Buttercrust Pizza in Edgewood - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The Buttercrust pizza was super good! The garlic cheese bread had so much cheese, I loved it, lol.

The young man who works in the Downtown Orlando location is very friendly and makes exquisite pizzas.

I go out of my way to get pizza at Buttercrust. I wish there was one in central eastern Florida.

Ordered a square pan pizza, first time try Butter Crust with some hot wings and was excellent. Definitely going back next time we're in town. 5 stars

Great pizza… so many toppings to choose and the gluten free/cauliflower crust is delicious

Delicious Detroit style pizza. I normally prefer thin crust but this Detroit style pizza pass with double thumbs up. The crust is thick, crispy, and chewy. They do use the small pepperoni too. We love to build our own squares that can feed up to 3 people. It does get pricey with the amount of toppings you want. Order online for pick up so that you don’t have to wait.

By far the best pizza in Orlando area!

It’s great to have real pizza made by real people who enjoy serving the best thank you

Today was my frist time here because i was next door to them at the wing spot so i said to myself what goes better with wings is pizza. Best believe that the pizza i got is off the chain. I got Pepperoni and sausage pizza i am telling you best believe me their pizza is better than some places i been living here in florida by far in the Orlando area

First time coming to this place and the pizza was so delicious! Staff was friendly and it only took about 10-15 minutes to get our food. Would definitely recommend and come back again (:

First time trying this pizza and I can rate this a solid 10/10. Best pizza I ever had.

This has always been my go to Pizza place. I can always get creative with whatever toppings I want and they always deliver with top notch quality and the Pizza just melts nicely with every bite! So good! So buttery!! Only dough I’ll eat!

Horrible management! Terrible place do not go here!

Great food...and great service as always. Open late and convenient

Great customer service & great pizza. We were out here visiting for Disney world and it’s always a hard time finding quality pizza out here. Look no further because this pizza is amazing

Great pizza and customer service

Glorified Costco pizza for double or triple the price. Pizza was overdone, greasy, cold, and did not taste fresh. Comparable to a Costco pizza, definitely not worth the price. I threw up on my second slice. Cheese bombs are OK but they come in a pool of grease. We will not be ordering from here again.

Maybe one of my new favorite pizza spots. The regular is great. Crust was awesome and the flavor is fantastic. Looking forward to trying the deeper dish next time.

We love everything we order from Buttercrust Pizza. The quality and quantity of ingredients is consistently high, our pickup orders are ready at the promised time, and orders are complete and accurate.

Buttercrust never disappoints! Tonight we tried the ultra thin crust and now it’s our new favorite!

I ordered a 12” pepperoni thin crust, well done. It’s delicious!! I also ordered the garlic bread knots, outstanding. This is my first time here, I’ll be back.

Just a take out and delivery place, but very good Detroit style pizza and cheese bombs

Just a quick no dine in pizza shop. More of a specialty item and a little expensive but it's absolutely fire! bread was super thick and was perfectly baked all across GG

Pretty good Detroit style pizza. It did not wow me but it was pretty good. No real seating so be prepared to just take it home.

There Buttercrust pizza pie is like the siciliana from back home in NJ!!

Pizza was delicious got the butter crust square with pep and red sauce it was so good and the car ride home smelled amazing

Darius is amazing! He has great vibes with positive chill energy. He took the time to make sure that every question I asked was answered. He went above and beyond with his customer service making sure I had everything I needed (parmesan cheese utensils etc.) and helping me when the machine didn’t work when I tapped to pay. Pizza was good! Definitely recommend to anyone thinking about getting directions here. This is your sign! Thank you so much for everything!!! 🫶🏽

2nd Time- The cheese bread is great! I think I liked it even more than the bombs. The garlic parm wings were okay, im not sure if I'd get them again. I tried the buffalo chicken square pizza. It was good! But I personally thought it had a bit too much buffalo sauce, it was swimming in it. All around still great food! 1st Time- Great! I got the cheese bombs and pepperoni buttercrust square pizza for delivery, I highly recommend. I'll definitely be ordering again!

Love This Place good stuff Right There yummy 🤤

Food was made fresh to order, but only because we ordered as they were about to close... at 8:30 PM... me and my wife went in around 8:30, and when we came in, the tablet to order off of was shutdown, and when we asked for help, after about 5-6 minutes of no greeting, and nothing but eye contact with each other, the staff was very short and brief and didn't seem to care of the customers in the restaurant. One of the team workers helped and unlocked the tablet, but then were told, "Were closing in 15 minutes." but it's only 8:30... the pizza was so so at the end of the day, would only go back during the afternoon when they're completely open. i guess we just went on a bad night.

This pizza 🍕 ROCKS !!! I m very critical and didn't know what to expect but it was better than I expected !!! Got the Supreme butter crust square pan, it was on point, fresh toppings, just enough sauce with great flavor! I 100% recommend the garlic butter - tastes homemade !!! Also got the sweet chili wings, soooo good with the ranch sauce that also tastes in-house homemade 😋 I did oder takeout - It was nicely packed - ready to go - the guy was super curious, detailed to make sure i had everything and super nice, also everything still tasted fresh by the time I got home !!! Great job Buttercrust !!! Most definitely will have you on my list as one of Orlandos best pizzas to order out from !!! 10 STARS in my book! ☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆

This pizza was recommended by my brother. As always, he knew exactly what he was talking about. The taste of the food, customer service, everything was top notch. We will happily keep coming back.

Have ordered before, but tried a couple specialty pizzas. So good ❤️

If you like square deep dish, this is the place to go. It reminds me of Michigan square deep dish. So good! It’s only a take out place, but there is table outside to eat if you can’t wait till you get home like I did tonight. Highly recommend it.

Super quick, crust and toppings were crispy. Very good pizza

This is one of my favorite goto pizza places always hits the spot!!!

Great staff with exceptional service. Priced fairly and located in a great location.

The young lady who is the cashier was also answering the phone when I called in the order she was very helpful and friendly.

This is an amazing pizza place. Delicious not too expensive and great marinara.

The pizza, salad, and cheesy bread was great! The service on ordering and pickup was outstanding.

Sold me a 2 liter of cola but they did not have cups for customers to use. Crust was too much and too much bread and needed more sauce.

I was in the area dropping my daughter at a friends and saw the sign from the road and decided to get a pizza to go. I had never been there before. I ordered the butter crust pepperoni pizza, it was delicious and the guy working “Darrius” was polite and professional. He made sure to ask if I needed plates, napkins, etc etc. Great experience.

Got a Mac and cheese with pickles pizza and it's probably the best pizza I've EVER Had

Love buttercrust pizza! Best pizza in Orlando. Get the red swirl on top of your favorite toppings.

Yum! I ordered pizza for delivery and was very impressed. Their delivery seems to be done through DoorDash - but food was made quickly, and delivered earlier than quoted on a Saturday night. It was also still fairly warm on arrival. The food itself was really good! I ordered a square pizza (just cheese), a round Bianca pizza, and an order of parmesan bread. The pizza was excellent. A nice crispy crust, and a flavorful crust. The bread was really tasty, and had a good texture. It's a little pricey, but common to what to you find for specialty pizzas. I'd definitely order from again.

We got the grandmas pretty mess and a supreme regular pie. Both were delicious, but I thought the pretty mess was an amazing simple pizza if you’re not in the mood for toppings that’s still really elevated compared to a plain cheese pizza. It also is very pretty, just like it says. I’ll definitely order it again!

The best pizza ever!!!!!! Always on point!!

Good food , nice place n cool people recommend it

Found on social media. Very deceptive posts. Pizza was decent, at best… there is 0 “dine in” option as listed, it’s a pizza counter and only that. Will give the Oviedo location a try before I write this one off as a social media over hype gimic.

I got the parmesan sub and pepperoni pinwheels. Both are absolutely delicious. Ordered online and picked up promptly. Would definitely order again.

Staff were pleasant and polite. In ordered for pick-up and drive an hr to get there so the food was a bit cold when I got home. But very delicious.

Was stunned by this pizza. Have never had a problem with Buttercrust but this pie is drowning in grease, the dough is disintegrating and each barely cut slice has massive lakes of grease on it. So many pizza options in the area this bummed me out.

The meat lovers pizza was a real treat and I’m looking forward to trying the supreme next time. Update: I took a break from visiting due to some repeated issues I encountered with too much red sauce. Tonight an incredible staff member assisted me over the telephone and my pizza was perfect again. Five stars!

Amazing pizza and vibe! Always greeted and talked to, really enjoy this place.

To me a 5 star is the top of the heap ....only 1 in the Orlando area. A 4 star is just excellent pie ....there are only a couple in the Orlando/Maitland area. This is a very good 3 star location. Read that is very good in my mind....it was close to a 4 star and that is amazing. Dave would rate at 7.6-7.7. The undercarriage and char were excellent, the sauce was very tasty and the cheese was good. So, this was a very decent pie. I might have gotten crazy and even gone to a 4 star, but the oil (shown in photo) was not to my liking. This is how I arrived at this score. A very tasty, good pizza. Maybe you guys can address the oil issue, which was a bit overwhelming and had to be removed with a paper towel.

Their square buttercrust pizza it’s unlike anything else you’ve ever tasted!!! We gladly drive 35-45 mins from our place just to have their pizza and garlic bombs!!!!

​Absolutely loved this pizza! We are from out of town and were looking for a good local pizza place and we were not disappointed!! We got a pan meat lovers and pepperoni, which were amazing but the icing on the cake was the pizza pinwheels!! Those are a must have. Highly recommend this spot. Also the staff was very friendly and helpful in making our selection with recommendations

I’ve come in to do a delivery last weekend, and the guy that was there very easy going. Upon leaving out the store, he realized that there were two orders with the same name. So he stopped me before he got in my car and double checked, the order I had in my hand, and whats on the app. I’m SO glad he did! Because somebody would’ve been upset! So yesterday for movie night, I figured I’d give them a try. It was the same guy, with same good attitude. It really seems like he loves what he does. I ordered the ButterCrust Supreme Pizza with the Garden salad. The pizza was FIRE and the salad was pretty and really good! I’ll definitely be back!

Butter crust. Eat here, you won’t be sorry!

The thin crust pizza and spinach artichoke pinwheels are delicious!

If you like a combination of buttery crust with a fluffy interior and awesome toppings then this is the place to go, the pizza was AWESOME!

This a great addition to Oviedo on the park! Their signature butter crust pizza is so good🤤 I recommend this place to everyone!!!

Oh man!!!! Talk about fresh. I usually feel fat and tired after pizza but not after eating here. Got two pies (pepperoni and veg) for the office. Both were on point; the veg was the best I've had. Also the crust was soft and buttery. I could still taste the ingredients long after it was finished. A must have!!!!!

Cauliflower crust pizza was great. It was ready when they said. The only small negative was trashed pizza boxes and uneaten food was on the ground outside the door.

The kickin Hawaiian is incredible. Everything here is good

Quick prep for online order and ready when they said it would be. Good pizza too!

Absolutely delicious. Love love love Buttercrust!

Wife and I tried the new location and loved every bite of it. Congratulations on the new location and great food and design 🍕🍕🍕

This has become our new favorite pizza stop. Great product and gourmet!

Great pizza, yummy crust, amazing pinwheels!!

What are great places for a pizza. Has its own swag, with a home feel to it. Food was amazing and the service is quicker and easy with a sprinkle of love and care. If ur in the Oviedo or north Orange stop in.

The pizza was phenomenal and would recommend it again on our next visit