New York Pizza in Pascagoula - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

As xlose to NY pizza as it gets. The sauce is amazing. I always get extra cheese and extra crispy...yummm

Never been disappointed with the food or service. We typically phone our order in while running errands and it's always ready to pick up. We have dined in before as well. Great service, great food. I highly recommend the blackened shrimp pizza.

The steak sandwich is my weakness it is so good

Great food and super friendly staff.

The service was amazing and the food came quick, hot and fresh

What a great step back in time to when great food was created by folks who love what they do. Pizza was delicious and excellent example of New York style. Staff was friendly. Restaurant was just fun old school.

Very good food service was good everything was nice

The sandwiches are sooo good especially the New York. The best pizzas on the coast and the menu has greatly expanded too.

I love New York Pizza, the best pizza in town.

Love the staff and the buffalo chicken pizza is so good. If you want it spicier, add spicy sauce instead of mild :)

Excellent taste and excellent service, I'll be coming back for more.

Staff was rude and very sarcastic to my husband and I.

Great place great pizza great people

I had the ham and cheese sandwich. It was delicious and so big that I couldn't eat it as a sandwich. I had to get a knife and fork. Well worth the money!

The food was pretty good - tried two slices of pepperoni and sausage AND the staff was awesome. Really friendly people and fairly priced food. I'll definitely come back.

This is the best New York Pizza on the coast. Staff is helpful and friendly. Will get the crust crispy if you want.

This place is absolutely amazing. I'm from Mobile, but when I'm going thru Mississippi, I have to stop there. The pizzas are simply delicious, and the cooks are so professional and good at what they do!!! Keep up the great work, team.. Chef Kevin

Love this place. Best pizza around.

I’m very disappointed at the fact that 9 youth basketball players and their coaches were denied seating in your establishment on last night. They were made to stand outside and eat their food like stray animals, all while other customers are being welcomed in and seated. The kids were very disappointed. Shame on you!

Favorite pizza place on the coast.

Medium pizza seemed a bit small but everything else was great.

I don't like pickles... and yet they make a pizza topped only with cheese and pickle chips that's just fantastic. Wonderful staff and delicious food. Atmosphere is nothing special, but neither is it off-putting. 10/10 would recommend.

It's a great place to get a slice of pizza in Pascagoula ms I love it.

Good price for a slice of Pizza good amount

They keep it cold in there was told that it was for the workers by the pizza oven to stay cool but every time I come in here we freeze while we eat need to make the patrons comfortable not the employees

Best pizza ive ever had, gone here since i was young and Antonio ran it, great size, price, and the crust is top tier.

My first time ever trying New York pizza the staff are very friendly food is quicker than the time they tell you it’s fresh and the atmosphere is peaceful as far as the food a definite 10/10

Great food, awesome people and great service 💯

My favorite pizza lately. By the slice. Love the crust.

Pizza is the best I've had since I left New York!!

Great food and great friendly service!

We placed a large order for pickup and after picking up our order and driving home we realized something was missing. We called them and explained what happened and they delivered the missing item. The food was delicious and the customer service was top notch. A+++++++

I love the food here, everything is always really good, my only thing is that the tables may be a bit too close to the chairs. I always feel a bit squished

Best place to get pizza and wings, there sandwiches are great

Pickle pizza is one to try. Very friendly staff

My order was incorrect, but they corrected it immediately. I still took the blame for the misunderstanding and paid for the mistake, a Supreme pizza when I wanted just pepperoni and sausage. The pizza is outstanding.

The service is very quick and friendly. The pizza I got was really good. I added extra shrimp and a couple extra toppings.

Great place to eat, never gotten anything I've not enjoyed.

My husband and I ate here for the first time today. We both had sub sandwiches and they were the best I've had! I am looking forward to trying their pizza next!!!

Stop cutting the pizza weird. Just cut it in normal slices.

So I had the new York pizza and the a stromboli, they forget the marinara sauce. That's maybe the only issue. Besides that the pizza was really great they don't stop with the cheese they load it up. Crust seemed great, only issue I had with the stromboli it was different than what I ordered but this was wasn't great but wasn't bad. The pizza is good enough just to go there for that. I've eaten pizza literally all over and it's pretty good here. Price is also pretty good as well not to expensive.

Drove over from Theodore today and ate at New York Pizza for the first time. Hands down...the best pizza I've had in years! That includes trips to Chicago and NY! Friendly service and speed of service was great! Highly recommend!!!

My vote for best pizza in the south! Cooked to perfection, crust is brown but not burnt, toppings cooked great. I'd be here once a week if I lived here.

I was so happy with the pizza next time I'm going to get a sub! Everything was very very good and they have watermelon tea my favorite!

Pizza by the slice joint. Quick and no frills place for pizza, salads, subs and Pickle pizza: a delicacy of Pascagoula.

If you're in the Pascagoula area and want north east style pie, this is the place.

Hey, New York Pizza is a little gem! We really enjoyed our Calzone and Stromboli! If you're in Pascagoula Mississippi, I recommend that you check it out!

Great food. Call ahead or prepare for a wait. I learned the hard way. Took me back to the store when it was in the Singing River Mall. All fives!

Always friendly and courteous. Of course the food is the best!

With any mistake offer an accommodation. We ordered pizza, boneless wings and onion rings. We received everything except the onion rings. After we were done eating and made a 2nd attempt at getting our onion rings checked on ..it was discovered that they forgot about them. 10 min later they were brought to us. The staff was friendly and inviting. The food was acceptable. Honestly because of the friendly staff, even including their HUMAN error....I'd go back. Family friendly.

Best Pizza I’ve Ever Had Keep Up The Good Work🙂👍🏾

Big Surprise For Mississippi, I'm a Bronx Boy

We love New York Pizza! We eat there 3 to 4 times a month. Everything on the menu is delicious and reasonably priced. They often try new things like pizza burgers and white pizzas and do it well. The drive through window is an added bonus since we live close by and they are always prompt at the window. If you have only had the pizza, you're missing out on delicious subs and calzones. Their staff is usually outgoing and polite. You won't be disappointed in New York Pizza!

The staff is friendly and helpful!! The pickle pizza has become my favorite!!

The pizza is awesome and so are the sammiches! I hit this place up anytime I'm in town 😋

I like this staff, very professional. Clean place, great food, fair prices and the food always on time.

Always great food. Clean. Love the crust on the pizza. Great selection of food options. Prompt & friendly service. Best in the area.

Service was excellent! The food was really good and hot. We ordered 2 cheesesteak a la garden's with fries, XL pepperoni pizza, and an Antipasto salad with house dressing.

I have been to New York Pizza several times and they never messed up my order. I ordered 2 chicken and shrimp Alfredos and one was supposed to have extra shrimp but only had 6. I was very disappointed because I have never had any issues with them before and the food is always delicious.

i'd eagerly sell a kidney in exchange for the pickle pizza. it's that good man, it's that good.

This place was pretty awesome. Very friendly service. Old school pizzeria feel. Handmade pizza. Food was spot on. Would recommend going in and having a great pizza.

This places is great , I stopped in to dine, the customer service was great and the the pizza was delicious 🤤. I got the cauliflower pizza with pepperoni and sausage and omg it was great and the the baby’s got the regular cheese and sausage they said it was pretty good and the hubby got the big pepperoni he ate all of it except one slice sooo they really enjoyed it and I did to . I will return again .🙂

MAN, this place always kills it. Today is a cold wet day, and to me besides soup on a day like this. The next best thing is a hot meatball sammich. And this place has once again, killed it. I have only been here a couple months, and absolutely love NEW YORK PIZZA!!!

Order to all meats, one of them was right, and the other one had black olives, and it was burned so bad it’s not edible

The pizza was good and the sauce was amazing!

This place is amazing. Good pizza and amazing staff.

Great pizza. Was a little disappointed when we ordered chicken fingers and had to pay .75 for dip for the chicken. They don't give you one with your order

Oh man. This pizza was soo good! The cheese was soo good and you can definitely tell the difference in fresh vs not. If I am back, I will be visiting! Although, the cheese bread wasn’t very good.

If you want a great pizza with fresh ingredients and real cheese, go try one. After eating one, domino's,Caesar's and pizza hut just don't taste as good. At least it didn't to me.

This is the second time I have ordered pizza from them since I quit The one in Gautier. Let me tell you both times the pizzas are FANTASTIC, FABULOUS, SPOT ON DELICIOUS!! You want good pizza go to New York Pizza in Pascagoula, it’s definitely worth driving over the bridge from Gautier lol.

The antipasta salad is delish! 😋

Walked in for a carry out pizza based on a local recommendation for a place to eat. I expected the usual pizza to fill the void while traveling but was pleasantly surprised with the quality of the food here. Great taste and selection for some unique ingredients. Will stay and eat on site next time.

They have the best Steak-a-la Garden PoBoy

Good pizza no lie..But when i go in before customers..We order the same food..But they food was giving first.n I was called last.But made my order.before guest.They was behind me.Must be a ticket mix up..I can tell u this.It made me feel some type of way.Until im skeptic on eating my pizza.Which is crazy.Ive always went to the one in Gautier.Ms.I also give credit wen due.My first time coming to this one&I dont think i will be back.Even if the pizza is good..Bad service n response.plus actions will do it too you..Thnks

Good food, friendly and courteous staff, and clean facility.

It's quite often busy so doing pickup at lunch is a good idea. I really like the Cauliflower crust pizza. It's small which makes it ideal for a meal. They bake it well and it doesn't taste like Cauliflower. My goto is the personal size calzone, I take the ham off and add veggies. My only real complaint is that I often count calories to make sure I'm eating in my target range and they don't have any paperwork for that. The people inside are very friendly and if you order the same thing regularly they'll remember you. Their fries are seasoned and thick. I haven't eaten a salad there but some of my friends have and they're huge. You can go in and just get a couple of slices of any pizza for not a whole lot. I've only gotten it a couple of times on special occasions but their cannolis are so good. I can't forget to mention the pickle pizza. It's surprisingly good. I like to order it with beef added and it's like a cheeseburger pizza. I haven't disliked anything I've eaten there. Thanks for your response, keep up the good work, my coworkers and I appreciate you!!

Pizza was good. But I did see the back room cook come out to front and grabbed 2 handfuls of pepperoni. The problem was he was not wearing gloves.

Cool and refreshing place to spend time and money for! Best and fresh stromboli and salads! Service is always amazing as are employees!

Great quality 🍕 pizza. Nice cozy environment to eat in. Best pizza in Pascagoula, MS for sure!! Also, they are now serving alcohol.

Awesome food was delicious definitely will return!

I've been here twice and got the same thing both times....the Blackened Shrimo pizza. It's amazing. Comes with an Alfredo as the base. Really tasty shrimp and a good amount. We'll be back every time we're in town...the question is will we ever try something different!

First time there it was pretty good and everyone was super nice

Good pizza. Very friendly staff

We were greeted as we walked in the door to this restaurant. Service, cleanliness, and food were great. I ordered the Antipasto Salad and my husband had the calzone. Both were delicious! Thank you

A local treasure. I am in love with their pickle pizza and watermelon tea.

I was on Market Street and we decided to stop and eat with my daughter. I like that you could buy by the slice. It was good. My husband didn't care for it but he is so picky.

New York Pizza has been a favorite since I was in high school. The staff has always been friendly and the food has always had the same great quality. I've literally never had a bad experience. It has been a pleasure watching them grow.

Their blackened chicken pizza is great!

Ordered pizza from phone.. put on hold. Then girl said go ahead, I’ll remember without writing. Picked up from window. Pizza not hot. Tipped girl at window. No manners! No thank you for tip. Very unusual service. Could use some manners.

The staff was so friendly! My pizza was so good! Perfect crispy brickoven style pizza. Has a drive through!

great prices fast service with a smile

Love their calzones! If you don't hurry for a quick meal try their pizza by the slice. My go to pizza place

Just got take out on time order correct staff was nice pizza is outstanding. What more could you ask for.

Today may 11 2022 after years of coming here , I had the worst experience with New York pizza Pascagoula. The attitude from the manager the trainee that no one helped or corrected on her wrong after me trying to be understanding because we all trained and messed up before understandable but to be rude and flat out oblivious to the wrong being done is dead wrong. I don’t recommend this place if you want quality service or food .

Not impressed with the food. I've had better pizza frozen

This place is great they have large sized food which is larger than what you would probably normally expect. It had me pleasantly surprised. I got the stromboli and the cheese steak stromboli. (The cheese steak stromboli is personal size and the request one is xl. The one that is a bit darker is the cheese steak.) Others I was with got the blackened shrimp Alfredo and a New York style pizza. Overall this place is amazing actually. I recommend all the things I have listed.

Service was friendly and quick but my cheese steak sandwich was terrible. The meat was soaked with oil and had no flavor. It all sat in the middle of my bread and just made for a sad lunch.

The bread sticks were pretty awesome and so was the service

Exciting g staff and always with a smile and great attitude. I'll keep going back.

picked up a half and half supreme/pepperoni pizza and breadsticks to go and went to share it with my grandma, it was delicious and we enjoyed it with a game of cards!