Nicky's Sammie Shack - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Sucks, got blt with hole in it and was smashed and soggy. Got hot Fudge at Sunday wanted whipped cream was unable to get whipped cream while running around trying to figure out the whip cream. I pretty pretty much had a bowl of soup. The fry’s were soggy and cold I threw it all in the trash and went without eating for the night.

Our second time here and it hits again, fun sammies that match a fun vibe. Excellent sides. We are from out of town but will be making this a regular stop anytime we come through

Holy moly! Every single thing we had here was amazing and top quality! My husband had the Korean burger and onion rings and they were both awesome, very flavorful. And I had the Bahn-Sami sandwich and sweet potato tots, and they were both so delicious! The portions are quite large and very filling. We will be back!

quite literally the nicest and sweetest people i’ve ever had greet me and take my order 🥹

Outstanding sandwich & burger joint with both classic and fusion-esque fare. Came for dinner on a Tuesday around 6, and while it never got packed, they did good business. Staff was very friendly and helpful, and food was ready quickly. There are a couple patio tables just outside, and a picnic pavilion further out. Ordered the Otis burger with sweet potato tots and the stoopid cheezie bacon burger with fries. All was fantastic. Burgers are default double patties, and the bacon burger was indeed stupid cheesy in the best way possible. Fries were very thin, but with good crispness and flavor. Can't wait to be back and work our way through all the other tempting menu options!

My husband and I both got a burger. His was Stoopid Cheezie Bacon Burger and I got the mushroom onion Swiss burger. Both were really good. I got the fries which were thin, crispy and salty which is my ideal fry. My husband got the Mac and cheese and it wasnt anything too special. It honestly looked like the deluxe Kraft Mac and cheese. The service was fast and the prices were fair.

The food and vibe are amazing! We got to sample their kraken and dirty ranch sauces both were amazing!

I knew I was in for a treat when I got my sandwich (wrapped to-go) and upon opening for consumption I noticed an adequate size piece of bacon stuck to the outside of the wrapper! This must have been a strategically placed free of charge appetizer, and it was delicious. Upon further examination and opening of my “Chickie Salad” Sammie I noticed delicious sauce was everywhere, and meat and deliciousness flowing outside the sandwich spilling everywhere. Guys, this sandwich is not for the dainty or for the faint of heart. If you don’t want to get your hands dirty, bring a pair of latex gloves and a bib. This sandwich will make you want to slap yo momma, not in a domestic abuse kind of way, but your mouth will try to find a way to speak in tongues. The zesty waffle fries are so seasoned that you can’t tell where one fry starts and the next fry ends. Your fingers will be orange and you going to need to wash your face after you get done eating. Well done guys, well done. (I’m filling in today at Shipps Pharmacy as a fillin pharmacist, and they recommend I try you guys, best suggestion ever).

Great restaurant. Always a great experience when visiting. Friendly staff. Delicious food. We visit often since it is the closest restaurant to us. Love it!

It’s overpriced and not good food.

A little bit off the beaten path, but well worth the drive. Been there twice now in a group, and everyone's food was excellent. They don't have a huge, overwhelming menu; but what they do, they do right! Great little place!

Not sure how all of these reviews are positive. Me and my wife went in there late Saturday night excited to try it out. We’ve had their ice cream before which was great so we were hopeful the food would be just as good. I got the chili cheese burger, and my wife got a hot ham and cheese sandwich. We both got fries and a drink. Fries and drink no problem, pretty typical stuff. The sandwiches on the other hand were hard to finish. My chili cheese burger was a complete soggy mess and the flavor was subpar. I was expecting it to be messy, but atleast taste good and I was wrong. My wife’s hot ham and cheese was essentially a big fatty piece of ham (something out of Easter or thanksgiving) thrown on a seeded bun with some lettuce. Neither of us could finish it, paid 30 dollars for everything and was extremely disappointed. Probably won’t be back. 3/10 only cause the fries were alright.

First time eat at this place. It was so delicious for lunch! I got BLT with decent bacon ! I would love come back for lunch in future!

Wow! I love burgers and I’m hard to impress when it comes to burgers but this place impressed me. I was stunned at how delicious everything was at this little out of the way sandwich shop. Everything was seasoned beautifully. The mayonnaise au jus was excellent, I could take that stuff by the gallons. The cheese was delicious and melted to perfection. The fries here are awesome too, very skinny and crispy. We will be coming back.

Excellent sandwiches and burgers. The Korean burger with kimchi and the cubano sandwich are my favorites. Their sweet potato tots are also wonderful

It is an oasis of flavor, highly recommended, very friendly and pleasant place

Very good food, very fair priced and just a cool place to go. We drive 45 minutes out of our way for a good burger.

10/10 this place is great! We’ll be back soon! ✨ Also people complaining about the price are weird. You can go to Jacks and get a combo for about the same price and it won’t taste as good.

My family eats here at least twice a month, we haven’t been disappointed at all. Our favorite items are the hot hammy & the ruben. The onion rings are a must, especially with some spicy ketchup. The atmosphere is fantastic, the employees are great.

Best fries I have ever had in my life ❤️❤️❤️

this place is perfect the good is out of this world!! if your tired of eating the same old thing give this place a try the menu items are all delicious and upscale, portion sizes are great! i got the korean burger and it changed my life

Amazing food! This isn’t just your ordinary sandwhich shop, all the food is elevated and executed perfectly, the service is friendly and fast and we love the atmosphere, some of The tvs are playing cooking shows and the decor includes unique food pictures and drawings and when your finished with your wonderful meal you can walk right next door to their ice cream shop Ice-c’s.

Great food and extremely friendly. They went out of their way to accommodate my daughters allergy.

Very good service we loved it!!! I went with my husband & child and we love the decorations, the service was awesome as well and the food was delicious. Everything was clean, bathrooms 10/10. I wish I can give more stars!! Definitely recommended.

Amazing food, a bit pricey but it's definitely worth it!

We stopped here on our way to Rickwood Caverns for their Christmas Wonderland and I am so glad we chose this place. The staff was absolutely wonderful, and the food was on point 💯. I went here with my 6-year-old and his grandmother (Yaya), and my little one said if he had the choice he would rate it a 100/10. He and I both got wings; I got garlic parmesean wings and he got honey BBQ, Yaya got a sloppy steak sandwich, and everyone loved their food. I will say the BBQ wings were not my cup of tea (as I like a more traditional BBQ sauce) but he absolutely loved them, and I also loved my garlic parmesan wings and Yaya loved her sloppy steak sandwich. We would absolutely be regulars at this place if we were closer.

This place is legit, the flavour is bomb and nothing was lacking in any way. Don't let its location stop you, it gives you a reason to go to the middle of nowhere.

Food was delicious and the people working there were super helpful and nice. This was a nice little gem that we found and highly recommend them.

Tons of flavor and great service

The atmosphere of this restaurant is amazing, and it comes with a completely nostalgic soundtrack as you eat. I ordered the Mushroom Swiss burger and it was delicious with a healthy portion of mushrooms and swiss. My son ordered the chili cheeseburger without reading the description and it came with green chilies, and pimento cheese. Not a very good sandwich, I imagine it is if you like that sort of thing. We ordered him a plain cheeseburger next and it was delicious. We had French fries, which were seasoned deliciously and then over seasoned waffle fries that somehow were even better. The employees are phenomenal!! Their service is seriously top notch.

Amazing food. They work extremely hard to make sure that the food takes fresh and consistent with every visit. I have been a total of 5 times since they have been open. Great options for anybody with different needs m.

Worth a trip. Awesome Sammie’s and friendly staff.

Got to be one of the best sandwich shops in central Alabama. Absolutely in the middle of no where but totally worth the drive. I’m having a real hard time picking a favorite, it’s between the Barbie, Reuben, or Cuban, every sandwich is very unique to itself. Hell it’s all good, even the fries are on point, especially the waffle fries. Lots of specialty sauces too, haven’t tried all of them yet. Staff is friendly, the food is hot and fast, the barqs root beer in a bottle is ice cold. My new favorite place for sure.

Ordered 80 of the bone wings with a variety of flavors. WOW!!!!!!! Those wings were so good. Can’t wait to try the boneless wings next time. If you like wings, this is the place to go.

Stopped by for the first time tonight and what a great little place! I had the mushroom burger and fries and my husband had the steak sandwich and onion rings. Everything was perfect!! Also the hot honey wings were great! Will be back 😁 I would post a photo but it was so good it’s already gone

We love this place! My husband and I were on the phone discussing what we were going to do for dinner and he happened to pass by this restaurant, (we had no idea it was there) and he quickly turned around and went back to see what they had and give it a try. That was about four weeks ago and we just placed our 4th order since!! The mushroom swiss burger and onion rings are so delicious! This is not your average burger! It is the best I have ever had at any restaurant. (I am not including fast food as a restaurant; they are just that; fast food). I gave five stars for service and atmosphere because every time we have placed orders over the phone or at the counter the staff has been exceptionally nice and friendly and when my husband has picked up the food they have been super nice and so far they have gotten our order correct every time! Now, I don't know about you, but I have not been able to say that about anyplace I have ordered from consistently in a very long time! I highly recommend this place! I do not think you will be disappointed or leave hungry! As for the price; they are a little expensive. However, you get high quality food that you can enjoy eating and the portions are plenty adequate and the cost is barely more than fast food! This place cannot be compared to a fast food restaurant . Everything we have had has been steakhouse quality or better! I definitely prefer the burgers over a Logan's burger any day of the week! I can't say enough about the quality of the food! You know what you are eating! We sure have not received anything that was anything but delicious! Just so you know; I do not know who owns this restaurant, nor do I know anyone that works there. I have not been paid for my review and they do not know I am writing this review! I am happy we found this little hidden gem!

We were in the area so we decided to try this place out, and we weren’t let down. I got the burger they recommended and it was good, so we’re the frys! The restaurant was clean and looked pretty cool. The cashier was nice and helpful on what to try! I did take out because we had a 10 hour drive home. My food came out very quickly!

Very nice place to eat, food is awesome, but a little bit on the pricey side

The service was exemplary. They were very nice and courteous. We were given plenty of time to decide, it being our first time we were unfamiliar with the menu. The staff made us feel very welcome and not rushed at all. I would give them 10 stars if that was an option. I can't remember the 2 girls names but it was Sunday July 23 around 7:30 maybe.

Great modern day clean atmosphere. Burgers can compare to 5 guys/smashbuger/good times and other knows burger joints. They have great options for the exotic tasters. The location is connected to creamery so you can eat some ice cream after you have a delicious sandwich or burger. Price is very affordable. Burger, fries and a canned soda for $12.

Yummy food, quality ingredients and lovely folks off the beaten path -- definitely worth the few extra miles from the interstate.

They have very good food. A plus for me is they are very close. Prices aren't bad for what you get. Give them a try you won't be sorry.

Excellent food, service and atmosphere. Went for lunch with 3 others on a weekday and had our food made to order within 10 minutes and at our table. Highly recommend this place, great diversity of sandwiches. This place will be on foodtv at some point. A hidden treasure!

Love this place!!! We are regulars. I love the specials and the classics.

Awesome food made from scratch including the ice cream!

Words can not explain the food. The food and staff was amazing. I had the Ruban and it was the best I e ever had.

I had the Mushroom Onion Swiss Burger. It was fantastic! I hesitated because it was not "pretty" to look at, but OMG!! I rarely get a burger and eat more than a few bites but I ate every bite of this. I will be back!!

Lived this place. Very much a little jem.

Food was good. Service was excellent.

Fantastic cheeseburgers, very nice people.

my husband and i LOVE Nicky’s! It’s just around the corner from our house, fast service, ALWAYS friendly, and great taste in music! My husband and i combined have tried almost everything on the menu, and we have no eaten something we wouldn’t eat again. ❤️❤️❤️

I was totally stoked the first time I Entered Nicky’s shack, but bro, you won’t be disappointed! First things first. Just get the tots. Amazing sweet potato tots that I will order. Every. Single. Time. Reuben was phenomenal. Crispy Chickie was perfectly fried and nice and juicy. Mushroom onion Swiss will change your life. I’ve been twice in two days. Send help.