The Starfish Cottage Cakes - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

A very clean taste and look, almond cake, mango inside with simple decoration, the hand made edible flowers were exquisite. The way that it tickled your taste buds was exceptional. Order and service was easy.

I had the pleasure of trying two different cakes from Starfish Cottage. The flavors were truly the best I’ve ever tasted, and the cake design and style was sublime. If you are looking for the best cakes in South Florida, you should definitely try Lilly and the Starfish Cottage team.

Best birthday cake ever , My husband got me a birthday cake from Starfish Cottage Cakes. He wanted it to be similar to our wedding cake. It was a multilayered almond pound cake With mango and pineapple filling. And a butter cream frosting. It was actually better than our wedding cake. It was amazing.

Was trying to reach them for couple weeks. No response. Nothing. Like "please leave us a massage we will call you back asap".. Yeah, still waiting. Total lost of time, don't even bother. They don't care about their clients at all.

Best cake place in south Florida! The cake was beautiful, just like the picture, and so delicious. Not dry at all. They were super friendly and easy to work with. It was a last minute order over the holidays and she came through for us, saving my daughters bday party. I couldn’t be happier and will definitely order from them again.

I was blown away from start to finish! Lily was so prompt in responding to my request and with some back and forth, we came up with a design for my sons 3rd birthday. Not only did the design exceed my expectations, but the taste was INCREDIBLE!!! Can't wait to use Lily and her team again for more family celebrations. Thank you thank you THANK YOU!!!!

With short notice I was able to receive an amazing birthday cake for my husband. Not only did the cake look great, but it tasted even better. The owner was very responsive, communicated effectively, delivered on every promise. Her professionalism was impeccable. On the day of the event it was pouring rain and she was able to transition the cake in perfect condition. I would definitely recommend this company for your next cake order.

You did an incredible job 🙌.Thanks a lot for that amazing cake🎂 . Please continue the great work. 🥰. Stay safe 🙏

Our wedding cake was BEYOND BEAUTIFUL and DELICIOUS! We trusted our wedding planner to have The Starfish Cottage Cakes to make our wedding cake, and it was so much worth the investment. Not only they created our cake based on the inspiration photos and a mood board but it tasted so good we enjoyed it for a few days after the wedding. HIGHLY RECOMMEND to have them on board for your event and don't be afraid to give them a freedom to create a cake based on their creative vision.

Lilly and her team are so sweet! We hired them to make our wedding cake and were not disappointed. Working with them was super easy. They were very responsive over email. They came to us for our tasting, which was very convenient. The flavors they offered were delicious.The strawberry cake/guava filling we came up with together was a hit with our guests! We showed them a simple cake we found on Pinterest and they created something similar and beautiful with hand-painted palm fronds. It was the perfect for the special flamingo cake toppers we had made. It showed up at the venue on time, tasted fresh and looked great. We appreciate they also provide a fresh anniversary tier for our first anniversary, which works for us as we'll be moving in this time and not be able to travel with a frozen cake tier. We recommend them without reservation to anyone looking for a cute and yummy cake in the South Florida area.

I cannot believe that the Starfish Cottage Cakes created a bundt cake out of my honey so I could give them to my honey clients. I was looking of a local cake company to give these as gifts. As a small business owner I look at other businesses to see how I could use them and Lilly and her team knocked these delicious cakes out of the park. If you are in Miami and need a local cake baker give her a call. I am sure she will make any sweet dessert you are looking for. Thank for making my clients holidays extra special and I look forward to your next tasty creation!

From the moment I contacted Lilly for my sons lumberjack birthday I knew I had found a match for us. We spoke and in about 5 emails we had decided, from the flavors to how they were going to look. She came through 100%. Everything looked magical and surreal! Definitely will not hesitate to contact her for my next gathering!

I absolutely loved a custom cake I ordered for a friend’s birthday. It was honestly the star off the party and my friend was overjoyed. Everyone said how great it tasted! It was the best red velvet I’ve ever had. Loved the little touches they added to make it look exactly like a few photos I sent as inspiration. Looking forward to using them for other cakes in the future!

Best wedding cake! Lilly made my wedding cake. not only was it delicious but it was beautiful. And the customer service was perfect from start to finish. I felt as if it was one less thing I had to worry about for my big, because she was on point, reliable, and a great communicator every step of the way. Thank you!

Once again, the Starfish Cottage cupcakes were delicious! I am a cupcake connoisseur... always on the hunt for a tasty cupcake. I finally found them. Lilly came through with an amazing cake and cupcakes for my son's birthday. In preparation, Lilly came up with a cupcake in Batman theme. These were to give my son a clue about his surprise party. The cake was a huge hit with the kids and parents, but the taste was the out of this world! After the party, there was barely any cake left. This cake was so moist and delicious. Thanks again for your amazing creativity! The hard work to make his birthday was a huge success by you and your team. Looking forward to working again with them on the next cake!

What can I say, these cake pops were the best I have ever tasted! After working with her the first time, everybody loves the cake pops gifts! I order from here constantly for delivery to my office in downtown in Pembroke Pines. I focus on customer relations and it's always somebody's birthday. It was GREAT to have found Lilly and her passion for baking. These add something different to order besides cupcakes or a birthday cake. They may be the moistest cake pops I have ever had. All the flavors are amazing, I always order the assorted ones and give 3 to each of my clients. Vanilla, Chocolate and Red Velvet. I highly recommend them. They knock out orders quickly but to make sure, I would give them a call if you're placing an order, especially a large order. They may be the best-kept secret in Miami for sweets and wedding cakes. I am sure I will be ordering from The Starfish Cottage Cakes again. Thank you............

Lilly’s wedding cakes are amazing and the presentation is impeccable. Her buttercream is the best I have ever tasted. I appreciate the time her and team gave me at our wedding. Thank you so very much for making our wedding cake the best in Miami. #WeddingCake

We had the most amazing experience when ordering cupcakes to accompany my friend's wedding cake. We wanted to surprise her so we found out The Starfish Cottage Cakes was baking the wedding cake and added them to the order. We were coming from out-of-state to Miami and made sure they were sent to The Addison, where the reception was being held. Lilly totally exceeded our expectations in every way. She responded to emails immediately! When we spoke on the phone she was kind and helpful knowing we wanted to make it a last minute surprise! She even went above and beyond and added a cupcake tower that we requested at no additional charge. Plus, the chocolate and vanilla cupcakes were beautiful and so delicious! I highly recommend her for cupcakes and wedding cakes too! #MiamiWeddingCakes

Great cake...Great service.... Great small business all around. Very attentive to detail and make sure you receive what you want in the final product. highly recommend!!!!

She made me an amazing wedding cake which served 150 servings. The taste was superb. I highly recommend her cakes and desserts to anyone in the Miami.