Brooklyn Pizzeria in Gulfport - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The best NY style pizza on the coast, hands down. The big guy that's usually there seems like he doesn't want you there, doesn't need you there, and has zero desire to strike up a conversation. He's not rude or anything, he's just there. I like that. It's as NY as it gets👍

Amazing food and excellent service. Was greeted with a smile as soon as we walked in. Staff was very friendly and food was amazing

As someone from New York, doesn't taste like Brooklyn or even New York pizza. That being said, it wasn't terrible, just not up my alley. Sauce wasn't good. Bland and probably put too much because my slice tasted soggy. Too much dough for me and the little bit of crust I did try was too hard. Tasted like reheated fries that hardened up again. I want my pizza with a crispy bottom, not a stale taste. Also skip the garlic knots, tasted like greasy dough. Knots should have the consistency of a baguette. Slight crunch on the outside, nice and fluffy on the inside. These knots achieved neither. The toppings barely saved the pizza.

One of the best pizzas that I have eaten on the coast. Loved the crispy thin crust.

Delicious pizza and calzones. Small business popular with locals. You may have a longer wait than chain restaurants but that’s because it takes time to make real food!

Great food and fast service. They are very professional

Nothing like fresh, handmade food!

Delicious & good prices. Even have cauliflower crust for gluten free pizza. Highly recommend. Feels like an old fashioned pizza parlor.

We drove from Agricola to visit my favorite pizza place about an hour one way. We got there after 7pm on Saturday. It was kinda busy, but after the dinner rush. We ordered a pie and sat and waited for them to call out when it was ready. They never called. After 40 minutes, my wife went to the counter. They thought it was a to go order. My wife bought the box to the table and it was the worse pie I ever saw. None of the usual cooks were there. There were a bunch of teenage kids behind the counter. The pizza was folded almost in half when they put it in the box. Cheese slid off the side and was piled up on the back of the box. The bottom of the pizza was black and burnt. This is not the same place it was a few months ago. We got a refund and left totally disappointed. Not sure where the good cooks were but if you go in and just see the teens behind the counter, do yourself a favor and leave!

So my first night living in Gulfport, and I was looking for a good pizza to be delivered. I saw them on line with good reviews and called. They told me that they DIDN'T deliver. So I said I'd pass tonight. (I had just moved in, and was exhausted). Then I realized how close I was and decided that I'd order and pick it up. Called and called. No answer. Called from my husband's phone and they answered right away. I wanted not only a pizza, but a Stromboli and a salad. Apparently I didn't talk fast enough to explain what I wanted because I was hung up on AGAIN! I don't know how good they are! But why should I give them a second chance? Ugh. I moved here for the friendly people!

What a pleasant surprise! Being from Philly, I know my pizza and this place is legit! 🍕 🍕 🍕

First time ever eating here and was some of the best pizza I’ve had. Everything was cooked to perfection. We only got pizza but it was good. We ordered a large and it was so big that it looked like an extra large. Definitely worth trying for the pizza.

Save the trip to New York. You can go right here and get the best pizza you've had ever period absolutely loved it

Literally the best pizza on the coast

The pizza is some of the best on coast. Can’t go wrong coming here.

The pizza was ok, but the wings were the worst I ever tasted. And I'm pretty sure they were precooked.

Philly cheese steak sub is the best loved it 😋😋😋😋

I love the steak - n- cheese subs! Yummy! And the pizza, too!

Never had bland pizza before, but definitely had it today. Cheese sticks are definitely frozen, not made in house, and have no flavor. Pizza was not that great, no flavor, and crust was super tough, the item my husband ordered was full of ground beef but didn't even have the flavor of any salt, pepper or anything. Definitely disappointed, didn't even finish our food. Will not be back. Tea was also old and nearly sour.

Loved it!!! Closest thing to home ...Brooklyn Ny..in the house!!!!

Great New York Style pizza in its original slender. It is a must and all will not be let down.

When traveling, we always try to find a good pizza joint and this place did not disappoint! Pizza had great flavor. The staff was nice and the place was very clean. Next time we are in the area, we will definitely go back!

When we travel, we always look for a hole-in-the-wall pizza place. We found a great one this time. The garlic knots were tasty, and the pizza was scrumptious. We ordered a medium pepperoni, sausage, and beef. It was much larger than I expected. If we go back to Biloxi, we will definitely hit this pizzeria up again.

Dined in. Food was hot, fresh and didn’t take long to get. I was surprised I could get it by the slice and it was not expensive. Free refills on my drink.

I love this place! It reminds me of the time I spent in Connecticut. The calzones are amazing, they melt in your mouth.

Great food and great service. Never a bad experience.

I love this place for EVERYTHING except the wings!

Really good food, give it a try!

Best NY style pizza on the coast.

Best Pizza! Always great service.They offer Cauliflower crust Pizza on the menu. Family member states it's the Best Cauliflower pizza !! Can get pizza by the slice , too. A lot on the menu to choose from. Comfortable atmosphere. Family owned business. Highly recommended. 🍕

Excellent NY Style pizza..our first time trying them and this will now be our regular pizza place!

Great pizza the old school way. Order and pickup at the counter. Salad was fresh and the garlic knots were awesome. We had the pepperoni pizza and the sauce was very good, the pepperoni was delicious.

There's not too much to say when you're the best pizza on the coast...

Great place. The best tasting, fresh pizza I have found across the South that comes the closest to actual Brooklyn, NY Pizza. Brings back so many memories growing up in Brooklyn, NY. I will definitely be back weekly,possibly 3 times a week!!

Best pizza on the Coast, and it's been that way since '93.

We loved it, great pizza and very good prices!

Love the local pizza joint vibe! Their calzones are the best!!!! Get extra ricotta you’ll be glad you did. Prices are good.

The pizza here is sublime. True New York pizza - the best I've had in the Gulf Coast area so far. Cheezy, thin crust, greasy. Fold it up, baby! There's been some improvement recently with the service and the atmosphere. The staff are a bit friendlier and the vibe feels fresh and uplifted. You may as well be in New York with the storefront location, laminate booths, table, and counter space. Love it. Grab a slice and a beer sometime!

Staff was incredibly friendly and the food was amazing.

The food was hot but not as good as before. The service was wonderful and cashier friendly.

31 years of proud SERVICE Owner actually came in at tail end of my Visit.... Somewhat lengthy Coversation, used same recipes for years. EXCELLENT Food

Very good pizza. I just got a slice of pepperoni. It was a large slice and very filling.

Pizza is a very individual and personal food of taste. This pizza was not I prefer pizza to taste.

Delicious pizza found by friends from NY wintering in Mississippi!

Decent take on a east coast pie and knots. Sauce and flavor were on point, but the crust was just okay. Knots didn't have a good rise.

Stopped in for a late lunch around 2pm. I ordered the lasagna, and my friend ordered the eggplant. Both came with garlic knots, which were fantastic. His eggplant was on top of spaghetti with meat sauce, and he also had a small salad. Both meals were very good, and we ended up getting go-boxes to take our leftovers. This is a place where you order at the counter, and your food is served on disposable dishes. So, it's definitely not a fancy establishment but has the tasty food of a much higher priced restaurant. Highly recommend it!

2 massive slices and a fountain drink for 10 even. Good for one fat person (me) or 2 skinny people to share 😂

We ate here while in Long Beach It is the Best Pizza! Will for sure be back when we come back down!

Love their homemade local vibes. Great marinara sauce.

Great pizza! Just like we had in Brooklyn and Manhatten!

Authentic New York City pizza. Just like pizza from my old neighborhood in Queens. I have ordered pizza here for last 20 years. STILL BEST pizza in the gulf coast. Love their calzones and strombolies. Only wished they had Cicilian pizza on the menu.

Never had a bad pizza! Always the best!

Best pizza on the gulf coast hands down ! The stromboli is the best I've ever had!

Order a pizza here and it was wrong location...called in to pay because it was my mistake...they said they would take care of it and not charge me...that's great customer service...thank yoi

2nd time eating here but first time dining in. As before, staff was very nice and friendly. Pizza was great. The garlic Knotts on the other hand were fantastic. Only thing I would suggest and I could be wrong but the garlic in the Knotts did not seem fresh. They were loaded with oil and garlic but just didn't see fresh. Bread was fresh and dense. Definitely recommend trying.

The food is good. The way things are set up leaves something to be desired. The service was a bit slower than I expected for it to be such a popular place.

Outstanding New York style pizza (and GF too!) I WILL BE BACK

Locally owned pizza place for over 35 years. It has great pizza and steak & cheese sandwich!!

The best pizza place on the Mississippi gulf coast hands down.

Don’t be fooled by appearances…pizza and legit New York Italian deliciousness served in an unassuming strip mall. The filled parking lot and the line of people at the counter should indicate how good Brooklyn Pizza really is…salads, pizza by the slice or a whole pie, sandwiches, entrees - there’s something for everyone.

Stopped in from out of town. Brooklyn's was recommended, and it did not disappoint for a quick lunch!

Horrible service and waste of money

Been coming here since a kiddo, still the best pizza South of New York

Best Pizza ever! I drive from LONG BEACH just to get it! Prices are AWESOME! CAN'T BEAT THE FLAVOR AND THE FACT THAT YOU CAN ALSO JUST GET A SLICE AND THAT'S ENOUGH CURB YOUR HUNGER BUT MAKES YOU WANTING MORE! IT'S A MUST TRY!!

I'm from the north east and this place hangs with the best of NYC pizza. Fair prices and delicious food. Definitely gets crowded at meal times so plan accordingly.

I’ll start by saying that their pizza really is good. But tonight was the third time I’ve ordered pizza to go and the third time I was disappointed. We called our order in of just two pizzas at 5:45 and they said 45 minutes to an hour. I show up at 6:45 go to the counter to tell them I’m here for my order and paid $40 plus a tip then after I’ve paid they tell me it won’t be ready for another 35 minutes. So I leave and go home. Then I come back at 7:20 only to be told my pizza still wasn’t ready so I had to sit and wait another ten minutes. So not only did I pay $20 per pizza and also tip them for a pick up order but I had to wait almost 2 hours for the food and this is the third time I’ve had a similar situation happen.

Always great food only had 1 mistake on an order

Been coming here for 3 years and this is the best pizza I’ve had on the coast, I can’t go anywhere else. This place never misses!

Brooklyn Pizzerias Pizza is great and they have a lot of other good items on the menu!

Don't get the hype. Good pizza sauce but nasty crust and terrible pesto bites

Decided to try this pizza restaurant. I ordered a slice of cheese pizza and I’ll tell you what it was awesome I was there at lunchtime, even though they were very busy. My order was quick and complete. They have a big menu with plenty of specialty dishes to put you in that Italian, New York atmosphere on the coast meal Food is fresh and pizza dough is tossed before your eyes imagine that. Depending on the time of day, parking in front of the restaurant may not be available, but there is plenty of parking with just a short distance to walk. You can dine in or carry out or order ahead for pick up. Plenty of seating available if you choose to dine in. it is a walk up counter to order. They will call your name when your order is ready. Oh yes and bring cash unless you want to pay a little extra for using plastic.

Always a hit what you want from a pizza place from the atmosphere to the people great food and you can expect its gonna be good every time

SO good. The essence of small, mom'n'pop pizza joint. Pizza took a while, but was worth the wait. DO try a drizzle of catalina/red french dressing on your pie!

I have live on the Gulf Coast for about 6 years now. I am from Ny and every time I get a little home sick to go to Brooklyn because it’s the closest thing on the coast to any NY food. I was genuinely impressed the first few years here by the pizza. However, the last 3 times I have gone it’s been sub par. Yesterday was the last time I’ll visit sadly. We got a Hawaiian pizza which had about 10 small pieces of pineapple on the entire thing. Very skimpy. Also got a pepperoni and banana pepper pizza and it was so over cooked my jaw hurt trying to chew it halfway through one slice. As someone in the restaurant industry I give places multiple chances to correct an issue. I’m sure if I called they would have done something for me but since the pizza being hard is happening about everytime now I didn’t bother to call. On top of the the younger kid working the front counter just seemed frazzled and seemed confused by my presence while I was up front like I was bothering him. I don’t know if it’s being too busy or understaffed but my jaw will need a chiropractor after the last couple visits. Definitely has gone downhill.

Absolutely love this pizza place. Great taste, HUGE slices, and at reasonable price too all inside a cool atmosphere 4.8/5 Crust: Crisp and satisfying Crust with a slight softening from toppings/sauce towards the center Cheese: Pretty quality stuff, greasy enough to soak up extra parmesan, but not too greasy where it pools Toppings: Decent toppings all around Sauce: Great taste, perfect amount Cost to value: 5/5. Usually buy by the slice, a whole pizza could practically feed a village Calzones here are also hard to beat

If I'm ever asked my favorite pizza joint... hands down, Brooklyn's pizza!!! I am in the mood to eat here any time, any day, and any company. There's always a slice and a beer with my name on it. The staff is always changing yet always recognizable. The pizza is imo better than actual pizza from Brooklyn, NY (I've tried). Although, I prefer to eat in because cold Brooklyn's is a jaw workout. 😅 Best of the best!

Unique establishment & best pizza on the coast! No one makes pizza like this!

I've been coming here for over a decade. We were previously stationed in Gulfport and this was THE pizza spot. I came back to visit recently and was trying to think of where to go to lunch and BROOKLYN WAS IT. I've lived all over, I've had pizza all over the place and this is HANDS DOWN my favorite. Pricing is very very fair and the pies are huge. And the cookies...listen. I'm a snob when it comes to chocolate chip cookies. Delicious. My husband and I used to call ahead to make sure they had cookies haha! Brooklyn, keep it up! I wish I wasn't across the country now, but know I will ALWAYS visit if I'm close! If you live here, you've GOT to try them!

This is the real deal...New York style pizza served up in an authentic atmosphere found in the neighborhood pizza shops of Brooklyn even down to the wonderful aromas greeting you upon entering. Crust is perfect, not too much sauce, just a great slice.

Best pizza in Gulfport! We always come here on vacation😊

Was able to have this today at my Job @ Philips Building Supply on 49. It's a amazing experience when you've had all the rest now having the Best!!! I can't speak for anyone else but myself. This is the place to eat at every so often when you definitely want Good Pizza!!!

Fantastic place, best Italian food in Biloxi hands down

What can I say, but.....It's Brooklyns!!!! Will always be our go to pizza when we are in the area 😋

Best NY pizza this side of NYC! Huge slices of pie and the calzones look amazing.

They lost our order so we waited for a while

The pizza is thin crust delicious. Great flavor fresh and delicious. The beer is really cold too.

Food is always fresh and customer service is great.

Best pizza on the MS Gulf Coast

New Yorker approved, authentic pizza and looks like a New York pizza place right down to the cups, if you are homesick, drop in.

Feels like an old school pizza place should. Without the pool table 😆

Tastes like a piece of New York! Highly recommended!

Truly a great pizza shop. The pizza is great!! And you can get it by the slice. Meatball sub is also fantastic. The staff is always friendly and the place is always clean.

Anita and her crew are awesome at getting the best pizza you could want in front of you. The subs are fantastic as are their salads.

We’ve been eating pizzas, Italian rolls, Italian salads, Stromboli’s and calzones since they opened. Mark is a great guy and business owner. I’ve eaten pizza in New York City and Italy. Brooklyn Pizzeria is as good if not better. The muffalletta is the bomb!

A couple new faces since we were here last but same great pizza!

If you want a great pizza in a layed back setting this is your place. Nothing fancy about the place but the pizza was great. Quick service. We were there on a Monday night and had brief conversation with who I believe was the owner. Friendly guy and the crew making the pizzas were back there making pizzas and singing with the radio. Just a nice quick dinner which was very reasonably priced. We are not from the area but like to try local restaurants. This was a good choice!

The food was delicious!! The wait was long to receive food. Two extra large pizzas.

You just can't beat this place. Love the food. Love the people and they way you are treated

Started by ordering a Stromboli and after waiting 30+ mins for it, I was handed a calzone. Wait staff was not inviting or welcoming, cleanliness bar is so low its under ground. Bread was dry which is amazing considering how greesy everything was, not seasoned, unless grease is a seasoning. Save yourself a headache and stomach ache and jist go find some different pizza.

Typical pizza place awesome food single slice was plenty for my kids and the stromboli was the bomb!