Smith's Orchard & Bake Shop - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

These are the absolute best pies. Perfect spices and not too much sugar. The pie crust is perfectly tender and flaky. Best pie crust ever!!! This is a once in a lifetime find!! Bery berry pie is my favorite.

No place like it. Absolute best pies! Also cheese, farm bred beef, ice cream, apples, and so much more. And don't forget the cider donuts! 5 stars all around.

The best pies in upstate NY. Enough said.

The piecrust is nice & flakey & the fruit filling is the real deal but I wish they would put a little salt in the pie crust. It's pretty flavorless and needs that little bit of salt to make it scrumptious. Also, it would be good if they listed the ingredients on the pie boxes. I would like to know if Smith's uses butter to make the crust.

The best pies and apple cider donuts anywhere.

Always a treat both physical and aroma wise.. Fresh backed pies.. Excellent product

The best Rasberry/ Peach pie I have ever had in my life!

Fantastic pies, the best fruit pies I ever had. Great fresh apples. The sugar cider donuts are always so fresh and delicious. It's worth the trip.

Bringing a Smith's Orchard pie(s) to a family event, is like Santa walking in with a sack full of gifts. The smiles and anticipation everyone has for these, "as good as grandma's" pie(s) is "Priceless".

Consistently AMAZING baked goods, fine assortment of produce, meats, sauces. Can't recommend highly enough!!!!

Delicious donuts, pies, cakes!!

Very friendly Baked goods are great

Best for pies and anything baked!! Buy my sausage and skirt steaks here too Highly recommend

I've been going here for many years, they make great pies and the best cinnamon & sugar cider donuts around !!

Great pies & more! Fair pricing.

Best pies ever! Best donuts ever! Also apples from their orchard, beef, eggs, ice cream and other homemade treats. Lots of free parking

Did you say Pie?!?!?!? We had the Rubarb / Strawberry pie. The sweetness was perfect,to me that means not sweet and not too tangy. And that crust was amazing. We also brought home some apple cider donuts and apples. Next time will be turnovers.

If you haven't had a pie or apple cider from Smiths, you're missing out. BEST pies around! So many flavors to choose from. Personal favorites are apple crumb, blueberry crumb and pecan! FYI They don't take CC cards but do take cash and personal checks. You can also pre order pie!

The best pies and turnovers I’ve ever had! A large variety of homemade items and pantry staples like pineapple salsa among others. I’m hooked on the pickled cauliflower!

Fresh picked apples, pies, cider donuts, and a whole lot more!

The pies are even better than our friends' grandma's fantastic homemade pies. Came a couple weeks ago from 40 minutes away and were instantly hooked on the apple and pecan pies. So, we came back the next week and got even more. Both Jessie and Riah at the front are very nice (names may not be spelled correctly).

Absolutely amazing pies and baked goods! Their apple crumb pie is the epitome of fall in Upstate, NY. Their attendant even helped me carry a hand-full of pies to my car today! Exceptional service from a locally owned business ☺️

Best pies around and all their products are the best ,along with the Smith family.❤️

Just had their turnovers for the first time , as delicious as their pies!

Apple peach pie and cider donuts were so yummy

We love their apple pie and plain cider donuts..another trip is required to try their small pecan pie and other goodies.

Go early to get their apple cider donuts! They really do have the best apple cider donuts, I almost hate to admit , but I think they may be better than Indian ladder farms's donuts! Lol and their freshly baked pies are heavenly!

OMG. The best pies ever..... great varity and good prices

Best donuts,pies and corn in town!

Their cherry pies are delicious and so are their turnovers. Well worth the drive from anywhere 👍

My friend and I were traveling through the area on our way to Ithaca and my friend LOVES their Raspberry pies! And although we were running late and could not make it there before they closed the owners were willing to make us fresh pies that day and we were able to pick it up after hours. My friend was so happy and all she could do was talk about how wonderful their raspberry pies are!

Great people that feel like your family. Good food made with love. The pies are to die for and great farm fresh eggs. Some of the best cheese curds in the area.

Love the pastry cheese apples cider and meat Love the family as well..

Wonderful cider donuts, great turnovers and delicious pies.

Stopped by to try one of their homemade pies. It was amazing quality and delicious 😋! Highly recommended

The pies are good. The help is surly. Lakeside has great pies. Also Smiths pies are sold at Fred the butcher so you don’t have to go to the actual store, which I’ll never go to again.

Their pies beat all, and they also have great turnovers, cider donuts, and carrot cakes! A broad selection of locally produced meats as well as garnishes and preserved foods. And of course, apples! Check 'em out, you won't be disappointed!

Good prices on all products they sell. Friendly staff

Wonderful family owned business. Delicious pies as well as local meats, eggs, dairy and other products. I thought I made the best strawberry rhubarb pie until I had one of Smith's... Highly recommend stopping by and seeing what fresh baked and locally sourced treats they have.

So had a basketball practice this morning with my Galway girls. One of my post players brought me a Peach pie. Wow. I'm a Peach pie expert. Anytime I go south it's the only dessert I order. I never thought I would be able to find a good one in the northeast. But I did, right here. Great job. Btw I know who my fav post player is now. Thank you. Go Eagles!!!

Absolutely the best place to get true delicious homemade pies around. The staff is so incredibly friendly and helpful. My girlfriend and I love the place.

Best place people n pie in the world

The pies are delicious, probably the best we’ve ever had. But I had a bad service experience. I ordered pies in October for Thanksgiving and I called the day of pickup, just to make sure they were ready/had our order so there wouldn’t be an issue. The person who answered the phone said, “I have a thousand pies here I’m in the kitchen and have no idea.” I asked if there was anyone else who would be able to help and they said they would check. I was on hold for about 10 mins. before I hung up, but could the people working chatting. I hung up when I heard, “We should charge them (the customers) more if they show up earlier.” To which someone replied, “fucking ridiculous.” Happy Thanksgiving…