Forrest's Pizza in Silver City - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

If you like thin pizza or garlic knots, this is the place for you! The garlic knots might just be the best thing on their menu- if you dont like a lot of garlic they might not be for you. I will say this place is more expensive than many places in bigger cities so just a heads up- menu on google maps is outdated for pricing so I’ve included an updated menu. If you’ve never been its easy to miss- its in the “hub” shopping /outdoor space. Street parking is available (no meter) and lots of outdoor seating surrounding. Over all the food is not bad, im not convinced the pizza is worth the price tag but the garlic knots are.

I ordered Kim's favorite to go so I could enjoy it at the Airbnb I was staying at. Perfect pizza while enjoying the view. Young lady taking orders was very sweet. Great little spot.

Delicious NY style pizza, glad we bought extra slices for leftovers, yummy! Fast and friendly service, cute little downtown location.

Best pizza in Silver City! Yes, their prices have gone up more than once during the time we've been eating Forrest's. For a minute it felt too expensive, but the pizza however is almost always perfectly on point with thin crust and fresh, delicious toppings. The Kim's Favorite (alfredo sauce, spinach, artichoke hearts, and fresh garlic) is our...favorite! FYI no indoor seating. Local love.

I only wish they were in Sierra Vista,AZ The best pizza 🍕..💕🤙🏻

I love this pizza!!! It’s home made everything!!! Delicious. It’s not a sit down place but there are cute tables and chairs outside.

I dont know what grateful living is but your service is terrible and so is the attitude of the pesron in charge of reviews. How about being professional and having some accountability.

This place is a downtown Silver City staple. Owned by some of the kindest people I’ve met since moving here. Their pizza is always fresh, hot and delicious. Their salads are always crisp and fresh (like better than I can find at the grocery stores here). They’re able to handle special requests like it nothing. They are probably one of the most consistent business in town. Can’t recommend this place enough.

The Angel is The best pizza ever !!

Tried it while we were in town for Tour of the Gila. Awesome pizza.

Nice covered outdoor spot to eat. Great quality pie and dessert.

Great pizza out of a closet sized kitchen! Friendly staff and great smells of pizza will lead you there. Highly recommend pizza stop.

Went here years ago, never reviewed, but still thinking about that pizza! Can't wait to make it back someday!

Best pizza I've had outside the tristate area. Took me back to when I worked out of north Jersey. Accommodations are non-existent (there's no dining room inside, take-out only) but the pie I got was fantastic. I live 90 minutes away, but I could see myself driving there just for this pizza.

Great pizza, quick service, and friendly staff. Supper yummy! Thanks for the great food!

This is top 5 the best pizza I’ve ever had.

Green chiles on your pizza is a requirement when you're around the area and Forrest's absolutely kills it every time. I appreciate the sense of care they have for the community and making even strangers feel welcome. I'll be back again for sure!

Big props to Matt and Miles. Told me I’d love pizza. They were absolutely correct. Thanks guys !!

Thank you for a great place to get tasty, affordable pizza in the heart of downtown!

The pizza slices are so big and delicious! Totally worth the price

The pizza and service was excellent!

It's just a grab and go! But wow, is it good!

I prefer Italian pizza to New York style (I'm Italian, have spent lots of time eating Pizza in Italy). It is rare to see 50 reviews here and nothing below 3 star, but Forrest's has pulled it off. Having been to New York and eating lots of those pies, it is hard for me to believe the many reviews here saying this pizza is as good/better than all those places in New York or New Jersey. Maybe Silver City is prettier and people figure they'll never get a good pizza there, so they're rating on some kind of curve. New York style is foldable. I don't think I'll ever rate that kind of pizza as 5 star, because I love something crunchy, or at least I can't do pizza with a mushy center, so that when you pick it up, it falls all over the place unless you fold it. This is American pizza, loaded with cheese. Italian Sausage was not much and ok. If you really want a great pizza like you can get in New York City, you'll have to go there. . With millions of people and all that history, they have way better "American pies". it was good. I'd get another one with less cheese and hope it is a little better than my first one. Basically it reminded me of the pizza i got in college at Uncle Jim's in Madison WI when i went to school years ago. I think I got less than usual, and will go back to see if it's any better next time, but I won't hope for the sky next time. Best pizza I've had in the US........is in Boise Idaho. Wylder is the restaurant. It's not wood fired, and it's not super expensive, but it is superior pizza.

The pizza was really good but I think it's a bit expensive.

Great pizza, I feel it's the best in town. I go every month. The Staff is awesome.

Visiting area, originally from New England. Bought slices of combo pizza that were amazingly good. Best pizza we have had in the Southwest! Excellent customer service, she sliced one piece in half for us to share. Highly recommend this place at the Hub. Outside seating in the sun or shade.

The building is small and it's not much to look at but the pizza is amazing!

Best pizza I’ve had in a long time.

Great pizza. 👍 remember, it's carry-out only.

Great pizza worth the drive from deming

Awesome variety of pizza toppings! I had the Angel pizza and every bite was delicious! Definitely would come back the next time I'm in town.

Best pizza in town!!! Fast service. There's rosemary growing in the back yard, I love to sprinkle it on my pizza!

We ordered 3 pies for lunch for work today!! They were the B O M B!!! Thanks, Kim and Forrest!! You guys are the Best!!

We ordered a pizza to take out (while we were in town for the Silver City Blues Festival) and it was really good: Ricotta Cheese, Pepperoni, Black Olives, and Green Chile! The crust and sauce were amazing. We even ate the leftovers for breakfast and it was still amazing!

Handmade pizza is the best and the cook here really makes it special everytime. Highly recommend!!👌😃

Delicious pizza, friendly service.

We had the 18" "Kim's favorite". According to my nephew, this is the best pizza ever! We even had the leftovers cold the next day and it was still wonderful. This pizza place comes highly recommended.

Came down to visit family. I was told this was the best pizza in town. Very disappointed.

We checked reviews and decided to try Forrest's Pizza. That was definitely a good call. The amount of toppings were a bit scant. The Italian sausage in particular was very good. The cheese was the quality cheese that you want to see on a pizza. The sauce was bland. The crust, however, was very good....over all, Forrest's Pizza puts out one of the better pizzas in the state. Definitely worth a try!

Best pizza I've had since I left the northeast

We recently had the pleasure of delicious pizza from Forest’s Pizza in Silver City. The pizza was great — good crust with fresh toppings. Beyond the high quality pizza, a staff member noticed our license plate was falling off so she fixed it while we picked up the pizzas!! Go to Forest’s pizza. Enjoy the pizza and truly kind staff.

Easily the best pizza in town! It's never once upset my stomach, and the staff is always a pleasure.

Stopped by to grab a pizza on the way home after a long day. Grabbed a large pepperoni and ricotta with a house salad. Absolutely amazing. Perfect chewy/crispy thin crust, bright tomato flavor, savory pepperoni and no shortage of creamy ricotta. This pizza is a must try. Don't be intimidated by it's size, leftovers reheat amazingly. Worth every penny!

Best pizza we've had in YEARS!! Bought 2 pizzas traveling through to bring home its so good!! Made with love ❤️

Super delicious pizza slices and salads

Our new favorite pizza place!! Great customer service, great food!!

They were an ok pizza place when they were one of the only few places open during the pandemic, but since then the quality has gone down drastically and the place always looks dirty

One of the worst and toughest pizza I’ve had. Dough was so tough and overcooked a sharp knife wouldn’t cut it. Save your money and get a frozen pizza.

Best pizza in Silver City! By the slice or get a whole pie. Thin crust, delicious toppings, friendly service.

Great crust and sauce and that's the base for an excellent pie!

The real deal, the crust holds it up, the sauce knocks it out. Order out or pick up, cause this isn't dine in (a few seats outside can be had). Big slices and a proper measure of cheese and toppings. No soggy pie here my friends. I dunno how you eat your pies, but this one promotes the fold, though a two handed feeder method works well. The crust has crunch and chew where you want crunch and chew, the sauce is king and they do it 100%. Get a sauce to go, cause you're gonna want it for the crusts. You can chill there and watch the world pass you bye, but I found that to many people distracted me from putting pizza in my face, so I took it home to be alone and get serious. Get some Forrest's and do you.

Great pizza! Pizza by the slice or whole. Slices are large and make for a nice lunch. There isn't any indoor seating or even large enough inside for more than one customer so food has to be to go or sit in one of the outdoor tables.

INCREDIBLE PIZZA, INCREDIBLE PEOPLE should be their slogan. What a great place with exceptional food. Easily the best pizza around.

Amazing food, service and prices Freshly made to order. I highly recommend them. Salads , whole pies or by the slice, drinks , cheese cakes canolli

takes forever but... their pizza its legit! the salad a little pricey for what it comes with. and they never seem to have the greek salad.

Took a bit but totally worth it. This pizza is amazing and it’s great sitting out in the plaza. Good experience

Awesome pizzas made by some of the nicest folks in town! You won't regret anything from this fantastic place!

Got a few slices and they were amazing. This place is a must try.

The best pizza! It's always perfect!!

Best pizza in town! The owner, Kim, is always so friendly. Their salads are amazing too. Freshly made dressing!

Sweet little pizza shop in the heart of town. Nice crust and the sauce is just right. You can just get a slice if you like.

Best Pizza in town for sure. you wont be disappointed.

Amazing pizza the best i have had in the USA in years. Try the popeye my brother got it for me I am a US Navy Veteran. Can't say enough the pizza is legit the dough is too die for. Hooyah the Journey Continues.

Very high quality pizza here. I was pleasantly surprised to find a high quality pie in Silver City. We honestly did not expect it. Ordered by the slice and timed it perfectly as the pizza had just came out of the oven.

By far the best pizza you can find in silver City. Right in the middle of downtown on bullard.

A "Must Have" when visiting Silver City!

This was the BEST pizza I’ve ever eaten. Ordered Margarite with Mushrooms. Crust was perfect with the toppings just right. Will be back, next time in Silver City.

Delicious pizza. I'd avoid the slices, buy a fresh made pizza instead.

Pizza was top quality, Loved it !! Employees are very friendly too :)

This hidden gem is amazing! The Popeye and garlic knots were delectable and the staff was friendly!

If you haven't tried Chente's yet you really need to get here and try there delicious Mexican food! I have and it's hands down the best in town

We've been enjoying Forrest's Pizza since they opened several years ago, every time we visit Silver City. We love the pizza and the staff is always so accommodating and friendly.

Moved to NM about 6 months ago and have made it my mission to find the best pies in the state. Our trip to Silver City brought us to Forrest's Pizza and we were not disappointed. A small take out with some outdoor seating. It seems to be a legit family enterprise. Crust is amazing...thin with a crunchy edge, but nicely foldable.

It's been too long always a treat

Good pizza but nothing crazy. Certainly the best food I have found in Silver City.

Awesome pizza! Great outdoor seating!

The ONLY reason it's not a 5th star is I'd of liked a desert or salad with the pizza. However, I really liked the New York style pizza for a change of life out west.

It's a mandatory pit stop when in Silver City! It's maybe not the best pizza I've ever had but definitely TOP 5. Taste, flavor and THE CRUST is mouth watering.

Best pizza crust I've eaten since childhood. The Angel pizza was a total delight. Pleasant people in the kitchen.

Only place in town to get amazing pizza.

The salads are so big and fresh. 🥗 The best pizza in town.🍕

Best pizza we’ve had in Silver City. Staff are amazing and the flavors are perfect. Highly recommend especially since they are fast and super tasty

Best Pizza in Silver City. Period.

Great pizza! Perfect crust, generous fresh toppings!

Great place for the grab and go pizza by the slice. One of those places that tosses the slices back in the oven for a moment before they serve to add that extra crispy crust. Make sure to try some homemade cheesecake or tiramisu!

Fantastic slices of pizza! Highly recommend the pepperoni.

The best pizza this side of New York!

Best pizza ever and! and everyone is so friendly

So good! The Angel was delicious. The garlic knots and cinnamon knots are soooo good.

They know what fresh garlic and and how to use it. Reminded me of a New York Pie. Excellent!

Some of the best pizzas we have ever had. The large one would feed about 4 people. Cooked thru like a pizza should be. Yummy!

I'm from NY. Some of the best pizza I've ever had.

Great for a quick slice at lunch. Really enjoyed the Angels.

Best pizza I had in years! From crust to sauce lol I ordered a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese w/green chili lol It was perfect! Soooo good! lol I love pizza!

Great pizza and the cinnamon knots were delicious. The owners were friendly and helpful - great food!

Loved it! Crispy thin crust, ooey goey cheese that slides into your mouth! So so good. Was traveling with kids/dogs so needed outdoor and simple...was able to sit in courtyard with dogs. Kids loved the pizza. If you like NY style pizza stpp here!

I thought it was a bit pricey, but very good pizza!

The Tombstone pizza OMG so good

If you like thin crust, MONSTER slices! This is the place! Love it. Great people, great customer service.

Tasty pizza by the slice, would absolutely return.