Elm Hill Pizza in Newington - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Best pizza you can get. We came all the way from Texas and made sure we got our pizza from here. They never disappoint and its always fresh.

This is the real deal, best pizza anywhere! The sauce, the crust, family owned and always consistent.

This place is classic in Newington for as long as I can remember. I grew up eating this pizza with my family every Friday night. I remember going there in the early 80’s as a kid and playing video games.. It’s been over 35 years and it’s still a great place. Great family that owns it too..

One of my all time favorite pizza places! They’re always busy, but they are always right on time with when they say the order will be ready. We always get a pepperoni and a buffalo chicken pizza. The buffalo chicken pizza is AMAZING. Red sauce but still with a great buffalo flavor. And breaded chicken… 😮‍💨 Last time we dined in and were taken such good care of. Forever suggesting this place to people! Usually our pizza is square cut (which we prefer), but wasn’t done this way on the medium.. maybe it’s just the size we ordered but square cut >>>

The number one pizza restaurant in Newington. The best.

Stopped at Elm Hill Pizza with my Dad on my way to see my Grandma. After 40+ years it’s still his favorite, and now it’s mine too. Easily the best pizza in Newington and possibly the best in Connecticut. A must-stop if you’re in the area, and worth going out of your way.

The place has a small staff, but the pizza is worth the wait. The prices are quite reasonable. Friendly customers.

I loved it there! People are friendly and efficient. It is a family place and one feels like one belongs to a family too. Delicious food!

A family owned establishment with excellent food is a must try.

Great sauce and pizza. Love the crust!

Clean place , staff is cool , needed some food so stoped here ordered a large sausage pie got home very greasy and dough was was under cooked

Food is very good. Salads are always fresh and dressings are perfect. Sometimes the grilled chicken is too hard. Grinders are great and huge. Chicken tenders and fries are well done but sometimes kind of spice (maybe they use pepper). Prices are fair. Overall excellent

Love the Calzones and Chicken Parmesan grinders here!

Hometown local and showed this place to some coworkers. Always quality food and customer service. The inside is small but for takeout its perfect. Their calzones are huge!!

I ordered a large cheese and meat and they didn't add the cheese as they should and then they charge $18.20 but it seems like they don't have any 🧀🧀🧀🧀🧀🧀🧀

One of the best place to get pizza and especially their wings! Will not regret coming here!

Their pizza not like they used to be! Dry alittle bit! But overall everything else is ok

Small place, great for takeout. Pizza is very good overall.

Not what It used to be, my pizza was tasteless and too bready. I once asked for a Greek pizza and the person asked me what goes on it. It wasn't good. I'm sorry.

We just order pizza from there Monday because the other place we went to the pizza was being burned on the toppings. This place is nice and friendly. The pizza was great Elm special. Next we're going to try the grinders

Superior Pizza 🤌🏽🤌🏽🤌🏽🤌🏽 nice crunchy crust and well seasoned 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 slices are a bit small but that’s fine when it taste so good 👅

Good grinders. Loved it there ♥

This is my local pizza place I have been coming to for over 10 years now and I have never been to a better place. Not only is the pizza AMAZING and I dream of it when i’m away at college but they truly care about their community and are the kindest people. They remember me year after year even after moving away to college and I cannot recommend them more to anyone in the area!

New to the area and first time having this pizza. Very good and would highly recommend.

Good food and pricing! Would recommend it for sure!

My go to place for pizza. Plus, very friendly staff. Not particularly found of the chicken parm grinders. The roll was burnt and the cutlet was not the best quality which was a surprise plus, the grinder was not assembled neatly

The food was amazing and Nick was very nice and helpful. The place was very clean and everyone was very friendly. I will back to try some of the other foods.

oh my god this pizza is from heaven the best pizza in ct amazing fast service, what a wonderful experience. I will be only ordering from here.

Pizza is always great an I love there grinders .❤️I never had any problems with there food .

Always great customer service and the food is so good! Especially the Buffalo chicken pizza!

Love the pizza. The grinders are huge and so delicious.

Best pizza around. Family owned, and everyone is so friendly. Growing up, we had pizza here every Fri night from Elm Hill. Even though we no longer live in town, Elm Hill Pizza is still our go-to.

Great food and large potions at reasonable prices. Try the chicken parmigiana grinder.

The wings were my favorite... so good

Great pizza and great people. could b loud, they always busy ❤️

Pizza Is Aways hot and fresh and delicious!

Family owned and operated by a great bunch! Food is always on point and fresh. Large special pizza well done is my go to beside their capicolla grinder with all the fixins!!

Best pizza around, never had a bad experience

Food is always great. Try the elm hill special

Very good pizza and calzone :D (Traducido por Google) Muy buena pizza y calzone :D

Great pizza (Traducido por Google) gran pizza

It's the worst 50 dollars I spent the pizza was 🍞 and is was so not good am use to my pizza having toppings i can see and a paid for extra cheese and sauce ill never be there (Traducido por Google) Son los peores 50 dólares que gasté en la pizza 🍞 y no fue tan bueno. Estoy acostumbrado a que mi pizza tenga ingredientes que puedo ver y nunca estaré allí.

I can't say enough good of this place! (Traducido por Google) No puedo decir lo suficiente de este lugar!

Best pizza! Sooooo good!!! Pleasant staff!! (Traducido por Google) ¡La mejor pizza! Muuuuy bien!!! Personal agradable!!

Was my favorite pizza house until last couple visits my calzone was full of some kind of liquid inside and it wasn’t baked enough the dough was still raw on one side🤬 (Traducido por Google) Era mi pizzería favorita hasta las últimas dos visitas, mi calzone estaba lleno de algún tipo de líquido por dentro y no estaba lo suficientemente horneado, la masa todavía estaba cruda por un lado 🤬

Been going there over 50 years. Had some downfalls few years ago but being so friendly I think customer vented. Issues solved! (Traducido por Google) He estado yendo allí más de 50 años. Tuve algunas fallas hace unos años, pero al ser tan amable, creo que el cliente se desahogó. ¡Problemas resueltos!

The standard by which I measure pizzerias. (Traducido por Google) El estándar por el cual mido las pizzerías.

Consistently great pizza since I was a kid. My go to when visiting Central Ct (Traducido por Google) Siempre una gran pizza desde que era un niño. Mi visita cuando visite Central Ct

Revisited this place after being out of state. The calzones and pizza still the best I have eaten. I live my calzones and no one can out do elm hill pizza (Traducido por Google) Volví a visitar este lugar después de estar fuera del estado. Los calzones y la pizza siguen siendo los mejores que he comido. Vivo mis calzones y nadie puede hacer pizza Elm Hill

This was one of the best local pizza places I had from the time I was a child until I was almost 16 years old. (Traducido por Google) Esta fue una de las mejores pizzerías locales que tuve desde que era niño hasta que tenía casi 16 años.

Best pizza in town! We go once a week, esp on Fridays and when we need food and don't want to cook. Will keep on coming back over and over again! (Traducido por Google) ¡La mejor pizza de la ciudad! Vamos una vez a la semana, especialmente los viernes y cuando necesitamos comida y no queremos cocinar. Seguirá viniendo una y otra vez!

Felt very unwelcoming and waitress was very rude..I will never return (Traducido por Google) Me sentí muy poco acogedor y la camarera fue muy grosera. Nunca volveré.

My pizza is always hot and good I love this place (Traducido por Google) Mi pizza siempre está caliente y buena. Me encanta este lugar.

Family owned pizza shop! Great service and awesome pizza a must try if your in Newington/New Britain (Traducido por Google) ¡Pizzería familiar! Gran servicio y pizza increíble que debes probar si estás en Newington / New Britain

One of the best pizza spots around , beautiful greek pie , everything is always fresh and delicious (Traducido por Google) Uno de los mejores lugares de pizza, hermoso pastel griego, todo es siempre fresco y delicioso.

Great Food🤌🏼 (Traducido por Google) Buena comida 🤌🏼

Great mom & pop pizza 🍕 place (Traducido por Google) ¿Gran lugar de pizza para mamá y papá?

The meal is excellent in both quality and quantity, and the prices are very, very fair. Everything was top-notch. Fair rates, excellent food, and a welcoming, family-run restaurant. (Traducido por Google) La comida es excelente tanto en calidad como en cantidad, y los precios son muy, muy justos. Todo fue de primera categoría. Tarifas justas, excelente comida y un acogedor restaurante familiar.

Great family restaurant (Traducido por Google) Gran restaurante familiar

Simply the Best!! (Traducido por Google) ¡¡Simplemente lo mejor!!

Great customer service! The staff is very professional & respectful. Best 🍕 pizza. (Traducido por Google) ¡Excelente servicio al cliente! El personal es muy profesional y respetuoso. La mejor 🍕pizza.

So we are new to Newinton and on the to do list is finding a go to pizza/grinder spot. Pros. They are open late and customer service was awesome. Cons...My Grinder was sub par...let's face it it was bad. The roll was dry and abrasive and the meat did not taste fresh. Alas this will not be my go to, at least not for Grinders. (Traducido por Google) Entonces, somos nuevos en Newinton y en la lista de cosas por hacer está encontrar un lugar para ir a pizza / molinillo. ventajas Están abiertos hasta tarde y el servicio al cliente fue increíble. Contras... Mi molinillo estaba por debajo de la media... seamos realistas, era malo. El rollo estaba seco y abrasivo y la carne no sabía fresca. Por desgracia, este no será mi destino, al menos no para Grinders.

Omg (Traducido por Google) Dios mío

I love that it is a family run restaurant with dining in or take out options, although the dining in area is small the food definitely makes up for it. Everyone that works there is very professional, very personable, and I have not had one problem with anything I have ever ordered from there. They definitely go the extra mile to give you exactly what you want. The quality and quantity of the food is awesome and the pricing is very very reasonable. I live on social security and they don't give you enough money to throw out the window for lousy food, but I love this place and I get to have their food a couple times a month. Thank you elm Hill Pizza (Traducido por Google) Me encanta que sea un restaurante familiar con opciones para cenar o para llevar, aunque el área para comer es pequeña, la comida definitivamente lo compensa. Todos los que trabajan allí son muy profesionales, muy agradables, y no he tenido ningún problema con nada de lo que he pedido allí. Definitivamente hacen un esfuerzo adicional para darte exactamente lo que quieres. La calidad y cantidad de la comida es increíble y el precio es muy razonable. Vivo de la seguridad social y no te dan suficiente dinero para tirar por la ventana por una comida pésima, pero me encanta este lugar y puedo tener su comida un par de veces al mes. Gracias Elm Hill Pizza

Pizza was soggy and full of grease and way over priced for what you get. I would never eat here again. If you live in this area do your self a favor and avoid this place at all costs. The inside is dirty too. (Traducido por Google) La pizza estaba empapada y llena de grasa y muy cara para lo que obtienes. Nunca volvería a comer aquí. Si vives en esta área, hazte un favor y evita este lugar a toda costa. El interior también está sucio.

We've lived around the corner for 36 years and this is the first time I've reviewed Elm hill Pizza, goes without saying it's awesome !! We got the most delicious roast beef grinder today and it never fails,, so good! We have Niece's and Nephew's who come home to Connecticut and always need to have your pizza before they leave! Tradition!! Awesome French fries too!!! And eggplant grinders!! (Traducido por Google) Hemos vivido a la vuelta de la esquina durante 36 años y esta es la primera vez que reviso Elm hill Pizza, ¡no hace falta decir que es increíble! Hoy tenemos el molinillo de carne asada más delicioso y nunca falla, ¡qué bueno! ¡Tenemos sobrinas y sobrinos que vienen a casa a Connecticut y siempre necesitan tener su pizza antes de irse! ¡¡Tradición!! Patatas fritas impresionantes también!!! Y molinillos de berenjenas!!

Great pizza! The crust was very nicely toasted and the sauce was very good! (Traducido por Google) ¡Gran pizza! ¡La corteza estaba muy bien tostada y la salsa era muy buena!

Awesome pizza, flaky crust is fantastic!! Delicious, generous grinders, kielbasa my favorite 😍. Add in great family business and customer service and all I can say is WOW!!! (Traducido por Google) Impresionante pizza, la corteza escamosa es fantástica!! Molinillos deliciosos y generosos, kielbasa mi favorito 😍. Agregue un gran negocio familiar y servicio al cliente y todo lo que puedo decir es ¡GUAU!

Omg ! Their wings to die for ! So crunchy and seasoned. Love their food (Traducido por Google) Dios mío ! ¡Sus alas para morirse! Tan crujiente y sazonada. Me encanta su comida

They have awesome food a staff is very friendly (Traducido por Google) Tienen comida increíble un personal es muy amable

Great food, unbelievable chicken wings best in the state,eat your heart out J Timothy (Traducido por Google) Buena comida, increíbles alitas de pollo, las mejores del estado, come tu corazón J Timothy

Great subs, good bread to filling portions. (Traducido por Google) Grandes sandwiches, buen pan para llenar porciones.

Had lunch with a friend, met the owner and a couple regulars. The food was great, staff was top notch. I'd be happy to go back any time I'm in the area (Traducido por Google) Almorcé con un amigo, conocí al dueño y a un par de clientes habituales. La comida era genial, el personal era de primera categoría. Estaría feliz de volver cada vez que esté en el área

Great Pizza! Great people! I ordered a pizza the other day and asked if they would lightly cook the crust. It was the most amazing pizza I've had in a long time! A+ pizza!🍕 (Traducido por Google) ¡Gran pizza! ¡Buena gente! Pedí una pizza el otro día y pregunté si cocinarían ligeramente la corteza. ¡Fue la pizza más increíble que he probado en mucho tiempo! ¡Pizza A+!🍕

Absolute best Greek pizza I have had. I Highly recommend (Traducido por Google) Absolutamente la mejor pizza griega que he tenido. Te lo recomiendo mucho

Great grinders some of the best in Newington. Great i left with a smile rare roast Beef (Traducido por Google) Grandes molinillos, algunos de los mejores en Newington. Genial, me fui con una sonrisa rara carne asada

Best pizza in town!!! Friendly service, good choices of toppings. Grinders are excellent. (Traducido por Google) La mejor pizza de la ciudad!!! Servicio amable, buenas opciones de coberturas. Los molinillos son excelentes.

First time trying this place and I don’t regret it. I ordered the Elm hill special pizza and it was amazing. (Traducido por Google) Primera vez que pruebo este lugar y no me arrepiento. Pedí la pizza especial de Elm Hill y fue increíble.

By far one of the best pizzas I’ve had in all of Connecticut. Had their supreme pizza. It is a must. (Traducido por Google) De lejos, una de las mejores pizzas que he probado en todo Connecticut. Tenía su pizza suprema. Es obligatorio.

Excellent pizza (Traducido por Google) excelente pizza

Elm Hill pizza is my favorite pizza in the world! It's the closest to S&G pizza, if you remember it from New Britain. It's amazing pizza house pizza! I get it every time I go home to visit family! (Traducido por Google) ¡La pizza Elm Hill es mi pizza favorita en el mundo! Es lo más parecido a la pizza S&G, si la recuerdas de New Britain. ¡Es una pizza increíble de la casa de pizza! ¡Lo recibo cada vez que voy a casa a visitar a la familia!

love their meatball and eggplant grinders (Traducido por Google) Me encantan sus molinillos de albóndigas y berenjenas.

This small town Pizza place must be one of the best kept secrets in Newington for Pizza. Have come her for years and they never stop amazing for quality and customer service even when they have a line of people waiting that extend outside. (Traducido por Google) Esta pizzería de pueblo pequeño debe ser uno de los secretos mejor guardados de Newington for Pizza. Han venido a ella durante años y nunca dejan de sorprender por la calidad y el servicio al cliente, incluso cuando tienen una fila de personas esperando que se extienden afuera.

Great food and amazing staff (Traducido por Google) Buena comida y personal increíble

Great service. Very friendly. Great pizza (Traducido por Google) Gran servicio. Muy amigable. gran pizza

Great pizza, great family run business (Traducido por Google) Gran pizza, gran negocio familiar.

My favorite place (Traducido por Google) Mi lugar favorito

The BEST Turkey/Bacon sub in the world, no joke! (Traducido por Google) El MEJOR submarino de pavo/bacon del mundo, ¡no es broma!

The food was really good and the waitress was very nice. I would definitely recommend and I will be returning in the future. Thanks (Traducido por Google) La comida era muy buena y la camarera era muy agradable. Sin duda lo recomendaría y volveré en el futuro. Gracias

Delicious pizza, with a superb crispy crust. Fries were phenomenal. Friendly staff greeted me warmly upon entering. Very clean and welcoming space. (Traducido por Google) Deliciosa pizza, con una excelente corteza crujiente. Las patatas fritas eran fenomenales. El amable personal me recibió calurosamente al entrar. Espacio muy limpio y acogedor.

Delicious grinders, (especially their roast beef). And they don't cheat on the meat. Quality pizza and grinders at a reasonable price! (Traducido por Google) Deliciosos molinillos, (especialmente su carne asada). Y no engañan con la carne. ¡Pizzas y molinillos de calidad a un precio razonable!

Amazing quality for a surprisingly affordable price. Wish the staff wore masks… but I still eat there bc it’s so damn good. (Traducido por Google) Increíble calidad a un precio sorprendentemente asequible. Ojalá el personal usara máscaras... pero sigo comiendo allí porque es tan bueno.

Food is excellent. Greek salad with Bleu cheese or creamy Italian cannot be beat. Order a large salad and pizza, plenty for 4 people. Highly recommend. (Traducido por Google) La comida es excelente. La ensalada griega con queso Bleu o la italiana cremosa son insuperables. Pida una ensalada grande y pizza, suficiente para 4 personas. Altamente recomendado.

Highly recommend their Vegetable Pizza (Traducido por Google) Recomiendo encarecidamente su pizza vegetal.

Food is excellent. Have been going there for many years. (Traducido por Google) La comida es excelente. He estado yendo allí durante muchos años.

As stated by the many awards plastered around its homely environment, this is the #1 pizza place in Connecticut‼ (Traducido por Google) Como lo indican los numerosos premios que se encuentran en su entorno hogareño, esta es la pizzería número 1 en Connecticut‼

Hands down my FAVORITE pizza place! They were more friends than a pizza place and EVERYONE that goes feels the same. All you've to do is walk in. The pizza is awesome and so is the lasagna, which feels as it will last days 😆 (Traducido por Google) Sin duda mi pizzería FAVORITA! Eran más amigos que una pizzería y TODOS los que van sienten lo mismo. Todo lo que tienes que hacer es entrar. La pizza es increíble y también lo es la lasaña, que parece que durará días 😆

Awesome Greek style pizza. Super friendly staff. (Traducido por Google) Impresionante pizza estilo griego. Personal súper amable.

Pizza hit the spot. (Traducido por Google) La pizza dio en el clavo.

Loves here since 1999. Assumed it was just like a zillion other pizza places but we didn't get pizza. I got lasagna, sausage and meatball and my wife a meatball grinder. We are both Italian ( my wife 100%; me 50%) and we're "fussy" about the flavor. No issues here;. Great home-made taste and we will be back to try other items !