Niyyah Coffee in Fishers - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The only descent Cortado I’ve been able to find in the area.

My family and I came down to Fishers & decided to try this coffee shop! The atmosphere was really cool, we received quick service, and the coffee was so rich & flavorful! If I ever come back to the area, we will definitely be visiting again!

Delicious orange strawberry matcha and beef hot dog! Extra delicious for being halal. Love the seating areas and the atmosphere

Tried the crème brûlée latte. It was really nice. Will be back for more.

I usually try to stop here when I'm in the Indy area and the conversation is always excellent! Hindd and Daija are always great at preparing top-notch coffee while providing great conversation. Definitely recommend the brown sugar shook, and the nearby balcony area is also a hidden gem.

Alhumdulilah! The customer service was amazing! Hindd and Daija Thank You! Great Atmosphere, Great Food, Great Drinks!

This place is GREAT!!! But the staff is even better! Hindd and Deija were so kind and helpful! This is the kind of staff I would want to hire for my own business. They offered me great suggestions and made me a matcha latte with cold foam (and honey) that was absolutely delicious. I don't normally have matcha and this was so good I would not only order it again, I highly recommend it. Can't say enough good things about Niyyah Coffee and this staff. This was also my first time at Hub and Spoke where this coffee shop sits and the place is bright, sunny, modern and QUIET! Super super place. I almost don't want to recommend it to keep it all to myself! :)

I was hesitant to write this review ONLY because I think this place is a true gem and I want to hoard it all for myself :) Niyyah is located super conveniently to walking trails and other shopping and has plenty of great parking. Their coffee and noncoffee menu is super extensive as well as their pastries. Service is excellent - both times I have been the baristas and staff have greeted me with smiling and welcoming faces and are full of suggestions and recommendations. This most recent time I went Hindd and Deija were super helpful and even made me a spring seasonal beverage even though it is summer (the chunky monkey is to die for!!). Overall, it is a great place to meet up with a friend, do some work or read a book and enjoy a delicious beverage and snack!!

Baristas are always friendly and brighten my day when I’m in. Wonderful tasting coffee (and I’m picky!) Their signature lattes are brilliant. Try the Brown Suga Shook Iced with Oat Milk! Best coffee in Fishers

Amazing drinks!! Creative and different! Mya and Rey are amazing barista’s!!

The summer drink menu is amazing!! I especially loved chatting with Rey & Mya! 😀

The team here is so friendly and the space is welcoming and clean. Highly recommend the bumble - buzz buzz it’s so good!

Cannot say enough great things about Niyyah! It is worth the trek for me as I drive about and hour and a half to get coffee (and sometimes a pastry). Their coffee is wonderful without milk or milk alternatives, and I find this marks a great cafe when they do not have to hide their quality behind milk and syrups. Despite this, among the many items I have tried, I believe the Bumble(cinnamon, honey, and cardamom) is my favorite flavored drink they serve. I recommend it as a cortado because it comes in a quaint clear glass mug with beautiful latte art on top. Pictured is their cortado flight, which is three flavored cortados of your choice. For the non-coffee folks there are matcha, chai, fruit smoothie, and sparkling tea options to enjoy. The froot loop iced matcha is certainly something to try, along with their blue bay sparkling tea. On my last visit I met the owner and chatted with him for a while. He was very kind and gracious, and I tried to persuade him to build a location on the west side of Indianapolis, ha. The baristas are kind as well, knowledgable about the menu and making recommendations, and excellent at latte art and making drinks. 10/10 recommend if you are in the Fishers area.

I love going to Niyyah because the drinks are always amazing, the vibes are immaculate, and it’s the perfect place to work or read my book! I especially love when my fave barista, Deija, is there always ready with a smile and easy, friendly conversation!

What an amazing coffee shop. Great atmosphere, incredible coffee and my barista, Hindd, was super friendly and welcoming. Definitely my new favorite place for coffee!!

I love that I found this coffee spot! Always a great experience from the ambience, to the coffee, to the service. Absolutely obsessed with every drink on the menu. The masala chai is just fantastic! Everyone is always so incredibly friendly and always happy to recommend a drink. Hindd and Deija are so great - always love to see them and chat when getting my morning coffee and chai fix.

I absolutely LOVE Niyyah! This is my new favorite coffee spot to go too. The coffee and Chai are delicious! I have to give a HUGE SHOUTOUT to Hindd and Deija! They are always smiling, super friendly and they make the best coffee and teas!

Hinnd and Deija remember my order and make the best drinks.

A lovely shop with 2 very hard working people behind the counter. I liked the place on first impression, and even more after realizing they serve Intelligentsia coffee. I ordered an espresso, sparkling mineral water, a small drip brew coffee and a lemon cookie. It was great.

Highly recommend going to Niyyah! It’s one of my fav go to coffee places in Fishers. 🥰 My two favorite baristas Hindd & Deija are always so efficient, kind, and helpful whenever I come visit the vibrant coffee shop. My drink recommendation to try is the brown suga’ shook! 😋😋🤎

My go to coffee spot now! I work in the Hub and Spoke building so when I found out we were getting a coffee shop last year, I was super excited! I was super excited to find out as well the staff is wonderful! Hindd and Deija took care of me today and it truly is such a nice brain break when I go get my coffee and they’re there. They take the time to chat with me and see how I’m doing when they are getting my things made up and it is such a great time to catch up with them! Highly recommend Niyyah, not just for the amazing coffee and pastries they have, but also the people there and the staff are always so kind!

Love this place! Perfect vibes tucked away from the hustle and bustle. My official neighborhood coffee spot. I walk here almost daily. Deija & Hindd have gotten to know my order — cold brew, straight up! Hits every time.

Really cute coffee shop with modern decor, lots of seating for work/hanging out, and good latte combinations.

Run, don’t walk to try this coffee! Not only is the space really cool and the coffee amazing but the people were so amazing. Deijia and Hindd were the absolute sweetest humans and helped us figure out what to try for our first time in here. I got the iced brown suga shook. And oh my gosh. This is hands down one of the best coffees I’ve had in a long time. I’m very picky about coffee and don’t tend to try new places. But I will definitely be coming back here. I can’t wait to try some of the other coffees that sound amazing as well

Deijia and Hindd were awesome and the drinks were great!

Lavender nitro cold brew with dark chocolate cold foam is a treat for the palate and the soul. Hindd and Deija were amazing and can slay some coffee. Do yourself a favor and stop by. You won’t be disappointed.

Cutest coffee shop I’ve ever been to! The drinks are so tasty and the baristas are so friendly and helpful. A must-try spot!

Easy to tune out the ambiance if you’re not into it with any headphones but also super nice to swim in it. Had their seasonal chocolate banana latte extra hot and it was great. Tina made my drink and Ray took my order. Had really great convo with both of them, can’t wait to see what the new seasonal menu will bring! (No cap I tried their “orange “ chai , their classic chai is just 100 x better imo)

Niyyah Coffee has been our local favorite ever since they opened! Our favorite barista, Tina is such a joy and will be missed!

This coffee shop is the best I’ve been to in a long time. The drinks are great, there’s a good variety that also includes tea, and the espresso is top quality. The atmosphere is also refreshing. It’s a good space to work, meet friends and coworkers, and everything in between. Shoutout to Rey for knowing my & my wife’s order every time we come in!

Some of the best coffee around! It’s super smooth and delicious! Now a part of my morning routine! My barista Rey was super sweet and always had a great recommendation for me!

Excellent service and really good coffee!

Try the Italian soda! I brought my kids. Our barista was very friendly and accommodating.

Welcoming staff, top tier coffee, great atmosphere to study, work, and converse! I’ll be back 💯

Gorgeous coffee shop, very nice employees and amazing coffee 😍☕

Their Masala Chai is the best i've ever had, you definately need to try it. This is also the perfect place to have a meeting or get some work done.

Staff is super kind and friendly. Atmosphere is incredible, very clean and well kept, tons of comfortable and accommodating seating. I love their seasonal drinks, everything is priced appropriately.

Never been big into writing reviews but I’ve had so many good experiences it felt wrong not to tell people. I’m sure the specials will change but if the chunky monkey is available get that! It’s amazing hot or iced. The service is always incredible and they’re open late on Friday’s and saturdays! Perf after dinner spot because it’ll still be open. Also the whole building is really cool. After or while waiting for drink you can walk around and look at art etc

Amazing quality tea and amazing service

Always have a great experience.

I love this cafe spot on 116 west of Allisonville Rd. Creative drinks in a relaxing atmosphere

We LOVE Niyyah Coffee!! Their staff is always so friendly, it's super clean, and everything from their drip coffee to their specialty drinks are great. We are pick up 2-3 times a week since they opened and it's ALWAYS good. This isn't always the case with all coffee shops so you can come here with confidence that your drink will be good :) One of the best in Fishers!

Have only been to this shop twice but will continue to keep coming back. Both drinks I’ve had have been 10/10. Great atmosphere, wide variety on their menu, kind and quick service.

Great place to work on a project for work or school.

Amazing ambiance and an interesting menu with a lot of options for both coffee and non coffee drinkers. The building itself is a great spot to relax and chill or even get your laptop and work. Definitely a place I would recommend

Incredible spot and the bumble is the move! Also props on the salted caramel and chocolate cookie.

Grabbed a quick cappuccino. Staff was nice and cappuccino was great. The atmosphere also exudes positive energy.

Coffee is OK. Specialty Tea quite expensive for 16 Oz. While lots of people are boycotting Starbucks I will still go there for the value.

Nice atmosphere and friendly staff

Great place with excellent ambience! The entire hub and spoke complex is so lovely and artsy. This is our new go to place for coffee. Even the service is so great so as all the coffee options they have. They give free milk for kids and toddlers in there which seemed so considerate and sweet.

Best coffee shop in Indianapolis

Quiet surroundings…good coffee…good service. Thanks!

Great coffee, warm baristas and a fantastic place to study or work! It is VERY quiet, not really a place to hang out with friends but that's part of the allure for me. I find that I can get so much done here!

Such kind employees! Will definitely be back!

This place is so good to work at! They have great coffee, and the staff are super nice. We loved it.

Enjoy their non-coffee options. Kind baristas and love the calm peaceful atmosphere!

This is an amazing coffee shop attached to the share office space. Conveniently located near the trail. Three of us got three different drinks and they did not miss. I personally recommend the Indigo. They also have fresh coffee beans from Intelligentsia Coffee which is nice!

I love this place! Anytime, I am walking the Fishers Nickle Plate Trail I stop by. Also a Great working space for meetings!

Great customer service! Awesome area and the best coffee I’ve tased in Indiana!!! 5 stars all day! Brown sugar shock is the da bomb!!

Truly the best coffee and spot near or around Indy. Proud coffee snob too! I drive 20 minutes for this coffee. I didn’t think they could get any better and then my coffee zarf (sleeve) was for suicide prevention. I love them!

Delicious coffee and a great atmosphere! Wifi very fast, quiet, good for remote work as well.

Great location across from Nickel Plate trail and great service!

We just wanted a cup of good coffee after staying at the Fairfield Inn. It is in a office building. A bit hard to find. Look for black letters up high on the building. Inside, it's a nice large amd serene space and it looks like a indoor playground too. The coffee is really good. Thr staff is so friendly We talked about soccer and where the batista went to school and we just enjoyed being in the shop. The clientele was friendly too. I recommend this sweet spot. Enjoy!

The lattes are delicious and the team is so nice. Love grabbing a latte here and glad to have great coffee places near me.

Beautiful shop with great coffee and atmosphere to chill/study, will definitely be coming more often 🤲

Love the ambient sunny atmosphere and the comfortable chairs.

I loved this place. I will be back

Niyyah is located in a very cool building called The Hub. There is plenty of comfortable seating and you can wander around the building to look at art and use the shared work space. Outdoor seating would be a great addition as well as more food options.

Baristas were amazing and super sweet

I cannot recall having a better tasting cup of coffee. It's s fun and inviting building.

Very nice coffee place in a community center from what I assume. The people were friendly, the coffee was good, the building was cool. Ordered a black Americano which was spot on, a creme brulee latte which was very good, even though a bit too sweet for myself. Son ordered a orange cream matcha drink which he liked as well. Only thing was that it was very quiet as there was no music or anything in the background and it was close to closing.

Friendly and professional staff, a variety of tasty beverages and treats -- even some gluten free! Comfy seating, good Wi-Fi, what else can I ask for?

Favorite coffee shop around! Such a friendly staff and the drinks are amazing❤️

Coffee wasn’t very hot. And the sweetener used was definitely not very good. Fat free milk, not available. Selection of edibles very poor. definitely won’t go here again.

Awesome coffee, the Barista offered an americano since their drip coffee isn’t available on the evening and it was great. She even offered to make me something else if I didn’t like it. Super nice people and delicious coffee!

Absolutely fantastic coffee locally owned coffee shop that I recently came across! Highly recommend to those who enjoy great quality coffee (and various latte drinks), teas and desserts. Quality is immaculate. Customer service is second to none. Large space. Very clean. Definitely returning here

Easily one of the best coffee shops on the north side. Their space is open with plenty of room for people to work or socialize. The baristas are beyond kind and always happy to offer recommendations if you’re unsure of what to get. They have a delicious year-round menu and fun seasonal drink menus as well. They don’t have a lot of savory food options, but they have your typical pastries and cookies. There’s plenty of parking in the lot out front as well. Great coffee shop all around!

Excellent coffee and inviting atmosphere, all staff is so kind and friendly. All drinks are delicious and crafted so well. There is a reason this place has 5 stars ! So glad Niyyah made their way to Fishers!! A must try !

This place is a little oasis of peace and tranquility. The environment is very clean, the cafe itself doesn't have any music to start with so if you want to sit down and focus on a thought while getting caffeinated then this is an ideal place to be. Having a small focus group was very productive. Secondly for a self service resteruant where people prefer little or no tips; the tables and chairs are spotless, the service was quick & food/Coffee was available for pickup within 5-7 minutes. The coffee itself is top of line with very vibrant snacks to pair with, Each person in our group (group of 6) tried different items from the menu and were happy with what they ordered. Overall a very good cafe experience & super recommended. Would be coming back.

I come every morning to get a Brown Sugar Shook, it is delicious. Great owners as well.

Great drinks and friendly service.

This is a great place to get coffee, the atmosphere is amazing, and the menu has some really good options.

Limited food choices. Their focus is on their coffee. The food items they have are pastries with potato or spinach, muffins, cookies. They are delicious food options to complement their several coffee varieties, but only a snack, not a meal or filling. Their coffee flights are a great way to sample several flavors at one visit. Very friendly and welcoming. Worth a visit!

Wow! Fantastic coffee! Cool atmosphere and super friendly staff! We tried the bumble and the Cinnamon roll and OMG! Can’t decide which one is more delicious! Star who? This is the coffee place to go!

Best of the best. Kind, thoughtful ownership, beautifully designed space, great coffee!

Great coffee and nice quiet atmosphere. I came in with my family and we were greeted quickly and the young lady who took our order was one of the nicest people ever. She made my whole family smile with her kindness. The drinks were already great but friendly staff will keep us coming back.

So much warm and calm place where you can have delicious coffee and healthy teas and food.I highly recommend everyone.

Nice place, cozy and friendly staff

"Finding this charming Muslim coffee shop was a delightful surprise. The hot caramel latte with whole milk and brown sugar was a true delight - perfectly balanced and rich in flavor. The cookies were absolutely delicious, adding a sweet touch to the experience. The quiet and calm atmosphere provided a peaceful setting for enjoying a cup of coffee or catching up with friends. The cleanliness of the shop was impeccable, and the staff's friendly and kind demeanor truly made the visit memorable. I look forward to returning to this welcoming gem for more delightful experiences."

The atmosphere is great and the customer service is fantastic. You have to try their masala chai!

First time to this place and it was amazing! The iced chai was delish and the gluten free chocolate chip cookie was 2 for! The girls behind the counter were so sweet and nice. The owner was equally welcoming! Can’t wait to officially move to Fishers and have this be one of my daily spots!

Love this coffee shop! Great atmosphere, great people & great coffee!

This place is amazing. If you haven't been, you need to go. Great specialty drinks and a very friendly staff. Locally owned and Right off the Monon. Try them out.

This place is a god sent! It’s open until 11 pm on Friday and Saturday evenings! This place is great. Please come here to drink coffee, and socialize, or just to come in to get some work done :)

Super cute and great coffee. The owner is one of the nicest ladies ever. I met her at Sherwin williams when she was picking out colors for this shop. The shop is now one of my go to places

So great! Aleena is such a kind and helpful barista! Will be returning!

Enjoyable and quiet atmosphere with quality coffee! Helpful and smart staff, which were friendly and quick to offer suggestions.

Amazing atmosphere! Great coffee! Great people!

Wow, I couldn't find anything to dislike....even if I tried. Tried the Cortado and the pour over, neither disappointed. They were both great. The staff is friendly and respectful. The atmosphere is clean and relaxed. Returning to fishers after years finding this place was a pleasant surprise. Keep up the good work guys

Very calm and relaxed atmosphere, excellent coffee and customer service. Great place to study and get work done