Captain Cone's Ice Cream - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Love this place! So many options, great pricing, the staff was just perfect and plus the vegan options for one of us worked out great. Thank you Captain Cone’s! 👍👍

Great place I have to say this is the first ice cream place I couldn’t eat all the ice cream example I ordered a nutty-buddy split pretty cool 😎 it’s a 🍌 banana split except the banana is replaced with a nutty nutty ! Super chocolatey and I usually have to order more to get my h chocolate fix. !!! So highly recommend!! It’s locally owned and the owners work it ! So definitely I hidden gem. 💎 gem!!! I found the treasure chest!!!

Arrived well after noon and the employee said she couldn’t serve us because she was still opening, despite their sign saying they open at 12. Might need to start opening later or coming in early to get everything done then. Combined with the awful smell and the stained dirty seats we decided to go somewhere else.

Cute ice cream parlor. Hershey's Ice cream with a pirate theme. Fun for kids and even older folks! Definitely cheered my mom right up after a rough week!

This place is on point! Great place with so many different flavor options. I’ve never seen ice cream nachos before but this place has them!

Their vegan section is pretty sad. It's nice they have in the first place, but all of the ice cream was covered in freezer burn. I asked the server if she could just scrape to the bottom since there really wasn't another option. Ice cream itself is decent. The cookie dough vegan option is oat based and tasted creamy, albeit slightly gummy.

We've been here several times. Their ice cream is really good. Brown Butter Bourbon and Midnight Caramel River... What a combo! 😋👍

My favorite ice cream in town!! Staff is ALWAYS friendly and the ice cream is da bomb! Please bring back birthday cake flavor! 🙌

Lots of flavors to choose from. Staff was friendly. Signage is terrible for locating the establishment. Pricing is outrageous. $4.25 for two small scoops of ice cream, making it very unaffordable for families.

Great ice cream shop! Lots of yummy flavors to choose from. Very friendly employees! Not overly crowded, very clean appearance and lots of tables & chairs. Will definitely go back to this ice cream shop.

I had some ice cream here with my little brother. Me and my brother were very satisfied with our ice cream. There were a Ton of different flavors and options. I highly recommend!

I'm a Local here and we love Captain Cone! They sell Hershey's ice cream and it's the best!

Never actually been there, but if there's a lady who owns a ferret and a lab-pittbull mix who's offering great ice cream, I'll certainly be there 🍦💪

We went today right as they were opening and got great ice cream and even better service! We had a large family group from 3 to 80 years old and the girl at the counter was so kind and accommodating.

Shakes taste very very bad old milk 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼 I offer best cow's ice cream that here

Good ice cream. Clean place. Nice service

Very good ice cream 🍨. Recommend 👍

So many flavors to choose from at Captain Cones. The girl scooping our ice cream was so friendly and helpful, and very knowledgeable about flavors and ingredients. We will definitely be back when we are in town again!

Customer service is not as good as their ice cream :(

Great place I had a banana split. Attendant was great.

Went their today at 2:30 and the door was locked. Are you still in business?

Great service friendly envirement.

Best ice cream sundae in St. Augustine. So many flavors and toppings to choose from.

This is the best Ice Cream spot in St. Augustine let alone all of Florida. If they had a location downtown and kept things the same the line would be blocks long!!

Captain Cone's has every flavor you want and every flavor you never knew you wanted. Milkshakes, sundaes, malts, and ice cream cakes and pies. There are even vegan and gluten free options.

1st time eating here and Omgosh the ice cream was awesome. I had the nachos and ice cream. So when I come back to St Augustine I will be back.

I’ve live in Jacksonville and st augustine my whole life and this is by far the BEST I’ve cream I’ve ever had! The variety & flavors offered is indescribable! Captain Cones has become our go to ice cream shop for my family & friends!

Awesome icecream parlor! Fun, friendly atmosphere. The price was not bad either. My granddaughter also enjoyed it. There were so many flavors to choose from! I highly recommend this place!

Three words ICE CREAM SANDWICHES! Made to order and stuffed with your choice of flavor. Their banana split was overfilled and delicious.

Ice cream choices all looked good and almost too much to choose from! They were all made extremely well, used very generous scoops, and had creative ways to enjoy them. We chose the Ice Cream "Nachos" (Waffle cone chips). Outstanding. Gotta love the New England influence such as the "Green Monstah" dish... a reference to Fenway Pahk in Boston. We look forward to coming back again.

60 flavors of ice cream. Great little shop.

Very good ice cream and very clean new place

This place knows ice cream! I've been to dozens of ice cream shops, but none of them had the selection this place has. They're not afraid to try flavors and the staff is super friendly.

Had the ice cream nachos with my son! Wonderful time! Clean!

I love this new Ice Cream shop in our little village. Great customer service as well!

I go here 3 to 4 times a week this place is so awesome they have so many choices to choose from. Their prices are great to They also do a punch card every 9 ice creams you get the 10th free and enter a chance to win their ice sandwiches yummy 😋

Delicious Hershey ice cream, reasonable price, friendly staff and laaaarge scoops. Definitely need to stop here if your craving some good ice cream. A great selection of standard flavors as well as some more unusual combinations.

Excellent ice cream and great employees

Biggest selection of ice cream in the area and of course awesome service! I recommend the no sugar added turtle sundae!

Great place to cool off with some ice cream. They serve numerous varieties of Hershey brand ice cream. Some really fantastic combinations such as Brown Butter Bourbon Truffle and Midnight Caramel River. I plan to return to try more flavors. Staff is very helpful and friendly. Parking is easy since they're located in a strip mall next to Winn Dixie. A little tricky to find since its behind a Walmart and Culver's. Definitely worth the trip

Always friendly and always delicious! Open later when others are closed!

We stopped last night and they have so many flavors and mix ins to choose from. They also have dairy free options which we have a hard time finding as my spouse is lactose intolerant. It wasn't just sorbet. They had actual "ice cream" flavors. My husband loved it! Many gluten free items too! It was seriously some of the best ice cream I have had. The owner was super sweet as was the gentleman working with her. Would definitely recommend!

Great local ice cream shop with lots of flavors. Friendly staff.