips suckedddddd! $40dollllassss for trashhhhhh no seasoning just grease!

Great food and very reasonable prices. Neighborhood atmosphere and awesome service. I highly recommend a visit. This is were the locals hang out.

Great pizza! Very cute place. Crowded but it didn’t take too long to seat us and it was a Friday night.

Highly enjoyed my visit to Jimmy's. The waitstaff was pleasant and helpful. The food was plentiful and very tasty. Convenient location with plenty of parking. I highly recommend this restaurant.

Great place , great food with friendly staff. Dog friendly as well . VERY RECOMMENDED

We were so pumped to go here! Brought our dogs and thankfully it was easy breezy! The food wasn't great, likely my Cuban was in the fridge from the day before. I appreciate food prep but at least make it hot. Thanks for the (zero) effort.

My first time there everything was nice service was good everything was pleasant food taste good I will definitely be back

We ate here last night at the request of our now 6 year old for his birthday. So happy to have found a local pizza place that offers such a variety of choices. The octopus was phenomenal, the shrimp scampi and sautéed vegetables were excellent. Our waitress Angie was the best! Our family will certainly be back. Wish I would have thought to take more photos.

We have a large wheelchair. We love the food we have had a variety of meals. We all loved the creek salad. Everything is made in house. Our car has a ramp it is usually easy to find a spot th let him out. The staff is very nice. We usually take things home.

Good food, for sure. Small, so had to sit outside, then it got very busy, so the service dropped off, but the lady serving us tried hard!

Everything on the menu is fresh and homemade. You can't go wrong with any of the menu choices. I ordered the Mediterranean Grouper with rice; amazingly delicious.

Neighborhood and local favorite! I frequent Jimmy’s 2-3 times a week. I enjoy the pizza burgers salads and sandwiches as well as the homemade specialties.

Always love Jimmy's! Good burgers, great pizza!

There bacon cheeseburger was so good thk you for the quick to go service great liitle spot burger was delicious will be back for another one lol 😋

We love this place! Every Friday night it’s our “go to” for take out pizza. Alyssa is always multi-tasking like crazy, but so efficient and friendly! All the food they serve looks great, happy diners! What a pleasure to have this gem in our neighborhood!

Just ate here no even 10 minutes ago. The blonde server with attitude should be fired. She was rude and unattentive. Didnt bring the check for 15 minutes after we finished. Then took 10 minutes to get our payment through. Had to ask the nice hostess to run it for us. Absolutely ridiculous. Will not return.

We love Jimmy's! Excellent pizza. Our favorite is meat lovers and they offer cauliflower crust too which is important to me! Everything else on the menu is delicious too. Get your Greek salad chopped. It's worth it! Definitely a regular go to spot in Tarpon.

Food is excellent but prices have been climbing

Very good. We went several times when vacationing in Tarpon Springs in October 2021 and STILL talk about it sometimes (it’s February 2024). Everything was really good, the cheesecake was amazing.

Always good food and great service

Good week night. Good pizza (all we've had).

Great local dive. Great food at low prices.

Was looking forward to this being a new place for us to go but won't be back. Husband sick all day and night after having octopus. We both had gyro but couldn't figure out how they get their gyro meat. It's not off a spit. Looks like tastes like and has the consistency of something like spam. Not very good at all and poor taste too serve this in tarpon springs of all places. Service ok and friendly though a bit slow considering they weren't busy at all. Big menu so maybe something else is okay here.

Wonderful food cooked and served by family. Popular with locals

from out of town food and service were A plus definitely would be my goto for a local hometown restaurant

Fun, family atmosphere. Terrific food and lots of choices. Everything is delicious and waitstaff is amazing!

This is our go to, feel good place!

Great little place with really good food. Had takeout and we really enjoyed it. Will try it again.

Excellent, popular local eatery. I really enjoyed Octopus legs, and my spaghetti meat sauce.

Authentic Greek items were wonderful as was everything else. Staff were excellent. For a 'local' eatery can't give enough stars.

A legit Greek spot with a lot of options. Great and friendly service. I know it's a bit off the beaten path, but it's worth the extra few minutes to try something new.

Came today and it's STILL my favorite place in Tarpon. Great to see you Victoria ! Thanks for the amazing service as always. The food is delicious and prices very reasonable. Their chopped salad and Gyro Platter are amazing. Wings, pizza, pasta need I say more? Actually, you cannot go wrong with anything on the menu. It's all delicious and fresh every day. The service is always fantastic.

Great food as always and the staff is very friendly. Their fish, Italian dishes, and especially the redneck pizza is great. The service is just as great too.

Been coming here for years. Service and quality is always top notch. The staff are awesome, the owner is the sweetest, the prices are affordable and the food is fresh. What's not to love. You really feel like family when you dine here. So glad to have this little local gem

Just had to right a review give a "well done" to the wait staff. No doubt the food is good at Jimmy's, it always is. However, with wait staff is terrific. I warms my heart when I give a thank you to a server and their reply is "your welcome" every time! So many places the reply I get is "no problem" . Your welcome makes me happy, no problem rubs me the wrong way. Keep up the good work servers.

My fiance has lived up the street from Jimmy's his entire life, so we pop in regularly. The food is great, service is even better. Definitely a staple to the Sunset Beach area.

Always a great meal! Excellent service with friendly wait staff. Where the locals go and we love it! The very best grilled 🐙 octopus. Super good pizza and calzone too.

The place was slammed when I got there. I waited an hour for my food. When you have two young kids with you, that is too long of a wait.

Great cod sandwich and wonderful soup.

One of the best greek pizzas ive had, huge burgers and salads. Great staff!!! Highly recommended

Excellent portions and good home style Italian food.

Friendly excellent service. Very comfortable. Great food. Dine in and take out. Great service

Always amazing food & great service!!

Food was wonderful. We had the eggplant with steamed vegetables and bbq chicken pizza. Our waitress was literally the sweetest. There were a ton of to go orders so I'm guessing everyone loves the food. Great atmosphere.

It's just a little diner but the food is fantastic. Got the calzone and ordered a large so I would have left overs. Yeah, I have left overs for 2-3 more meals. Wife got the stuffed grouper and it was the same. Best service we have had in a while. You know the kind of server who brings everything before you can even ask. Got to love this place!

Good spot! Prices weren't too bad and the food flavors were great! The steamed veggies w garlic had a bit more garlic than I liked, but was still good. Service was friendly and attentive. The decor could be better. Placed looked clean, but could yluae a bit of modernization. Will try again. Close to lots of other local spots as well.

great service , great food! Stuffed grouper was awesome

BEEN GOING HERE FOR 34 YEARS pizzas great best around I think

My husband loves the Chicken Marsala. I have had several good dishes here. It's a little tight with space but they make it work.

A Fritomann review. We went for a late lunch after spending the day, early September 2023 around Tarpon Springs, FL. Jimmy's was on our list because of the super high ratings on some travel site or whatnot. Fritomann had scallops on the brain so that was the deciding factor. Also because the wife wanted Clam Chowder and she said it was great. The scallops were oily. I also got a huge Greek salad (mmm, those olives) and a side something, I forget. Eileen's burger was one of the best burgers she ever tried and too much food with the french fries, for a reasonable price.

Got a sausage and pepperoni pizza to go and it was awesome, lots of toppings, crunchy crust, just perfect! Highly recommended!

This place is awesome. The food is always delicious. Everything from wings, subs and pizza. Spinach pizza with feta is my favorite. They also have fresh seafood. Grilled octopus and grouper and a whole array of dinner specials. Love this place. Jimmy and his crew always aim to please.

Jimmy’s Blvd Restaurant is an Outstanding place for food and waitresses are all friendly.

Staff was kind and good was delicious.

Just got takeout, two pieces of Grouper, lemon potatoes, and a 14” pizza. I was surprised the total amount was $81 and change. Guess I’m out of touch with the prices, I know market price of Grouper, may be a while before I go back!

Jimmy's has terrific food! Many items to choose from. Salads and pizza are my favorites.

Fantastic food and service. This is a great spot to dine.

My favorite breakfast place. Great service, lots of menue options at reasonable prices

Always a great meal there. Staff is awesome also.

Great food, great atmosphere. This is my go-to place!

Love this place. All the locals eat there because all of their food is very tasty. Never had a bad meal there

Jimmy's has great food! A variety of Greek and Italian plus American too. I love their grinders and their antipasto. But everything is simply delicious!

Great food, great customer service. Cleopatra salmon is the best salmon in Florida. Ilirjan, the chef is a outstanding cook!

Great Greek salad with a mushroom pizza! Very good!

We really enjoyed our dinner at Jimmy’s. The food was good. We had the cheese steak sandwich and spinach calzone. Our server on the other hand was awesome! She was so much fun and great at laughing with me when I couldn’t decide so I put her on the spot by ordering all of her favorites the way she likes them cooked. I’m so mad at myself for not remembering her name but she’s got a great future ahead of her no matter what she decides to do. And actually everyone working there was fantastic, helpful and super friendly. The service made a good meal great.

Really like this place. Food is great and the service is excellent.. and right around the corner from the house

Jimmy’s had the best pizza and the best homemade cheesecake. I suggest giving Jimmy’s a try. You won’t be sorry.

No better food in Pinellas county, great staff, everything is fresh

Everything I've had here has been amazing 🤩 Nice neighborhood restaurant.

Honestly, I think Jimmy's is the best restaurant in Tarpon. Seafood is fresh and cooked perfectly, pizzas are awesome and unique. Great service. I love going here, best restaurant in the community and not touristy. Grouper bites, calamari, wings, pizza, salads- all delicious and consistent over many years.

Spinach & feta pizza was yummy with a light & crispy (not burned) crust. Party of 3, each tried a different grouper sandwich - grilled, blackened & fried- really good. The chipotle sauce was just enough to taste but not overwhelm the fish, coupled with chopped lettuce, tomato, pickle rounds & a bit of onion. The bun was lovely & light, no grocery store yuk that sticks to your teeth. Staff were very friendly & attentive. Clean restroom. Really good meal, thank you!

The spinach pizza is always the best but not as great as our server Autumn. She was so sweet and considerate. Lovely experience

Very sweet & funny staff, the small calzone is perfect for $15 filled with pepperoni & mushrooms! Autumn; our waitress, is very sweet. She even boxed the food for my family. She deserves a compliment. ♡

Great food and great service. Party of 6 and was seated right away. Daughter had spaghetti and meatball, mom had a calzone and wings, and the rest shared pizza. Everything came out great. Rice pudding for dessert. Will definitely come again!

Excellent! The sauce is the boss

The restaurant is a top level family restaurant. The seafood is better than a seafood restaurant and the burgers are better than a burger joint. Soups are fantastic and the salads are perfect. Very friendly staff.