Gatsby's Pizza in Bonita Springs - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I was a little surprised about this little place in a small shopping center off of Tamiami Trail, we had a couple of sandwiches and they were actually very good. It was really surprised and a decent price. For less than $21 out the door.

Pizza was exceptional, and the owners were so sweet. We will be back!

Great pizza with a mid western flare. Dog friendly.

Did not expect the food to be this tasty on this coast of FL. This was delicious, didn’t expect it to be cut like this but still tasty nonetheless. Try it you won’t be disappointed. Service also was outstanding and very friendly.

Service was awesome & pizza was great. Definitely will be back when I’m in town again.

Like indoor cozy and outside dining options. Large variety of pizzas. Blue Chicken is my favorite. Good selection of subs. Gatsby's sub is traditional Italian sub and is delicious. Nice variety of appetizers. Pretzel bites are great with a cold beer.

The best pizza in the world, very friendly and they also treat you like family

I am so happy to finally find things crust pizza with sauce so awesome I always get a side of it to dip my pizza in! I am from Saint Louis grew up on IMO's pizza... No problem but the homemade sauce is so delicious I could eat it with a spoon! Also love the homemade blue cheese! When I get hot wings elsewhere I always make a second stop to get a side of Gatsbys blue cheese dressing! It's the BEST! All the dressings are good and I get a couple extras for when I just have a salad at home. When u get a salad make sure to get extra dressing.. so u will have some at home! So delicious! I'm glad the rebuilded after loosing the first store at the beach! I love finally having thin crust super fresh homemade pizza! Thank u so much!

Family owned place that we’ve loved for years! Thin crust is DELICIOUS!! This is out favorite place for pizza, excellent all around!

Conveniently located extremely dog friendly the nicest people serving delicious food

The thin crust pizza was delicious! Can’t wait for my next trip to Florida so I can enjoy it again.

I love, love,love the thin crust pizza. It's perfect for a low carb diet and fabulously delicious.

Pretty disappointed, heard and read good things about this place. Finally got a chance to pop in and order some food. One large cheese pizza chicken bites and some pretzel bites to go. Got home opened boxes and immediately got sad 😞 half empty chicken that was so dry ! Half empty pretzels? I mean I understand the box won’t be loaded but seriously like 8 pieces for 7.99-9.99 get real. Didn’t realize the pizza was thinner than my eyebrows in the 90s. Food including pizza wasn’t anything special. I can’t even say it was good. It was edible because that’s all I planned to feeed me and my family (and everyone is still hungry!) All this for 48 bucks with tip. The lady at the counter was nice and welcoming and raved about how good it was and unfortunately it was pretty misleading. Change your prices to match your serving size and quality. Feels like i lost my hard earned 48 bucks 😓

Needed a late night dinner on Sunday night due to cousin moving to Bonita and late arrival of truck bringing things down from NY. Found Gatsby around the corner and despite looking like it was ready to close, the Owner was wonderful and very accommodating, fun and extremely pleasant and entertaining. Plus the food was delicious. Gets our vote for great place. Marilyn Oliva

Loved how nice we were treated, smells amazing and it just feels like home.

Tim the owner was real friendly and informative of the area. We enjoyed the thin crust pizza and blue cheese salad. Great family run restaurant!

Ordered Pizza for dinner during my stay in Bonita Springs. The service was exceptional even as they were about to close. The pizza and garlic cheese breads are phenomenal. Would definitely recommend it to anyone in the city. They gave me a magnet and I will be leaving it at the Airbnb as a form of recommendation to anyone that stays there.

Great food, service and wonderful owners. I will be back soon!

Hands down the BEST pizza in Florida!!

Amazing food super fresh and the staff is so friendly. Pizza is specially delicious. Highly recommended

The food and service here are both top notch! The owners are welcoming and the atmosphere is family-friendly. Consider the value of home cooked meals and keep supporting our small businesses who care about their customers. We loved our dining experience at Gatsby's, and look forward to many more visits!

The pizza at Gatsby's is phenomenally good! I'm usually a meat-lover, but couldn't stop eating their Margherita pizza. Every layer offers their signature crust, sauce, and unique flavors, and if you appreciate the authenticity of food that looks exactly like it does in photos, then these are your people. We ordered a signature Buckeye pizza as well, which did not disappoint! The salads are fresh and plentiful, served with HOMEMADE salad dressing. The dressing alone gets 5 stars from me, but the homemade cheese balls, marinara dipping sauce and dessert canolis are not to be missed, trust me! So delish! Gatsby's offers a truly unique dining experience in the heart of an ocean-side "paradise". We'll be back for more, thanks Robynn and Tim. Alla prossima!

Stoped in to fix a craven for pizza, and have a new favorite pizza place in Bonita Springs /North Naples. Will be driving from Fort Myers Beach for all my pizza cravings from now on. Thanks Tim for a great pizza and great service so hard to find now days.

Gatsby's Pizza was amazing! We ordered lunch for my team of 12 employees and everyone was raving about how delicious it was. 100% would reccomend and we definitely will be ordering again! Impeccable customer service by Robin! Thank you so much!!!

Pizza was fantastic and the service was even better. Ordered catering for work from Gatsby's and they were amazing. We appreciate them for coming out. Definitely worth trying it!

Super great and sweet people, best pizza I’ve had!!

The food was so good! It was so flavorful! We got The buckeye pizza and a pepperoni pizza. We did pick up but they have dine in and outdoor seating- so cute! My only regret is we didn’t come earlier in the week because we probably would have come twice because we are on vacation . The subs looked really good! We ended up getting cannoli’s bc my son loves them and we were going to have one bite but the homemade filling was irresistible! Highly recommend this restaurant! They also had beer and wine- Fun atmosphere!

Everything we tried was amazing! Great pizza and the potato skins and cheese balls were to die for. The owners are absolute sweethearts. Will be your new favorite place.

We enjoyed another great experience with the owners at Gatsby's. Tonight we tried the garlic cheese bread which was great along with our sausage pizza which was awesome as usual. If you have not tried this place , i5 is time to do so as you are missing out. It is great to find places to eat with great food and service as well as unique tastes and house made items but there folks take friendly service to a whole new level, they really care about the taste and the experience. Keep up the great pizza and other menu items and see you soon.

The pizza is absolutely amazing. The Gatsby sub is the best ever. Robyn and David made this an unforgettable memory and we definitely will be back.

Great pizza and friendly, local owner! Tried the cheese, veggie, and pepperoni. I liked the thin crust.

Our group held a dinner meeting at Gatsby’s last night and it was a wonderful experience. The owner Robynn set up an awesome pizza and salad buffet, rearranged the tables to accommodate a meeting format with a speaker and made everyone feel so very welcome! All that for the same price we usually pay to just rent a meeting room! We will definitely be back again - with our families and as a group!

Amazing food and wonderful people! My family and I have dined in, ordered take-out and used their catering services. They exceeded our expectations every time.

Great thin crust Chicago style pizza. Perfect crispiness. Cut in little rectangles so I did not over eat. Will order again!

The owners are very kind!! Great food!

fabulous pizza!! The Buckeye pizza had amazing flavor and the margarita pizza was sooo yummy! the crust on their pizza is thin, which we loved!!

Excellent atmosphere whether you are inside or out. Presented by a mom and pop location with a big heart and amazing food. The pizza flavor is one that is special to this recipe.

A quaint mom and pop location with a special flavor unique to their pizza recipes. Whether you sit inside or out, you'll be greeted with a warm welcome and amazing food.

Excellent and flavorful pizza, great crust, fresh, I highly recommend to all pizza lovers. Wonderful people who show great hospitality.

Margherita pizza to send not enough cheese and tomato, cheese very thin , hardly any and too crispy , almost burned.

Absolutely wonderful service by both the waiter, and the two cooks. Me and my family are from Indiana and stopped here today on vacation, and I can safely say this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. I greatly enjoyed hanging out and chatting with the waiter, and both cooks did an amazing job tonight. Absolutely killer experience, wonderful!!!

This place is amazing! The owners are so friendly and go above and beyond to make sure everything is fresh and tasty! How many other pizza shop grows their own basil?! My favorite pizza place by far!!

Best Midwest style pizza in Naples. Tastes like Monicals in Peoria. It’s delicious

I met the woman owner. (I don’t know if she’s solely the owner) I get my nails done in the same plaza. Went over there to buy waters for my daughter, her friend and I. The owner was soooo beyond rude that she wouldn’t even let me buy water. She said “I’m not open, this is a private party) and laughed with all her little friends in there. 1. Grand opening coming soon and this is my first impression!? 2. Denying WATER to someone whom is paying!? 3. My friend brought home pizza from there and it’s terrible. Swallow your pride. You’re nothing special. Your pizza tastes terrible! However, your lack of humanity, denying water to someone paying & your entitled attitude is appalling!

Fabulous thin crust pizza…best I’ve ever had. I’m from Detroit and generally prefer Detroit style pizza, but was recommended by a couple of friends to try Gatsby’s Pizza. I am so glad that I did! The crust, which is wafer thin, is chewy and absolutely delicious. I had the “Buckeye” and “Marguerita”. Both outstanding!

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Gatsby's Pizza in Florida, and it was an experience worth raving about. As a first-timer, I was impressed by the excellent service and mouthwatering pizza. Every bite was a burst of flavor, and the crust achieved that perfect balance of crispiness that pizza enthusiasts can truly appreciate. Robin, the owner, went above and beyond to ensure my experience was enjoyable and convenient. She packed plates, napkins, and utensils in my bag since I returned to my hotel room to relax and enjoy the meal. I found myself in a bit of a predicament when I realized I had misplaced my receipt, which I needed for a business expense report. Without hesitation, Robin graciously offered to provide me with a copy of the receipt, demonstrating a level of customer care that is increasingly hard to find. I highly recommend stopping by Gatsby's for a delicious Italian pizza.

the food was amazing, the staff are so nice and accommodating, and you could see the cooks making all of the food fresh in the kitchen. i have no complaints, and i will absolutely be returning!

Pizza is excellent! Great crust and topping are just right. Owners are wonderful, too.

El 🧀 es una delicia !! La masa no se queda atrás

Had a great experience today eating at Gatsby’s in Bonita. The owners Robin and Tim were amazingly friendly and run a super clean kitchen serving amazing pizza. Hubby had pepperoni and I had a veggie Gluten Free. Both outstanding. Highly recommend!!!

Great Pizza cooked and served by awesome people👍

Good people and a delicious crispy thin crust with amazing flavor

Excellent pizza with fresh ingredients

First time there tonight and it was by far the best pi🍕🍕🍕I’ve had in the Bonita Springs /Naples area. All of the employees were very engaging and friendly when I walked in. I’ll be back!

Hands down best pizza we had in 20 yrs in the area.

Great pizza! Fresh salads! Wonderful staff! This is our favorite local pizza place!

Excellent pizza! We enjoyed the pizza and potato skins. Friendly owners made for a great atmosphere. This will be our go to place for pizza!

A hidden gem in Bonita, the owners Robynn and Tim are so passionate about what they do! It pours right into the food THEY prepare. Food is always consistent. Pizza is so clean and fresh. Not greasy! Great find especially with the OH connection! Best of luck to this venture!!

We have ordered take-out twice. Both times our pizza was superb! They do not skimp on the toppings, the spices they use really enhance the flavor and the thin crust is perfect. We will continue to have Gatsby's as our go-to pizza place!

The only thing I can think of is: WOW! Gatsby's Pizza is phenomenal! We ordered 1 large cheese pie, one pepperoni, and a 5 veg pie. It was SO GOOD. And the staff are just as amazing as the food! This is the kind of place you can come and really enjoy yourself after a long weekend with friends and family, the whole vibe really is just great!! We will be back again and again!

They accommodated my son’s U10 soccer team. They were great with the kids and super friendly and excited to have us. The owners seem very hospitable.

10 stars they squeezed our entire soccer team! The staff was so accommodating and even offered to make pizzas i advance after a game! It was great experience for the team! Not many places are so accommodating we truly appreciate you communicating with us before the event and hopefully your ears are ok after all of that squealing!

exceeded expectations! very delicious pizza, my party guests loved it, I was very happy and grateful for the excellent service

Crust to the pizza was hard like cardboard. Will not return.

Delicious!! The homemade cheese balls were wonderful. The crust was thin and not greasy at all!!

Not only is the pizza so delicious (thin crust, but soft and crispy, the sauce was perfection, and the pepperoni/sausage, mushrooms/onions were so fresh and tasty), the inside is super cute too, even the bathroom was cool! Also, the owners are two of the sweetest, friendliest people I have ever met! I could have chatted with them for hours! I will definitely be back—highly recommended!

So so so good!!!!! I am thrilled that Bonita Springs finally has an even better Gatsbys Pizza then the previous one, that was fabulous, but this… Oh my goodness! The pretzel bites and beer cheese, so good and the Pizza, well, it doesn’t get better than this!!! Yummy!!!

A wonderful little Gem on Bonita Beach Road. The minute we walked in we were welcomed to this family owned establishment by the friendly staff. Jackie, the owner was in the kitchen making the meals even on her birthday. Her husband and co owner Greg, was not in today, so she had her dear friend assisting with the order to go and sit in customers. Not only did we enjoy the margarita pizza but we truly enjoyed meeting other customers who are regulars and had a wonderful time eating and hanging out with the everyone. As people walked in they all knew eachother, which made the experience even better. I got to meet a Fellow Mets fan and chatted it up about our team as if we have been friends for years. They are within 5 minutes of Bonita Beach so on our next trip to the beach, we have found our spot to enjoy great tasting pizza. We heard their salad is just as good. Cant wait to get back out there.

Great food and great owners. Love to talk to them. Always walk away with a a piece of knowledge

Pizza and garlic bread are delicious!, but what’s even better about this place is Greg and Jackie: they treat you like family. Stop if you’re around; you won’t regret it.

One of the best pizza place in Bonita springs

Horrible pizza Overall taste was cartón The tomato sauce was too strong/salty overpowering the pepperoni Will never order from here

Ok, this is just the cutest mom and pop pizza place. Mr. Greg and Ms. Jackie are absolutely precious people with an incredible story to share. Pizza and cheese garlic bread was tasty. Mr. Greg prayed a blessing over our meal. Listen y'all. Excellent service. Sweet people. Yummy, cheesy pizza thin crust style. Give this place a try!

Edited the original Review to 3 stars from 1 because the owner responded and tried to explain and apologize. I did use the slice app and it let me place the order at 7:30. Moved to 3 stars and will try again when we visit the area again. Pizza could be great just never had the chance…………”Tried to call to order at 7:30, they said you have to order delivery online, ok so I order from their 3rd party website at 7:30. They close at 9:00 and I see Freon my bank website the canceled the order at 8:45 and never delivered dinner. No call or message”

Love their pizza. Greg, the Owner, is the nicest guy, and makes everyone feel like family.

Everything about this place is amazing. The inside is small with just a couple tables, but has a nice comfortable atmosphere. The service was great, and the staff were super friendly. The pizza was hot, fresh, and delicious. Would highly recommend Gatsby's!

I saw someone post on Facebook about this place and wanted to give it a try! The lady that worked there was super friendly (owner). Think it is a husband and wife that runs the restaurant. Go Buckeyes! They are from Ohio which I am too! The pizza was really good. Each slice had a good crunch to it and loved the taste. I like how it is cut into tiny squares and is thin sliced.

When I walked in with my bf for our valentines date, we thought it was the cutest place ever, with tons of sports regalia and a sign supporting FGCU. Jackie and Sandy were so sweet, asking our names and checking in on us, asking how we were, if we needed anything and sharing a bit about their struggles, like a friend who has brain cancer… it felt like we became part of the family of the restaurant, just from having a few interactions with the staff and other customers. The food was just as good. We thought we would get a large pizza and save some for leftovers… the two of us ate the entire thing because it was so good. Definitely can’t recommend enough. I’ve never wanted to give a tip as big as we left here. Will definitely go again.

This is pathetic. $10 LG salad that barely feeds 1 and a $20 pizza that looks like it has been sitting out since last night. Very disappointing and will never go back. Pictures speak for themselves.

HoHoHo!!! “Of course Everett Michael I Love Gatsby Pizza 🍕 👍😘

Great pizza and very friendly. Recommend going

Definitely the best pizza in Bonita Springs everybody's friendly

If you are in the Bonita Springs area and our originally from the Midwest, specifically Ohio, this pizza is a must try. The owner Greg is a very humble guy. He talked with me while my pizza was being prepared. Great pizza with a great story.

Pizza was good thin crust. Sauce could use a bit more flavor.

Delicious pizza and friendly staff! Definitely going back.

Great pizza, incredible staff. I’ll reminder this place!

Very eclectic. Great Margareta Pizza

Wonderful atmosphere and you can’t help but adore this mom and pop restaurant!

The owners were really nice, the pizza was amazing!!!

Great pizza and service, it's like one of those mom and pop shops. Overall it was amazing

Excellent pizza. Owners are awesome. We will get pizza from there from now on.

Had a great visit and some great food. If you're in the area, stop and see Greg and his staff. the food is fantastic.

Great pizza with thin crust. Friendly hospitality.

Great place, great pizza, great people. Amazing people. My better half's card would not run. She told Mr Gatsby she would retrieve another card or get cash. He told her not to worry and just comeback next day. Unfortunately this was Saturday we forgot Sunday and they were not open until following Thurs. She finally did make it back in to take care of it and he still couldn't of been nicer. GREAT PEOPLE.

Ordered this pizza as takeout. I enjoyed the crust and it was a solid pizza overall. I will echo though that the Rosemary or whatever herbs are being used are very strong. Not my preference for pizza, but some others may really like it. I was disappointed though with the Buckeye bites. They were inedible - tasted like chicken that had been cooked for way too long and turned into a cubed jerky. I couldn't even chew them they were so hard.

Just ordered from here for the 1st time and it was a very nice surprise. Best Margherita pizza we've had in Naples. Absolutely delicious!

What a great spot! We ordered a pizza and some cheesy garlic bread for takeout, and it was ready super fast. The pizza was delicious, with crispy crust and plenty of cheese and the garlic bread had extra sauce for dipping. The staff was SO kind and went out of their way to accommodate us, and I wish we would have found this place sooner during our trip. The inside is really cute - I love their decorations. If you’re going to get the garlic bread, definitely get it with cheese! You won’t regret it.

"Excellent Pizza" and service. First time trying out their pizza and we definitely werent disappointed. Ordered takeout and will dine in next time. Will recommend to our family and friends to visit this local establishment.

My friend and I went there on chance and I was amazed. Greg was a kind man that shows he truly has a love for what he's doing. The place had this comforting feeling and the pizza was spectacular. I will definitely go back.

Thin crispy crust with the best toppings. Pepperoni and cheese or sausage green pepper and onion are our favorites. Great service from the delightful owner Greg as well! It's a wonderful experience and so close to the beach, what more could you ask for? If you are in the area and you love fresh pizza you have to give it a try.