Scotty's Pizzeria in Bayonet Point - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Closest to N.Y pizza.. great calzones!!!! Great food. Friendly service.. my favorate is the meatball parm sub..

Excellent supreme pizza and apps. Loaded with toppings.

Great food and service. Continues to have a great pizza. Back again for more great pizza. Has been a few months and it still is great. Another visit and not disappointed. Continues to have great pizza.

I live right down the street from Scottys and have been eating there regularly for years. They know me by name and everyone is always very nice. The food is consistintly very good. I recommend the... Well, everything 😁

Such a cute little pizzeria! Owner is so sweet. Just had our kids birthday party there, pizza was so good. Highly recommended!!

Ordered wet wings. Got no sauce on the mild wings. See pics. Barbecue where fine, mild had no sauce. You decide. Tiffany was no help what so ever. Last time I am spending $70 for wing at Scotty's. To many other places with great customer service.

We received a menu in the mail did not know they were there so decided to try them. We ordered a supreme pizza and it was delicious will definitely go back

Didn't go inside picked up a Togo with friends. Pizza was good and fried pickles with fresh ranch was delish!

The wings are good, the pizza is excellent. I like the pepperoni and sausage. The meatballs are good, there's a meatball sub that's delicious. Good prices too, compared to other pizza places. Also he is local to me, so super convenient. Oh, the brownies are awesome. Can't really think of a negative...

There pizza not the greatest, garlic knots are good everytime. The subs u have to order extra meat or it's all vegetables can't taste the meat.The Spaghetti sauce not that great. The meatballs are ok.. Idk haven't been to happy with some orders lately. Fries are always too done. Mozzarella sticks, cheese never melted all the way. Have had hard ones with cheese not melted at all. So far mushrooms no complaints from others in home. Calazone was ok. Chicken wings won't order from there. So far that's what we had from there. Try to order from other places but the close to me to walk to. I still will eat there but no spaghetti for sure. Pizza I can tolerate,... Delivery is good and fast when delivered.

I ordered $30 worth of food and I got my fried mushrooms their were only 6 in an order but they were so over fried the mushrooms were hard I got Alfredo fried for 7.50 good about 15 fries in the order and I got a meatball Parmesan sub and it was dry as hell when I called to let them know the hotel who shared didn't care less did nothing to resolve the issue and was rude will not order again would post photos but it's not letting me

Normally when we ordered from here they was really good. The past few times idk what happened it got worse. It took over an hour and half to get. Which for places like that its normal? The last time the pizza was supposed to be cooked well done it wasn't. This time we got a 1/2 cheese and 1/2 pepperoni. There wasnt hardly any sauce or cheese on the cheese only side. It was dry. I tried to pull off just the cheese off of 2.5 pieces I got a small pile of cheese. So sad. The wings were dry and looked over cooked. So sad cause they used to be so good. Guess we'll be looking for a new pizza place. 😑

Very quick service. Pizza was amazing Loved the garlic wings.

I went into Scottys today to tell them about a benefit being held tomorrow for a well known local business. I told them I was making a raffle basket. I asked if he would like to donate a gift card. He treated me like trash. Extremely rude. I asked when the owner would be in so I could talk to him. He replied he wont.. he walked away ignoring that I was still there. What a great way to treat people who live in your community and trying to help others. I used to go there once a week. My friends and I will not return to someone who is so disrespectful.... thank you for supporting your community. You could have been polite and just said no thank you

We order delivery a lot and are always happy. Last weekend I took my son and a few of his friends inside to do the beast challenge and everything was perfect (we lost horribly)!

Oh wow this was my first time ordering from Scotty’s pizza. It was absolutely phenomenal. One of the best pizzas I’ve had in the last 10 years. I ordered the chicken Alfredo with pepperoni absolutely amazing. I wish I tipped my delivery person more.

Our food was hot and delicious when it arrived. The cheese was ooey gooey and the crust was cooked perfectly. Highly recommend!!

I have been ordering from Scotty's for allmost 2 years. We have just finished lunch, the Philly cheesesteak and orders of fried mushrooms with the Cajun Ranch dip. Another 5 star lunch. If you have not eaten here you are missing out. Their pizza, wings, subs, mushrooms and many more items are simply perfect. Thank you for another great lunch. The 1 star for atmosphere is only because I have never been there.

Great crust. It's not a thin crust but it doesn't try to be either. They chose another route & they were awesome at it .

Cannot follow directions when customer orders. Asked for lightly toasted and sub came home cold with never seeing an oven. Bread fresh but more bread than meat. Asked for grilled onions but again did not follow customers request. First time trying and will be the last

This place has truly gone downhill. My order was completely wrong. Asked for extra well done wings with hotsauce and Cajun. Ordered several blue cheeses. I got regular somewhat cold hot wings with a single blue cheese for 20 wings. What a waste of time.

Ordered a pizza and fried mushrooms for delivery. Was given an time of 30mins, ok i get it was lunch time. Took an Hr to get to me and I don't live that far from the place. The mushrooms were burnt and greasy. The pizza was was equally as greasy to the point i could pour the grease off of it. Very disappointing for what was paid!

Ordered a medium supreme, and it might have been the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. Edited to add, lighthouse pizza south of here is far better NY style pizza, and the owners are wonderful. Scotty doesn't know, apparently.

Hands down the best pizza in Florida! Fresh ingredients, homemade menu items, friendly staff.. excellent menu options.. can’t say enough great things about Scotty’s! I believe they ruined all other pizza places for me as they are the very best I’ve ever had and any other pizza place will never compare! Excited to visit again!

It was OK. The pizza was good but the Garlic was over kill. Sooo much Garlic on our pizza this time. It was really really really Garlicy I think next time we'll ask if they can go light with it

My only complaint is they do not offer flavored crust. But that is a good thing too bc sometimes the other places in this area offer flavored crust options that are excessive in terms of salt or oil. Scotty's has competitive prices but offer a superior pie. For example other local pizza options tend to rush their products it would seem bc the product you get is a bit soggy. Scotty's pizza is fully cooked and the crust must use old fashioned ingredients from a time before everybody decided to switch to whatever is going on now with big chain ingredients? Overall I would say this establishment deserves a 4.5...but the quibbles are minor and whenever I am in a mood for pizza scotty's will be my first choice and I recommend it highly that others should see for themselves the difference in quality compared to other options.

I just ordered a pizza from you this evening. I worked a long day and while making dinner my oven died. Ordered pizza and a sub. My pizza was RAW! It's not the first time you've disappointed us. I took a chance with your restaurant because of circumstances and you failed me miserably.

The best Caesar salad I’ve ever had! Frank was friendly along with the rest of the staff. Good job Google for leading us to Scotty’s!

Today I received a flyer for Scotty's Pizzeria, never having heard of it before. I called in to ask a couple allergen questions per some restrictions in my household; I am giving 4 stars despite not ordering yet because Sam (who answered the phone) was SO friendly, honest and patient going through the multitude of questions I had. Will be ordering later this week, and already happy to support a local, small business establishment with friendly character and **gluten free** options!! Also looking forward to trying the egg and dairy-free fried pickles. --------- Update: 4/11/24 I spoke with the owner and unfortunately the pickles are NOT plant based since they contain Romano cheese in the batter. Still good to know, and I appreciate the honesty.

Tired of fast food fake pizza? I know i am so Scotty's is real pizza and real good. I enjoyed my visit and definitely suggest you try for yourself, you won't be disappointed

Used to order from them 2-3 times a week, but the last Two times were terrible. I will not go here anymore. When the owner is not there they don't do well. My pizza had hardly any toppings wasn't even acceptable and my salad had no dressing in the order. When I called to complain they said they couldn't do anything cause the owner wasn't there. Way overpriced for the bad food and service. They lost a good customer

I don't normally leave reviews but this place deserves one. Great food even better ranch dressing.

Just moved here from CO. When I asked how good the philly was, her face lit up and she may as well drooled with her recommendation. So of course if an employee reacts like that I have to have it. It was that good and more. OMG can I say the meat was spot on for flavor and size. Because I initially ordered a half sandwich......During my first bite I was looking for my money to order the second half that I knew I should have gotten in the first place. While still chewing it and giving compliments to Scotty for the amazing philly I received (my poor manors talking with food in my mouth but wow I had to!)....... Thank you for having exactly what this chic needed in her life! Freaking yumyumyumyumyum! This will be a regular stop on my food list. Absolutely the BOMB!!

Had the Supreme and it was delicious. I highly recommend scottys.

Terrible service when you order by home there is a girl who is racist

Best pizza in our area. We ordered a pie today.... The delivery guy was great..the pie was hot and Delicious.

The pizza tasted good. The crust was tough. The crust was good when reheated in the oven directly on the oven rack.

I'd give Scotty's more stars if I could! My family and I have been living in NPR/Port Richey for years now, and we're HUGE Pizza fanatics it's our Go-To meal when we're all unsure what we want to eat. We of course support local business ESPECIALLY for food because everyone knows the Mom&Pop shops are the best when it comes to food. For a long time now we've struggled to find the Perfect Pizza place, ever since our usual spot downtown closed we've tried a handful of different places that were closer to home. We thought we found our place (I won't drop names) in Hudson but we were sorely mistaken after a horrible experience (we were sat at a table and ignored for 30 minutes on a slow night). Anyways, back in February we came to Scotty's for my sons birthday dinner, we came with a fairly large group and the awesome folks at Scotty's let us push two tables together without question, and even remade a dish after it was ordered incorrectly (it was completely on us and they took care of it anyway) so the first impression was amazing. We did a carry out order a couple weeks later and as with the first time, the food and the service was top notch. Fast Forward to last night (March 6th), the reason I am writing this, I got home after a long day at work and the missus said she had a long day too, neither one of us wanted to cook. Without any debate whatsoever we decided we're going to Scotty's! Wife called ahead of time to place the order for dine in which was a surprise to me because we typically just take the food home and watch a family movie, after telling the lady taking the order that we were dining in, she said "give us about 20 minutes and we'll have a table ready for you". After she hung up we both said "there's no way they’re about to have a whole table ready for us". Sure enough we get there basically 20 minutes on the spot, we walk in and sure enough there is a table with four cups and a rack for the pizza to sit on, not two minutes later a fresh pie and a dozen of Pasco County's BEST Garlic Knots was brought out for us. We were so grateful for everything we even cleaned up after ourselves afterwards because that's the least we could do. We knew we found our new Pizza Place after the first time we went, but our experience last night solidified it, Scotty's is our new home for Pizza. I don't typically write reviews, but after the absolutely incredibly exceptionally PERFECT service every single time we've visited, especially last night, Scotty's deserves every single bit of recognition. Thank you to the Owner for running such a fine establishment, and thank you to the whole Crew for providing service that is unheard of in todays day and age. A HUGE hats off to Scotty's, thank yall again for everything!! 10/5* I will recommend Scotty's to anyone and everyone who will listen.

Absolutely disgusting food and disgusting service I have never been so treated so badly. Do you have cockroaches in their food when I try to adjust the owner about the situation of the food he got really rude with me I told them that I have a recorded device absolutely disgusting I will be reporting this to the health department

Gluten Free pizza was delicious. Wish they served Coke products.

Been going there over 10 years and haven't had anything bad from there. They are very helpful and food is great.

I usually always order a sub and fries and it's always good, but this time something was wrong. The fries were cold and the ham had an odor and a bad taste. Disappointing.

I called for delivery and the never came after waiting 45 mins! So I called and they said it was on the way.... 1 mins later called me back to tell me to come pick up my pizza that it was getting cold! I said I just called you! I'm waiting for delivery! Over n hour now for a delivery that's 1 mile away which usually takes 30 mins. Cause they didnt pay attention to details. DELIVERY... MEANS DELIVER.

Love their pizza. The subs are a little small compared to what I am used to. They are kiddie size at adult prices. They tasted decent though.

My uncle highly recommended Scotty's pizza so we got delivery. My uncle sure did not lie! It was delicious. The dough was perfect, it wasn't greasy, it was delivered hot & fresh! And the garlic knots!!! Yummy 😋 We will definitely be ordering from you again Scotty's & look forward to trying more of your menu!!! Big THUMBS UP 👍☺️

I've never been in, but every time I order delivery it's always quick, and my order is always correct. The food is delicious! They also are getting a special shout out for understanding the assignment. I asked them to drown my garlic knots in garlic sauce, and they absolutely delivered.

The calzones were huge and packed with toppings. You can eat in or take out. It is what you expect a local pizza shop to be.

Still great pizza, but your new online ordering system is less than useless. Tried 4 times place an order and gave up. Don't fix something that works fine!

Recently ordered a few pizzas and they were pretty tasty. The Inside could use a remodel and the parking lot needs to be repaired. The food was delicious

This was my first visit to Scotty’s pizzeria. I waited for quite some time due to the cashier taking a long order and was on the phone a long time. No other employee came up to take my order while I waited. I walked in to place an order for a whole sub, The Italian. Finally the cashier got off the phone to take my order. I paid for it and was told it would take a few minutes so I sat down. The sub was made as I ordered and it was wrapped in two pieces. The sub was very tasty with a lot of lettuce and really not all that much meat. The roll tasted good and fresh. I’ll probably be back for more subs and to try the Strombolis. I asked to buy a gift certificate but the employee said he could not get me one because the owner was not there and the owner is the only one who knows how to do them. Not good!

Was willing to try this place cause of all the 5-star Google reviews.... Maaaaan ..these people definitely don't know their pizza.... Asked for it well done...it was not... Pieces were tearting apart cause it wasn't cut very well... Pre-made crust...sauce taste like spaghetti sauce from a jar...not very high quality cheese or pepperoni.... $22 for this trash If yinz are ever in this area...avoid this place ...do not recommend...n won't be going back...

The owner tries his best to be very accommodating. As far as the atmosphere, it's not Italian restaurant. It's a pizzeria, so expect the environment of a pizzeria. As soon as you opened the door it takes you back to a New York pizzeria. The smells and the atmosphere yummm

Ordered take out. I would never consider eating at this restaurant ever again. Sadly reading through the other reviews, this is consistent. The pizza was so greasy I couldn’t pick it up. The one bite I took, was completely uneatable. The manager let me know that they don’t offer refunds. He had no concern about how I felt about the pizza. I would highly recommend not taking the chance with this company. Read the other reviews. This isn’t the first and won’t be the last of this type of experience.

Horrible experience. Didn’t get everything I ordered. Horrible supposed manager was rude and hung up phone on me. Will not order from there again. And the girl Answering the phone questions why you want to speak to a manager. Not good.

Great staff and delicious pizza

Have been coming here for many many years. We found this place through friends. Their garlic knots are truly the best I have ever found; drenched, floating in butter 😋 their pizza is also very good. I had the spinach and cheese calzone for the first time. I got the small; it was HUGE!!!!!!!!

I order from here every time i get the chance yes there a lil bit more expensive but worth every dime

The beast was 28 inches of cheesy goodness the crust was my favorite just amazing like I’m still shook 🤤 Currently sitting in a pizza coma 👍👍

Honestly the calzone had too many seasonings in it . Ordered a cheese calzone and couldn't taste the cheese.

I'm not normally one to leave negative reviews, but we had a bad experience with their pizza and customer service tonight. The manager would not even speak to us directly and came across through the relayed messages as dismissive. One of our pizzas was so soggy and greasy that it could not be picked up and the cheese/toppings would immediately fall off. We've had this pizza many times and it never comes like this, even though the employee claimed it does. We asked for extra sauce on our other pizza, but they put so much extra sauce that the pizza was like soup. While we did ask for extra, the professional making the pizza should have used their discretion or told us that it could not be done without ruining the pizza. None of the pizza we ordered could be eaten like a pizza. That is a problem.

Best pizza joint I’ve had. This buffalo chicken salad was so phenomenal and fresh. Had one yesterday and today. Keep up the great work and quality.

Will not deliver 5.2 miles away really wanted to try. Guess not

Ordering online easy peasy. Great access off 19 and good parking. Fresh!

I would rate this place as a 5 star but I would actually like to dine in and have more then one pizza from these peeps. Great pizza, luckily we planned on taking our pizza to go cuz the dining area closes at 9pm. Otherwise I have no complaints staff seemed very friendly took just under 15 minutes to get our order cooked and in our hands and the pizza was marvelous. I'll be back for sure.

Friendly staff my future was exactly the way I ordered it

So glad we stopped here!!! Great pizza. Can’t wait to travel back through for more.

I was looking forward to finally having a good pizza but I was so DISAPPOINTED!! First the pizza came off the top of oven so it felt hot, however, a 5min drive later and it was cold within a couple of minutes on my plate. Plus who ever made it needs to learn how to spread the dough. Paper thin in middle for about a cup size than nothing but thick bread, very little sauce so it was dry and little cheese on one side other side more but no flavor. A true pizza man knows that good cheese should be oily, and tasty. Very disappointed. Will never return.

The Florentine pizza is amazing!

Pretty expensive for a slice of 🍕

We have ordered pizza for years from here but we are done. I have now gotten 4 burned pizzas. My wife even says on the order lightly cook. I'm not paying for burnt Pizza again. I said something to the young staff and nobody offered to assist so we are not coming back. It used to be our weekly go to place.

Walked through the door and the smell immediately took me back home up north. And that's a great thing. The sandwiches were simply amazing, along with their Alfredo fries and simply the absolute best pizza I've had since moving to Florida 20+ years ago. The staff and owner are very friendly and helpful. Unlike the service I got from the my last visit to one of the big chains around here. A place I'm never going back to. I have no need to now that I found this! Awesome food. Can't recommend this place enough. Additionally Simply the best pizza I've had in Florida since moving here 20 years ago. The Alfredo fries are insane as are the Philly cheese steak fries. Tremendous salads too! Please keep in mind that for dining in it's closed 30 minutes before the doors are locked.

Amazing food!!! Definitely will be my go to pizza place!

I can’t say enough good things about their pizza and wings! As a native New Yorker I always crave a certain taste and texture to my pizza. That’s the feeling I get when I’ve received my Scotty’s Pizza. My whole family goes back for more slices. Their wings are excellent and I believe their prices are fair! Kudos to Scotty’s..I’ll be ordering again soon!!

Slice of heaven barbaque chicken pizza with onions garlic bacon and chicken and a parmesian crust served with a side of butter garlic sauce and scottys great pizza sauce for my crust witch might I say what a fine absolute perfection on that crust it was beyond words, trully epic. But that pizza sauce yo, absolutly no complaints. Thankyou to scottys pizza your pizza is what the world needs.

Great lasagna and peanut butter pie. 😋 yummy

Good pizza 🍕 and products....very recommended

If I had a pic I'd post it......Best pizza I've had since I moved here in November. Definitely be back!

Coming from NY we will personally never order from here again. My mother and I’s first time trying pizza around the area I think we’ll stick with dominos or frozen pizza. The young lady at the counter was pleasant, however, the quality and the taste of the food was truly mediocre. Picture of the wings are deceiving they’re actually merely the size of a quarter. I know it’s easy to burn cauliflower pizza but the whole bottom was burnt as well not just edges. Just disappointed because we were really craving good food.

got a large meatlovers with green peppers and onions it was the best pizza I HV ever ate

Never a bad meal, we have tried 3 different calzones, all were jammed stuffed and tasted amazing, white pizza- very flavorful looking forward to next meal there

Best pizza in the Port Richey area.. It's our go-to for friday night pizzas with the grandchildren.

Pizza is pizza, and my family eats it quite often on trips. Stopped in this one. First off the big pizzas price is higher than on the menu. And every extra topping was 5 on top of that. Dude was rude at the counter. Pizza was okay gave us all upset stomachs afterwards. So for the price ehh go somewhere else

Let's talk about the Beast, and I am talking the biggest Pizza I have seen here in Pasco. This pizza is huge and well worth the money. As a Foster family of 10, I bought 2 of these big babies and this did not disappoint! We were in heaven.

Been here several times, never disappoints! Food is great and the guys behind the counter are great. Fried pickles were very very well seasoned and the Cajun ranch is a must get! We also got the fat Jon calzone and a chicken bacon ranch sandwich, both were phenomenal. Prices were very reasonable. Highly recommend giving this place a try.

I get delivery a couple times a week ,always good food and fasrmt delivery ,love them ...

This place has never let us down. This pizza is really good 😊

They used to be good a couple years ago. Then something happened, not sure what. It is some of the mostly boring and tasteless food now.

Terrible Terrible Terrible customer service. Called three times and was put on hold all three times for over 5 minutes and nobody took my order.

This place is as good as it gets around here. You can find other places that do it different, but not as good as Scotty’s. Their Pizzas and Strombolis remind me of the north east (NY/NJ) where I grew up.

We get Delivery, and are So Happy they do to us..and Even More Happy we found Scotty's...Their Pizza is the BEST we have had in Years...and Prices are Great to boot...I Rarely eat the crust on Pizza but their's I do!

Philly cheesesreak pizza is awesome

Really happy with Scotty's. Ordered a pizza, plus hot subs twice from here. They were soooo good. Delivery was fast too. So fast that each time my food was still piping hot when it got here. I love how they prepare the sandwiches. Where half of it, isn't falling onto your plate with each bite. Very tasty hot sandwiches. Had the meatball sub, and their Philly cheese steak is the best I've had between Brooksville to Port Richey! Delivery drivers are awesome as well. Very friendly people person's. I finally found a pizzeria that I can call home. Tried many of them here in FL. Scotty's is the only one that has impressed me all around. Don't think I need to Google another pizzeria number again. Both times I ordered I was getting dizzy from not eating. Yes, my fault for waiting so long to eat. Scotty's fast service, had me grateful. Since I can't comment on another post. I am adding that I agree. Scotty's leaves you wanting more of the awesome flavors. I might have to start ordering an extra sandwich. To satisfy that craving.

First time ordering from Scotty's. The order was on time for pickup. The calzone and stromboli were good sizes and both delicious. The employee / owner was nice to talk too as well. We will definitely be going back again for more takeout. Thanks Scotty's. Keep it up.

I recently ordered a large half Hawaiian, half pepperoni and pineapple pizza along with some hot wings from Scotty's Pizzarea, and I must say, I was thoroughly impressed with the entire experience. Let's start with the pizza itself. The combination of flavors on the half Hawaiian and half pepperoni and pineapple was simply divine. The crust was perfectly cooked, with a delightful crunch on the outside and a soft, chewy texture on the inside. The generous toppings were fresh, and the balance between the savory pepperoni, sweet pineapple, and savory ham was spot on. Each bite was a burst of deliciousness, leaving me craving for more. The pizza truly exceeded my expectations, and I couldn't have asked for a better combination. Moving on to the hot wings, they were an absolute delight. Not only were they huge in size, but they were also cooked to perfection. The wings had a crispy exterior that gave way to tender and juicy meat inside. The flavor was on point, with just the right amount of spice and a well-balanced tangy and savory profile. It was evident that great care was taken in marinating and cooking these wings to ensure maximum flavor and satisfaction. They were a fantastic accompaniment to the pizza and left me wanting to order more. In addition to the outstanding food, I was highly impressed with the delivery service provided by Scotty's Pizzarea. The delivery was exceptionally quick, ensuring that the food arrived fresh and piping hot. The efficiency and promptness of the delivery added to the overall positive experience. Overall, I cannot recommend Scotty's Pizzarea enough. Their pizza, particularly the half Hawaiian and half pepperoni and pineapple, was out of this world, delivering an explosion of flavors that left me in awe. The hot wings were equally delicious, with a generous size and a perfect balance of spices. Furthermore, the speedy delivery ensured that my food arrived promptly and in excellent condition. If you're in Port Richmond, Florida, and craving some fantastic pizza and wings, look no further than Scotty's Pizzarea. You won't be disappointed!

Was extremely disappointed last night. Ordered over a hour before pick up. Ordered wings got bites that you couldn't even bite into they were so burnt. Ordered a large supreme cut in squares, pizza was pie cut, dough you couldn't bite through and was so dry there was no sauce on the pie. The pizza was clearly burnt and should not have been served. Extremely disappointed

We frequently order from here. It's our go to pizza shop. My new favorite is the chicken parmesan calzone. Delicious!

Excellent food! Best pizza place in town.

Fed a family of 12 with The Beast Cheese pizza. No leftovers. Will absolutely order again. Delivery was punctual and the 28 inch pizza arrived in excellent condition. Couldn't have been happier. Highly recommend.

Always great, even when I ordered a unusual Stromboli, it was perfect

Got a large pizza, it was delicious!