Island Creamery - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Ice cream is always good. Service is quick and efficient! Parking lot can be a little tight when they’re busy but if you’re in the area it’s worth a stop.

Great night for an ice cream! This place always delivers and the staff are nice and friendly.

Wow! The service is the first thing I want to discuss. I was so impressed how hard all 6 young ladies were working. I'd addition to their work effort, the team work was beyond compare! Super impressed! Now the ice cream. Amazing! Large portions and the salted caramel is out of this world. Tip this team well America! They are worth it.

Great icecream. Their Almond Joy is my favorite.

You're butter pecan was the best in the world. Saturday my butter pecan had one sliver and two small chunks of pecan. Do better.

The best ice cream on the planet

So many choices and so delicious! Great, friendly staff, too!

Lots of flavors and the Ice Cream is made there on site. The rum raisin is out of this world ! Made with care Service is excellent . The staff is very friendly and fast. We will be back

You lost points this time, Island Creamery. The Salisbury location has never been the best for service or value, but we still go for convenience when the craving is on because the ice cream is still second-to-none. However, the quantity we got for the money this time was dodgy: my 4 year-old got more in his kid's cone than I got in mine. And my senior mom couldn't get the senior discount here in Salisbury, as she does when she goes to the other locations. That should be consistent across locations, especially when that discount can make or break our ability to afford this place...the prices having gone up exponentially in recent years. Food for thought, folks...

Great ice cream! Drive thru is a plus! Fast service and load of options.

Delicious Ice Cream from a local establishment. There was no good seating so minus one star.

My new favorite ice cream place. Ice cream rich and delicious! Home made crunchies is a must have! Love the cherry jubilee ice cream, oreo, peanut butter and many more flavors I look forward to trying! All our birthday cakes are coming from here from now on! Oh! And I did enjoy the waffle cones. Fragile but tasty! Ask for a container for your waffle cone so you can enjoy every bite. And no, I do not work here. 😆 I am just an ice cream lover.

Was really busy but they were still fast and on top of things. Many thanks to the hard working employees!

Lots of options. Good old-fashioned ice cream.

Delicious Ice Cream and a great selection of flavors and choices!

Fantastic ice cream. Lots of interesting flavors.

My favorite ice cream place. The seasonal flavors are the best. I look forward to the seasonal flavors.

The staff are always so friendly. Drive thru is quick. Great flavors.

I'm not sure what I like more the ice cream or the waffle cones

This place is amazing! We just found it recently, and it is criminally close to my house. The ice cream is the real deal - super creamy and the flavors are powerful. Black raspberry is a house favorite, and you can't go wrong with the chocolate, but try the mud marsh if you are feeling the extra chocolate need. What blew me away, though, was the snickers cheesecake... the ice cream actually did taste like cheese cake 🤌🏻

The peanut butter cup Ice cream was great it was a lil pricey but they give you a decent amount! And the staff was very friendly and welcoming!

Hands down the best ice cream I've had! And the amazing waffle cone. We drive from Pocomoke city!

Excellent ice cream and service

Had the PB&J and Bourbon Caramel Crunch & they were absolutely delicious!!! My mom had the Coconut and Mud Marsh and she loved them as well. 10/10 would recommend!!!

Hands down, my Favorite Ice cream! Locally made; rich and creamy sinful satisfaction. The waffle cone is soo good.. The Staff is super friendly. Reasonably priced too. I absolutely love this place. Check em out..they are open every day!

Wow had the oreo ice cream cake for my birthday haven't had ice cream this good in along time! DELICIOUS

Everyone needs an Ice cream from the Creamery.

Delicious!!! I had the cherries jubilee and Marsh Mud (chocolate). Still as good as ever. Service was great. Love the crunchy Carmel bourbon, the taste on cantaloupe was awesome.

Best ice cream on the shore. It's creamy and every flavor I've tried is spot on.

Delicious with a side of friendly service. A great experience!

Excellent ice cream and super quick service.

Excellent great portions. The best in the area for ice cream. Cakes are number 1. You have to try one.

Staff was nice but the flavors of ice cream tasted like medicine and cone was stale.

The ice cream was great and the waffle come was just as great

The cantaloupe ice cream is delicious

Always Great service and Best Ice Cream around!!! Try the Cantaloupe!!!

Best ice cream on the Eastern Shore!!!! Possibly the east cost!!! If your anywhere near any of their locations you have to stop!!!!!

They have a few vegan choices so thank you for that! Service is very good. The taste of the ice cream was reasonably good. Looking forward to more flavors on our next visit!

Now the #1 ice cream in the US according to USA Today 2023 poll.

The ice cream is superb. Nothing else needs to be said

We come here because my little one can't tolerate dairy products and they have amazing diary free options. Everything we've tasted is out of this world. And I love that they serve even the cones with spoons and drip catchers. The only wrinkle in this operation at the Salisbury location is there is extremely limited seating. It's a tiny area with a couple benches indoors and a few more large benches outside. Not a problem if you use their drive through but with toddlers or kids that you don't want eating ice cream in the car that doesn't work.

Quaint store wonderful homemade ice cream. Positive and helpful staff

Always a good experience. Ice cream is delicious 😋

Our ice cream was excellent. The staff was excellent. The waffle cone was not rigid enough and fell apart and had no flavor. The store was not welcoming for people to stay. ( But I'm not about to eat ice cream in my car. ) Needs a nice outdoor seating area. Indoor decor needs freshening up/ doesn't look very clean.

Great ice cream and awesome employees.

A little expensive but great ice cream. The oreo cakes aren't home made and on the small side so stick with ice cream. The oreo ice cream is bomb!!

Ice cream is very good. Nice and creamy. The best that I have had in Salisbury MD. Tasty treat.

Yummy flavors, best ice cream around

Best ice cream hands down!! Creative flavors too!!

Island Creamery is awesome in every way. Large selection of awesome creative flavors. Service is fast and friendly. It's not cheap but the ice cream doesn't taste cheap either so it's a win every time.

First time going and I fell IN LOVE with Marsh Mud. As a person who is sensitive to sweets, it was a perfect balance of chocolatey goodness. I will definitely be back

Would have been 5 stars but they removed the tables so you can no longer sit quietly inside and enjoy your ice cream. They still have the best flavor going anywhere!!

Loved the ice cream...so,so good

Island Creamery is the best ice cream place I’ve ever been too! They have Strawberry, Birthday Cake, Cookie Dough, Chocolate, Vanilla, and all other different kinds of Ice Cream! I just bought myself strawberry Ice Cream. *I also bought my Mom Chocolate.* If you want any Ice Cream you should go to this place. It’s the greatest. Trust me!

The Best ice cream around. I can never decide which flavor. They are all great!! Ice Cream Cakes are Great!

Amazing ice cream. No place to sit and eat inside though 😕

Do not go there. It is not the same as the Chincoteague location. No seating, and when you order a cone you get slop on a paper french fry plate. As soon as I tried to lift my cone it disintegrated in my hands. Will never return we wasted a 20 dollar IHC gift card there. Thanks for nothing.

Very delicious homemade ice cream. It was worth the price.

Best place for ice cream!! Yummy flavors, pints to go, and a drive thru!!

My favorite ice cream. Outstanding service.

They always have a wide variety of flavors and at a reasonable price. It's my favorite ice cream shop.

Ice cream with a drive through, yes please. And not only is it excellent ice cream but the portions are HUGE. This is my go to ice cream place. We love it, the kiddos love it. Please try!

A really nice ice cream place, a ton of options to choose from, and season themed flavors as well.

Lots of flavors to choose from and great customer service.

great ice cream! friendly staff!

The Island Creamery is one of the best ice creams around! They have a consistent base of delicious flavors such as pineapple upsidedown cake, cookie dough, and coffee, but they are often trying out new flavors as well! I highly recommend.

Always worth stopping by. Great ice cream, great staff, GREAT portions. Big guy that loves ice cream and I usually find a kid size cone to be just right.

Good ice cream, not better than cold stone.

The icecream is great. The service was good. The place was clean. We had a great experience.

Nice place first time coming there...co worker recommend I try it...excellent customer awesome ice cream

Great staff, they spoke as soon as I hut the door and they were smiling

Pleasant servers and delicious ice cream!

Great ice cream with tons of options at a very reasonable price! Staff is young, friendly and full of energy! Love this place!

Delicious! My favorite flavor is Burbon Caramel, its so so good! I love vanilla and caramel flavors so if u are like me go for this one! Busy place and I understand why! Its so good

The Island Creamery was very delicious they had a variety of ice creams, vegan and no sugar options as well. It was very busy but we were in and out in no time ... The perfect way to end a summer day

Excellent flavors, the banana split is to die for. Staff is all top notch customer service representatives. A ++++

Scoops are hefty size. Tried the Peanut Butter Cup. It was good. Got me wanting to try more flavors.

Fun and happy service! Marsh mud is the best!

Loooooove Island Creamery!! If you've never been, what are you waiting for?

Delicious! Fast! Great and friendly service!

Best shakes and ice cream in town

Awesome ice cream and service excellent!!

Make sure that you get the mint chocolate chip with Java child. You won't regret it.

Always plenty of great flavors and dips are generous!

Strongly recommend the best ice cream ever

Great local creamery near the college. Grab a cup or cone and either sit on the benches outside or take a beautiful walk through the Salisbury University campus!

My daughter and I Favorite Place to go For Ice Cream. Homemade and Rich Flavors. Staff is Always Soo Nice!

Absolutely delicious! Tons of flavors to try. My favorite is oreo. Excellent customer service in a very clean, inviting environment.

Definitely pricey. 9 bucks for two scoops 😵‍💫 but the flavors are good and the staff are friendly

Always delicious, and always friendly, smiling staff! Love Island Creamery!

LOVE this place! Great ice cream!

It seems I can't figure out this place. Awesome ice cream no doubt. The rules to purchase it alludes me. New rule only 2 samples per customer. I understand this but the way they question you is inappropriate. 7 or 8 employees working but you can't get mixed pints or quarts. I was the only customer in the store.

This is hands down my favorite ice cream shop. The flavors are rich but I tend to go between my two favorites, coffee and/or cake batter. When I come to either Salisbury or Chincoteague (it's original location) this is always my first stop.

Might be the best icecream I've ever had. The waffle cones are worth the trip alone!

I loved the ice cream and loved the workers there. Everyone had a smile on there face and greeted me as a friend and not just another costumer. I’ve recommended this place to all my friends and I will be coming again. If I could give this place more than 5 stars, then I would. Best ice cream in MD 🙌

Best homemade ice cream ever! Decent prices and excellent selection of flavors to choose from. My personal favorites and recommendations are Java Jolt and Coffee.

Excellent ice cream and service!

Many different flavors, and a few seasonal options. The best ice cream!!

Excellent ice cream and service. Came highly recommended and was worth it.

Good price for alot of ice cream