Nutmeg Cookie & Pastry Co. - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I ordered four-dozen cookies for my daughter's baby shower. The baker was fantastic at communicating throughout the entire process. For Covid safety, they has contactless pickup, which I appreciate. Let me tell you. . . the designs were FAR above all possible expectations! Each cookie was individually wrapped. The design was beyond perfect. The cookies were sizeable and oh my, they were delicious too! They stayed soft and were flavored perfectly. Everyone at the shower loved them. I will return for all of my cookie needs because everything was amazing. I really appreciate your attention to detail and for helping make this celebration all that it was. THANK YOU

We ordered the M&M cookies and they were extremely tasty, well packaged, and ready for pickup immediately when we arrived. I’m already ordering my next batch! :)

Got these cookies for Valentine's Day and they were perfect! They looked even better than the picture I sent for inspiration. Nutmeg is super responsive, timely, and friendly. Highly recommend!

We purchased the Paint Your Own cookies for Valentines Day. They were so fun and delicious. Very soft sugar cookies with excellent frosting. Highly recommend!

I purchased a cookie cake for my husband for Veteran's Day. It not only looked amazing with the decorations on it, but it was the best tasting cookie cake my family has ever had. The owner is absolutely talented.

My family LOVES this bakery so much! The owner is so sweet and always blows us away with her gorgeous and delicious cookies! The owner even donated dozens of cookies to a veteran nonprofit I work for!