Common Tart in Tulsa - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

This is the best pie I’ve ever had! It is absolutely perfect in every way all the way down to the presentation!

Absolutely great experience. The service was excellent. The chocolate silk pie had hand made whip cream. The crust was above average ,the chocolate was rich and creamy. Check the website for hours. This eatery is super clean. A hidden "Gem". I am adding that after you have purchased 5 choices you get a free piece. What a good deal. I must admit I have more than 8 pieces to my credit.

Wow what a great place so cute!Their to go boxes are over the top!

Wow! If you love pie, TOU MUST TRY THIS PLACE! Went to Common Tart to pick up a little something special for desert. I purchased the key lime, the brownie pie, and the Chocolates chip cookie pie. I had a long drive and most of the regular pie slices would not travel well. Holy Moly! Wow! Hands down the best pie I have ever had in my life. The cookie pie slice; if it was just a cookie it was the best chocolate chip cookie I have EVER had. The Brownie pie slice; So god damn good it made me want to just save half of it and take a small bite every day for the next week! The Key Lime; I do not like key lime. This was for my wife. She forced me to take a bite….it was the best damn key lime I have EVER had. Whoa. 😳 I will be back as soon as I can!

What an amazing place! Awesome music, great atmosphere, friendly workers! Thank you for amazon pie!

Best pies in town. Not over sweet just perfect. Beautiful atmosphere. Great service unique packaging flare. We will be back for more

Such a cute and delicious pie shop! The slices are absolutely worth it! We came up from Norman and found this spot for desert on social media. The Coconut Cream and Peanut Butter Mouse were to die for! The atmosphere was dainty and the inside smells heavenly.

Amazing pie, beautiful and clean atmosphere, great service. Very well done. We’ll be back.

The best key lime pie I’ve ever had!

We thoroughly enjoyed our experience at Common Tart. The staff was so kind, accommodating, and helpful. The atmosphere was so inviting, and the desserts were amazing! We will definitely stop by again next time we're in Tulsa!

In my opinion, the best pie in Tulsa. This is a true small, family business that has the heart of a family that cares. The best is fantastic, staff are lovely, space is sweet.

What a beautiful place for a piece of amazing pie, or two or more...

Lovely experience, staff was friendly even though I came in right close to closing on Pi day.

I love this business and their pies so much. Absolutely the best in town

This is a magical place. If you haven’t been here, skip dinner and bring your date for pie.

Specialty pie shop that’s locally owned with scrumptious selections.

Quite possibly one of the most delightful dining experiences in Green Country.

There was good music, water and nice employees

The cutest pie shop I’ve ever been to. They have the sweetest staff and the best tasting sweets.

Awesome pies! Just walking in to the smells is enough! But I still walked around it with a pie LOL

It’s such a cute shop! It’s about time something like this was around!

INCREDIBLE! Highly recommend the coconut cream pie!

There was great pie, friendly music and nice employees

A perfect little pie shop in Tulsa. Top recommended for locals and visitors alike.

Love the variety of pie flavors and am always pleased with my choices. The staff is warm and welcoming. Will continue to visit regularly!

Great presentation and variety of flavors. I like that they are involved in the community and host classes as well!

Pies are always good, and the rotating flavors are fun.

SO excited for PI Day! This place is adorable!

Delicious pie, exceptional service, and a cozy atmosphere. One of my favorite places to get a dessert in Tulsa. I would highly recommend Common Tart, especially the banana Nutella pie! If you choose to dine in, they bring a small pitcher of water to your table for you to enjoy with your pie. They also have a few card games scattered around that you can play with while you’re there. If you choose to take it to go, they oftentimes wrap the boxes with a pretty fabric and include a fresh floral stem tied on top. The slices of pie pictured are banana Nutella (normally only offered on Fridays), blueberry pie bar (a special for pi day), and German chocolate pie (also a special for pi day that they have occasionally).

This was our first Common Tart experience and it was a huge hit!! We ordered for the office and our favorites were the Pear Almond Tart and the Peanut Butter Mousse! Also ordered French Silk, Key Lime, Oatmeal Crème Pie (delicious!). The crust was incredible on every pie. Our only complaint was that the Key Lime could have been tarter, but I’m blaming that on the limes themselves. Nothing was overly sweet and everything was fresh! You are special Common Tart! Well done.

The best pie in Tulsa, and Friday pie nights are a must!

Love Common Tart! The store is super cute and the staff is so friendly.

This is the best place in town for pie

Such great pie and it’s super consistent! Great family that runs it and they are so friendly!

Delicious pie and a great storefront!

Common Tart has the best pie in town! The atmosphere is lovely and the key lime pie is to die for!

Came to this little shop on “pie day” (3.14) so I wouldn’t feel like I was missing all of the hype. Good pies and service.

Delicious pie and adorable shop

Delish pie, lovely staff and great rotating specials!

The best hands down. Perfection every time!

Love this place! The pie is delicious and the people who work there are so kind. I cannot recommend this place enough!

Visiting Tulsa for the weekend and decided to get dessert after dinner. We popped in this small shop and we were blown away by the atmosphere inside. The displays were so good we ordered 6 slices so we could all try a bite of different pies. The key lime was out of this world, German chocolate was on another level, the one with a pear on it was super delicious. This place truly made our stressful cheerleading competition weekend better and we will be back if we are ever back in Tulsa.

My biggest fear of leaving a good review is it brings more people to Common Tart but this is easily one of the best hidden gems of Tulsa. I highly recommend for a quick little date night for a slice of pie or just to treat yourself on an evening/afternoon.

I bought the whole, take and bake, chicken pot pie for Super Bowl. It was delicious!! Very fresh and full of chicken and veggies. It was worth every penny!! Easy instructions.

It's just pies...but dang! Cmon, I'm enjoying this pumping pie whipped cream with tiny chocolate chips and a light shave of oreo atop, Then notice a cookie bottom. Oh my. Top it off, they had a chicken pot pie you would have to taste to believe how good it was. Closed Sunday and Mondays

Awesome pie and friendly service! What more can I say?

Wonderful small bakery with amazing food. Not overly sweet of rich like some other local bakeries that just fill their items with more sugar. The richness, sweetness, texture is just right.

Amazing service and quality, both of which are unmatched in the Tulsa metro. The artisanship that goes into these pies is simply amazing and I couldn't have been happier with the two whole pies I ordered for my wife's bday. The coconut cream was lauded as the best anyone had ever had and I can personally attest to the Banana Nutella which was decadent and delicious. I highly recommend giving this spot your attention if you like pies, good service, and great atmosphere!

My favorite pie place in Tulsa!

The Key Lime pie was the best I've ever had.

We ate brownie and lime pie. Very Very good best pie ever!!!

I couldn't love this place more! The only problem is I don't go often enough! I love the movie nights! My favorite is the fudge brownie pie! I loved the pumpkin mousse pie most recently! It is the most charming little pie shop and I love playing the games when we wait for our pie! Love the boxing and flower when you order to go! I would love to take the pie class but the times don't see to align with my schedule.

Cutest pie shop, best customer service, and amazing pies. The brownie fudge, peanut butter mousse, pecan, and apple butter pies are to die for. All are delicious and made with love!!

OMG...best pies ever...from opera singer to pie maker...she is definitely awesome no matter what she does

Great pie - this is my new favorite dessert place!

Best pies ever! I crave the coconut cream pie often.

What a wonderful and charming place. The service was outstanding, as soon as you walk in you get hit with a wonderful delicious smell. We ordered a brownie and key lime pie and they were amazing. Too bad we were just visiting for the football game but if we lived in Tulsa we would be in this place everyday. Keep it up!

Such a cute place with great service! Lots of delicious flavors to choose from.

Very flavorful creations. You won't be disappointed. Peach Pie Shake was on point. Peaches and Cream was delicious.

Amazing. It's so delicious that I daydream about what I am going to eat when I go there again!!!

Amazing pie! I had the fudge brownie my wife had the strawberry crème! Both very delicious and filling! Would recommend to anyone looking for a great pie. Plus the inside is beautiful

We went to go grab a slice of heaven yesterday for my husbands and my date night and he is already wondering when we are going back. 10/10 wouldnt change a thing.

Wonderful pie place. (Best key lime in town!) Cute atmosphere, great staff.

Best pie shop in all of Tulsa!!! We bought 4 different slices today and the Key Lime is the best I have ever had!! The shop is very cute and the staff was very friendly. You have to visit this place.

Never miss a beat here. Literally. Wow.

We accidentally found this place while driving through a neighborhood near Utica square and it was the best accident we could’ve made! As soon as you walk in, you’re instantly ready to try everything. The service is fantastic and the pies are amazing!

We’ve been here a few times and we’ve tried something different every time and haven’t been disappointed. I’m not a fan at all of Key Lime but 10/10 would recommend theirs! 👩🏼‍🍳💋

Best homemade pies in tulsa.extremely nice people and the atmosphere is amazing

Very cute pie shop filled with sweet smells and delicious treats. It’s not very big but very cute and chic. And the pies are super sweet!

Hands down the best pie shop I've ever been too. Their crust and any of their tarts with custard are a 10 out of 10. Even their whip cream is amazing. I got the rhubarb tart, key lime pie, and apple pie. The rhubarb and key lime desserts will be in my dreams. I signed up for their rewards program and I look forward to returning.

So much more than just a Common Tart. Lovely decor, comfortable seating, gracious service and oh, those pies!! We got 6 different slices..."the custom pie"...and each slice was as delicious as the next. The coconut cream, the key lime, the oatmeal cream, the fudge brownie, the apple tart and the pear almond - all were truly scrumptious. I'm looking forward to going back for more!

Common Tart and Antoinettes best pies in Tulsa

I’ve been looking for places that sell dessert that is not ice cream and is open at night. Tonight, after dinner, I google “Tulsa pie”. I get the usuals but then I see this place. What? Wife and I go there and sure enough they have pie and are open at night! Anyway, it’s small but very inviting inside. They had many pies but were out of a couple and had a savory pie. I chose the key lime and my wife the coconut cream. I’m new to key lime pies but it was very good. Not too sweet and just the right amount of tartness. The crust was graham cracker and on the thick side which is a good thing because it’s very tasty. The coconut cream pie was as you’d expect(very delicious) with the addition of toasted coconut on top. The crust was buttery and delicious. Definitely going back because I really need to try all the pies.

The Key Lime pie is otherworldly.

Great atmosphere and pie! Wish they served coffee!

Great place to get a slice of pie or a whole pie to take home. All homemade and fresh everyday

Absolutely delicious and decadent pies. We have used them several times and always order the Pear Almond, but the Brownie is a show stopper as well. Their pie shop is adorable with above and beyond customer service.

Delicious pies every time! The most adorable pie shop in Tulsa!