Cafe Bagel in South Venice - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Best bagels around, if you haven't been I suggest you try them out and see for yourself

Best bagels around! Always busy, but they rarely run out of my favorite bagels. Sandwiches are made to order and delicious.

We enjoyed another great breakfast!!! Thank you so much.

A cute bagel shop worth visiting with generous cream cheese serving

The best bagels I've found outside of New York, and reasonably priced too at about a dollar apiece. The bagels are big and dense! Many great flavours and friendly courteous service too.

Great, authentic bagels. Variety of cream cheese. An eat in menu is available too, along with muffins and pastries.

Bagels are good but they are always out of the best ones. Make more salt bagels for the love of god.

Absolutely delish! Great service! Every morning of our mother / daughter vacation we had one bagel for breakfast and one for an evening snack. We loved this place. We are going to miss the bagels when we go back home, but it’s probably a good thing, our waistline couldn’t handle it much longer. Yummy!

Food has been wrong the past few times and I’ve been overcharged. This last time was probably the last time I’m gonna deal with this. Overcharged me on three items gave me two items that were wrong and charged me for one item I didn’t receive this is happened the last few times I’ve gone there so I won’t be going back sadly because their food is good. I don’t feel like I should have to double check the receipt and the food each time I go. I paid double (they charged me twice) for extra onions and paid for extra cheese on my potatoes (see picture) yes it’s on my home plate because they put the food on this clear paper that ends up disintegrating and you end up eating it

The best bagel shop in southwest Florida

I had a breakfast bagel, coffee, and Danish. The service was superb. The food was fresh and tasted excellent. I will be back.

Just discovered this place and is now a favorite. Bagels were true New York style and delicious. The staff was all friendly, but one member of the team, Haley, went out of her way. Definitely check this place out.

Great bagels, service excellent, atmosphere is so so. I enjoyed my bagel and coffee with a great friend and did not care if the atmosphere was great or not. Bough baker's dozen to take home.

Best bagels in the state of Florida. That's coming from a New York refugee lol. Amazing.

I had a minor complaint about an order that had ordered online so I called to speak to the manager. I was completely calm, but accidentally dropped an F bomb on the phone. The manager lied and acted like I was cussing him out, and used it as a pretense to scream at me for 2 mins and to threaten me by saying: "Do you know who you are messing with?! Do you know who I am?! " He inferred that he was willing to do harm me over a bagel, and then threatened to call the police. For what? Huh? What has the world come to? I don't care much about $4.63, its a small price to not to support a business like this. I am astonished. I was simply questioning having to pay almost five dollars to add bacon to a four dollar sandwich. Seems totally reasonable. He is young and he gave me a refund so I am not going to press charges, If your order is wrong here I do not suggest calling. I will find a new place to get bagels. Customer service rating: 0

Great bagels. Great breakfast sandwiches.

The only bagel store you visit for delicious bagels freshly baked

Love this restaurant. Great bagels, and they carry pork roll.

Love this place. It’s changed owners over the years but for the most part it’s still the same. We have to get there a little earlier to avoid the invasion of people that have plagued our state as of late but we’re learning how to avoid the terrorists.

Excellent Bagels and a fantastic cream cheese assortment.

New owners cannot scramble an egg. Do not have scram bagel in the menu if you plan to give me a FRIED egg. It doesn’t matter if you call and tell them it’s fried. Maybe take it off the menu. This is the third time I have given you a chance and each time you mess it up. This bagel is now going in the trash. So sad j grew up eating at cafe bagel!

Freshest & most flavorful! You can tell they are made with love, and it is a wonderful staff that cares too!

Love their bagels. You can get them still warm if you are lucky.

I stopped in on Sunday for a Taylor ham egg and cheese and a Bacon egg and cheese on a toasted everything bagel. The line was out the door which I thought was good because the food must be very good. I then found out why the line was out the door. Only 1 person taking orders and when I got to her she rolled her eyes because I wanted my sandwiches toasted. When I got home I found the bagel sandwich was kinda small and only 1 egg on each sandwich. I would have thought there would be 2 eggs for the $8 I paid for each. Boy do I miss Firehouse Bagel in Branchville, NJ. I will again try to find a good breakfast sandwich shop.

This is a great place with awesome “like New York” bagels. Very friendly and really good food in casual atmosphere. Love it!

I’m from NY so maybe my standards are different, but… Bagel was good. Got an everything. Cream cheese was gross. I order scallion and there was one piece of scallion and it didn’t have any flavor except normal cream cheese. Disappointed

In love! My favorite cream cheese is strawberry flavored. My younger sister just moved in for college to my home here in Venice. I have always wanted to stop in and she went and grabbed me one yesterday. I have finally found the best bagel shop with the best strawberry cream cheese. Hands-down better than anything I had growing up in Rhode Island or here in Florida.

Being from NJ, this felt like home. Great Taylor ham, egg, & cheese sandwich. Even have Kaiser rolls if you prefer over a bagel. Bagels are excellent with many varieties to pick from. Generous portion of cream cheese for those who like a bagel with cream cheese 😋! Plenty of space to sit inside or out. Venice is lucky to have this place!

Good, but getting pricey, 2 bagels, 1 coffee over $10....

Good bagels, the sandwich was good, but the rolls were sold out that's what l wanted, have to go earlier.

Bagels get hard fast and 6 cost $13 expensive for me.

Excellent only open till 2 but good and CLEAN!

The food was pretty good but this is the bag they gave me- totally greasy and the outside of the plastic bag was also greasy. They should just serve butter on the side instead of packaging it that way. The bagels we not cut either. They should ask you that because if you’re taking bagels to people they don’t necessarily have a sharp knife. She could have also doubled the amount I bought if she had asked me if I wanted anything on the bagels or anything else. She saw how greasy it was and could have grabbed a plastic bag- I don’t get it why people won’t think.

mmmmmmmmmmmm, bagels!!!!! Definitely try their cream cheeses. Very tasty

Been going to the establishment for years, family tradition every weekend. Fresh food, friendly staff. Owners are great people who care. Best Breakfast joint in town.

They make a killer pastrami bagel sandwich! And they did it again

Great coffee and no skimping on the creme cheese.

We've been looking for a NY style bagel since we moved here a year ago! Finally found it! The bagels are amazing and nice and big just like back home! We will be very frequent customers!!

great service but not a single dairy free option

Amazing breakfast burrito! This place is my new go to for breakfast on the run.

Love their bagels. Their bagel and lox is also outstanding!

Just for the spinach bagel alone she gets 5 stars! Overall bagels are not like up north but the best in Venice,,

Super cute, local place with great food of course

Not NY, but the best of Venice

Delicious bagel, friendly staff!

If you want the real deal, these bagels are it. Fantastic place.

Best bagel I’ve had since moving to Florida from NJ 6 years ago!

Excellent bagels. Reminds me of home

Hands down the best bagels in town very similar to what I use to get in New York excellent food!

Best bagels in Venice and the surrounding areas hand's down. Service top notch always get you in and out. Great job Cafe Bagel!

Beware Everything bagels have strong garlic. Otherwise good breakfast.

My go-to place for bagels. Great service.

Excellent bagels, always the perfect fit

Bagels that are better than panara.

We love the place we love the food but what's the point of ordering ahead? When you have to wait in A-line 30 deep while? Your food is getting cold to pay. There needs to be another cashier.

It's a good, not great bagel. I think they salted my egg. Yuck. Good service. Fair prices. I'd go back.

My bagel sandwich was good, the coffee was tall, there’s plenty of indoor and outdoor seating, can’t ask for much more.

Freshest, bestest bagels in Venice. Made daily, wide selection and friendly staff. Never mind those supermarket plastic bagged bagels. Go early while they’re still warm.