Benny Vitali's in Fredericksburg - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

HUGE slices of very tasty pizza. I'm a Jersey girl, and Benny's comes close to NJ/NY style pizza. Always a treat.

Love this place! The look, the feel the FOOD!

The pizza here's are enormous and worth.Every cent that you pay, this place probably goes in my top 5 pizzas that I've ever had in my entire life, I'm 45 an pozza is.one of.my fav food of course.They made it fresh had it out quickly. was so good...

I recently visited Benny's Pizza for the first time. I was told by a friend that you need to call an hour before you arrive to get your pizza without a long wait. We did that and only had to wait about 5 minutes before getting the pizza but did get a table (booth) There are only 5 booths but there is side counter eating. Come late there will be no booths. I really like this pizza. The crust is crispy but not overdone, and the edge is soft and chewy. It's chessy and has just the right amount of sauce. My only complaint is that it's too salty. If they could tone down the salt, it would be perfect.

Love this dive, the closest you can get to NY Pizza in Virginia

Went to Bennys not only for the pizza, but to see Joe, the cashier. He is always super happy to be there and brings a smile to my face just to walk in the restaurant.

Best vibe, amazing Pizza and overlord of selection of IPA's to choose from!

Very pleasant place to get a quick bite or a huge pizza pie. NY Style Pizza at its best. One slice is the equivalent to 2 or 3 silces from a national chain. And yes, the Pizza is definitely foldable. Looking forward to a return visit.

Very amazing pizza place all I have to say is try it for your self you won't be disappointed this pizza will make your tongue slap your Brian out 😂

We love coming here for a quick bite.

Always a great place to grab a slice. We ordered a couple of whole pizzas in addition to the catering for my daughter's wedding, and they did an excellent job. Pizzas were perfect, hot and fresh, ready exactly on time, and they even carried them to the truck for me. Thanks to the staff for such a great job!!

Bought 2 slices at 4pm. I believe these were left over from lunch. Poor quality. Seemed to be reheated twice after being cooked. Used to be better quality.

Funny lil place to get a good slice of pizza

OK New York style pizza but there's something funky-tasting about the crust. AND THE MUSIC IS TOO LOUD TO ORDER WITHOUT YELLING AT THE CASHIER! Seating is limited - probably why the music is so loud - annoy everyone to make them leave quickly.

Very cool place to hang out! Very great pizza! Incredible staff! What else could you ask for? Will be coming back and bringing others 😉

Great pizza and cool selection of beers!

Family loved these enormous slices. I had initially scoffed at the by the slice price, but it is well worth it. The dough is thin and crispy, the sauce delicious and ample without going overboard cheese. The trifecta of pizza attributes that I look for in my pie.

I could eat here once a day for a longgggg time!!! Beyond the nostalgic atmosphere and look this place hooks me up with exactly how I want my slice every time! Ask about the hot honey 🥵 🍯 and get it on your slice or the monthly special and enjoy the best in FXBG !

This is a swell place. Pizza slices bigger than your head, served on two paper plates, and the breading is oh-so perfectly crispy. The place is busy! and the staff handles it well.

This is Benny Vitali's place. He wants you to know

Great management & a quality NY slice.

The box shocked my son.. In a good way... We walked the pizza down the street thinking we could get jumped for it...Huge...And really good New York style pizza...

Third time getting pizza from this place and it’s still amazing. From the single slices to the ‘Pies’ (they are bigger then pies) they are extremely filling and honestly great for groups if you’re getting a whole pizza. Would recommend.

Awesome new York pizza had garlic and mushrooms the largest slice I ever had.. best flavor. All that and a cold orange fanta .. wonderful place so much to see on the wall s

I was really surprised by how large the pizza was and how there was virtually no flop when picking up the pizza! Probably one of the best pizza’s I have ever had in a long time! One pizza was definitely enough to fill me out and great place to take a group of hungry friends or family!

Local Pizza shop with Pizza. What you would expect! Hit the spot.

I was your first two pizzas out the door this morning. Thank you so much for your professionalism, service, and quality! Your team rocked it today, and you made my son's birthday the best imaginable! The pizzas were a hit! I'm looking forward to the next visit, thanks again!

After deciding to head out and enjoy lunch I chose to go back to this restaurant located downtown. Upon my arrival was able to fortunately get a parking spot close enough to walk to Bennys' pizza. This place has 2 customized pizza options every month and boy oh boy was I thrilled to get a seat and decided to dine in. Glad I did!

Being from NYC, this is the closest if not spot on from New York tasting pizza. The jumbo slice with the combo of good NYC tasting pizza and a good ambience, makes this the number one spot in Northern VA hands down!

Huge pizzas! The boxes for a whole pie is absolutely huge. I have to say being from Jersey it’s hard to find good pizza in this area Benny comes close to Jersey/New York pizza. You can buy pizza by the slice or a whole pie. It’s usually pretty crowded and it is a small place. There are bar seating and tables but they fill up quick

We really enjoyed the pizza! There aren’t many places to sit, only 4 booths, but people don’t linger so we were able to sit before our pizza was ready. Highly recommend!

Great, huge pizza, cool spot. Limited seating when it's busy.

It was festive and crowded. Pizza was great and it had a fabulous drink menu.

Pizza was ok, but they were blaring the devil's music at full volume. I couldn't hear myself fart. I grabbed one of the few tables and was immediately being eyed by rude, entitled Millenials in line who seemed to be expecting me to give up my table for them.

Best pizza by the slice. Pepperoni & extra cheese with a drink $8.

Exactly what a NY style slice should be. Got "The Tarantino" this time ... Delicious!!

Cool little pizza shop with huge slices

Ordered my pizzas for takeout as we had a limited time between appointments. When my order came it they gave it to another customer. When shown that they made an error, the waitress was well he can wait for the next pizzas to come out. Rather nonchalant about their mistake. Got my refund and left. This place is one I will avoid

pizza was good but close to no seating and the smell was off-putting but the pizza is unmatched in taste reminiscent of 99 cent new York pizza and if yk yk bc that stuffs amazing.

The pizza was delicious and the staff have their order taking workflow perfected. Customers weren’t waiting long during a very busy Saturday lunch shift, and everyone was calm!

Funky space with pizza crust made just right, not too think and not too thin! You only need one slice but will be tempted to order more!

One of the coolest places to go for Pizza in the area. Great beer and soda selections, and the slices are always awesome. Bring your appitite, they are BIG slices...for a seriously amazing price.

I loved the energy in here. And GOD the aroma is just 😙🤌🏼✨️. My friend brought me here and I just knew I would love it. And coming back feels like the first time every time. The employees are so nice and patient too. Absolutely 💯 love this place🫣💜👌🏼

Long wait but totally worth it! My hubby loves pizza so we drove an hour to check this place out. Delicious pizza. He’s a happy boy!

Don’t shoot the messenger, it’s just decent pizza. I know it’s oversized but it’s not crispy or cheesy enough in my opinion.

Huge pizza with perfectly done crust. Seating can be an issue but there is always City Docks, Market Square, or the new riverside park within walking distance to make a great outing.

Great little place with huge slices!! Limited indoor tables but the ambiance is lovely if you do stay.

Always busy and always good. If you plan to buy a whole pizza, call ahead and make sure it fits in your car.

The people who work here are amongst the best people in Fredericksburg, and therefore some of the best people in America. I've checked..

Biggest slice of pizza you will find!

I love this place, slices of pizza bigger than your face, and in old Fredericksburg, great staff and awesome atmosphere. And if you drove a car big enough, you can take home a full 42" pizza! Love it love it!

There service times have improved since last time I was there, and I wasn't disappointed then!

Local favorite with giant slices of pizza. Service is always great

I absolutely love Benny's and the employees! The pizza is just delicious and the employees are just amazing. I order from them a lot, and they always have my food ready on time with plates and cheese packets and they are just so friendly. The pizza is always crispy with melting cheese just, mhmmmmmm!

If you want a cheap pizza, go to Domino's or Little Ceasars. If you want a huge slice of super tasty pizza, go no further. I can't say enough good things about this place. This is, by far, my favorite pizza place of all time. I would eat here everyday, if I could.

Great tasting pizza, good folks, always packed for good reason, ... The huge slices are awesome 😎

Bennys is always a great choice if you are looking for a quick slice of pizza. This was our first time ordering a slice of their monthly option and it was one of my favorites! The pancetta and roasted pepper pizza was amazing. I kept going back for more bites! I want to go back one more time before the menu changes…. IT WAS THAT GOOD! Also they have an assortment of options for ipa’s for the beer lover.

Ambiance is that of a college pizza place. Busy in a a Saturday afternoon. Pizza was ok. Huge slices, which is cool (makes for a cheap lunch) but they aren't crisp. Sauce and pepperoni was pretty good, not spectacular but ok. Crust was just okay. Chewy. I'd go back, especially if I was in downtown and craving a slice.

Pizza is a little doughy. Can be more crispy and more on the sauce. Trying to be a NY slice, but still missing that extra to be that great pizza. Right now it's just good and presentation wise you'd think NY slice but than as you eat it. The more you realize it's still a Virginia style pizza.

Great place to pick up a pizza. Huge portions and fun flavors. Personally I’m not a huge fan of the crust that these pizzas come on, but that doesn’t stop me from getting them. If you haven’t eaten here, you have to. The people here are so nice and always make you feel welcome. I would highly recommend this place to anyone who loves pizza!

Cute little spot! Super busy! Huge slices of pizza! Taste amazing! Worth the wait

The pizza is huge and delicious! The service was great and everyone is so nice to talk to.

OMG! The hubby and I tried this place for the first time tonight! It was absolutely one of the best dishes I’ve had! It was a fired chicken cutlet with some sauce and well seasoned potatoes. Tim and Sidney provided excellence service. Hats off to the chefs!!!!!! We will be back ❣️

Pizza dough is salty and taste is so and so. The gimmick is that the pizza is very large. I thought this place was a small mom and pop shop but they have many locations which means its probably lost its touch.However the service is fast and friendly.

Great big slices and great prices!

The pizza is so delicious! Truly rare to find a place with pies that are this good! Come hungry cause the slices are HUGE. Great selection of beers and other N/A drinks as well. Staff are cheerful and seem happy to have you in. Will definitely be back.

Been coming here 4 years but my visit on Sunday was very very disappointing. In the past, Benny's had pizza that was very crispy. It had a nice flavored sauce with a lot of cheese along with the pepperoni and sausages. This time the pizza was half cooked. There was barely any sauce on this pizza and the cheese was almost non-existent. Very very disappointed. I don't know if they're under new management or if they have just gotten lazy, but it is not what it used to be and I won't be back. Little Ceasar's makes better pizza.

No better value around. Giant slices of pizza for $6.50 each. Pair that with a can of soda for $1.50, and you have the cheapest, high quality ingredients, filling meal around.

Giant giant slices of pizza. It is a busy place and the wait was a little ling but understandable due to the crowds. The pizza was good!

I was a lil disappointed this last trip... first, there wasn't very much topping on the pizza...2nd the bottom of the crust was burnt...3rd we had to ask 2x for the grated parmesan cheese to be refilled, all were empty! The bar where we had to eat ( no tables available) was dirty, I actually went in the restroom and got a wet paper towel to wipe the counter off before we sat to eat. So yea, I was less than impressed this last time!

Very busy when we went. The line was efficient, food out fast, very friendly staff. The staff worked so well together. If you haven't been go get your slice.

Disappointed. I ate here years ago and it was amazing! Recently came back and unfortunately it lacked flavor and just didn’t taste the same. Tasted blend and the crust was too doughy. Very unfortunate.

I wouldn’t say a true New York style pizza. Big portions good taste and good price. Nothing close to brothers pizza in the area. straight from queens cash only. If you know you know .

Small space with large pizza. The pizza is amazing and the service is even better. We love stopping by Benny's any chance we get for a slice or whole pie.

Not much to say, pizza was delicious and they had birch beer (soda) which was pleasantly surprising and good

The slices are huge and full of flavor!!!

Food---- got different slices to try. Phenomenal. Really great pizza that holds up well. Service---i would say that this place has a more casual vibe and is a fun place to unwind and hang out with friends, so not much "service" happens. But what little there is, is polite. Atmosphere---as stated above; the casual and fun vibe is a hit. Music, cold beer, no complaints. Only issue is its small, busy so order take out ahead, if eating in expect a wait. And may have difficulty hearing your company due to the volume of the music.

NY native. This is the only pizza shop worth going to in the Northern Virginia area.

Biggest an best pizza u can get love kids love little on high end but worth it

I mean it’s good pizza, I guess. If you’re waiting thirty minutes for a slice, what’s the point?

Definitely some good Pizza! The pizzas are #HUGE and a piece is like bigger than your head! If you haven't been there you're definitely missing out.

Great food, good customer service, and quick service. As close to a NY style slice of pizzs as you're going to get in VA. The pepperoni slice is 👨🏾‍🍳 💋.

Refused to let me order over the phone. They said I can only place an order there but I waited 30 minutes for my food standing. Their system demands a tip regardless if u want to leave one in cash. Barely any seating for how much business they get. They have two counters to eat with no chairs. Food was cold by the time I got it as it was sitting on the counter waiting to be packaged for too long. Terrible customer service. WOULD NOT RECOMMEND. Find another pizza place for the same taste just because it's a big pizza they lack everywhere else.

We absolutely love this pizza. Great atmosphere. A must when we come to visit.

The absolute best place to get suds and a slice. Or two. I can't drive by the place. I love it. The hostess is so fine. Best looking service in the Burg I'm back for more in 2024! Love Benny's.... Let's get wrecked and have a great lunch at the same time. Let's roll!!!!? Best pizza anywhere Period

This place is so great! A beautiful old building with a cool tin ceiling and antique truck memorabilia on the walls. Grunge rock on the sound system. Efficient and friendly staff. And the pizza is excellent. I wish I could give it six stars.

Great atmosphere...in a beautiful old building with a tin ceiling. Grunge rock playing on the sound system. Excellent, friendly service from the super attractive staff member. Huge, delicious pizza. Highly recommended.

By far the best pizza in Fredericksburg VA. Update, still the best...

크고 따뜻하고 맛있었어요. 가격은 한국에서 가장 부유한 도시인 강남에서 먹는 가격이랑 맞먹어요.

Biggest slices I have ever seen! Even bigger whole pies!

Benny Vitali's is the biggest pizza 🍕 I javelin ever had. It is a fun place and the staff are dedicated to providing a great product! Well done!!!!

I've been here many times and they never fail me. Love the scene the atmosphere and people. I love bringing my friends from out of town here. They all always love it.

Very happy with the taste and how quick the pizza was done.

Great service here! Yummy pizza! Stop by for a jumbo slice!

Gem of a spot. No shortcuts. Classic feel. Exceptional pizza.

Great pizza and better service :)

This is hands down the best pizza in Virginia. Coming from NYC, this is just like a NY slice. Great price for a great pizza. 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼😁 12/04/2023 Popped in for some pizza cravings. This is truly the best pizza out here. 😁

One of the better pizza places in the old town Fredericksburg area. NY style pizza with slices equal to 3 regular slices. A whole pie will feed a family of 10. Can't go wrong with pepperoni or cheese.

hmmm. never had “pizza” quite like it. not a good thing.

...moving to area for military duty, stopped to order...attendant looked at me three times never acknowledged me then tried to say she never saw me...customer service?