Oley's Pizza in Fort Wayne - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Probably my favorite pizza... EVER! The deep dish... even just cheese... was amazing! I will have to try some toppings next time. The meat lovers and veggie hand-yossed was great as well!

Pizza falls apart you need a spoon to eat it. And garlic cheese bread is disgusting.

Great deep dish pizza and salad!

This is some of the better Pizza around the Ft Wayne area. Their sandwiches and pasta are very good. Pasta dishes are probably my favorite out of all places. Salvatore has been my favorite Italian place. Oleys pasta has made me rethink that. Lexys has always been my favorite pizza place. Oleys is right there too. I've tried most all and you can never go wrong at Oley's.

Amazing pizza! Delicious garlic knots! Cozy bar! Great staff!

Heard that had great pizza so tried twice 1st time got deep dish veggie add pepperoni didn't like was soggy and watery still got half in my freezer so thinking 🤔 give another try so went got veggie plus pepperoni reg crust cause don't like sausage and got more veggies on veggie pizza and same thing my pizza came in a puddle of liquid they said next time won't be like that might try just reg deluxe minas sausage but at $60 pop idk putting a piece in the to warm up see if takes some away but Pizza Hut on Coventry had best veggie pizza I've had

There's a pokestop here so I frequent this place.

Everything is homemade and amazing.

Great pizza. Quite possibly the best in the Fort Wayne area.

The food is amazing! Any shortcomings this place may have will always be trumped by the excellence of the food! The building is smaller and is hard to get into for dinner most times, which can mean some longer service times. But again, it has never disappointed! Highly recommend!

I hadn’t eaten here in a long time but goodness I’ve been missing out. The service was amazing and the pizza was excellent!

Solid pizza! Crust reminds me of a nice crisp sourdough. Topping plentiful. Will go back for sure!

Cheese bread was perfect, and pizza was very tastie. Delicius. I'm going to come back

Amazing pizza and garlic knots that are the bomb!!! Always very nice and generous with the toppings. These folks are top notch. Thanks for always making a great pizza!

Great place to eat. Excellent service. Warning the sausage rolls are as big as your head. Pizza is really good. Delicious salad dressing and sinful garlic knots. Highly recommend.

Best pizza I seriously ever had

You haven't eaten real pizza till you've had Oley's well worth the price and the servings are out of the world. So much cheese you can literally pull a piece from the back to the ceiling and it won't break you literally have to cut the cheese to have a piece

Great food. Horrible parking. Made several laps, waiting for someone to leave so I could snag their spot. It was frustrating. Thankfully, the pizza was delicious, as usual!

First time coming, and was totally impressed by the friendliness and honesty of the staff. Instead of letting me just place a massive order just to profit, they took time out and explained how many people each size would feed, and walked me through the menu as well. As a crayon eating Marine, that earned my respect and continued support. And as for the pizza, this is the only deep dish pizza this New Yorker will ever eat!!!!!

I've been going to Oley's for over 35 years, and this restaurant lives up to the old expectations! Their deep dish pizza is so massive that unless you have a hearty appetite, it is a meal in and of itself. I highly recommend Oley's pizza - especially if you're a fan of deep dish!

Busy on weekends. Good food. Dining room is a bit cramped

If you love pizza, or want the best pizza in the Fort Wayne area, Oley's Pizza is you place! Oley's Pizza is by far some of the best pizza we have ever had! While their deep dish is very much like Chicago Style, you do not have the Chicago Style wait! Being a small place, we didn't have high expectations for their cocktails. But let me tell you, their cocktails are on point! Their old fashioned was excellent! The burned brown sugar on the orange slice is a really great look, taste, and aroma! The house salad was excellent, and we all enjoyed the house dressing. It is like Italian dressing with some unexpected sweetness! It's a definite must have. Pizza: we had the Oley's deluxe and made some substitutions which was absolutely no problem. Our friend got the Italian beef sub, and it was also phenomenal! They also got the margarita pizza, and as you can see in our pictures they are not shy with the basil! In conclusion, would we drive 2 hours from Detroit for this pizza? YES!! Would we recommend Oley's Pizza? HECK YES You need Oley's Pizza in you life. Do whatever you can to try it!

I ordered the chicken bacon ranch sub. Was so so so so good! I'd eat it weekly if I didn't live an hour away. 😋

Great pizza! Doesn’t disappoint all the time!

Everything about this place is excellent

Perfect, we received phenomenal service no complaints. Had basketball team dinner there. Thanks for accommodating the team at such short notice. Brittany & James Hough

In the mood for pizza, we Googled 'best pizza places Fort Wayne' and ended up here after looking at review ratings. Totally glad we did! Their salad dressing? We bought a bottle to bring home. Their pizza? We tried both the hand tossed & deep dish. Awesome! We are totally going to make this our go to for pizza from here forward.

This is one place we always look foward going too as a family and Normally from my other reviews it's always great but tonight was worst experience I've had service wise and really wasn't that busy as well... took 10-15min for drink order which understandable im not picking at that but by that point we were ready for food as well so we ordered but once the food came the service stopped food was great but waitress was too busy sitting and talking rather than seeing if we needed anything else waited on Refills multiple times than my daughter was trying as for a refil but she was too in a hurry too go back and sit I get it if was busy and also understand the days get long I'm in food myself but we stopped eating cause we were thirsty and kids were getting tired so at this point finally took one of our signals and came over asked if we want food and bixed and said yeah we were trying still eat but at this point yes cause kids are tired and we haven't had drinks she says sorry then another waitress comes and asks if we need drinks they bring our food boxed and drinks and drop bill and never came back so luckily I had cash and took our card out and left exact cash cause at this point I was just upset... mind you we've been coming here for years now and I been going since a kid I can understand if was busy but it wasn't and that's what gets me... we will be going elsewhere for a while unfortunately

Fantastic pizza. All of us in our group got something different and we were all pleased with our decisions. They'll even do a half and half pizza if you want.

Very, very good in all aspects. If you've not been to Oley's, you need to go. It's not fancy but it's fantastic.

Came from Ohio to try this pizza and it did not disappoint!!! Delicious Alfredo pasta too!!!

Absolutely the best pizza in town! Excellent beer and mixed drink choices! A must visit to anyone's list!

I had the Soprano (Italian meat lovers). It was fantastic. Also had a piece of the Italian wedding cake. It was great. Always fast friendly service. I highly recommend Oley's.

Great food, really good drinks.

The double crust is the best pizza anywhere! Curbside delivery makes up for the small parking lot.

Oh MY, MY, MY!!!!!! WE WILL BE BACK!!! The house salad with house dressing was AMAZING!!! The garlic knots are like HEAVEN! We had a small deep dish Deluxe. Neither one of us could eat more than one piece! Reasonably priced and DEEEEEELISH!!!!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Amazing pizza, great people,and wonderful service. This is the only pizza place that friends and family ask to eat at when they come to town and visit. They also make half baked pizzas that you can cook at home. This works well when you have family 600 miles away that beg you to bring their pizza when you visit them

ABSOLUTELY HANDS DOWN THE BEST PIZZA PLACE IN INDIANA !!!

Oleys always delivers the best product for so many years and service is spot on.

The best deep dish pizza! You don’t have to go to Chicago just make a trip to Oley’s!

We do take out. Best pizza in Indiana.

The pizza is UNIQUE and DELICIOUS. We also love the house salad. We’ve eaten in the restaurant and take out several times. This is one of our “special” restaurants. Use the website for takeout orders, they have always been ready on time.

Kayla served us with great confidence and demeanor. We had 2 guest wait there was bar service available while you wait. There is plenty of upscale beers and artistic classic cocktails, psst the Manhattan is amazing. 15 minutes later table was ready. Started with garlic knots generous portion. Then deep dish oohh its 7/8 ‐ 1" . Relaxing but busy Friday night. $42 for 14" pie and worth it..

Been here an hour and no food. Waited 20 minutes for waitregood experience. Not a good experience.

Love Oleys deep dish pizza, and it did not disappoint. We always get a large so we can take some home.

Excellent service and great food. We had a double crust deluxe and it was amazing.

Moved nearby and now frequenting often!! Food everytime is 💯. Sandwiches phenomenal. House salad is 💯. Deep dish sauce and crispy edge crust is 💯. Dine in service is slow but prob just because they're so busy and everyone struggles finding employees nowadays. Cozy neighborhood vibe. Love it here and so happy it's around the corner. 😊

My favorite seep dish around. Love the Soprano!

They have the best deep dish pizza in the area!!!

Got a "pre-bake pizza" the great big one. Instructions were not accurate at all which caused us to have to put way more effort into cooking this thing than necessary. It was for a super bowl party. Once we got it hot in the middle, finally, it was great, instructions are worthless though. And it's a $40+ dollar pizza so it should be right.

Excellent pizza and friendly service.

Better Get You Some Of That Oley's Famous Deep Dish. TOP OF THE LINE!!!!

Great food but pricey!! I remember their large salad being way bigger. Seems like they are skimping out. Now it's the size of their used to be medium size. Also the place is so packed that I had to park out back in the mud just for takeout.

The pizza is great but the tiramisu is amazing

We are from Chicago… and we really enjoyed the hand tossed and deep dish pizza! The crispy crust is what you love and cheese with no shortage of toppings were excellent. Drinks were delicious as well. Our evening in the bar with Karmen was a great Friday night! We will be back!!

The family decided they wanted pizza last night but from somewhere other than our local pizza places, so we ordered from Oleys off of US24, and they were definitely worth it. The pizza and salad were delicious, and the employees were friendly and polite. Will definitely be going back again.

Oley's is a Fort Wayne staple. From the roasted garlic cloves to the double crust deep dish... It's unique and absolutely delicious. There is nothing else like it in town.

Oley's Pizza in Fort Wayne, Indiana, is an absolute gem! The flavors bursting from their pizzas are a delightful symphony for the taste buds. From the perfectly crisp crust to the mouthwatering toppings, each bite is a culinary masterpiece. The friendly staff and cozy ambiance make every visit an enjoyable experience. Oley's Pizza has undoubtedly mastered the art of crafting pizzas that leave you craving more. A must-try for any pizza enthusiast in the Fort Wayne area!

I’m from NWI & it’s been hard finding good food this way but this pizza was the best pizza I had in ft Wayne so far . I also had a brownie it was good a little more choc chips it would’ve been perfect !

Pizza great and so was the salad. Service was great even as they cleaned up to close.

2024-01-12 ... Think of "Cheers" (TV show) combined with great food ... especially the Margareita pizza ... It takes a little longer, but certainly worth the wait ... The staff is warm and welcoming ... You'll really enjoy Oley's Pizza and Pasta ... God Bless You ...

I haven't had many deep dish pizzas before, but this is the only one I would eat again, and gladly. Service was great, multiple waitresses checked in on us. Wine was tasty too and garlic knots fantastic.

When you want the best pizza in town, Oley’s double crust, meat lovers is it! Get some!!!

1st time their. Great service. good food, good pizza. Will for sure eat their again.

We live in Defiance, OH, and were introduced to Oley's by friends. We ate-in and also ordered a large par-baked pizza to-go, which was perfect for the two of us and another couple whom we invited over for a football game.

We ordered delivery, said 45 minutes was a hour and 20 , we live 2 minutes away... Ordered a large meat lovers extra cheese handtossed and breadsticks. The box was dripping in grease... Way to greasy... Breadsticks were good Delivery driver was friendly Not worth the money spent

Our fist time eating here and pizza and breadsticks are great

Still the BEST pizza around fort wayne, in my opinion.

We ordered one large pizza half cheese half pepperoni and another large pizza half ham and mushrooms and half ham and cheese. Both with hand tossed crust. The first pizza the cheese was almost black but the crust was soggy and flimsy. Both half’s were very greasy. The second pizza was also very greasy. Not worth $50.00. Not even close

Awesome marinara sauce!! Everything was great!!

This was my first time going there. The service and the food was fantastic!

Need to work on dine in experience, but the carryout is always well done and it’s some of the best food I have ever had.

Ordered take out for my entire family and we were not disappointed. Everything was delicious and the order was ready and on time. Tried the meatballs for the first time and they were absolutely delicious.

Highly recommend their deep dish pizza and garlic knots. Place is busy especially on fridays but the staff are very friendly and attentive. We will definitely come back!

Going miss this place when my job assignment is over!!

It was my first time there, and I had the best Stromboli ever!

The pizza was delicious. The mozzarella and the vegetables were fresh. The staff was friendly and inviting. The deep dish pizza is the way to go in my opinion. Very thick with tons of mozzarella. Delicious!

Such amazing food and friendly service!! Takes awhile, but the wait is so worth it.

First time visit. Loved the deep dish pizza. Place was busy, glad we arrived early... about 4:30 on a Saturday... was full as we left about 6.

A hidden gem on Fort Wayne's Southwest side. Great food, incredibly friendly service. Will be back here again.

I found out about Oley's pizza way back in the 1980's. A friend suggested it, said, "You'll never believe this pizza". Holy guacamole, was he right! Now, every time I get to this burg a stop at Oley's is required! Not an option, don't care what you're hungry for. I'm a little saddened to see they're down to just two locations, there used to be four and this is one I've never been to. Don't walk through the door too fast, you'll end up on the line making pies. At least you can watch the magic happening while you wait the world's slowest 30 minutes which is how long it takes make a double crust pizza (call ahead!). It is sooooo worth it. Or wait in your car, they'll bring it to you. Wait in the bar and remember not to drink or your pizza will get cold while you sober up. The family room and bar look like they haven't been updated since they opened this location in 1990. All those wafer-thin New York style pizza fans have no idea what they are missing. If you don't need a ruler to measure your pizza's thickness, it's just a frisbee and should be thrown as far as it'll go.

Always good. They are busy just need to plan for wait time.

Only thing I would change is olives not being a whole olive. Other than that this is yummy pizza.

The bottom of pizza was burned.

Great tasting pizza. Will definitely fill you up

Great pizza, excellent service!

Absolutely delicious and top notch staff! Deep dish pizza and garlic knots were great. We will definitely be back. A hidden gem worth the drive.

What it's lacking in atmosphere Oley's makes up for in quality and service. The pizza was amazing. This place is a gem!!

The best pizza and friendliest people!!! Bravo Zulu!!👏👏👏👏

The one on Lake and Coliseum is Excellent also

Door dashed delivery so can't comment on service / atmosphere. First time customer for Oley pizza trying experience and officially saying their single crust deluxe pizza (added banana peppers) has replaced my love for Pizza Kings Royal Feast. Absolutely will purchase again! Yummmy!

Can't go wrong here. Pizza deep dish and bread knots were deliscious. Staff is great.

I recently starting ordering takeout from here, and I’m always extremely pleased with everything I get, and also they never mess up like so many other restaurants do on takeout! My new place to go for Italian…I’m only mad I only just now started going there and should’ve way sooner. Thank you for your awesome food and service!

Got the wrong pizza and it was under cooked

Garlic knots are absolutely delicious! Pizza is really good too but those garlic knots are worth the drive!!

Amazing food, portions are enormous and delicious! I only wish we lived closer, but the food was worth the drive. We will definitely be back!

Went for the first time this week and 10/10 recommend coming here if you’re wanting some good pizza! Their kids pasta with Alfredo was great too!

I had been here before but my husband had not. I expected some things that disappointed me. Our garlic knots were flat which was strange. The pizza came not quickly than expected. We ordered a Chicago style pizza and brought leftovers home. At home we could see that it was one very thick crust but not a Chicago style with sausage and cheese inside and a crust on top of that. Hopefully we will give them another chance on the pizza.

We love Oley's Pizza! Salad with house made dressing was great! Deluxe deep dish without green peppers and add green olives was excellent!

The pizza is awesome!! Our server was good, just not very attentive. We were jammed into a half-booth in the bar room. In their defense they were extremely busy. I suggest you go on a weeknight.