All Shook Up Tavern - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

We love coming to this quaint little bar weekly for the best pizza, appetizers and old fashions. My favorite is the Jameson Orange old fashioned sweet!

Fresh fresh fresh! Just delicious. We ordered 5 different pizza and each one was better than the previous! Great job!

So good, unique flavors, great setting, just all around thumbs up! Spanish Eyes is my fav pizza but like trying the new weekly variety too!

Great fresh food, drinks, and hospitality. The owner always has a new surprising dish or cocktail to share. Enjoy!!

AMAZING and creative pizza and cocktails!! Will deffinetly be back!! Such a cool atmosphere as well with fun games outside!!

This is such a great hidden gem! The menu was creative and I love that they support local farms and grow their own ingredients! Yummy cocktails and an awesome outdoor patio. The service was great and the atmosphere was on point. Would absolutely recommend.

The best services is great, and the food is amazing

Best restaurant I've ever eaten at, 50% the food, 50% the drinks and 1000% the atmosphere.

Super cute Elvis themed bar that serves home-made pizzas and craft cocktails in a beautiful country setting. The owner does a fantastic job focusing on hyperlocal ingredients for her cocktails and food. Definitely recommended trying the street corn pizza if it's available! Tater is an added bonus.

We received a gift certificate from my daughter and thought we should give it a try. First thing we discovered was it’s great ratings, Yelp 5 stars, Facebook 4.7 stars, and Google 4.7 stars. On the way there we were treated to a beautiful double rainbow … a good start. On arrival, we spent a few minutes outside with a group of the bar’s patrons and the property owner, admiring the rainbows. Inside, we were warmly welcomed and sat at the bar. My wife had a very good Muddled Old Fashion and I had SunDrop (I’m driving). Our appetizer was a plate of Nachos which was unique, made with real cheese and appeared to be baked. The jalapenos had the seeds removed to lessen the heat, lots of taste, not hot. It was a nice size for two. The pizzas are 10 inch and thin crust. This made the decision easy, we each had our own pizza. I had the “In the Ghetto” which is a meat pizza … I know, it’s a male thing:). My wife had the “Blue Suede Shrooms” Which she loved! This place is super friendly. The owner, Katie, the bartenders and even the customers were friendly. We will be back and do recommend you give it a try:)

Always a good time , great out of town stop

Drive out to this hidden gem. DELICIOUS food and incredible drinks. I had the charcuterie board with just amazing cheeses, a Chai Russian drink, and the pizzas are the best in the area. Charming hangout with wonderful staff.

Our cooler than us friends invited us for a double date away from the kids… FANTASTIC! Getting a bunch of pizzas to share tapas style in a chill, clean, and fun environment. The owner served us and was crazy knowledgeable about all the local ingredients too! Oh; the mocktail menu for us non alcohol drinkers was VERY appreciated too.

This place needs to be on everyone's itinerary! Katie has turned this spot into a must stop for locals and out of towners day and night!

Best cocktails around! What a tavern should be!

Excellent service first and foremost! By far one of the coolest cocktail menus in Northeast Wisconsin. Need to come back to try some more. Thank you for a great afternoon!

Great pizza, gluten free options, organically local sourced foods. Loved the atmosphere!! Must stop, a hidden gem. Burning Love pizza was amazing, just the right amount of heat!!!

Absolutely delicious local food (with GF options!) and tasty drinks at a cozy neighborhood tavern! What more could you ask for 😍

Great service, drinks, salads, pizza, and grasshoppers.

Had the elder lavender margarita and it was fabulous. In fact, I ended up having two. I would go back just for those. We were there for a bday and they served all their pizzas. There is not one of them that wasn't delicious but I will say my favorite was the All Shook Up. Amazing taste, great crust, the flavors were fantastic. I will be back.

WOW! Seriously the best craft pizza I have ever had. Even the gluten free crust was light and crispy but held together perfectly. Unique locally sourced ingredients meet culinary artistry in this quaint fifties-themed tavern. Well worth a little drive!

Incredible service, great food and great environment!

Crazy good, what a wonderful surprise! I didn’t know what to expect, but truly blown away. If you haven't stopped by, do so now because it's under new ownership (Katie & Ryan) and they are doing a great job! The pizza was truly amazing, all from scratch. Everything you need from a good ol' country bar but at the next level!

An unexpected gem! From the outside it appears to be your typical old house turned “dive bar” in WI, but once inside, the decor, food, and drinks did not disappoint! Enjoyed some red wine and a cauliflower crust pizza with uncured pepperoni, wild mushrooms, olive blend, and their made from scratch sauce. It was cooked perfectly. Honestly better than some of our favorite local pizza places. Absolutely delicious!! The owners Ryan and Katie are wonderful. You can tell they’ve put their heart and soul into creating a casual Elvis and 50’s themed atmosphere. Add to that the delicious food and drink…it’s 5 stars for me! We’ll definitely be back.

Don’t hesitate, just go! This place was so much fun and the bartenders were awesome! Slots, pool table, darts, pull tabs and touch tunes. Perfect “Wisconsin” bar!

Delicious food and great service.

The new owners did a phenomenal job updating & creating a 50's theme. Ryan & Katie make great Sunday morning bloody marys & craft coctails and the pizza was awesome too. Elvis is in the building!!

Great entertainment, fair prices and friendly employees!

Brooke is awesome. Tip her good!

Brook is the best bartender! She is friendly and you never have to wait for service.

Always nice to have a beverage or two and chat with Brenda.

Great place ..cheap beers for a saturday night

Seemed like only locals were welcome. Bartender was friendly enough.