Colatina Exit in Bradford - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Excellent restaurant with excellent food (pizza calzone pasta, everything) and outstanding service. Very pleasant.

This place is awesome. I still think about their pizzas decades since visiting. Best pizza I've ever had in my whole life.

Come here once a year on a motorcycle ride. The greatest food, very happy Chef cooking

Wonderful place, great service. Pleasant atmosphere. Highly recommend it.

One week it was great the next week Awful chicken parm, the chicken was burnt. If they can only be consistent

Searched a pizza place on our route and found this gem! Delicious and staff was very friendly.

Barbeque pizza is the best this side of the country. But I think the online pricing is wrong- says $22 but actually came out to $28+. Love this place, just sayin' 🙃

Delicious food, great waitstaff, comfortable atmosphere. Highly recommend.

Good service! Had a great time w Sophia as our server. Very witty!

Everything you want in an Italian restaurant! Great food, friendly service, fresh wine, at a reasonable price point. I’ve had their pizza for take out and it’s great, plenty of topping choices.

Over priced, owners are not great people kicking me out of my apartment for no reason and pushing me out from my service job for no apparent reason. They also stole money from us all me especially. Straight up like some of the people who work there but giving it a 1 star and wish I could leave 0. Foods just ok. Super dark atmosphere.

Oh, how we love this place. It has a very nice variety of distinctive dishes, not the same sauce, over and over. And there are usually interesting specials. Friendly service.

What was I thinking? (Ordering scallops....). That dish was really really bad. Pure glop. My sister ordered crab cakes which basically tasted like deep fried pureed moosh. Couldn't eat that either. Nice service, nice atmosphere. Most expensive dog food I ever got.

First let me say that the service was excellent. The food was pretty awful. I couldn't eat my crabcakes which were mushy dog food like texture, my sisters risotto was a sludge and my other sister's alfredo came out of a bottle, we think. I would never go back there for anything other than pizza. Which makes me sad since Colatina was my absolute favorite restaurant 30 years ago.

Excellent service, excellent food, excellent atmosphere. 100% recommendable

Excellent gluten free pizza! I have had a lot and this has been my favorite, it was delicious. I appreciate they take the need for gluten free and asked if it was allergy, celiac, or preference. Highly recommend!

We had an incredible meal and our server Greg was amazing!!!!!

What an amazing place. I cannot say enough good things about it. the food was so good. Our server was the best I've had in a long time. My first time here and I will definitely be going back.

Has a good wing night on Thursday.

We really like it here. Down to earth atmosphere. Good food. Awesome maple butter.

Awesome atmosphere! Very friendly service and Fantastic food! Definitely will be dining again!

Excellent service in a comfortable atmosphere. Extensive menu- consistently reliable and delicious. 😋🧄🍻

What a great find! We were staying at some lodging in Pike, NH and found this place. Whole family lived our meals. Wife and I had Veal Marsala and Veal Piccata and it was perfect.

Eaten here three times. The food is poor to average at best and the service is almost nonexistent. What other reviews have said about flavorless bland food is accurate. $60.00 for a pizza and a couple of soft drinks is outrageous. Our first reaction to the pizza was that it looked like a frozen pizza from the grocery store, barely warm, and flavorless.

Our server was nice but my wife and daughter got food poisoning after sharing the same entree. 🤮

A regional treasure. The pizza is world class.

Quaint place with overpriced low quality food. Presentation was a kids meal level.

Collatina was fantastic! It checked all the boxes. I was with 7 people and we received great service.

Excellent service provided by Morgan the barkeep, surpassed only by the obvious respect for craft and passion they express in their food. Really reasonable cost for the quality they provide!

Great food with an extensive menu. Accommodating and friendly staff, always.

Do you like being overcharged for sloppy food that sits on the pass getting cold? Then this is the place for you. Don’t get too close to the magician he smells like baby powder. Go elsewhere.

Amazing time! Went to see Marko and was just amazed…..wonderful salmon with a very big portion. Delicious veggies too! Super friendly server as well! All in all 10/10!!

Have been dining here for many years. Consistent and excellent food and service. Staff is fantastic. They were helpful and responsive in helping us set up for a birthday party lunch.

I liked it....good food the table bread was nice and hot. Staff was very nice and accommodating

Food here was excellent. Everything we ordered was cooked to perfection. Service was great. We will definitely be back to try more of the menu.

Always good food. Consistent. Local ingredients. Great service. Great beer selection. Pizza is good too. Kids enjoy this place. Delicious desserts. Unfortunately no espresso 😲 We eat here several times per year. Highly recommended.

I’ve been to this place so many times and I’ve never had any bad experiences here! LOVE their maple butter that comes with the bread, I wish they would sell it in store!! (It was garlic olive oil when I went today, so I’m not sure if the maple butter is seasonal. The olive oil was great too!) Their mista salad with maple balsamic is a must try. One of the best salad dressing that I have ever tried! Pizza is great too! Staffs are friendly. Highly recommend this place!

Food and service were excellent.

Girls night out - we were lucky enough to have Logan as our server. Knowledgeable, very attentive and great personality. 100% great dining experience.

I think these folks forgot or never knew what Italian food is. I had a steak that wasn't as good as I can buy at Shaws and cook myself. Tough. Grizzly. Asparagus was too raw to eat. Mashed cold and tasteless. Gin and Tonics were the only good part. Prices too high for low quality food.

Food is OK but employees aren't treated well. "Austin" the manager who looks like he is 14 is very rude to the staff.

Great pizza place in an interesting small Vermont town close to Lake Morey.

Pizza was great seems popular on a Fri, so may want a reservation.

The pizza is amazing! Great deals tues.and Thursdays! Also, do not leave without trying the terimisu!

Great 👍 👌 food and great service 👍 👌 and great deals 👍 👌

I’m telling you right now, if you’re looking for a great burger, this is the spot.. to die for PB&J burger with fresh local ingredients. A great view, a good vibe, and even better food! A must try if you’re passing by this area 😋

Stopped in for lunch. Had half pizza, half salad. Delicious! Recommend to a friend.

All I can say is wow the food was amazing. The service was kinda slow but you will have that with such a busy restaurant. My advice. Get yourself one of their signature drinks, order one of their great appetizers and relax. Enjoy the experience there while you wait for your dinner.

My son was stranded on the road and they found a way to deliver delicious food to him. Great service!!!

We were a walk-in party of five and they were busy, but they still accommodated us. Really grateful. Pizza was high-end and delicious. Good range of good local beers. They looked after our little girl very well!

Best pizza north of Boston. Gerardo's in St Johnsbury held that title for a little while, but sadly they closed. Colatina Exit has been consistently good for decades. I have no qualms going miles out of my way for their pie. Anyone traveling on 91 that's anywhere close to Bradford VT should give it a try. You won't be disappointed

Very good formal takeaway. Some of the best pizza I have ever had even compared to those in NYC.

Food was great! Had the bolognese!

Stopped here while traveling through Bradford. Pizza and calamari were very good. Really enjoyed the marinara sauce which had a spicy kick. There are a handful of shops on Main Street to visit. Great restaurant in a quant small town. Classic Vermont!

Went in on a whim for lunch, has pizza and wings, nice little place! Food was good, place was clean, staff was friendly.

7 of us Sunday evening (our party) every item was delicious, great service, will return soon (we are from burlington vt.) Marinara sauce was the best, wish I could make it at home.

We stopped here on our way home. The food is absolutely amazing. The meatballs are not only amazing, they are blended with mixed meats old world style. I would def stop here again, or if I am in the area.

We are local and visit every few weeks Absolutely fabulous menu to choose from

Always a good spot for a nice dinner. Excellent food and good portions. Upstairs is more relaxed bar atmosphere. Downstairs is more mid range to fine dining.

Good Italian food. Varied menu. Generous portions. Pleasant servers. We have been going there for many years. Very consistent preparation. If you liked it 10 years ago, and order it now it will taste the same.

Waitress seemed a little inexperienced but still did a good job. The food was very very good.

Delicious, well -crafted dishes in a cozy, casual environment. Staff is very friendly.

Always good food at the "Exit" we like the smaller portion choice and actually end up taking some home anyway. Our favorites ... chicken prosciutto marsala and clams on Linguini ( when they have it). Good cocktails, wine and beers. We prefer upstairs seating, . Has a view and has a little more intimate pub feel. Enjoyed a cold frosty mule on this 92 degree afternoon and great view too!

Such a great local establishment. Been there 50 years, solid service, quality menu, quality food and a friendly environment.

I have eaten here many times through the years. Decent food for American cuisine but the Italian dishes are sub par. Maybe I'm particularly picky because I am Sicilian, but the eggplant is awful by my standards. They do not know how to make this dish correctly. The lasagna sucks. Philly Cheesesteak sandwich-overcooked, dry beef shavings. Their pizzas are good and their sandwiches and wraps are good. The clam mushroom soup is delicious. IMO their calzones are mostly pizza dough. Used to be better but I've never considered it a high end "Italian" restaurant.

Riley C. Is an awesome waitress. I am a business owner of a Cafe'. Riley knowledge of the menu & her pleasant smile & attitude, she was genuinely pleased to do her job & did it very well. We had gone here with some friends for dinner. Riley, keep up the good work it was a pleasurable experience. Thank you. Jesse

Fantastic food, great service and a rustic vibe where casual meets fine dining. Can't wait to go back!

This place is great! Been in business for 50 years, super consistent, people working there care, menu is great. Can’t say enough good things. Been going here for over 30 years. Great job Colatina!

Pizza was good. Waitress was very nice and talkative

Cost way to much for what you get

We eat here often. Good pizza and entrees plus daily specials. Very nice staff. Good local beers.

Nice place even has an in house magician, but the prices were a bit steep, stools were to high to allow seated views of anything but the golf course nearby.

Service was fantastic. Riley was very lovely as our waitress, when I brought up a very small issue, she immediately addressed it. And the manager (Jordan) immediately apologized, gave us dessert on the house, and took my daughter on a tour of the desserts to help her decide. Super accommodating, super friendly, and very professional. 10/10 service.

Exceptional! I'm not a huge fan of Italian cuisine but this place was so great that I want to come back some time :-)

We go here often. The food is quite good and the service is always friendly and professional.

Authentic and generous toppings on the pizza. The gluten free crust was crisp and thin, the toppings are your flavoring.

Food was good, service was excellent, prices were a little high for the quantity but everything has gone up

What a delightful gem to find in a (very) small Vermont town! Our party included vegetarians and gluten-free folks and Colatina Exit did not disappoint! The roasted vegetables insalata was particularly delicious. Ample portions and an extensive wine list too!

Great food. Very friendly and helpful staff. Love eating here!

The food was great. I shared a pizza with a friend and others got the lasanaga bolognese and the cabonara. All were tasty, well prepared meals. The server was very friendly.

My husband and I tried this spot for dinner after a local friend recommended them. We sat upstairs and had a wonderful time! The atmosphere is cozy and clean, the staff attentive and friendly, and food delicious and fresh! In my husbands words “I’d move here just for the food”

Next time, I’ll stick to the pizza

Always amazing food highly recommended!

Excellent food. Very friendly staff. Will come back for sure.

Decent. They were out of meatballs, bread, diet soda, and one other thing so it was kinda funny but good enough food

Delicious Italian cuisine with a great beer selection. Have tried their pizza and calzones; haven't ordered an entree yet but, I would expect dinners to be excellent. Gets very busy so call ahead.

Excellent place to take a date, yourself or your family. Spacious booths downstairs and live music and a beautiful bar upstairs. To go is amazing as well. Using local products with elegance! Thanks so much Coli!

Food is always delicious, we've been multiple times. Highly recommend the Cajun Chicken Fettuccine

Awesome place to check out. Great food, customer service, and cool atmosphere. Worth giving them a shot!

I would not recommend this restaurant. The heavy set bald gentleman/sever was rude to me when I asked to update my bill. I ordered the fried calamari appetizer and a side plain order of fettuccine pasta over with oil and I was charged 18$ for just a pasta. The manager took 5$ off from my bill. The calamari was not good at all. Hardly any spice. I also ate dinner here 3 days before. The food was mediocre. I came back because I thought I would give it a second chance. I was not pleased at all the second time. Spend your money somewhere else.

It is too dark to suit me. The food and service is great though.

Trivia night was fun! Food good as always

Very nice restaurant - rustic and comfortable. Lots of variety on the menu. For lunch I opted for the Italian Hero - it was perfect!!!!! Good beer selection. Alyssa was a personable server! We'll be back next time we are in the area.

Food was delicious, drinks were good and Marko the magician was amazing! Some of the best closeup magic I've ever seen!

I was very disappointed. I ordered a burger medium and it came out well done and very dry. The waitress was very nice.

Wonderful food! Pizza place doesn't do it justice. Very good Italian food!

I got no napkins at all !!! An yes I asked for them .. an I got oil for my rolls and see something floating at the top !!! It’s a piece of plastic!!!!

Who would have known going to Bradford Vermont you could have one of the best Italian meals I have ever had. Everything was excellent

Went for my fiancees birthday. Upstairs was closed but we got private dining for 8 or 9 people. Was excellent. We were served by (according to my fiancees mother) the person who was running the upstairs. Super stand up guy. Had anecdotes for everything. Recommended a perfect replacement beer when they were out of the one I wanted (I knew both beers very well.) The food was what you'd want. Don't pass on the mozzarella carrozza.

Came back up to VT after 20 years. My family and I ate here for dinner (along with the rest of my family that has eaten here for YEARS) and we were so unsatisfied with our food. I got the Alfredo, my brother got lasagne, dad got some shrimp scampi. All of it was awful, even smelled funky (glad none of us got sick). Only thing that was okay was pizza. AND WE SPENT $99!!!! NOT OKAY. when the waitress noticed I didn’t eat practically any of it, she asked if I wanted a box, I quickly said, “no” after that, I figured she’d ask, “was the food okay?” Because that’s just standard to ask. I highly recommend only getting pizza here. We could’ve had better pasta from Fazoli’s in Kansas. Sheesh.