Gimme S'more Bakery in Old Bridge - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Cake was delicious & design was exactly what I wanted! Great communication throughout. Overall wonderful experience.

Amazing Amazing Amazing! Don’t hesitate definitely book them for your party! The owners are very sweet and quick to respond to any questions you may have and their cakes are not only beautiful but delicious! Very easy to work with and already booked them for our next party!

This was honestly one of the best cakes! From the experience of ordering to the follow through, everything was top notch. I gave an idea of what I wanted and she brought my idea to life. The cake was so delicious and so fresh! Everyone was raving about it the entire party! I cannot recommend Gimme S’more enough! Absolutely amazing experience. Highly recommend.

Wonderful local bakery! Listens to your wants for the perfect cake for any celebration. Not only do the cakes look wonderful but they taste just as good! The owners are wonderful & thrive in customer satisfaction. Highly recommend!

I ordered a cake for my 50th birthday and it was not only beautiful but delicious. Not too sweet and very moist. People said it was the best cake they ever had. The owner is also super nice. This is my new go to bakery.

I cannot say enough kind words about Victoria and her team! Not only is her work unbelievably stunning, her pricing is fair, she is so easy to communicate with, and she is incredibly accommodating. Victoria even helped problem solve an issue I had with the name plaque I purchased from an outside business just days before the party. Oh and I forgot to mention a very important detail, the cakes are absolutely delicious. Book her now!

I ordered two cakes in one month because the first one was just that GREAT! I was absolutely blown away both times. The first time I ordered a vanilla cake with cookies and cream filling and the second time I ordered a red velvet cake. Both were delicious!

The cake was beautiful, it was exactly what I wanted and my girlfriend absolutely loved It. I definitely recommend going to gimmes’more for all your bakery needs, and I would definitely buy from here again.

I worked with Jamie and Victoria at the bakery. Jamie was so amazing to work with on my wife’s birthday cake! We discussed design ideas, delivery etc. it was extremely easy working with the entire staff during the process. On the day of delivery, Victoria sent me final pictures of the cake, and more pictures once the cake was delivered to ensure I knew how it was packaged etc. the final product was absolutely amazing, and it tasted even better! I highly recommend this bakery. They are friendly, attentive to your needs and ideas, and extremely talented! Thank you Jamie and the Gimme S’more Bakery staff!

Gimme S'more did an amazing job creating a very cool Harley Davidson cake and cupcakes for our wedding. They were responsive and very helpful with suggestions throughout the whole process. And everything was delicious!!!

Cake was decorated exactly as per request - very beautiful. Tastes very good too - not to sweet. Got a confetti flavor of cake with custard strawberry filling - yummy! Very easy to communicate with the seller and very easy pick up. Would recommend and come back for another specialty cake.

I cannot express enough how thrilled I was with the exquisite cake that was crafted for my daughter's Sweet 16 celebration. The cake itself was a work of art. The attention to detail was impeccable, from the delicate frosting swirls to the intricate decorations that perfectly captured the essence of my daughter's personality and the theme of the occasion. It was clear that every element was crafted with care and precision, resulting in a truly breathtaking centerpiece for the celebration. And let's not forget about the taste! My guests couldn't stop raving about how wonderful it tasted! But what truly sets this bakery apart is the exceptional service provided. From our initial consultation to the final delivery, everyone we interacted with was incredibly kind, attentive, and accommodating. They listened attentively to our vision and worked tirelessly to bring it to life, ensuring that every detail was perfect. In summary, I cannot recommend this bakery highly enough. If you're looking for a show-stopping cake that tastes as good as it looks, look no further. Trust me, you won't be disappointed! Thank you once again to Victoria & Jaime for making my daughter's Sweet 16 celebration truly unforgettable. We will cherish the memories – and the delicious cake – for years to come. Warm regards, The Perez Family

I placed an order for a cake for my daughter’s bridal shower and GimmeSmore was incredible!!!!! I sent ideas of what I was looking for and they went above and beyond. They delivered the cake to the venue, so it was one less thing for me to worry about which I loved. The cake was delicious!!!! Everyone was raving about it and it really added to my daughter’s special day. I will absolutely be using them again for future events and recommend them highly!!!! Amazing!!

From initial contact to delivery, communication was exceptional. Design was followed perfectly. Recommendations were given in terms of flavor and display. We are still eating leftover cake 3 days later because it is absolutely delicious! We can’t wait to order again! So glad we found you!

I cannot say enough amazing things about the cake, cake pops, and chocolate covered Oreos I ordered with Victoria and Jaime at Gimme S’more for my best friend’s baby shower. They not only came out beautiful, but tasted incredible!!! Victoria and Jaime listened to what I wanted exactly (down to the shades of pink!) and were extremely communicative throughout the entire process. I sent Jaime photos of what I was hoping to achieve and she nailed it. The cake was out of this world!! Highly recommend the chocolate cake with vanilla custard 🤤 I cannot wait for my next event so I can order with them again!! Thank you, Jaime and Victoria for making my event so perfect!!! 💕

They made a beautiful cake for my Wife's birthday. I didn't know what design for the cake so they asked for the invitation and made the design based on the invitation. The cake was delicious and added a great touch. They even delivered to the cake to the venue. I will definitely be ordering more cakes in the future.

The absolute best cakes in the game!! Any cake from Gimme S’more is guaranteed to be the center of attention no matter the event!! Vicki truly is an artist and never fails to amaze me and my family with her creations. She always gets the job done on time and still manages to go far above and BEYOND expectations. I can’t thank her enough for the memories she has made for me and my family all thru her cakes!!

A really good company to order desserts from.

Very good service. Friendly staff. Beautiful cake & tasted very good.

Delicious cake and great customer service! Will be ordering from Gimme S’more again, can’t wait!

I am completely blown away with this company. From start to finish they were incredible! I contacted them a few weeks before my event, sent them my inspo pictures (it’s through text so it’s SUPER easy and convenient) and what they gave me was even better than the inspo pictures. I never imagined the cake being so amazing and detailed. The family was in awe at the cake! I was getting questioned about it all night and I’m so happy to be sharing them with everyone. On top of that, the cake was delicious!! That was the most important part! They give you a bunch of choices to choose from and work with you from start to finish. They also deliver for a fee or you can pick it up. The owner literally placed it in my car for me. I’m so excited I found this place!!!!!

The cake for my mom’s 70th was absolutely perfect! It was gorgeous and delicious! Jaime and Victoria were wonderful to work with and helpful too! Looking forward to working with them again!

Best cake EVER!!!! They were easy to work with, responded quickly and the cake looked and tasted amazing!! I would highly recommend and would 100% use again!! :)

I am so glad I found them ! Gimme S’more is definitely going to be my go to for any events! Vicky made everything so seamless and made exactly what my son wanted happen not to mention the cake was so delicious and so soft 😍

It was a pleasure working with Vicky from the beginning, to the delivery of the most beautiful and delicious cake and desserts for my daughter's Bridal Shower. I HIGHLY recommend Gimmesmore's!!!!!

I was absolutely amazed how beautiful the cupcake bouquet came out for my moms 70th birthday. They tasted just as amazing!! The team was so professional and truly helped me in such short notice! I highly recommend and will be ordering again in the future!

I stumbled across Gimme S'more Bakery through Instagram. The images of the cake creations were outstanding. I was so amazed that I was ready to go there to buy some goodies, unfortunately they did not have a brick and mortar location yet. I can't wait. Nonetheless I contacted them to make a cake for a 60th birthday party. Everyone that I communicated with was so patient and understanding. Gimme S'more did not disappoint. They made a beautiful pull-a-part cake, when I tellvyou it was not only perfect, it was simply delicious, moist, the icing was nice and fluffy, not sickeningsweet, but it was so good, that I even ate the excessicingwhen I finishedmy cupcake. They will definitely be my go to bakery whenever I'm in Jersey. I highly recommend Gimme S'more for your bakery needs, and what a perfect name, because I definitely want s'more 😋

This my first time using Gimme S'more Bakery and i will definitely be back! The cake turned out amazing and it was really tasty too. They designed a beautiful cake for my son's first birthday (space theme cake and smash cake). Alot of my guest thought it was a cake boss cake because of how amazing it turned out. We were super happy with the whole experience!

Highly recommend. Cake was delicious, they were very responsive and friendly. Will be ordering again Forsure !

Thank you so much for our beautiful and delicious cake. Everyone at the party loved it. Look forward to future orders!!

We ordered a cake from Gimme S’more Bakery and it definitely exceeded our expectations. Thank you so much for making a beautiful cake for my husbands birthday! It was perfect!

Cake was everything we asked for and more. It was so delicious and all my guests were amazed at the work. They were very easy to work with and communication made everything so easy and effortless. Would highly recommend and use in the future. Thanks again

We were so happy to stumble upon GimmeSmore!! Such an easy ordering process & pick up (they offer delivery as well). Our cakes not only looked STUNNING! But they tasted equally as good! Highly recommend!!!

We ordered cake pops for our western-themed party and they came out amazing and delicious! They were so friendly and were quick to respond and answer any questions. We will definitely be ordering again for future parties :)

The cake I ordered from Gimme S'more was absolutely fantastic! The ordering and payment processes were easy. The owner is so friendly and helpful. I highly recommend this baker and look forward to future orders!

Gimme S’more gets it PERFECT every time! We use them multiple times a year for cakes, cake pops, hot chocolate bombs, and all kinds of treats that always look & taste amazing. They truly never disappoint!!

The cake design was awesome and the taste was excellent and most of all their service was outstanding! They have been professional and patient. I would highly recommend!

AMAZING! Actually that word isn't enough to describe the beautiful things I've gotten from them! I ordered a smash cake for my 35th and couldn't have lived the way the cake looked any more than I did! And it wasn't just looks. It was seriously THE BEST red velvet I've ever had. The cake was so soft and moist, the frosting the perfect amount of fluffy cream cheese. 💚 The hot cocoa bombs. So good. I don't think I've tried any I didn't like. Although Snickers and Snickerdoodle were definitely some of my faves. 1000% recommend for your next sweet treat need!

If you want your cake to exactly what you want than you have found the right business to order from. Not only is the cake made to look incredible but, it also tastes incredible!

Most delicious and beautiful cakes I’ve ever received. Highly recommend! I’ll continue to order from Gimme S’more, client for life.

I loved their cake pops, chocolate covered strawberries, and so much more. Everything tastes so good and definitely buying more things in the future. Great prices for home made treats. Everything is made to order. Not mass products or frozen.

I had been following Gimme S’more for quite awhile on FB and was amazed at their artistry with each cake the bake. I had the honor of tasting their cake at a recent birthday party and it was exquisite. I would highly recommend for style, taste, and service.

Victoria & team went above & beyond to bring our gender reveal cake to life. Not only was it beautiful, but it was so delicious! With local pickup as well as delivery options, you can’t beat Gimme S’more to make your event complete! Thank you so much again!

Best cheesecakes around! And very professional, I wouldn't hesitate to do business with them for any occasion.