Corey's Bakery - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Can’t say enough good things about Corey and his shop. My daughter wanted a custom heart hello Kitty cake for her 16th birthday. I spoke with Corey and told him the idea she had and he made it all come to life. She wanted it to be red velvet, and it was the best tasting cake I have ever had. I will definitely be doing my business here again! Thank you again, Corey!

My fiance and I went to Corey's Bakery today for a cake tasting and had the most heartfelt time with him! His cakes are phenomenal such as his hospitality! Corey has taken the time to get to know us so he knows what he is working with and it makes me so thankful to find someone who cares so much about his clients! We had decided to go with his cakes for our wedding and I am so excited!!!

Corey made a pineapple upside down cake for my mom’s birthday and she said it was a 10/10. Thanks Corey 😊

My daughter and I had the best taste testing experience at Corey’s. When we walked in my daughters first response was it looked like a set right out of Bridgerton. And we loved the red wine glasses. Corey was a blast to chat with! Plus, we got to eat the most delicious cake ever. Spoiler alert…He picks his own strawberries for His strawberry flavor. It’s like eating fresh strawberries with the best buttercream icing on top. And don’t forget his special with the champagne flavoring. It was our favorite. Check out the website. It’s very helpful. And he will be doing my daughter’s 35 birthday cake. He’s the first one I called and I didn’t have to go any further. Corey aims to please. Xoxo PS More to follow. lol

Corey was absolutely amazing to work with making our wedding day past special. He paid attention to intricate detail and 100% mapped it out on our cake. I fully recommend him and his team for any and every occasion!

Corey did an amazing job on our wedding cake! It was absolutely beautiful! He is also a wonderful person to work with. He is so sweet, and he makes sure to get back to you if you have any questions or need anything. Amazing artistry on the cake, and the best customer service!

This was my first time ordering from Corey’s Bakery and it was such a great experience ! Corey helped me fulfill my dream birthday party through this beautiful cake. It was exactly what I wanted. Also, the BEST customer service ever. I loved the vanilla champagne cake flavor. Thank you, Corey.

I love my cake! My sister turned 30 and wanted a personalized cake and I got exactly what I wanted! 🖤🖤

All we tried so far are the chocolate chip cookies. These are the cookies that made Cookie the Cookie Monster! Wonderful taste and texture We will try more. Thank you-Corey!

Being from Tampa originally it's too far to drive to my old bakery Alessi. So I gave this bakery a try and was not disappointed. Everything we picked out was so delicious and was at a reasonable price. Will differently be a repeat customer.

Hi ..this is my first time trying this at Brooksville Bites Nites and it won't be my last I loved it all

Corey and his team are amazing!!! They were so easy to work with to make my vision come true!! I wanted a dartboard themed cake for a surprise for my now husband during our rehearsal dinner. The whole process was a breeze, I sent them a picture of what I wanted and they far exceeded my expectations!! AND it was delicious!!!! Thank you so so much, my husband was so surprised and everyone loved the cake!!!!

Freshly baked banana bread is awesome!

So i went all the way to Key West for Key Lime Pie and I should not have left New Port Richey. Corey’s is to die for. Can’t wait to try the Pumpkin Pie! I will be back! He has now done two wedding cakes for our family both were amazing, vanilla with raspberry filling and red velvet with cream cheese frosting! Not sure which was my favorite both were the best!

Corey makes a cake to remember! We got so many compliments after my daughter’s wedding we enjoyed another one for my moms 80th birthday!!! Thank you Corey!!! You are great to deal with and your cakes are superb.

Corey that birthday cake was amazing!! Youd did such a great job on it! Thank you so much!!

I called in 2 days before thanksgiving for an Apple Pie for a dessert for thanksgiving. Corey was super friendly and funny! We bought the apple pie and when I got there he recommended one of his limited Peach pies. Both were absolutely amazing! I don’t like pie but I loved these!! It was even better he’s 2 mins away from where I live! I will definitely be back for Christmas pies! Definitely a little hidden gem and so glad I found them.

We picked up a Dutch Blueberry pie from Corey for Thanksgiving and it was hands down the best blueberry pie we've ever had. It was definitely a hit at the potluck! Corey himself is a lovely person, and cares very much about his customers. Don't hesitate to visit Corey and pick up some of his delicious desserts.

I'm not petty.. but I would have made more phone calls, I need a pie tomorrow afternoon.. don't say you can do something if you can't just really frustrating And after reading the response I have to add more I was not told to call back in ten minutes like your assistant said or a half hour like yourself just said.. Infact I had asked when you close to make sure to call back before... And I also confirmed you could make the pie for me so I wouldn't call more people... You literally took my order and said to call back... At the end of the day you can be busy that's fine but don't make people wait for you just to tell them no in the end now I have to scramble around today to make up for your lack of professionalism I hope you guys do better in the future Customer service is a big part of running a business..

Cory’s bakery is amazing we went on 11/11 for a wedding cake tasting and the cake was the best flavored and best tasting we have ever eaten. And there isn’t enough positive things I can say about Cory himself what an amazing person and baker!!!! We booked him on the spot!!! The best baker and bakery in Tampa Bay, all the cakes we tried we were blown away by. Cory you have customers for life we will be using you for all of our events in the future. Thank you again for an excellent experience your truly are an amazing person.

This has been a long time coming but my wife and I were married just over 5 years ago and Corey made an absolutely amazing cake for us. We went with the Caribbean Cooler, which was an absolute hit and had people raving about the flavor. We placed an order to celebrate our 5th anniversary with the same cake (one tier this time) and can't wait to dive in again. Corey, thank you so much for helping to make our big day that much more special!

This place is amazing. Corey was able to make me a last minute cake for my friend's bridal shower. He was slammed but still made time to make me a cake, even with me contacting him 48 hours prior. The customer service is oustanding and the cake was absolutely beautiful, and delicious. It was made just the way I wanted it. Thank you Corey!

Tried the Brownie and Strawberry Sangria, they were both amazing!!

We loved 😍 ❤️ it. Service was great and the taste of the cake was exquisite.... Highly recommend

I could add in countless wedding cakes that Corey's Bakery has done for weddings I have photographed. Corey and his team create the most beautiful and delicious creations and are also so caring and thoughtful. I've known Corey my entire time in business and he did chocolate chip cookie favors for my party and they were the most delicious and amazing. I can not recommend Corey's Bakery enough you must use them for all your events and celebrations!!!

Thank You Corey , the wife loved her Birthday Cake . I wish I took a pic of it . She was amazed at the size and how much more flavor it had then a store bought German chocolate cake . She was surprised with the cheesecake filling it made her very happy that her two favorite cakes were combined into one . I will be purchasing another cake from you again soon . Thank You for everything. 🎉

After having a small issue with a cake corey contacted me personally to make sure I ended up being a happy customer. He was personable, friendly, and went above and beyond to make sure I was happy. He's a great example of what all business owners should aspire to be, exemplary customer service oriented. Took ownership, rectified the situation and created a happy customer. Thank you Corey, we'll see you soon.

Excuse Me!!!!! I purchased a brownie while at Bexley's Hub and my god. You absolutely can tell this is a passed down recipe. The whole brownie is delicious. I'm just hoping it can make it home to my husband. I 100% recommend and will shop in the near future.

Our cake was fabulous! The taste was perfect, not sickening sweet. The decoration was adorable! With very little instruction Corey made the cutest sloth cake for us. I highly recommend Corey's Bakery. Corey is a super nice guy too!

Ordered some goodies as a Thank You and the group absolutely loved them!! Corey did an amazing job designing a cake and assortment of sweets with the budget I had given him. Service was fast and courteous and I highly recommend!!!!

Oh my goodness I cannot even express the absolute deliciousness. Corey is so very talented and every bakery good he has made taste fantastic. He literally puts his heart and soul into his craft!

Fix your hours!! Drove 20 mins to find you closed. Google said open until 6pm

Corey's Bakery by far is the best Bakery in the town!!! You better get you one of these Cakes!! Thank you again Corey!!!! :)

We were lucky enough to see Corey in action during an event at our B&B and were thoroughly impressed by him and his baking abilities! This is one baker you defjnitely want on your side! His creativity blends so well with his baking skills and you will not be disappointed in the final result! We can't wait to have another taste!

He made us a vegan and nut free cake for our wedding with a dietary restriction, you can tell he takes pride in what he does. Will definitely use him in the future! Thanks Corey!

The cakes and pies are amazing. I have ordered there many times and I have never had a bad experience. Corey’s cakes are always moist and delicious

What can I say other than EXCELLENT. Corey is always putting his own creative twists on the classics and I am always amazed. Corey’s cakes and pies are always moist, and flavorful without being overly sweet. I highly recommend checking him out. You won’t be disappointed

When the 5 year old decides she wants a birthday cake a few days prior to the party I called Corey’s. With no real ideas outside of rainbows, unicorns, glitter. We did the entire transaction over the phone and email. Went to pickup up and it looked great! A cakes look is important, but the taste matters and frankly the cake flavor was perfectly balanced with the frosting for an all around decadent experience. My only complaint would be not eating a second slice… it was that good 🤠😎. Corey’s cakes are amazing !

Corey is ABSOLUTELY amazing. 5 stars from the start. I called stressed, needing a last minute cake for my brothers birthday. He was very accommodating and patient. They even added a little personal touch to this cake. It turned out so much better than I imagined. I thank him and his team forever! I will definitely be back. Thank you Corey, my brother loves his cake <3

Corey's Bakery you have blown our minds! Not only was the cake breathtaking, it was so delicious! My mom took Corey a piece of my dress that was trimmed off during alterations and he matched the color and overall design to it. The detail is mesmerizing! A total masterpiece and we are forever grateful ❤️🎂 just amazing! ❤️❤️❤️

Corey’s helped us get a delicious wedding cake for my family. It was PERFECT, moist and turned out just as expected. Thank you!

He did a wedding cake for my cousin and it was honestly one of the best cakes I’ve had! It was the perfect frosting to cake ratio, and tasted so good!!

Very helpful when I called to order a cake with short notice. The cake was truly beautiful and tasted wonderful! My only complaint is that the cake boxes are so flimsy and make it hard to handle when carrying/transporting. That won't keep me from going back but I'll just know to be prepared for that next time. Overall great service, very accommodating, great decorating, and great taste!

Corey's Bakery is an amazing place for cakes and Pastries.

Corey's bakery did my daughter's wedding cake 2 years ago, I went to the cake tasting beforehand and every sample was delicious. The wedding cakes were beautiful and delicious. I just had Corey do a Finding Nemo cake for my granddaughter's 2nd birthday. The blueberry cake is and was wonderful. I have also sampled Cory's mini loaf cakes, the Caribbean Cooler and Strawberry. You have to try this bakery and custom cake shop. I don't live near this shop so ordered extra mini loaves in different flavors just so I could put them in the freezer to have whenever I want some delicious cake! I will definitely be back!

Corey made our wedding cake and it was beautiful and everyone enjoyed it. Would highly recommend using Corey's Bakery for any special occasion where a sweet treat is needed!

Corey is no joke! My fiancés birthday/mother’s day cake was truly outstanding. We were quiet and just shaking our heads saying “ummmm”. Fantastic work Mr. Corey and we will be seeing you in June 2024!

My 50th birthday 2 tier cake surpassed all my expectations. Wasn't a piece left. The butter cream frosting was perfect and the cake itself inside was just the right amount of texture.

I cannot say enough about chef Corey and Corey’s Bakery. His personality and his cakes are both wonderful! We have been ordering from Corey for many years: just because, birthdays, engagement party and finally our wedding. Everybody couldn’t stop raving about the cake and many wanted seconds! His vanilla cake is some of the best I’ve ever had. If you want simple and elegant or fun and unique, Corey’s Bakery is the place to order from hands down!!

This man's cakes are phenomenal! You need a cake done for a birthday, wedding, special event, then look no further!