Papa's Pizza - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Food was great. I only give it 3 stars because they were so busy the young man at the counter just couldn't keep up on everything. He was making shakes, taking orders, and delivering orders to the tables. A little more staff up front would been nice.

I love Papa's Pizza sandwiches had the steak sandwich in the honey mustard chicken sandwich their pretzel and a shake since I've been in town and hasn't disappointed. Also the little homie Lincoln front counter provided excellent service!

Great pizza shop. Very tasty food. Excellent shakes.

Pizza, sandwiches, ice cream, good go to for lunch or dinner, also delivers.

Clean facilities, courteous staff

Excellent pizza. Would definitely go back

A welcoming environment with good food. I liked that there was some variety on the menu. My husband and I really enjoyed our meal!

I made a order paid with credit card. The guy on the other end was a little stuck up so I asked for a refund they couldn’t so I just kept with my order and this is how my Pizza showed up.

Will let the phone ring for 2 min and not pick up. Buddy calls and they let him sit on the line for 1 min and they finally picked up. Still won't pick it when I call.

There is a playground, so it is recommended for families with children. There are usually two types of pizza slices, and you can eat them immediately after ordering. Milkshakes can be selected from ice cream available at the store. I had an unusual shake made from huckleberry ice cream and it was very tasty.

Pizza was really good.Nice restaurant and service is good too. Serves ice cream and the dining in option is available.

The pizza was amazing. I had the chicken bacon ranch along with some of the best cheese bread and the best ranch I’ve ever had. The owner is a very warm and amazing guy, met him for the first time on the day I got the pizza. It was priced really fair for being in a small town cheaper the. Anchorage where I’m from, and by far better pizza then anchorage too. -inspector guy

Great pizza, I especially liked their crust. Good service too.

I make a delivery and i try to explain about my order and this people ignore me

Great little pizza shop to relax in while you eat. Relaxed environment and good food and icecream

I came in to seat and eat with my wife and friends my friends ordered nachos it took more than normal but I ordered wings and that took like 45 minutes by the time my wings came to the table my wife and friends had finished their food and the wing were just nasty I couldn’t even eat it horribly service

We love Papa’s Pizza! It’s a must at least once every time we travel to Craig. Absolutely yummy pizza, and friendly staff.

Had a large supreme combo. Very good pizza and friendly service.

Great pizza and always reliable

Great pizza at a reasonable price, good service and a good ice cream cone after lunch. Overall, great experience at Papa's.

Papa's is a regular stop for me on the annual trip to POW. Great pizza, good service, reasonable prices, and a good ice cream cone after lunch.

Pretty good, shared a pizza and wings. Ate here a couple years ago finally tried again, really surprised. Will add back to our lunch stops. Service was great 👍

Wish thay delivered to mile creek subdivision

Nice little mom & pop shop, recommended by locals, so I went.

Very kind to cook us food right before close after a long day outside. Great pep and mushroom. Also liked the combo. Came back for sandwiches. Clean place.

This food was beyond delicious! A GREAT variety of pizza...calzone & more. Loved it! Wish I would've taken some pictures to show on here.

If you are out exploring Prince of Wales during the day (as you should be, since the hiking is great) and get in later, your options for dinner in either Craig or Klawock are limited. As in, after 7 pm at the end of June, the only dine-in place that was open was Papa’s Pizza. But that’s ok. We ended up at Papa’s twice, and both times our experience was about the same. Not the best pizza I’ve ever had, but good enough pizza, and the friendliest, hardest-working staff you could ask for. Be careful how much you load up your pizza – it’s a little thicker crust and we almost had too much on it the first night! You're better off with a few less toppings and a slightly crisper crust.

It's one of 2 pizza places in Craig...we stop in when we go to town to shop...love their crust...

Absolutely delicious. I was up from Alabama on mission trip to Liberty Church when I visited this establishment. All of the food was outstanding! I highly recommend PaPa's!!!

We really enjoyed our lunch here. The food was great and the atmosphere casual and friendly. We were visiting from out of town and had a little sticker shock at the prices everywhere, but this place was quite reasonable.

Best pizza on the island. I drive from Klawock every week for one of their pizzas done just the way I like. They have Izze soda and ice cream too. A treat for the whole family

Awesome service by awesome people.

My favorite pizza place nation wide! Excellent family environment.

Not a happy customer the last time I went to Papa's Pizza my youngest daughter and I got sick after eating their pizza. The pizza dough wasn't fully cooked. We went their cause it was the only pizza place where they offered dine in due to the COVID19. This isn't the first time I received a pizza not fully cooked. Will not be going back. I rather do business with Zat's Pizza in Craig.

I love love love the new papas pizza

Of the 2 pizza places in town papas comes in 3rd

New owners ❤ they have amazing food omg yumm try there chicken stuff bread sticks with ranch

The pizza is delicious! The place is always clean and the bathrooms are clean. I haven’t tried a thing else besides the pizza but who can pass that up?

Great service and great pizza and more

Good food. Always open. Great staff.

Best Pizza ever!!! We ask for extra, extra, extra crispy crust and they can do it without burning it!!! No big globs of sauce and no overpowering herbs to deflect the flavors...it is perfection!!! And the crew is terrific...friendly, funny and efficient. Thanks for our monthly or bi-monthly pizza out!

Went with a group of 30 and the staff was well prepared for us. My wife had the California salad which was fresh and covered with a tasty Gorgonzola cheese dressing. I had a bbq chicken wings which were good. The ice cream selection was very good!

What a great place, kids get to have a nice job and interact with the community. Pizza is okay too

This is a great pizza place for such a small town. They have calzones, sandwiches, ice cream, and milkshakes too. They have pizza by the slice if you're in a hurry. I think they delivery as well, but we've always picked up our orders or dined in. The place is clean and the people are friendly. Yes, it's expensive. Show me something on the island that isn't. We had 2 calzones and small drinks. With a $6 tip it came out to around $35.

Salad and breadsticks are my favorite.

Nice time. Great pizza, friendly staff

They have some good nachos grande.

Best pizza on the Island! Love the crust, and definitely a place I visit every time i return.

Not a great fan of this place over priced.

Fast and friendly! They have Wifi and are a wholesome family environment. Don't forget the Hungry man salad!

I arrived on the ferry and got to town pretty late. Instead of seeking food, I checked in to the motel. First time on the island and didn't know better. When I did get around to food, everything was closed except Papa's and I snuck in under the wire. Even though my pizza was holding up the closing, they did it right and were cheerful about it. They even patiently talked me through directions to find them for pick up. This is the best pizza on POW.

The food was fantastic... great atmosphere... and the wait staff was awesome!

Great Pizza and Friendly workers!!

We have been a regular patron from time to time when ever my dad wants to go there mostly for a sandwich. My dad likes his Bleu New York sandwich and I like the Philly Cheese sandwich. They do make all kinds of pizza to order to go and they always have pizza slices on display for lunch so you don't have to wait for your pizza to arrive and they do door to door delivery in Craig & Klawock area. .

So the last time I went here I wanted a slice of pizza, but alas they were out at that time, so I decided on the Italian Salami Sub. MAN what a great choice!! delicious, fresh and tasty!! Would recommend to anyone who likes salami :))

Pepperoni mushroom pizza is da bomb!!

Went in and had 30 min, I ask the counter gril and she asked her manager if I had time for breadsticks. The manager said yes so I ordered and had to pay up front. 40 minutes went by, I was already late, the check out girl checked and told me it was going to be another 7 min. Then said all she could do was a credit for later. By this time I 10 minutes late and had to go. Long story short they stole my $10 and I get nothing. After I went to the airport one if the airport employees called and had the breadsticks delivered to the plane.

I had to lay over in Craig because of weather. Ordered the lasagna from Papa’s Pizza. Fast friendly and delicious delivery. Thanks papas will order aging.

Decent menu and reasonable prices. Normally quick service. Most of the staff is friendly.

Fun, and good pizza. They have a large selection of pizzas and several flavors of hard ice cream! Small town pizza rules!

Loved this place. We went here during a wrestling trip and the cheese pizza is the. 💣 Come try it.

Awesome sandwiches and wraps. Really fresh. Great value.

Great place -- food really good, staff friendly. Owner in & about checking on things all the time.

Good food. I recommend the taco pizza or chicken and cheese stuffed breadsticks!

Best pizza in Southeast Alaska in my family's opinion! Whenever I go over to Craig from Ketchikan, I always bring back a pizza or two! Way to go Papa!

Love their salads. Hungry man and Greek salad the best. Big and feeling. Love the customer service and WiFi, and watch TV.

I had lunch during a business trip a few months ago. The meal, a sandwich, was so-so. I vowed to return and try something else, like pizza (of all things). Fast-forward to the present day - or shall I say evening. I had dinner at Papa's Pizza amid the cacophony of running, screaming children. I ordered a pepperoni pizza. It came out about 20 minutes later, piping hot. It looked very appetizing with plenty of cheese and pepperoni. I dug in. The toppings tasted as good as they looked. The crust - not so much. This was not fresh pizza dough. To be clear, it was perfectly serviceable. But the pie would have been extraordinary if it had been made with fresh dough. Glad I gave this place a second try. I was right when I said that pizza must be the strong suit here.

I had lunch here one day in October 2016. I ordered a steak and cheese sandwich with a side of apple slices (for redemption purposes). The sandwich was stuffed into a really good bun - fresh and chewy, it was the part of the meal most closely resembling the Philadelphia version. The steak was rolled-up cold roast beef. They did not skimp on the amount of meat, but it made me wonder if their grill was out of service. It made for a dry sandwich. On the other hand, the cheese (American) was perfectly melted. The onions and green peppers were barely cooked. But it tasted good and I was hungry. So I left a happy camper. Pizza is most likely the strong suit here. Next time.

Dining in at Papa's Pizza is a lot like stepping into a sauna to eat, only I have to keep my pants on. It was at least 90°F in there and they refused to leave the door open let alone turn the AC on. I eventually had to box up my pizza and leave because the heat in the building was making me physically ill. Would I go there again? Not for pizza. They do have ice cream cones, which I could probably go for assuming it doesn't melt before I got it out the door...