Antonio's New York Style Pizza in East Palatka - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Oh my goodness, I think Helen Keller could have made better food. The lasagna if that's what it was called, it looked like sausage balls over some kind of pasta with a ton of mozzarella cheese hiding the content. And the chicken parmigiana, if you are vegetarian get this. I couldn't find the chicken. And the mozzarella cheese as so covered on the top that it resembeled chicken. And the pasta. I think I got 2 fork fulls of spaghetti that was mocked by all the cheese covering the evidence of a lazy cook who wanted to close and not even work labor day. He should have stayed closed. Don't Google best lasagna in palatka because you will get him as an option, well Google you lied.

Got charged $17.54 for 1 pepperoni calzone. The guy definitely over charge me, i told him and he gave me a receipt for $15.99 its still overpriced.

Awesome place! Have gone here since it opened in 2008, everyone was great.

I have ordered here for years and every time it's delicious and Hot and a good potion 😋

Apparently he's not opened until 9 o'clock there's a call at 830 to order a pizza and I was told that already closed it down For the night

Delicious, very fair priced pizza and fast, friendly service

Good food and friendly employees.

I ordered pizza from them one night, the delivery driver was so lazy that instead of bringing the food to the door, he spent 15 minutes in the driveway honking his horn before finally getting out of his car to actually deliver the food. When he did come up to the porch area to deliver the food, he didn't even knock on the front door. The delivery driver's name is Brian, please request that he is not your delivery driver, I spoke with management afterwards and was told that I would receive some type of credit for the incident, but when trying to redeem it I was told it didn't exist essentially. Pizza is great, customer service sucks

Horrible food!! Everything there is frozen nothing homemade and expensive for what it is. I should have stuck with my gut instincts when that restaurant is always empty.

Read the negative reviews. They are true. Pizza and salad horrible. Called to complain, they were rude, uncaring and hung up on me. I will be sure to tell everyone I know not to order from Antionio's.

This small gem is am awesome place to eat! The staff were nice and the food was really good!

Been a customer since 2017, pre and post COVID, their doors are still open. Actually they built a new building nearby and plan to relocate shortly. I have had less than 5 star experiences here, I haven't found the perfect restaurant that doesn't. I am posting now due to my experience last night with a medium supreme pizza. It was hands down one of the best pizzas I have had anywhere. I had leftovers for lunch, still wonderful. Can't wait to dine at the new location.

Best pizza in the area, real food served hot and made to order. Small dining area with friendly atmosphere

I usually come in for a ten inch but like a couple days ago I discovered they deliver to me I was like whatt I ordered from them yesterday like always the food was great and the service even better I’m just sorry I couldn’t tip more the delivery driver went above and beyond when she didn’t have to love the place and the people I’ll definitely be ordering more

This place is just rude. Corrupt owner overcharging for delivery of pizza, overcharging for the pizza and a small salad ($30 1 small pizza and salad). NEVER WILL I ORDER FROM THIS PLACE !!!!

Best lasagna from Jax To Daytona. Service ia great food is even better. Anytime im in palatka stopping here is a must. Food always hot and fresh. Lifetime customer as long as they are in business.

My fiance and I drove up from FL heading to Nashville and I was dying for 🍕. Found Antonio's and I am glad I did. The pizza and wings are fantastic. Very nice people and great prices. Stop in for some good food.

Amazing pizza. Even those of us that only wanted one piece ate two large pieces. The cook was amazing. Very friendly. Even took a homeless man out some food. We would totally go here again.

Was a delivery order and they were quick and very nice. Not only did Beth bring pizza, but also thought enough to add plates and napkins.

Excellent pizza, good delivery and on time. Love this place for Pizza

Wow! We stopped in for spaghetti after driving all day, and as little mom and pop places can be hit or miss, we took our chances. First, the service is great, and you can tell the owner loves what he does. Second, the food is amazing! The sauce tastes like fresh tomatoes and just the right amount of spice. The meats are obviously blended in-house because the beef a the sausage, like the sauce, tastes like they are fresh and seasoned just right. The pasta was cooked just right (I don't like mushy spaghetti). Now for the cheese topping.......again, perfect! Nice even layer of mozzarella / parmesam mix broiled to a light golden color. Cost was less than expected, especially for the quality! Antonio's is an hour drive one way for us but is well worth it for the experience. We will be back!

Love this place.. great food great delivery service.. I hear they're opening a new location next to Musselwhite's in East Palatka.

Hands down the best pizza around. I'll happily drive from Gainesville just to have this pizza. 100% new York style

This pizza is very good, and every time we come through this area we always get a pie.

I don't like that I want to look at their website and I'm not allowed unless I allow them to go through my cookies

I ordered from here the day before yesterday. My total was $69. I woke up this morning and there was a five dollar tip left to the Driver I didn’t leave a tip I put zero on the receipt For tip and $69 and signed my name

My new 🍕 spot only wish I found this place years ago. Good food, good price, nice family owned pizza place. U will not be disappointed

I make a point to stop by when I am in the area because the pizza is amazing and the fellow that owns the place is very friendly.

Pizzas are VERY good!!! Love Antonio's!!

After calling in an order for 2 subs, I specifically asked for no mayo. This is the second time that this has happened and the guy who answers the phone cuts you off while trying to place your order. He messed up once before with another sub and once with a pizza order. Not recommended.

I grew up in NJ and then lived in NY State for over 20 years, so I know pizza! Antonio’s is the real deal! They are amazing and their food is on point! The Stromboli is to die for!

Ordered pizza to go. Their pizza is always fresh, hot, and delicious. Family friendly. Ready on time and as promised. Quality is definitely way above chain-type offerings.

Very best lasagna and spaghetti and meatballs. Staff and owners are fabulous!

Small hole in the wall place that is DELICIOUS. If you're on the fence about it, give them a try. We're from out of town and eat here every time we're in palatka.

The food here was incredible. Everything else could use some polish, but maybe the hole-in-the-wall feeling was their goal. I'd eat here again regardless.

Awesome food !! Staff is amazing! Dine in take out or delivery this place is just amazing!

Pizza, Gyro, and garlic knots all really good. Service was excellent. Employees super nice. Atmosphere could use a sprucing.

First time trying the food. Great food. Kinda of a lil wait but understandable. He was the only one working that day. Great place can't wait to go again

Best pizza around. Haven't tasted anything bad at this place. Calzones are delicious! A little pricey but worth it.

I don't normally write reviews but this is the worst pizza I've ever seen/ate. It's soggy with some cheap mozzarella all over it

One of the best mushroom, spinach, feta, light sauce pizzas I've ever had. Literally almost ate the whole thing myself. I can't even move now I'm so full.

Delivery was fast and food was good

Love the food here..we spend a couple months each year here near palatka and we always eat at antonios

This place is a gem hidden away. The food is awesome. Best thing ever is they deliver to Satsuma. I love this place and the Oner is authentic Italian. You will love it.

Delicious food and great service

I ate at Antonio's for the very first time on 12.28.22. I was in town and looking for an Italian restaurant to eat at and found them listed on Google. So I decided to give them a try. That was the BEST decision I could have made. Not only was the food amazing, so was our service. I had the BEST baked Ziti.. Omg!!! I loved it!! And I will definitely go back there to eat again. So if you live in Palatka, Fl or if you are just passing through town you should give them a try. I don't think you will be disappointed.. I hope that you enjoy the food as much as we did.

This was our second chance with this place and we got cheesesteaks.. the peppers,onions and mushrooms were raw, the was cheese in globs and not melted. Honestly spent way too much $$ just to throw it away. Just stick with the pizza.. it's decent.

Gave this place a second chance.. Got the same results. Crust was ok... Second time there was like no sauce on the pie. Tasted like a mozzarella sticks with no sauce .Was basically cheese bread .. Aweful .

Great food friendly service and fair pricing. Really enjoyed all

The food was awesome, definitely some authentic food

Best pizza, Stromboli's and Calzone's in town!!!

My wife and I with 2 grandkids stopped for lunch - we shared an antipasti salad, Italian sub, calzone & Hawaiin pizza - all were very good - the service was excellent, and we had a very pleasant experience dining in. We will definitely go back!!!!!!

Great services, delicious Chicken Parmesan

Ordered delivery and it was very timely. But what we ordered was not correct. And the delivery fee was astronomical.

Sort of a dive, but the pizza was delicious. No complaints on the food

Excellent. Small spot only 4 tables. I had the manicotti with beef and sausage. Fresh hot and delicious. On a Friday night they were constantly delivering. They are obviously popular with the locals. I do recommend this place if you are visiting.

Absolutely disgusting. I ordered a pizza and got it over an hour later. It was over cooked and cold. 38$ down the toilet. So I called the owner and he decided to ask me if I know how much food costs these days and that he can’t just give away free food. I simply wanted what I paid for. I will never go back. That is for sure. Very dissatisfied

Great pizza and lasagna. Super friendly and welcoming staff.

Best best pizza. Fresh ingredients! Lovely atmosphere. Can't wait to go back.

Stopped in for the usual slice-of-plain and slice-with-sausage. Impressed with the amount of cheese. A bit heavy on the sauce, but its good sauce.

We stopped by the dine in and enjoy one of their outstanding pizzas

We had a GREAT salad and GREAT service. Thank you !

Had pizza and wings. All food was very tasty.

Always good friendly service and awesome food I have never been disappointed

Delicious pizza by the slice! 2 was plenty.

For East Palatka, Florida this place is GREAT. Good pizza and Calzone

This place is a diamond in the rough. Be far the best pizza in town

Always friendly. Food is always superb.

East Palatka Antonio's is GREAT, always. Never had a problem. They are the only place that delivers to Hoot Owl Ridge w/o having to use an expensive delivery service. One service wanted to charge me $60 to deliver Burger King! Wth! So I'll pay Antonio's awesome employees to bring me pizza!

Very friendly very clean and Every dish I've tried there is Good the pizza is amazing

This was the most perfect Pizza that I've ever had

Ordered a large stromboli and it was excellent, fed 4 people.

We LOVE this pizza. Unfortunately it is about 1 1/2 hours from the house, but we stop each time that our travels bring us by. Food is great and staff is super friendly.

Very good pizza and customer service was great.

I have had a lot of pizza in a lot of places, even the middle of New York City and beyond a shadow of any doubt.... Antonio's pizza in east Palatka is by far the very best....I saved a piece to eat cold (that's the real test of a good pizza) OMG......it was awesome, made my eyes roll back. Try it, you'll like it!

First time going there. Great food and service!

Great 🍕. Definitely recommend the calzones too.

Love this eatery. Great food, awesome service. Treated like family here.

My Favorite pizza place in town and well worth the Money!! This place always has the Best Pizza and the owner is super nice. I just recently found out i can't have Mozzarella and he makes me a Delicious specialty pizza.

We ordered a pizza with toppings we liked as a build your own and we were only charged the price of a super supreme because we were told it was less expensive than adding up all the additional toppings. The pizza was excellent and the cook asked more than once whether we had everything we needed and if we liked it. It was fantastic and we will definitely be back!

Looking for New York style pizza ,at a local business,and on our way Home. found this gem! Antipasto,fresh and tasty.cheesesteak pizza,half no peppers and onions,and Chef marked it especially ! Guest service will set you above others! SHOP AND EAT LOCAL folks. These are your neighbors! When we trek to east coast again,definite stop! Mangia!

Absolutely Delicious! We had a Hawaiian Pizza, best pizza cooked in a brick oven, perfection.

They will make a garlic shrimp pizza and it was good.

Count on them to make an excellent pizza every time!

Great tasting pizza from a local pizza shop. They are one of the few that deliver to our neighborhood. The entire family enjoyed it during a recent pizza night. It can rack up though with toppings and specialty pizzas.

Awesome Pizza. Very friendly asked about manicotti not only explained also showed . When in the area definitely be back.

We love the 18" Hawaiian! We usually have it delivered, but we have eaten in a couple of times. The staff is friendly. They offer more than just pizza!

This is the best pizza I have ever tasted! We came always all the way from Georgia and we were not disappointed! It’s so freaking good, the white pizza especially was amazing. It’s a local small business and it deserves to stay a float. The workers were so freaking friendly and genuine, we asked to see a football game and this man worked tirelessly working the tv trying to find the game well after we said “stop it’s okay.” Seriously go here and buy this pizza, you will not be disappointed!

This is possibly the best pizza I've ever tasted! At first we thought it was odd that this guy manned the shop all alone (he was busy) but then as we discovered the guy had two other helpers but they were on deliveries. My wife and I are keen on moving to Palatka and this experience just moved us a little closer! Oh yes BTW this guy speaks broken English as his main language sounds Italian! AWESOME pizza! I'm moving!

Great food but no help for customer service.

Taste like New England pizza.. great

I was passing by on my way back home and I saw this pizza place and give it a try. Best decision ever!! Pizza was delicious I think I’ll drive 2 hours to get back another time is worth it. Also they are very nice and welcoming.

Great pizza place.. good friendly staff. Very accommodating to what I needed. I am a vegetarian and I got the pizza better than what I wanted.

Been to Antonio's before, they always have great pizza. The crust is perfect. Not too thick and crunchy crust. How to be back in my journeys to the Palatka area.

Pizza is Absolutely DELICIOUS, Excellent menu variety, restaurant is clean, cozy, friendly staff and a great place that you can feel comfortable bringing your family.

I really debated between four and five stars for this restaurant. It's not a corporate joint but owned by an Italian gentleman (Antonio), whose English is pretty good and way better than my Italian. The white cheese pizza with tomatoes and spinach is off the charts good. The sandwiches are really solid, n the iced tea is fabulous. The Supreme pizza is also great, but fairly heavy on the meat. The one flaw to me is the lack of a true veggie pizza on the menu. You can build one of course, but adding five $2 items to a $15 base pizza puts you at $25 for a simple veggie pizza. This is silly. Anyway, while the pizzas are not the cheapest in town, they use top-notch ingredients and the taste is fabulous. You pay for the good stuff, and the food at Antonio's is worth it.

They where very friendly and they were quick about getting my food out

Great pizza at great price love Antonio's New York Style Pizza

This is absolutely the best pizza in the greater Palatka area! It is so delicious!!! My favorite for sure! My whole family loves it! I get the vegetarian and their vegetables are fresh and tasty! These guys are authentic pizza makers. Enjoy!

Ate there for the first time today must say I was impressed. Great pizza!!