Infinity Steakhouse in LaBelle - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Excellent restaurant experience. Great drinks. Fantastic food. The service was VERY very good.

By far the BEST restaurant in Labelle!!!! My wife and I have had some of our most memorable meals in this establishment. The owner is welcoming and helpful with tips about Labelle, since my wife and I haven’t lived here long. It’s unfortunate this restaurant has not been supported more in the Labelle community because its food is far superior to ANY other restaurant in Labelle! Try to go on a Saturday for their locally butchered Prime Rib. It is truly amazing!

I highly recommend this establishment!!! The food is very tasty and the portions are big enough. The owner is a pleasant and interesting person!

I have eaten here several times and the food and services always spot on.

Wonderful meals there were four of us had oysters on the half shell and oysters Rockefeller for apps. Main entrees rib eye steaks prime rib and salmon stuffed with spinach and lobster risotto everything was delicious fresh hot, and so tasty waitress was very pleasant. Service was great. Everyone needs to try infinity restaurant. Owner was also very friendly.

There are not enough stars to justify how good the food was at this place We had the prime rib special on Saturday. This prime rib will be the prime rib you will compare all other restaurants to. I guarantee you no place else will even come close. The owner and service was amazing. If I didn’t live so far away, I would be here once or twice a week.

First time was great....refered by an innvestor...steaks were delish. Second time was not good... steaks were mostly fat.... Went back the third time because investor said it improved...waiting for a drink took longer than the food....owner was to busy talking to people at bar and taking his own sweet time. Food was literally embarrassing. Steaks I bragged on to family were all fat. Grand daughter got pasta with red sauce that tasted like can dumped. The only positive thing I can say is they have good desserts. The only time this place was ever decent is when the first shift was there I understand he was sick with cancer and left but they need to work this thing out people shouldn't have to pay $148 for two steaks and bad pasta and two mixed drinks two Waters. Go see the big haired lady if you want to stay this has become more of a country bumpkin type place where they sit around and talk even a tequila sunrise was orange juice yes fresh squeezed but not a tequila sunrise

Had a lovely dinner this evening at Infinity Steak House restaurant in LaBelle. I had the petite filet, which was delicious, and prepared as requested. My husband had the smoked salmon, and was VERY pleased with it. Sorry! I was hungry and failed to take pictures. My Caesar Salad was huge, and wonderful. So the next time you’re looking for somewhere to go for Dinner, but don’t want to drive to Ft Myers, give Infinity a chance. We need to take advantage of our small town businesses, or they won’t survive.

Excellent food, drinks, and service. Definitely will be back. Great find.

Aceleigh was one of the best waitresses I’ve ever had!!

The portions are very large. We had 3 different dishes. Chicken Marsala, beef short ribs over linguine & open face ribeye sandwich. All 3 were perfect & the French Onion soup will feed 3 people ! I didn’t get our waitress name but she was the only one waiting tables and did a great job. The owner was mixing up cocktails and could’ve been more helpful to her, would be my only complaint about the whole experience. And maybe put some foam squares in the corners to absorb some of the echo as it got busier it did become a little loud. But we will definitely go back again !

Always a great experience. Perfectly accommodating for our large family of 7. I think our 18 month old son ate more of my steak than I got to. Love the lobster risotto. Friendly service, friendly owner- all around good time. Will always continue to come back!

I had the privilege of eating at this terrific restaurant for my birthday, Friday night. It's not a fancy place, but the food, and the atmosphere was wonderful. It truly is the best steak I have ever tasted. The dessert was out of this world. Eric, the owner, made the evening very entertaining. Infinity Steakhouse is a "not to be missed" experience.

Impressed by the CLEAN restaurant! We had reservations & were greeted & seated promptly - plenty of ice water in our glasses and a carafe. Waiter explained menu & answered every question. Filet mignon was cooked perfectly excellent & prime rib meal was HUGE & delicious. The waiter assisted my shy wife & he treated my wife like a queen which impressed me. Bill was $80+ and I left a $100 tip for excellent service, food, and kindness. We live more than an hours drive away but we'll definitely return.

This was a 5 star experience all the way. We were greeted by a pleasant hostess who was also our waitress. Our Appetizers were a little late coming out and so was our wine, but the appetizers did come out before the meal. I was hesitant to try anything called a Deviled Egg Slider but to my amazement they were quite good. You can’t really eat it like a slider because after the first bite it falls apart and a fork is required thereafter. But they were delicious and a first for me. We both decided on the petite filet mignon. These 8oz steaks are aged for 30 days and seared to perfection then cooked exactly med rare which was our preference. They very tender and basted in a garlic butter sauce. Absolutely delicious. Then there was the Lobster Risotto… The Lobster Risotto was perfectly cooked and the flavor was delightful. It had the perfect texture and stickiness. The only problem I had with it was in the presentation, it’s served in a small ceramic cup on the entree’ plate. It cheapens the look of the entire plate served that way. Since risotto is so sticky I would suggest allowing it to form in the cup, then turning it over out of the cup onto the plate and adding a little parsley garnish to the top. It it was delicious regardless of presentation. For desert don’t miss the White Chocolate Brioche in a reduced raspberry sauce. Absolutely delicious but it contains a lot of bread like a bread pudding. After a heavy meal you’ll have trouble finishing it. It’s a delightful desert. The desert plate is coated in raspberry sauce and the brioche is placed in the middle standing upright like a tower. We toppled it over onto the plate to eat it. It’s definitely a desert for two. Overall a wonderful dining experience. I spoke with the chef and he happily told us about his wonderful recipes and how things were cooked. Don’t miss this place when in the area! We will be back to try other items on the menu.

Why anyone would give a 5 star review is beyond me. You get a better meal and service from mc Donald's. Why anyone would pay that kind of money for a steak from Walmart I cannot imagine. Everything was terrible, food, service, staff and ambiance. I have been reading through quite a few reviews and I have not seen one response from owners, they do not care! If you are looking for a good meal, service, staff and atmosphere then go to FOREY GRILL. EXCELLENT!

This place is great! Atmosphere is chill and cool and the staff is also friendly and knowledgeable. Full bar. Amazing dishes for a Steakhouse which some included some Italian classics and some twists. Do yourself a favor and visit this lovely restaurant. I will definitely be coming back.

This was one of the best steaks I have had. Being from Texas that's a tall order but without a doubt the food was the best.

I'm all for supporting small businesses. However, not when the owners have a reputation of stealing (on 3 separate occasions in the last year from Costco). All I'm saying is be caution on who you support. Seems like the owners have been doing this a while. I've never eaten here simply for the bad reviews I have heard from people around town. But you can't lie about the facts and the probable cause report and arrest records that are public record.

My husband and I loved this place! The owner Eric greeted us with gracious hospitality and served us up the best prime rib dinner I have ever had, cooked to perfection and extremely tender. The house vegetables were delicious. My husband had a perfect margarita which was also very tasty and if we didn’t have to drive home we would have stayed for more. We will be back! It’s worth the drive. See you soon Eric!

Delightful! My fiance and I happened in to Eric's wonderful establishment. What a gem, from the hospitality to the excellent and creative fare and craft signature Old Fashioned. Thank you kindly for a most enjoyable and memorable evening including your amazing deviled eggs!

Awesome food, great service, we will be back.

Awesome service awesome people. I knew when I walked into the restaurant that the food was gonna be great. Kudos to them. We will be back.

Eric was the best host. Everything was 5star on point

Owners are fantastic. Everyone treats you like family. Food is absolutely amazing and delicious. Great atmosphere

The food is always great here, and the Saturday night prime rib special is outstanding. Also, make sure to get a brioche for dessert or to take home.

I ordered the filet (small) medium rare. It had to be one of the best steaks I have ever had in my life. ( I am 80 so that includes many meals). Everything was delicious. My wife had a mudslide from the bar and loved it.

We were with 2 other couples for dinner Friday night. My New York strip steak was amazingly tasty and tender, 5 stars. Our friend described his filet as among the best he ever had. The side salads were large, loaded and fresh. Get the side salad! My wife got the beautiful and tasty Infinity Pineapple Express, which is shrimp and chicken served in a half pineapple. It was full of flavor with a bit of a spicy kick. They made special-request mixed drinks for two of the ladies and a lemon drop martini for the other. All got enthusiastic thumbs up. We were too full for dessert, but heard great things about the fresh baked brioche...next time. Our server, Vika (msp?), took great care of us and made us feel welcomed and special. The coyboy-hat-wearing owner visited our table several times to check on us and inquire about our meals and drinks. He couldn't have done anymore to make us feel like family. Infinity is a hidden gem just a block off of the main road. We will be back for the amazing food, great service and friendly casual atmosphere.

The food was amazing! Eric the owner was very personable and friendly! We went for my birthday and everything was amazing, the food, the drinks, the portions, it was all delicious! I loved it even more when Eric (the owner) told us that (in a long story short) it was all locally sourced! For the price vs how much food you get and the quality, you can't beat it!

We live in Fort Worth TX, and totally here to tell you that Eric’s steaks are as good as anything you’d have in Texas. Fantastic! Infinity Chicken was also dynomite. Don’t miss this place. 🙂 Not to mention that Eric is a good strong name.. 🤣

I've eaten here off and on since the restaurant opened with my family and it never fails. The food is always on point and very tasty. Honestly, one of the best restaurants here in LaBelle.

We arrived shortly after they opened on a Sunday. The wait staff were sitting at the bar even after we were seated including our server. However, Service was excellent and we tipped her well. The atmosphere was okay, it seemed more Sports bar than Steakhouse. I ordered Chicken Marsala and a side salad. The salad was outstanding! Kudos on that, very fresh. However, not sure what +2 means on the menu, I thought $2.00 more if ordering an entree but guess not, we were charged $6.00 for each house salad. The Chicken Marsala looked good and had a delicious flavor but the chicken breast was so tough I couldn't eat it. I got my meal to go, stopped on the way home and bought a fresh cooked chicken, threw out the chicken I was served at your restaurant and replaced it with a nice juice tender piece of chicken breast. That made my meal perfect.

Definitely our favorite restaurant!

used too be a waiter here in the early 90,s when it was Big Oak steak House aka B.O.S.H

Very nice owner and super cool atmosphere plus the best food I’ve ever had definitely worth the price, you get what you pay for here. Great food and great service!

Best steak ever!! My favorite place in LaBelle.

Eric, the owner, and Erika, our waitress, created a welcoming atmosphere for our 25th wedding anniversary dinner. The food and drinks were outstanding! Thank you! We will return!

Best food in this area! Customer service was great as well. Steak and my Cajun chicken was soo good. I also got a drink good as well. Definitely going back.

Food was delicious on Friday night but we weren't served for over an hour & half. Apparently the Chef called off sick. Waitress remained calm & apologetic.

The food was delicious and the drinks were amazing. Eric, the owner, made a point to stop at our table and make sure we were satisfied. My filet was cooked perfectly. Definitely will be back!

Best restaurant in LaBelle. If you are just passing through or living in the area, make sure to stop here for the best meal in town. All food is made to order. Special requests are accommodated. Full bar with a nice selection of wine & beer. Owner is on site to oversee operations.

I go there as much as possible with my neighbors and any friends that visit. The food is amazing! The drinks are some of the best ever.

It was our first time there and we were very excited to try a new steakhouse that was locally owned. Extremely disappointed. We waited 45 mins for food when the restaurant was less than busy, when food arrived my husbands steak was cold and had less than desirable flavor. It tasted less like beef than a steak should… didn’t know that was possible?! We were told about the famous dessert, white chocolate brioche with fresh peaches. When it came out 40 mins later, very delicious, but when eating it we noticed there was an artichoke sticking out of where it was baked. We let the waitress know and she asked if she should comp it, we left it up to her to which she replied she would comp it, then didn’t… she dropped our check then walked away without saying anything. We just spent $150 with tip on a meal that was not worth it.

This was our first time eating here. We absolutely loved the food and our waitress was great. Eric is a great person, we enjoyed talking to him.

Great food, people, and love supporting REAL AMERICANS. 2A

WOW!! Delicious!! We weren't going to come here after reading reviews, but glad we decided to try it! Very impressed. They were busy, but the owner (Eric) came to our table, told us about his hand cut steaks and helped the waitress by taking our order. The steaks were perfect! I got a filet and my husband got ribeye. He suggested dessert, and I went for it! Raspberry Brioche with white chocolate, fresh out of the oven!! So delicious! You will have to wait for them to bake it, but worth the wait! Everything is made from scratch!! Highly recommend!!

Excellent food, service and environment! Great place to go for dinner. Steak cooked to perfection and service 10/10. Well worth the drive if you are in Alva, Fort Myers, Naples or anywhere else in Southwest Florida.

Excellent experience with the family dining here! The owner personally greeted us and was extremely polite and attentive. Service was exceptional and the food was delicious! I ordered the Tomahawk and was NOT disappointed, it was cooked to perfection. I love to support a business owner with a passion, we need more restaurants like this in SWFL!

This is our favorite restaurant in SW Florida. A+ all around!!! Amazing food and the best Old Fashion ever made!!!

Infinity has the BEST beef soup around! The peach brioche is amazing. The service is always friendly. We are regular customers and the food is great time after time.

My husband, myself, and my 10 year old went this evening for dinner. It was amazing. We got there as soon as they opened and were one of the few inside. The owner was amazing and greeted us straight away and made me the best strawberry margaritas. Try the spinach dip. It was delicious. Shout out to the chef also. Our steaks were cooked perfectly, and my daughter is super picky and we asked for plain salmon and not their specials, stuffed salmon and the chef honored our request and made the best tasting salmon, my picky daughter ate the whole thing. My husband and daughter also raved about the cheesecake. Waitress was super nice. Definitely will be returning. Excellent local business.