Anomaly Sourdough Craft Pizza in Manhattan - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Damn some of the most unique ingredients and delicious tasting pizzas I've had! Do plan on trying another sometime soon. Must be ordered in anticipation on Tuesday or Wednesday before the Friday they cook it in.

We love anomaly! My husband and I decided to have a staycation for our anniversary and hit all of the local Manhattan gems. The date night special here did not disappoint! Highly recommend

Didn’t know what to expect but was pleasantly surprised! We did the date night special with two pies and a dessert. The food was fantastic and the service was the same. I said I would arrive at 5:45 and was a little early. The food was at my vehicle by 5:40. We’ll definitely be back! Highly recommend Anomoly Pizza!

This is definitely the best food I’ve had in Manhattan and potentially the best pizza I’ve ever had. Really cool flavors and the crust + honey butter is to die for.

This place is awesome! I ordered the chimichurri steak pizza and it was top notch. They even let me pick up my pizza early because I had something come up. It took less than 5 minutes to bring out my pizza when I texted to let them know I was in the parking lot. The flavor was everything I hoped for.

Their pizza is unique and flavorful, for a great price too! Would highly recommend trying Anomaly out if you get the chance. Service is above and beyond!

Very yummy pizza! Got two of their pre made options, both great and two create your own. All awesome flavors and fresh yumminess!

We decided to try Anomaly after seeing several posts about them on Facebook. Their pizza was amazing and I could eat that crust/dough every day! Definitely give them a try.

We had our first experience with Anomaly Sourdough Pizza this evening. We ordered the Chicken Pesto pizza - loved it! It was delicious! We will definitely order again. 🍕

This was probably the best pizza we've ever had. All 3 kinds we tried we awesome but the elote pizza was so unique and delicious! Our kids even ate all their pizza crust which never happens, we will be ordering again!

Amazing crust - check. High quality ingredients - check. Promo code for two delicious pizzas - check. I'd recommend the carnitas y elote pizza with honey butter (another game changer). So glad to have them in MHK!

Best pizza around! Definitely worth trying.

Great pizza; it's clearly an effortful and intentionally crafted meal. The process of ordering is unique (clever really), but doesn't get in the way of the experience. Tried a few, all we're good,, but the Carnita was my favorite...corn on pizza...you should try it!

My family and I really loved this pizza! The crust is absolutely fabulous, yummy toppings and the service was great. We can’t wait to try more!

This pizza is amazing. Artfully crafted and different than any other pizza in Manhattan! Highly recommend!!

So much flavor and sooo freaking delicious! I think I've found my new favorite pizza! Best pizza in KS!!

Excellent pizza! The dough is amazing and top notch toppings

Absolutely delicious Pizza! Excited to try all the flavors. Definitely worth ordering ahead of time, crust is amazing. Highly recommend!

This place is the best kept secret in Manhattan. Their pizza has the freshest ingredients and the sourdough crust is to die for! It reminds me of the pizza in Italy.

We absolutely love everything about Anomaly!!! High quality ingredients, unique flavors, and amazing crust. I’ve traveled to a lot of places and tasted many artisan pizzas - this ranks right up there with the best of them. Plus it’s run by some really great people! We will be regular customers here for sure!

Before this place I've never had Sourdough pizza. Now that I have, I am disappointed whenever I get normal crust pizza.

Seriously the best pizza ever! Crust is so fabulous no one left a morsel uneaten. So much better than regular pizza & topped in unique combinations. Never had anything like it!

What a Friday night treat! The sauce was so balanced and flavorful and the sourdough crust was surprisingly light. Definitely recommend to try out, and an awesome addition to the Little Apple!!

Ah-mazing. Best pizza I’ve had, maybe ever. Highly recommend - counting down the days until we order again. The pizza Manhattan has been needing!!

The best and most unique pizza I have probably ever tasted. The people at Anomaly genuinely care about you and your pizza experience. Highly recommend!

This is special pizza. Very unique. Everything is made from scratch—even the pesto. They’ve perfected the sourdough crust, and all the toppings are gourmet. Our favorites are the rib eye chimichurri and the carnitas. So delicious!

Anomaly pizza is exceptional pizza , they use only the best ingredients always fresh and the sour dough crust sends it over the top. Flavors are perfect with the best balance and blend. Also the crust has the perfect bite. It is pure Art.You can tell that Matt, Brandon and Lynette care about people by how much thought and love they put in their pizza and business!!

Some of the best pizza I've had! The Chicken Pesto is one of my favorites!

Amazing flavor! I can’t say enough about this pizza. Fresh ingredients!! I’ve had the chicken pesto genovese and the ribeye chimichurri and I don’t know which is my favorite. The crust is also so good!

The crust was amazing, unique to this area. The toppings also provide a one-of-a-kind experience.

This is some of the best pizza I've ever had (and I lived in Chicago for 9 years!!) Fresh, unique ingredients and amazing crust. Highly recommend

I have tried almost all their pizzas and I can honestly say that there is not one that I don’t like! My personal favorite is the carnitas, but a close second is the ribeye chimmy-churry. If your looking for a one of a kind taste made by an amazing group of people Anomaly is the place for you!!!

It was GREAT! My family and I really enjoyed their great pizza!! We LOVED the chewy and flavorful crust, and all the gourmet toppings! She even made a special Pesto for my daughter who is allergic to pine nuts. We did not see any pieces left behind! (I usually leave some crust, but Anomaly’s crust is too good to miss!)

Fantastic flavors and chewy tasty crust across four different pizzas tonight - a home run! Sourdough flavor isn’t too strong, and overall pizza experience felt Italian, with unique flavors like carnitas and chicken pesto. Our family loved it.