Keith Heinritz Katering in Trafford - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Keith’s has the best fried fish in the world. I’ve been eating here since Keith opened. I traveled extensively throughout my lifetime and have eaten a lot of fried fish. I never found better fried fish than Keith’s. I make certain to get one sandwich (one easily feeds my wife and me) every time I visit Trafford. If you like a big fish sandwich try Keith’s. You’ll be glad you did.

Atmosphere is severely outdated, but the fish sandwiches here are worth it. Definitely more of a take out place. The haluski and macaroni and cheese are okay. The fish, however, is pretty good.

Excellent fish sandwich! More than enough food! Very nice people!

This is still the best fish sandwich in the world. The perfectly simmered hot sauce and the abundance of perfectly breaded, tasty fish. Impossible to beat.

The fish is delicious! You get a pound of fish for $15. Cash only.

The largest fish sandwich in East Pittsburgh. 4 whole filets. Very good. Good bun too. All the sides were delicious. Highly recommend.

Delicious food! Generous portions for the price!! Best food in Trafford!

Best fish I've ever had!! Huge fish sandwich!

Great food! Awesome fish! owner does have an attitude but the food is worth it.

Best fish in the area. And the hot sauce is incredible. Make sure you call ahead of time as they are very popular. But if you have a chance

Although the fish was good, the whole order was wrong. (because of how busy we did not check the order there).Ordered 3 fish dinners, 2 chicken tenders dinners. Only received 2 fish sandwiches (no sides).Got 1 order of chicken not the 2 I ordered, but we got sides for 2 chicken tenders dinner. One last issue, the Mac and cheese ordered with 1 of the chicken tender meals was COLD. Fresh out of the fridge.Paid $72 + $5 tip for maybe $50 of food.

Great fish sandwich huge portion love the slaw too

Delicious fish sandwich and home style food

Great fish sandwich..feed two easily. Delicious coleslaw as well.do not miss the homemade hot sauce!

Some of the most delicious fried fish we’ve ever had. The only negative was how dangerous it is to be waiting while the food is cooking, smelling the savory aroma and of course drooling on the floor causing a traffic hazard!(jk). The chicken wings were just as delicious as the fish, and not the teeny one-bite ‘winglets’ most places sell now. These were huge, hugely delicious and now I’m drooling again! Becka was awesome too, friendly and funny! We WILL be returning regularly. Note: it’s a cash-only place. Also great wings take time so order in advance or take a mop and a bucket to deal with the drool while waiting. Soooo well worth the wait.

Not open, yet online/google said they were. This was Saturday 1/13 6pm.

Keith and his crew took on the task of catering 280 cheese burgers for our assemble your own burger bar. The burgers were delicious, the buns were super fresh, and the spread of fixing was a hit with our group of people. Keith was super easy to work with and everything arrived on time. All of the participants had nothing but good things to say about the spread of food. Highly recommend Keith for all your catering needs.

Best steak sandwich anywhere!!! Spicey C steak rules.

One fish sandwich had 4 oversize pieces of delicious fish. Feeds 2 people. The place to go for fish.

I cannot say enough good things about Keith and Paulette they catered my daughters wedding this past weekend everyone raved how delicious the food was I would recommend them to anyone

Our cousin took us while we were visiting from out of state. OMG the fish dinner was AMAZING!!!!! Great folks!!!

I thought they would have more food options. Their catering was outstanding.

Keith catered pulled pork, mac & cheese and salad for our church group today. Absolutely delicious.

I know everyone goes to Keith fir the famous fish sandwiches but his catering is even better. We've had them multiple times, but recently had them for my father's funeral luncheon. We ordered for 90 people, fed 115 people and they all had extra to take home for another meal!!! We mixed it up with stuffed chicken breasts and mashed potatoes and Italian beef instead of chicken and rigatoni. So glad we did. Prices are so economical, portions are huge and the food is delicious. I can't thank Paulette and Keith so much. They are wonderful. Thanks!!!@

The fish was awesome as always!

Fish sandwich is big @ $14 and change. Reuben sub had coleslaw on it - perhaps not traditional - may not appeal to some.

So I was at work thinking about a fish sandwich and my coworker told me about this place I drove 4 miles to get there! On my lunch break mind you. Got there the place was just as she explained a little small joint but they serve “great food “she said. I ordered the fish the portion was very large but it taste like paper there was absolutely no seasoning in the cornmeal or whatever it is he uses nor on the fish I was so disappointed with the taste also I ordered french fries to go with my fish crinkle cut french fries were dark brown and hard too hard for me to actually enjoy Crinkle Cut french fries are supposed to be crisp on the outside and soft on the inside these were hard as rocks. He asked if he could give me extra hot sauce I said sure then try to charge me for it not only that the hot sauce was like no other add some type of peppers or something inside of it was not hot and taste it like the refrigerator it was Stored in.

Best fish sandwich in the valley

This place has the best fried fish ever!!! I go here year round! The sandwiches are huge and are suitable for 2 meals. The only thing to note is that it is a cash only place.

Always a great experience. Food is beyond excellent!!! Only place to go for Fish during lent !!!!!!

This was absolutely 💯 delicious a hot and fresh. Huge portions! And that homemade hot sauce is so good I could drink it! I will definitely be back! #SupportLocal

It's not pretty, it's not fancy, they don't take cards. There ya go, the cons are out of the way. IMHO this place has the best fish sandwich around. Also unlike local fish fries around lent, you can come here whenever you want. Sure Fridays during lent are crazy busy and for good reason, but don't let that stop you from deciding in the middle a September on Wednesday that you can't get a killer good and huge fish sandwich. Other stuff on the menu is good too. The onion rings are solid, the haluski is spot on, and the hot sauce for the fish is fantastic.

Best fish sandwich around! And everything else is good too, fair prices as well

Phenomenal fish sandwich once again this lenten season. You definitely get your moneys worth.

Great little spot with a killer and huge fish sandwich. Great place for lent.

We moved to Florida over 20 years ago, but everytime we visit family in Greensburg, we make sure we head down to Keith's to get our Giant Fish Sandwich/Dinner fix, he still serves one of the Biggest and Tastiest Fish Sandwich in Western Pennsylvania.

Don’t let the building fool you. This is a great and tasty place to eat. Everyone goes for the fish sandwich which is excellent, but so too the soups and wings. Awesome Service by the owner.

They serve the best fish sandwich in the area.

Crispy, delicious fish, huge servings. Great hot sauce.

HIDDEN GEM ALERT! We had Keith cater a party of 70 for us in late July. They made BBQ pulled pork, sweet & hot sausage, mac n' cheese, cole slaw, and chicken tenders (for the kids). The pricing per person was the best around. The food was excellent! Heard nothing but good things from all of our guests. And they provided enough to feed an army - we had so much leftovers! I'll also add in that we stopped there to have dinner a few weeks prior to booking our catered event - we had the famous fish sandwich... which is literally gigantic! It has 4 huge pieces of fish on it and was also delicious!

Fish sandwich is out of this world. Their homemade hot sauce is also amazing!

You need to eat fish here one time

Best fish sandwich around. 1 sandwich feeds 3 people. You’ll need extra buns of course. Homemade hot sauce is unbelievable and soooooo good.

Good tasting food I will back for more

This is where you need to go for an EXCELLENT fish sandwich!!!

Won't find a better fish sandwich enough to feed a small village

Fish was absolutely awesome, very large portion, coleslaw, Mac & cheese, potato pancakes fabulous!!! Very homey environment, and a very nice owner

I highly recommend the fish sandwich 10 out of 10. Great Coleslaw

Food is mom n pops style always fresh. Never had anything that wasn't good or hot made from Keith's. I just happened to have lunch with the wrong person that ruined the experience for me and my partner.

Potato pancakes like momma used to make

Had their fish sandwich with the homemade hot sauce. A lot of fish on the sandwich(enough for two people) and the hot sauce is good.

Have eaten everything on menu and never had anything bad . Strongly recommend

Best tasting breaded cod anywhere!

Best fish sandwich in the tri-state area!

Huge pieces of fish, the best around.

The worst fish I have had the pleasure of trying to eat

Keith is the man Best fish in 100 miles!!

Best fish sandwich anywhere in Pittsburgh

Ordered the fish sandwich for the first time today, absolutely delicious and done properly, crunchy, meaty, not greasy and easily enough to share. Excellent quality and value.

Excellent fish sandwiches and awesome homemade hot sauce.

Frequented this business when I lived in Trafford, excellent fish sandwiches in my opinion.. Make sure you're hungry when you order because they give you enough to feed two people!

Fish sandwiches that can seem to feed a village .wonderful tastes but be warned cash only.

Best fish sandwich ever!! To be honest, one of the best restaurants period. Keep up the great food Mr. Keith!!

I had the fish sandwich meal it was large enough to feed both my girlfriend and myself. The food was excellant and the price was as lot lower than i would have expected for such a great meal. I will definately return.

This Lobster Bisque was awesome...fish sandwich as always. Worth the trip from Mt pleasant to Trafford.. just the BEST...EVER!!

Best and biggest fish sandwiches around

The fish sandwiches are delicious and are a good value. If only the owner would update the archaic point of sale system the restaurant would earn a 5 star rating.

OMG! What a fish sandwich! As the sign inside the door says, "Glory to cod in the fryer." Best. Ever.

The fish sandwich's are amazing

Great fried fish for Fish Friday

Best fish sandwich around. The homemade hot sauce is great. Call ahead during Lent.

Fish was good! Wish we knew it was a cash only place without a ATM.

The outside of the deli may look plain, but Keith's fish sandwiches are the bomb! For that matter, all the food is great. People are willing to drive the distance to pick up food from Keith's!!! Don't forget to try Keith's special homemade hot sauce... it's such a delicious addition to a crispy, hot fish sandwich!

Terrific. Everything was great and the price was very good.

Unbelievable!! 1 fish sandwich platter including sides, fed my husband and me. We also each got chowder & dessert and had to roll ourselves out of there! Delicious!!!

The fish sandwich was excellent!

The fried fish sandwiches are second to none. Extremely generous portions and the hot sauce is unique and pairs with the fish perfectly. One sandwich easily feeds two people.

Best fish sandwich hands down! One fish dinner easily satisfies two people because portions are huge. Keith uses the best fish and breading technique to make this awesome sandwich. The side dishes are super too. Don't forget the homemade hot sauce to compliment your meal!

You’ve never had a better fish sandwich and you never will. Keith’s is the epitome of fried fish perfection. Oh and the hot sauce? Yeah, you’re going to want to try it.

Anyone east of downtown knows this place is the best. Good food. Great prices and lots of fish. We get one fish sandwich and split it between us. The lobster bisque is really good too.. and the fries.

Awesome fish sandwich!!! I think it's the best in Pittsburgh area. Definitely give it a try

You will not find a better fish sandwich within a 100 miles!! Thanks for doing a excellent job!!

Very nice people and customer service was good.

Great food! You get what you pay for! Always going there for the fish !(p.s. this photo was for when ther Corona Corona virus had just started.. ) love it thoigh!

Food was all really good. Great Service!

Easily out of one sandwich u have enough fish to make another and then some... don't forget the extra bun and homemade hot sauce!

2020 0311 great fish sandwich great people great service great price great food

always great fish and plenty of it at keiths

Keith Heinrtiz Katering makes the absolute best food. We've had them cater several events for us and everything they make is amazing. However, the real star of the show is their big fish sandwich. Best in Pittsburgh, by far!!

Great fish sandwiches but the bun is way to small for what they give you

Hands down best fish sandwich in the Burgh. NOT JUST LENT. They serve it all year. Also their lobster bisque is incredible. Bonus------- Keith and Paulette are nice people.

I have used Keith Katering for 5 partys and could not be happier.The food is always great, and there is always so much. You can ask for just about anything and he can make it.

They are known for their fried fish and fried fish sandwiches! The rest of the menu is great, but that is what they are known for. During Lent, I try to visit a lot of fish places but I always have to order at least twice from them! They are the gold standard, the rest falter…

Best fish sandwich I have had in the Pittsburgh area. Hand dips and dredges all of it. Has a top notch hot sauce to go with it along with great slaw.

The best fried fish sandwich in Allegheny country.

Great fish sandwich! Their home made hot sauce was really good too. The sign outside doesn't tell you that it's a small sit down restaurant or take out. Luckily, I heard about the size of the fish sandwich (huge).

The best fish sandwich and homemade hot sauce

Five of us from Atlanta, Charlotte, Harrisburg, Washington, DC and Trafford went to Keith’s last weekend having heard about the fish. All five loved it! Fish, breading, fries and Keith’s homemade hot sauce were all outstanding. We plan to go back next time we’re in Pittsburgh.

Great fish! Best in the area. Seems a little pricey until you get your order. Wow! You get what you pay for. Well worth the money and the wait.

Keith's has the best fish in western Pennsylvania. My wife and I moved north near Cranberry Township and haven't found anywhere that comes close. My wife loves it so much, she wanted to go there for her birthday. The haluski is awesome too.