Fisherman's Island in Chicago - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Customer service was great didn’t really enjoy the food wasn’t fresh but the workers are great and friendly

Because they gave me all their food

Cool place/atmosphere with large selection of seafood. I really liked being there. Workers were friendly/helpful. I thought what I had (crab cake sandwich & clam chowder) was good but not great. Will definitely come back to try more things when we are in town again.

Love this place best in the city

I always get a #1 with a pound of shrimp and extra broccoli. I just hate this location because there's never anywhere to park. The food is always on point. Never had a problem here.

When I first started going here it was amazing! Good food at a reasonable price. Well not anymore! For the last couple of years the price has more than doubled and the portions are less than half. More times than not I have had under cooked fish or fries or both. I order the halibut fish and chips which is now $25.50 if you order an extra piece of fish. I had to start ordering the extra piece because I can't get full anymore with what they give me. By the way I weigh 155 lbs it doesn't take a lot to get me full but it's the quality that's gone down hill lately. I just got home with my order that was under cooked again! Both the fish and the Frye's so I called and let them know and the owner told me if I don't like it don't come back . So I won't! I just want all of you hard working people out there to know that this isn't the same place that Guy rated so highly Year's ago on diner's drive-ins and dives.

Nice spot, it's always crowded, so order ahead. Be careful of the possible crime eliminate there otherwise you're good to go

You can really taste a difference. The fish is fresh for the fish and chips. Lots of sauces to pick from and who doesn’t love a good waffle fry sort of our go to place when we drive through Eugene.

Looks like a hole in the wall but it's full of fresh fish and flavors. I got the halibut cheeks which I've never seen except when I was deep sea fishing. I also got the Fisherman soup which was super delicious, they have sandwiches and a wide range of beer selections. The line started to grow so make sure you give yourself plenty of time.

The clam chowder is the best there is. It is a little expensive, but well worth it. The parking lot is small and so is the seating area. However the quality of food cancelled out everything else.

They gave me a free order of shrimp, but it was still equivalent of how much they normally used to put shrimp altogether so they gave me one for free, but really didn’t because that’s how much would normally be in the regular pan

My food is always fresh! I get the veggie steam tray for $7 and add my own seafood, sauce and seasoning. I often have to ask for extra seasoning as they get a bit stingy but overall good seafood.

It’s very good everyone, clean, fresh and delicious! Pleasantly surprised!

I loved their chicken tender meal

Love this location the Cajun flavor a hit I even had the tbone steak was good I didn't get a pic but everything on the link they cook for a 1$ Bomb

Cool spot. Helpful staff. Great Ling Cod fish & chips. They have a really nice fresh fish section so you can take-away for home.

We rate the clam chowder here as our favorite in Oregon! A quart of clam chowder is not much more than a bowl in some places. We love the fish tacos, too. It's a great place to eat, take out or buy fresh seafood to prepare yourself.

Top notch seafood , loved watching people pick their crabs . Did a Cajun crawfish pie and grilled cod with chips . Awesome friendly staff and lots of locals !

Dungeness Crab was sweet and fresh. It was good as itself and doesn't need any dressing. Perfect service and staff were patient.

This place is so fire, the younger Mo specifically was the employee that made my experience truly 5 starts. Other than the the place is okay but he is the star of the show.

The seasoning and cooking I believe is timed very well.Ty.

The food was raw I got real sick

Pretty fast an order was right friendly customer service as well

Stopped in for a late lunch early dinner. Not only do they sell fresh seafood, but also have a pretty decent menu. This is not a traditional restaurant as seating AND parking are limited but the food is really good. Had the crab ravioli which was good, nice blended mix of cream and tomatoes, also had the crab mac and cheese. The New England stye clam chowder is good, had it in the bread bowl. To be honest should have had more thicker consistency but had a good flavor. They also provided samples, and the salmon sticks and salmon summer sausage were good. Staff was friendly. Prices seemed to be average for the area. If we were to be in the area, we would stop again. In speaking to a few locals, they were consistent in compliments of the restaurant and said that we made a good choice to eat there.

My favorite location hands down they got the best flavor and size of crab legs and you could use the link loving it

The food has always been good à little pricey but, you get your money worth. Love it.

Who knew you could pay for seafood with link.

Never a disappointment as far as I'm concerned as far as dinner goes. Great seafood, served with awesomely seasoned veggies 2 meet your every pallets desires.

My son and I shared shrimp and baked catfish with potatoes and Brussel sprouts.

I liked this place but everything tasted un done (told him shrimps was raw cause they was grey but he claims since they were busted open they were done well sir if they busted open then they should be red or light orange not freakin grey something is definitely wrong with shrimp & crableg meat was so crumbly ????? Be foreal!!)will be contacting business bureau because I’m nauseas & sick to my stomach I can’t believe them smh !!!! It’s always best to cook own anyways

Lobster tail was a little overcooked but overall decent food.

Food was okay, not as good as it use to be. The prices have doubled.

#20 snow crab legs are good I highly recommend this restaurant to family and friends and the public.

I like the food. Service was fast and efficient. Definitely will vist soon.

They Crab legs, Large Shrimps, Jumbo Shrimps, are good. I highly recommend this Restaurant to families and friends. Prices has increased on Seafood

I had the crab legs, shrimp, corn on the cob, broccoli, potatoes all covered in butter. It was delicious. I ate everything.

Wonderfully delicious seafood! I had the crab bisque, it was so good! Not too thick, lots of crab! Halibut and also Rockfish fish and chip meals were also ordered and they were both were really good as well. Limited seating inside and out. Not a fancy place, it is a fish market, but they have a great menu to order from!

Wow, fish was really fresh and very fair prices. Loved the waffle fries as the condiment bar. Overall very worthy of a return trip. Also a fish market

If someone looking for fish and sea products, it’s not a place for that. You will get better options even in small grocery stores

Great seafood 🦞. Get the Cajun seasoning.

Sought a fish place with a good Yelp rating. The Fisherman's Market came up, so we headed over. It has a unique layout but not bad - very casual and in no way formal. Ordered fish tacos and Rockfish sandwich and a side bowl of clam chowder. Tacos and Rockfish sandwich were very good. We enjoyed the sauce on the taco so much we bought a container of it to take with us when leaving. The clam chowder at many small pieces of potato with the skin still on it, which we liked very much. Unfortunately, the sense that there were any clams in a clam chowder did not exist. This was more like a good potato chowder. Be sure you use the restroom someplace before arriving. The restrooms here are outside the restaurant area, require getting a key to get into, and are disgusting. Would we return? Because we enjoy the tacos and the Rockfish sandwich so much, we would come back to try them again or other things. We would pass on the clam chowder and would use the restroom before heading to the restaurant.

It's normally crazy in this place but the food is great

Overcooked lobster and mussels. Not seasoned well enough compared to the other seafood places similar and the seafood isn't fresh at all just wasted $67. salmon was also overcooked and they give you small crab legs the vegetables are plentiful if your a vegan

I food was good I'm not shore if they own the gas station next door I felt like I need to watch my 6 while I was In there

Stepping into this place is like being on a dock next to the seaworthy fishing boats! It smells of fresh fish and the water tanks containing live shellfish. But it is a tight fit! There are a small number of tables inside and a few closely positioned tables outside. The seating makes little difference. The food is amazing. The chowders were filled with clams or salmon in a heavy creamy base seasoned perfectly! The fish tacos were a bargain. The portions are huge. The fish was very well prepared and filled with perfect combinations of toppings. You cannot go wrong with the crayfish pie! The crust is flaky and the filling was perfect. Unfortunately, we filled up on tacos, crayfish pie, and chowder before the enormous container of seafood boil arrived! Seafood gluttony! Clams, mussels, shrimp, sausage, crab, crayfish, potatoes, corn on the cob all smothered in superb buttery seasoning ! What a delicious mess we made!

If you go at night it's a wait but the food is seasoned and cooked perfect.

Rodney and I enjoy seafood a lot. We have gone a couple of times. He have to remember to order more of what we like

Happy Mother’s Day I Love this Restaurant customer service phenomenal food fantastic ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🍷🍷🍷🍷🍷🍷🍷🫂

Ordered catfish and perch and got tilapia.

I was very pleased with my very good food, pleasing to the eyes as well as the stomach! The place was very clean and I will recommend family/friends.

This is the best Fisherman's Island to me

The Worst place ever ,I do not recommend this location they are so slow..... they are so bad at taking orders they have young females working that have horrible attitudes 1st of all I ordered something at 5 PM my order wasn't even put in I go back at 5:30 to pick up they can't find my order it took them 10 minutes to give me back my money on my link card yes my f$!$@ link card They kept trying to make my food over at that point i was over it..The manager is horrible at customer service he couldn't even talk to me he sent another female up there to talk to me he kept trying to make my food in order to get my money yes my link card money all of that to make a sale ..Didnt even stop the line kept taking orders..... [87th Location BETTER] 😤that $1 cook fee they can keep it

Don't let the outside fool you - this is a great to either buy fish and cook it yourself or stop in and eat inside. We loved everything we ordered here: captains platter, fish and chips (halibut), shrimp, etc. We even bought a few things to go. These people know how to do fish and they know about fish, too! Highly recommend and definitely hope to return some day when we're back in the area.

All I can say if you like steamed seafood. That's the place

Their Seafood it's the best seafood that I pay can you get more for your money

I LIKE THE MORNING COOK BETTER THAN THE EVENING COOK

I always get my food from this location. Customer Service varies depending on the staff that is working, on the time and day of your visit! VERY LIMITED PARKING! Seeing that this location is connected to a gas station. People have a tendency to park at the pumps to go in, order, and wait in their food. They have security there to attend to these issues. However, they don't get ANY RESPECT for trying to do thier job, to maintain the operation in an orderly fashion!! I wish PEOPLE had more common sense these days, instead of thinking the world revolves around them!!! We are all trying to get our food and go!!!

My daughter had no complaints or my son I don't eat sea creatures, if a king crab came walking through my door I'm going to get a gun not a knife and fork.

Always good my kids love this place

The food was good but not enough food for the price i paid

Food is consistently fresh and delicious.They need to develop a quicker preparation time, so you don't have to wait so long!

Fish was good, but don't laugh at me cause when I finished eat the catfish I had to reorder some more to take home with me

💯They Da Plug Slide through if u haven't Already

The food is good hands down been eating there for yrs

Great food, great service....🦐🦞🦀🥦🥔🌽🍤

They need d real butter 🧈 no popcorn

I went with a coworker and we both ended up getting two different types of fish and chips. Both were amazing and we also got the crawfish pie that was excellent. We are from out of town and heard about it from DDD and we are glad we stopped by.

Great seafood boils choose your choice of seafood and sides 1st time ordering very satisfied 😌

Stopped in here quite by chance while driving to Portland and at first thought it couldn't serve food. But it does! Extremely friendly staff, and a long list of choices. Had a grilled tuna burger AND clam chowder and they were simply fantastic. My traveling companion had the crabcake sandwich that was declared very good even though it was not a Maryland crab cake, Pretty high praise indeed Picnic tables inside and out and some off-street parking. Found it on the google machine and did not disappoint, in fact it gladdened us for the rest of our journey,

I always have a great experience, the cashier female is always nice. Fresh good seafood

This place stay packed and they pretty quick with the food but check your food before you leave because they don't always get it 100% right

The corn isn’t fresh enough and there’s not enough season but overall it’s good

Dear God You buy we fry eat good on eat better today/Link card (EBT) prices a lil high

Good food. The girls that take the orders, are always nice.

Great dinner! We had a variety of things from the Captains Platter, Red Snapper Sandwich, Crab Cake Sandwich, Salmon sandwich. Everyone really enjoyed their meals and the fries and slaw that came with each meal was also delish! It was obvious the staff enjoy their jobs. A fun group! The only negative was that the tables were nasty as was the floor around them. It was 6:30 pm but not super swamped.

Husband & I visited for lunch. Glad we got there early, parking is a little painful! I ordered the halibut fish & chips grilled, it was perfectly cooked. Husband had the fried snapper sandwich and really enjoyed it. They have a sauce bar so you can pick and choose what you want to accompany your fish. Friendly service at the counter. Saw an employee nearby the counter slicing up a whole tuna - you don't get any fresher than this.

The best seafood!, I love the tilapia!

Too crowded but when u do get your order it is worth it

we both enjoyed our fresh fish dinners. my wife had the Captains Platter with chips and slaw, that was quite generous for the price and tasty, delicious and yummy. I had the Halibut Cheeks fried with chips and slaw. very good food for the great reasonable price. great people watching.

Always packed should call order in ahead of time

It's okay when you drunk my daughter wanted that

Their fish was juicy, tasty and delicious

We ate here en route to an afternoon of wine-tasting. Not fancy, loud, and parking is awful, but the fish is great. Love the sauce bar. The cocktail sauce is spicy! We meant to buy some, but forgot. We will be back to try some...

Great seafood at reasonable prices, I will definitely keep coming back to this place.

Its was excellent to order food with link card. My only problem everything tasted so blan...like no seasoning. It was like I was eating straight out the ocean.

Excellent seafood market with small kitchen pumping out great food out. Fish tacos are big. Also the creamy Cajun pasta was delicious. Plenty of homeward dipping sauces if you get fish and chips. The curry and the Cajun sauce I tried were both awesome. Fast...

Minus location, food was fresh my guy added some additional seasoning so pretty good overall.

Food is sooo good super cheap . You may wait a little bit but so worth it. It been amazing you get a lot food fo what you pay and is delicious take out only .

Very good sea food at reasonable prices

Food so fresh and good great customer service 👍

A little slow but delish none the less

Love this place. Just need more parking spaces

The goods - fresh fish & fries - cod and wahoo tacos - simple but fresh fish made a difference. Waffle fries were great. Price point was OK. Not so good - small portion of fish. The crayfish pot pie was just average (this is...

Very friendly. Professional. Parking could be a pain. Be Easy People. Love 💚💛🧡

I want to be clear about this rating. The food was excellent. What brought the rating down was telling me 20-25 minutes and I get there maybe 35 minutes later to wait 20-25 minutes AND THE PARKING SITUATION isn't good at all.

You can purchase the sea food with a link card. Food stamps great food so good

Very good seafood one of the best.

2nd time eating from there..👍🏾🔥🔥

Food is amazing & u get a lot for your buck

Good for my Daughter, but bad for me. I get sick from seafood smells, sorry