Jeremiah's Italian Ice in Hunters Creek - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Really good spot to have a quick stop with the kids, for those of you from the East coast, the closest thing you can get to Rita’s on the South.

Always great treats and service 👌🏾

Jeremiah’s Italian Ice is more than just a dessert spot—it’s a fun and flavorful experience. With its wide array of flavors and the innovative Gelati creations, it’s no wonder that Jeremiah’s has garnered a loyal following. Whether you’re a fan of traditional Italian ice or looking to try something new, Jeremiah’s is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

I placed a catering order for my workplace. Brianna responded right away, put everything together and delivered on time. PLUS the gelatis were exceptionally good -- a perfect refreshment for a hot day. I highly recommend this location!

We have always been a fan of Jeremiah's but this past experience was disappointing due to the cold and rude service of the person working the window. Really made us feel unwelcome. Will not return to this particular location again

It's delicious BUT... there are some ice creams that are not delicious. Gelato doesn't taste that good

Green apple all the way. Not exactly cheap, not expensive. Salted caramel is pretty good as well. The line system sucks. You never know if its one line or two. I wish staff would give some direction. The lines start to become little lakes of people whenever groups form. Winter Park location has a better system (and a drive thru).

Delicious American version of an Italian ice!

The attention of the girls is super friendly, there are not many tables and chairs to sit and very close to the parking street, you must be very careful with children.

Ice creams of excellent flavor and quality.

Staff is super nice and helpful when it comes to suggesting which flavors to try and combine! They have seasonal flavors and you can mix and match between italian ice, soft serve, and gelati. I highly recommend the mango gelati! Sizes are actually pretty big and I tend to share a small with someone else

There ices are delicious. They have fast and friendly service. I like the gelati. My favorite ice is mango, but all the flavors I've tried are good. I buy the quarts because you can get 4-5 servings from it for $6 compared to $2-3 per cup.

I've visited this location many times and have always had good experiences. However, in the last three visits I've noticed that I always receive very little soft serve ice cream in the gelatis I've ordered. So little, in fact, that there's always open space left in the cup. I've gone to other locations to see if this is a new practice across all locations, but it seems like this location is the only one that is skimping on the soft serve ice cream. All other Jeremiah's I've visited have always been generous with the soft serve ice cream. I hope they fix this issue.

Best place to get soft serve 🍦.

I’ve been living in Florida for 10 years and tried Jeremiah since. But lately at least the last 4 times I’ve been there my favorite flavor that is coconut is just has gone bad Super frozen and not flavor at all, just taste ice. Honestly the quality for me isn’t there anymore.

I love Jeremiah's. Their Italian water ice is unmatched!!!

Deliciosos helados , y personal amable 😊

Just sooooo good, especially in this summer heat

really good ice cream. shout out to victoria who made the experience a 11/10. give her a raise🙌🏽

Excelente helado, puedes ver mi foto jajaja 😂no deje nada de nada Volveré 🤗

THE ICE CREAM IS SO GOOOOOOOD AND THE ITALIAN ICE

Great spot on a hot day to cool off....

Most flavors offered are overly sweet and overpriced too. I recommend sharing an ice cream if possible.

Tried this location for the first time. Ordered an Italian ice and an Italian ice and gelato mix. They messed up the mix but made another and gave me both, which was fine, I guess, because they both tasted ok. Jeremiah's is certainly not my favorite frozen snack establishment because the flavors are kinda bland, but it's nice in a pinch.

I know their location from Bradenton been there many times, when I saw they had a place in Orlando I jumped and got there asap, great Italian ice!

If u love ice cream then you should go to Jeremiah's Italian lce!

Today's new GM is doing great job. Have been coming here for tasty ice for a long time. Thank you.

What can I say! Yummy Italian ice!; I love their gelatos!!

When in town I must stop and have a treat.

Loveeeee this ice cream!!! If you’re a soft serve ice cream this is your place to go! The texture is unbelievable, the variety of flavors this Jeremiah’s offer for the affordability is amazing!! You must go here!!! This spot is more a to go place since they don’t It’a outside, however, they al have some tables and chaira for you to sit but sometimes is packed!! But go and try it!!!

Excelentes helados, deben mejorar la crema me causo dolor de estómago

Our favorite location and such a tasty treat!

Delicious dessert, friendly and fast service. Had an allergen menu handy when we asked and everything our group ordered was excellent. Even their small size is a generous portion (heaped well over the top of the cup)

Enjoyed this unique Italian ice cream. Liked the cotton candy flavor. Tasted couple of other flavors. Outlet is open till 11 pm. Sunday is closed.

This place is awesome, staff is always awesome and patient, I bring my little ones and they can be unsure of what they want that evening. Helps when you're able to taste something before buying it.

Helados deliciosos, los de sabores mango y coco excelentes... solo una pequeña recomendacion: mantener un poco más limpio el área de las mesas, es un poco desagradable sentarse y tu mismo limpiar tu mesa y ver el piso con un poco de servilletas tiradas..

Awesome treats , I love getting the mango gelati super yummy . The staff is also super nice .

Good ice cream at a reasonable price. The workers are nice and they do free samples. 💯 recommended 👍

Auto servicio, variedad en sabores, precios moderados.

Big Fan of their sugar free Gelato especially the Tangerine flavor

El de coco es excelente, además la atención de una chica llamada Leslie, fue excepcional