All Star Pizza in Deerfield Beach - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I'm sad because I paid for add ons, they forgot the sausage. But it's decent

Great service and excellent pizza. Order House Special Pizza is delicious. Try the fried calamari. Best breading and Marinara sauce is excellent. Highly recommend

I just moved here from New Jersey in March, an I have been searching for months to find a slice that tastes like home. Unreal pizza. Also every time I’ve been in there the staff is so nice. Worth trying out if you haven’t been here before.

When I called the lady on the phone, Kelly, the owners wife was very rude. In person even worse. To make matters worse there was a tall skinny guy, I believe a driver cursing and complaining very loudly. Food was ok but the service was atrocious

Absolutely delicious and amazing service!

Great food great people definitely going back

They are very friendly and always go above and beyond every time! The food is really good especially the cheese pizza.

The new owners have taken over the All Star Pizza place and have improved it 100%. Pizza is great and so i are their entrées.

Hidden gem! Get the lunch special… 2 slices and a soda for like $7 or $8 bucks! Can’t beat it

The people here are so nice! The pizza is Phenomenal!!! I order at least 3 times a month and it is always soooo good!

Had a wonderful dining experience! The food was delicious I ate my entire meal which I hardly do. The staff team Amy was truly a delight to engage with and thanks to Chip for making me feel so welcomed. Looking forward to returning soon. ♥️

This is NY style thin pizza. Quick service. I recommend this place.

very good service and amazing food, all the staff was very friendly and helpful, overall an amazing place to eat 10/10

owner so was nice and outgoing talked with us while we were waiting and just overall a genuine good guy the lady who worked behind the counter was also amazing great place everyone should come here!!!

Absolutely delicious proper pizza amazing and kind staff. Definitely coming back again

5 star pizza and five star service. Very welcoming and friendly owner.

The salad and meal was terrific. Everything about the experience was terrific. We met the new owner Chip who explained the changes he's made to the menu and the ingredients being used as well as the cooking process. It was a genuine pleasure. We'll be going back for sure. Joe (aka Ron)

delivery . my local pizza restaurant

Best chicken and eggplant parm anywhere. The staff is friendly and helpful. The bathrooms are clean. A great all around place

Nothing special. Pizza is just like pizza... The staff could have been more cheerful

Two things thumbs up. The meatball parmigian was delicious. They delivered very quickly.

It was my first delivery. They where on time! Very important when your drunk and hungry lol. I was very happy with the food. My suggestion is drenching your garlic twists with garlic and oil. Check out John the Baker. People love tons of garlic oil and Parmigiano.

After scouring Deerfield Beach for the perfect slice, I stumbled upon All Star Pizza, a spot that might not grab your attention at first glance but will forever hold a place in your heart once you've had a taste. Walking in, the vibe is immediately welcoming—staff greet you like an old friend, ready to share their love for pizza with every customer who walks through the door. But let's talk about the main event: the pizza. Imagine a crust so perfectly cooked it offers that rare, elusive crunch with every bite, a harmonious balance that's neither too thick nor too thin, just sturdy enough to hold the generous, melty blanket of cheese on top. The cheese itself is a star; it's clear they use a high-quality blend that's rich, flavorful, and pulls just right—every cheese lover's dream. What makes this pizza stand out is the attention to detail. The sauce is tangy and applied with restraint, allowing the crunch of the crust and the savory cheese to take center stage. Every bite is a testament to the craftsmanship and passion that goes into making these pies. While I'm no Dave Portnoy, if I were to channel my inner pizza connoisseur, I'd give All Star Pizza in Deerfield Beach a solid 8.0. In a world of endless pizza options, All Star Pizza distinguishes itself with its friendly staff, impeccable crunch, and cheese that's simply out of this world. This isn't just a pizza; it's an experience—one that I'll be coming back for again and again.

Apparently this place had a recent ownership change and the new ownership seems to be doing an awesome job. The owner and his family were the staff working and they were all great. Owner made sure to check in with all tables, run food and was making food as well. His wife was our server and she made very polite talk throughout the meal, constantly checking in. Their young daughter was serving other tables and seemed to be on top of everything as well. The food was great too. I had a gluten free pizza and it had a very nice crackery consistency, without being dry or bland. The cheese and sauce were both fresh. My girlfriend had the eggplant parm which the owner advised was made fresh by him personally and apparently that was great as well. Our toddler daughter enjoyed the pasta and breadsticks that came as a side with the parm. She liked them so much(she ate 2.5 of the 3 that came with the meal herself…) that the Owners wife brought us out some more breadsticks for her, complimentary. This place seems to be doing everything well after the change in ownership. Hopefully their success continues.

First time there. Great service, very friendly & polite staff. Had the square sicilian slices which were excellent, very light & large size slice. Will certainly be back

These people are so nice. I order all the time, and their pizza is the best. Ive had a few of their pasta dishes also. They were also very good. I grew up in an Italian family in New York City, so I consider myself quite the expert on pizza and pasta 🤣. I’m always going to order from here. Also their delivery people are the best.

Ordered online, they delivered what we ordered on time.

Extremely disappointed in my order. In town on business ordered a salad and they did not include the dressing for it. I called and would be another hour for them to deliver the dressing. It's 7 pm and I have a very early meeting in the morning so waiting for dressing is NOT an option! Been here since Sunday and have yet to get a decent meal here. Very disappointing, what does it take to get at least a half decent meal here. Spent $40 including a $10 tip for the driver for food I can't even eat

⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ One of the best pizza joints I have ever been to. The staff is so warm and welcoming and friendly. And the pizza 🍕 is absolutely incredible and very reasonably priced. It’s thin crust and delicious. It’s hot and fresh and they have all the fixings. They’ll even give you a little togo box just for one slice. They also have a late night delivery special for $10 which is pretty great. It’s just around the corner from my house, so I will probably be going there a few times a week for the rest of my life! Please note: past reviews reflect past management. The place has completely changed since then. The new owners are wonderful and take great care in what they do.

very friendly and amazing pizza

We had their Chicken Caesar Salad and Chicken a La Parmegiana and loved it! Chip and Kelly are awesome owners unlike the previous owner James who is an adshole.... Thank you All Star Pizza Deerfield Beach for making last night's dinner epic for my family and I!

Worst Pizza I ever had somehow you guys managed to burn it on the bottom but the pizza was undercooked obviously my boy Jeff didn't make it please do not have anybody else make my pizza but Jeff😡😡😡 oh and it was soggy unreal whoever made mine get rid of him

Been here plenty of times and always had good experiences but this time was different. This time we came specifically because of Chip. So Chip about 2 weeks ago helped my daughter in the biggest way. She needed a pizza box for a school project. He told her to bring it back finished for some complimentary food. So she was excited when she got a good grade so we went back. Well Chip wasn’t there unfortunately…. But the whole staff didn’t even question our story as Chip has done this many times before…. I tell that story to say… Even if they had average food we would return for service like that. The fact that the food was amazing on top of it. Thanks for being such an old school caring business. Exceptional service and good but deeds like that make you guys a staple in the community. We will always recommend All Star Pizza for this reason and will surely be back soon

Everyone was so nice and food was delicious, highly recommend the Deerfield location.

Pizza wasn’t all that and they messed up our order had to go back and pick up correct order

I have been going here for 3 years since I moved across the street. I have been looking for pizza in Florida that comes even close to New York style and it’s been tough. At first I’d get a slice and it was just okay. A little too thin but better than most. NOW, With the new owners and changing the pizza recipe, this is my new weekly spot. I am so happy I can finally have consistently delicious New York style pizza! My family came to visit for the holidays and we ordered the pizza and wing combo and everyone was shocked by how good it is! Give the new pizza a shot and I really think you will be pleased. Also every single person I have met has been very kind and respectful. Can’t ask for more.

All Stars Pizza offers tasty pizzas with a variety of toppings. Good for a quick and satisfying meal.

Stopped in for a couple slices after getting a recommendation from the manager at UPS up the street. The pizza was fantastic, the owner was welcoming, and the prices were really reasonable. Looking forward to trying other things on the menu! Thank you!

AVOID COMING IN .We Love 😍 Pizza , specially Good New York one . After reading the positive reviews wanted to give it a try. We were in the area. NEGATIVE vibe. Don't know what all the good reviews were really about??? The employees were talking to each other and showing things on the phone. Didn't acknowledge us for a good couple of min . (Place wasn't busy) . They acted like they were doing us a favor. Was going on . We're is the customer service !? After all pizza was alright . Not impressed . Rated eat and bring business somewhere else . Bad manners ,rude. 1st and last .

love the new owner! such great energy and felt like i’ve known the workers and him forever. The new flavor of wings they have changed my life!! also a new fan of the honey garlic. Went in with my friends and we were served quickly and with a smile. highly recommend

Amazing customer service I placed an order for pickup and was treated so nice and friendly! And the food was delicious! I will be ordering from here again!

Sad gloomy crew Not a greeting when walk in . Whole bunch of guys on their phones talking to each other, to busy with their own thing to actually provide customer service. Apparently interrupting. Not inviting atmosphere or family oriented. Pizza it’s ok compared to a nearby places. Still blend. Not impressed.

OUR GO-TO PIZZA SPOT! We order delivery here several times a month for the last year and a half, since we moved to Deerfield Beach and they ALWAYS get the order right! Seriously! They never mess up the order, it delivers super fast, and it's always fresh! We order pizza, wings, fries, meatballs, salads, eggplant parm, meatball subs, etc. and everything is ALWAYS DELICIOUS! Wonderful customer service and friendly delivery drivers! Great prices and even better food! All Star Pizza in Deerfield you will always be our favorite pizza spot! A+++

I have re- reviewed our experience with this pizza, and we are really enjoying it. Please continue to keep the extra cheese 'extra'! Yum.

So, former employee here. James will "round up" on totals, treats people with the utmost disrespect and sells a subpar product. I would never recommend anyone coming here, the food is bland and majority of his customers are seniors. Also, he attempted to make me work 21 days straight with no day off before I quit. He is also refusing to pay me my final check of 300$.

Best pizza I have had since moving from NYC, and great delivery service. I will always order from them.

So, good we doubled up and had seconds. it's it's melt your your mouth Pizza deliciousness.

Excellent food, atmosphere and also clean place. Owner very nice and helpful. Love soup and Hawaii pizza. I recommend it.

The food, service and atmosphere was so professional. Everyone was so friendly and welcoming, the eggplant was delicious and divine.

Delicious they know how to make a proper slice 😋

All Star Pizza.. who made it? Wayne Gretzky, Shaquille O’Neal and Pete Rose? Great pie, but $$$$, (laughter, more laughter).

This is hands down the best pizza in all of South Florida and probably in the entire state! If you want REAL pizza you better come go to All Stars

Since Mikes Pizza in Deerfield closed I have been looking for good Pizza. I found it really good!

This was our first but not last visit to this restaurant. Their pizzas come in only one size, large. I called in my order and went to pick it up 15 minutes later. When I arrived, James, the owner was at the cash and found my order quickly. Our pizza, Meal Lovers ($24.10) was delicious. Not greasy at all and loaded with ingredients!! I understand that they have been around for a very long time and this is probably due to the quality of their pizza. Don’t want to be disappointed, order your pizza here. Parking is not a problem and they offer outside/inside seating. Enjoy.

Best pizza I've ever had in the US!

Older gentleman behind counter, shaved head, mustache, not a good front man. Attitude was terrible. I seem to have bothered him coming in to get my pizza while he was chatting with the other guys. No hello, just stared at me when he was ready. OK, bye bye Allstar on Military Trail, Deerfield

The people that work there are so disgustingly rude. Would never go there again.

Sorry but this is the worst of all the All Star locations we have experienced, and we have tried quite a few of them, especially the ones in Parkland and Coconut Creek. The guy that works the counter is so stale and dry with a terrible manner, they need a better personality in the front. Then he always says they don't take Amex because of the higher fees, when every one of their locations has never questioned the American Express card. The food is ok, could be a lot better. I just think they need to improve a lot and it would be so much nicer of a place to get linch or pizzas and subs. I would have given them 3 stars, but that guy who works the register really kills the experience.

Friendly staff and great pizza. Fun little lunch spot to buy by the slice.

Chewy dough , bland sauce nothing about it was good . Got mozzarella sticks and honestly was some of the worst I’ve ever had waste of money really , it was like cheap cheese sticks rolled in unseasoned bread crumbs . I’ve had frozen pizza and mozzarella sticks better quality .

I have ordered take out a handful of times, always happy with it.

Hands down best Alfredo spinach pizza, may be pricey but if your looking for real authentic Italian pizza flavors this is the joint, a real crowd pleaser, iyc you're looking for your taste buds to dance around in your palate, 😋🤩😍🥰

Not trucker friendly when it comes to delivery. They made it seem impossible to deliver to an over the road truck driver. Establishments like this seem to forget the truck drivers haul their products down to FL.

Stopped by here to grab some pizza and was not disappointed. The pizza was delicious and hot plus I love that they had a bar with a variety of spices in shakers. Would def recommend stopping by to grab some slices for lunch or a whole pie

I ordered 2 subs (hoagies I’m from Philly) they had no choice of bread, fine. But they had nothing but lettuce n tomato to put on a sub WHAT!?!?! No onions no green pepper no hot peppers no spinach nothing but provolone cheese. They put no requested oil/vinegar or salt/pepper BIG FAIL OH did I mention 2 dubs with Turkey cheese let.Tom cost me 25$ NEVER AGAIN **Hate to taste their non existent topping pizza!!!!

Horrible place owner wants to argue more than do his job. People shouldn’t eat at a place the owner dislikes as well

My husband and I love the other All Stars location, not sure if these are franchise or both own by the same people but this location was quite disappointing. We walked in and stood there for several minutes without being acknowledged. The staff were among themselves chatting behind the counter with one of them showing something on their phone. When they finally realized we were standing there waiting one of the three gentleman walked over to the register to take our order and just as I was going to say what I wanted he answered the phone. Didn’t say anything just picked up the phone that had just rung and proceeded to take their order. We wanted to get the lunch special and got there three minutes before 3pm, by the time they took our order it was 3:05 and they didn’t even honor the lunch special! 1) we were waiting there first & 2) we were dinning in, does this not matter? I would have appreciated if they had taken our order first since we patiently waited instead of answering the phone. One of the men noticed we were irritated and came over to take out order. Once we paid and finished, I saw the other one that was on the phone wiping his face, had picked his nose and then touched everything around him before tossing the dough up in the air. He did NOT wash his hands before this, I repeat HE DID NOT WASH HIS HANDS and I just watched him pick his nose! I immediately was turned off and did not want to eat there, maybe this stuff happens behind the scenes, I sure hope not but I don’t want to see it happen in front of me. We had already paid for our food minutes before so I literally watched the other gentleman make our pizzas, he was way more responsible but seriously that was disgusting. The pizza was good and so were the mozzarella but I was too grossed out to even finish my food and just threw it away once we left. I will not be returning to this location. It takes a lot for me to leave bad reviews, I don’t like leaving them but I don’t like having bad experiences either and this was a bad one for me.

Ordered from slice app pizza was delivered on time but, I ordered a Sicilian ultimate pizza Which was 32+ dollars with tip and delivery fee Received a medium sized thin crust pizza with the right toppings but wrong size and crust. I believe the price differential is over 10 dollars. Had I not prepaid I might have sent it back and ate something else Not a fan of thin crust and pizza a bit bland Was too tired and hungry to send it back and risk another bait and switch. A shame they pulled that Could be app mistake but before delivery I checked the app and saw they had the correct one. Saw they had a stuffed too would have ordered a couple of them tomorrow if not for being ripped off tonight

Been a customer for 15 years. Received a pizza tonight and it was the worst I have ever eaten from there. I called and complained and he tells me first time any one complained. LIAR LIAR LIAR. He refused to do anything about it. Never buying there again.

They say it’s “New York Style” NOT!! I had the round pie & the slice size was 1/3 of NY pizza slice. The favoring is okay, nothing amazing. This review is for New Yorkers only if you’re from another state I’m sure you will enjoy it. The place itself is nice & inviting; staff were friendly & courteous. (Deerfield Beach location)

Thank you for a yummy chicken parm sub.

The service was great, the food affordable, and THE BEST WHITE PIZZA I’ve EVER had and I’m from NYC!

Other than Primanti Brothers pizza, this is the only place I even bother to get a quality pie from. They also have a spot in the Pompano flea market. - I drive there all the time just to get 2 slices and a root beer.🥰

I'm sorry villagers They call all of rude and demanding. Isn't that stereotyping?? Asking from a White... Single Mom.. Catholic..

Delicious thin crispy New York style Pizza

Friendly staff,great Calamari,The BLT pizza is beyond delicious,fantastic!!

Wings and pizza, both were killer. I am from NY and if want real pizza in FL this is the place

One word FANTASTIC!!!! this place is Absolutely Delicious... If your looking to totally satisfy your taste buds All Star Pizza in Deerfield is the place to go 🤗

We like All Star a lot. The food is very good, the portion sizes are generous, and the prices are reasonable. I usually walk in and order and then wait for it to be prepared. I recently tried online ordering and that worked well, but incurs a "technology fee" added by the platform they use. I'll just walk in and order or phone it in going forward.

Excellent pizza and less expensive than other local pizza places! My Mom was born in Italy & my Mom loves their pizza! Friends help support this local business survive the "after pandemic effects" Excellent sauce, excellent dough, EXCELLENT PIZZA! See you soon James! Peggy

Food was great... Delivery was professional

My husband brought home a Philly Cheesesteak pizza that was delicious even though it was cold. Stopped by on Sunday afternoon for subs. The bread was toasted to perfection and the chicken parm was perfect. The tuna melt was wonderful. Just the right amount of each ingredient. We ate in. Will be returning. As a side note the restroom was spotless.

Love the food but employees to serious not friendly

Great place, tasty food, and awesome service!!!

Food was awesome Pizza was so delicious. They have great specials.

Favorite and authentic NY style pizza in Deerfield Beach! Always friendly service and prompt delivery!!

Great pizza. Ready right on time and quick. The neighbors were drooling as I walked by.

Great cheese pizza. I'm going to order from here now

This is the best Pizzeria in the State of Florida hands down pans up!!!

Large cheese pizza good, but over price compared to other pizza places

I had for the first time the other day and it was absolutely amazing I love the mushroom onion and pepperoni. This is definitely one of the best pizza places in the area.

Great pizza!! I order the Margarita pizza delicious!! Thanks guys!

Clean place. Excellent quality of food. They are following CDC regulations at all times.

We order from here regularly. Food is consistently good. Delivery is fast and friendly. We love the Hawaiian pizza.

It's ok, Cannoli are the best around, pizza ok but needs to be more crispy . Workers very nice, convenient location. Quick & easy service !

We get this pizza every week. It’s not an easy thing pleasing a northerner when it comes to pizza but this place is consistently good every single time. Their wings are crispy which I’m a huge fan of and they’re always very quick to deliver. Can’t say enough good things about this place.

Awesome pizza and great service!!! I will definitely return again soon

Male own is very rude he hung phone on me. I was not rude but he did he thinks he is better than every body els. I ate in his place with family for lunch and it was not all that I ask for owner and was told he is not here now I left my phone number never received call back.

Consistently great pizza! I have been dining here for over 12 years.

Great food and pizza! Great and friendly guys working there. And they are fast at getting the food to you.