Piccolino Restaurant in Hagerman - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Excellent place to eat in Hagerman N.M

The food is amazing as is the service. I love their seasoned olive oil with the bread. You have to ask for the oil..

Truly one of the BEST MEALS I have had since eating in Italy!! Chardonnay Shrimp or Chicken is AMAZING. Worth the drive!!!

It's the only place I like to eat cheeseburgers.

Try to call multiple times no one picked up the phone. I called Total of about 10 times

Today April 25,2024 I enjoyed the best sit down Italian meal I've had in ten years. The CHICKEN BOLOCO with their in house bread exceeded my highest expectations. Go see. Your reward is waiting......

All their dishes are amazing & the staff is super friendly!

Good food great service nice place and service 🤗

Quality has really gone down lately and the dish I regularly order seems to be a roulette about whether it will be properly made. I'm over it.

Really awesome people and the food is great. I have been going there for years and the food is so good

Every time we go there the people are so nice and friendly

Anteriormente disfrute del chicken Marsella,y el chicken piccata las recetas deliciosas, ahora deguste de una hamburguesa doble a la parrilla que parecía no podría acabarla!!

That chicken Bolloco or however spelled

Muy rica la comida y la atención de una jovencita

Such amazing food that we had to go twice. Everyone in my large party was extremely happy and full when we left. Family owned. Even the pasta tastes like it was made there. I am looking forward to my next trip through there so I can eat the Bolloco lasagna again. I posted that review 4 years ago. My daughter and I have discussed it was worth going back simply to get the Bolloco Lasagna or Pasta. I recently went back there alone. Called ahead to discuss picking up 8 orders to go and mentioned I planned to freeze them to bring them home on a long drive. They had never done that but completely worked with me on what would work best. Even had it frozen for me on pick up. Fyi: It travels great in a cooler across 3 states. It was heavenly to eat.

Today's service was very slow. If it wasn't for having great company with me this evening I would have left and made dinner at my own house. However, the food tasted good once it was served to me.

The food was absolutely delicious! We enjoyed everything and we will go back.

Pretty great food, decent service. Only one lady was waitressing for the entire restaurant. Not her fault. But needed at least two for the floor.

Tried the chicken marales, OMG this is amazing. Better then any 4 Star we have ever had. The vegetables still crispy, the sauce and mushrooms.

Ordered a stromboli. Received a calzone. The sweet tea there is really good. Waitress was wonderful even though she dumped my husband's drink in his lap. Complete accident. Have only ever seen that really happen on TV. Food is really really good. Felt like we were in a bar. Very loud people in there talking over each other while they were trying to speak louder than the child who was crying. Overall, I've been to this place two times now. Food was great both times. I recommend the stromboli.

Their service was great and they have great affordable food!

I am so upset charge me 76 dollars for 3 burgers and pasta it took 45 minutes. Im sticking to Toby's

Staff was friendly but we ordered 3 🍔 and 1 pasta waited for 45 minutes plus, total bill was $77.00 highway robbery! Never again.

Ordered food over phone. Husband went to pick up to find outthey were out of what i ordered. Called got put on hold and forgot. Finally got someone to answer phone only to order foor told 25 mins been sitting in lounge for 15 minutes. Wont be eating here again.

Very well priced! Got a menu to try other dishes. Pizza was yummy🤤 just what I was craving on a Friday night after work.

What a little treasure this is in Hagerman. Everything was delicious and the fresh bread is amazing. We look forward to going back soon.

Amazing family style Italian food quick and no fuss right off the highway. Staff were super friendly and gave us some fun ideas for our trip to Roswell,NM. 5* Would eat again!!

One of the best small town places to eat. I try to come here every time I work in this town. Never had a bad thing from this place.

Its a very nice, little hometown restaurant. Excellent Italian food and friendly service! The chicken parmesan sandwich was great! Very good quality ingredients and very good flavor. Definitely worth the trip!

Delicious food. Great service. Can't wait to go back!

The food and the service was impeccable. We had the Chicken Chardonnay. Literally melted in our mouths.

Best Italian food in New Mexico! Owners are the best! Every plate they make hits the spot!! Definitely recommend!

The food is AMAZING!!! Waitresses very friendly and on top of stuff! Chicken Mafioso, Spaghetti, pizza, chicken parm, chicken bruschetta (my new favorite 😍) and shrimp Alfredo are ALL AMAZING!

I love it here, great food and amazing staff

Hagermen nm location is awesome Artesia NM location cant cook a pizza

Ok, this is an odd review as we only stopped for coffee and I had a slice of cheesecake. But the menu looked awesome and we spent about an hour talking to the owner Fernando as well as Christina and they were both lovely interesting people.

Always good food. Pizza, salads, hambugers. Friendly staff. Sometimes there's a line so a wait but it's worth it.

Great food and service. Will come again.

Great pizza would recommend to all.

Piccolinos open for dine in. Freshly bake bread and sauce delicious! Shrimp primavera and salad excellent. So happy to be able to dine in.

Great food and awesome service!!!

First ever review about any business.... food here was awesome... Awesome doesn't do it justice and the owner Fernando was polite, professional and great person. Im not from this area but will go out of my way to stop but again. See you soon!!

In 4 years never had a bad cheeseburger, its clean, plenty of room to park.

Great food, great service, great prices!

So much better in dexter. Better service by far. Food was better to. Dexter puccolinos all the way

Very delicious food, definitely worth stopping and eat there

Had a wonderful dinner, food well presented and tasty. Waitstaff were professional and courteous. Wine selection great

We had the Huevos Rancheros and wow were they fantastic. The green chile on top was so good I ordered a side of it. The service was impeccable. My husband forgot his reading glasses and Wanda found a pair for him to borrow. She was awesome. We'll be back for sure.

Amazing food and top notch value. They start you off with amazing dinner roll bread and fresh homemade marinara sauce. I thought it was one of the best pizza's I've ever head. Top notch ingredients. Very friendly staff and fair prices. Would highly recommend if you are in the area. Worth the drive from Roswell or Artesia.

We have enjoyed their selection, dessert is a no brainer Italian wedding cake for myself. Only complaint is the lack of a baked ziti (personal fav).

Chicken Chardenay is wonderful!

I’ll give the Hagerman location a three star only because the workers are nice and the restaurant is clean, but since they opened the one in Artesia this one had dropped in food quality

Best chicken parmesan sandwich ever!

Food and service was great will be going back for sure

Amazing food and great service definitely recommend

This place is truly delicious!! I’m so glad I ate here . I proposed to my fiancé here 2 weeks ago and I’m so glad I did . This service here is amazing . The waitress’s are super helpful and nice . The food is amazing. I love their lasagna, I could eat it all day , every day of the week .

This is one of the best restaurant’s I have ever been to. The food here is amazing and is at a very reasonable price as well. I wish there was more of these kinds of restaurants everywhere. The service was also amazing and the waiters were very friendly. Would definitely come here again!!!!

I love there bread definitely would go back

Great food and service 5 stars. Everyone was so nice we got are food fast and it was delicious. Food was high quality. Definitely suggest to anyone looking for a amazing meal.

Best Italian restaurant in Chaves county :)! The Chicken Poloco (that’s how I ask for it) since the first time I tried it, I fell IN LOVE ! You definitely have to try this plate if your traveling through or just want to try something different!

GREAT EVERYTHING. Wife had Italian. I had the Steak Both amazing. Ordered to go. Ready when I arrived. Served by very nice folks No question about it. I will be a repeat customer

Riquisimo lo que comi amables y buen servicio

Wonderful little out of the way 8talina restaurant! He had pizza and I had chicken parmesan. Yummy!

Great food and the service is very good nice wait staff and very attentive

Joana & Leslie are the BEST servers I’ve ever had, really great food !

Great meal! More than we could eat! Service was outstanding! Didn't catch the young ladies name but she was AWESOME! Highly recommend this place. Well worth the drive & the money (which was very reasonable)!

Very good food and good service.

I had been living in this little 'in the middle of nowhere' town 6 months & never knew they made pizza! We ordered for the first time today & I have to say I was pleasantly surprised! DELICIOUS!!

I came in expecting a simple Sandwich and was blown away by the extra detail and work they put into the meal. Fresh oil for the frys The bread they used for the sandwich The warm mozzarella sauce and garlic bread for the wait And service wow, great job I'll be back

The food is excellent, friendly staff. This honey hole is tucked away in a small town. This is my second visit and I'll be visiting again. Thanks for the excellent service.

Great food, great atmosphere & great Service!!!!

They have very good 3 leeches cake

Good food. In my opinion best in this area so far.

Related to the Artesia restaurant of the same name. Ceasar salad was ok, chicken parmesan was ok, marinara sauce was smooth, no chunks of tomato or onion, pizza was good and service was good. I guess I'm just a little snooty about Italian food.

We decided to get away from the madness in Carlsbad and go to a fantastic restaurant in Hagerman, NM. The food is great; reinforced by the line of people coming in to get take out. The owners are super friendly and checked on our table multiple times while we ate. It was nice to receive such service. If you are looking for a lighthouse in an ocean of desert sand; Piccolino’s is the place for you. 5 stars for awesome food and great service.

They get orders right and their really friendly! Love it.

Stop by here for a surprisingly amazing italian meal on the way to Carlsbad

A hidden gem on the back roads of New Mexico in Hagerman. The food, the service and the secret location make it a sublime experience. Well worth the drive if you're not local

I love the restaurant and the only reason why I didn’t rate 5 stars is I’ve had a few instances where the Alfredo sauce has made both me and my sister vomit, other wise the food is fantastic.

Absolutely fantastic. The alfredo sauce was some of the best I've ever had. The lasagna bolloco is definitely something I want to come back for again.

A little Italian restaurant in a very small town. However the food is full of flavor. Great atmosphere, and very clean.

It has some of the best Italian food I've ever had. Everything is good and the service was excellant.

I like to stop for lunch when I’m in this area. I think the food in this Piccolino’s seems better than the one in Artesia. I usually order a calzone with mushrooms. But this time I tried the Shrimp Bolloloco. It is linguine with a cream sauce and lots of green chilies. The large shrimp were perfectly cooked. This dish is also wonderful with chicken. (I’ve had that several times) Their pizza is also very good.

Every visit to my home town I must have Piccolinos. Wonderful service and food.

I loved their meat lovers pizza

Piccolino offers every kind of Italian food and some of the best pizzas in town. It's unique bread and sauces make it way more special.

Always a treat to go here. Love it!

Fabulous food! Worth the drive 😊

Went to the Hagerman restaurant. The best food for the price. Had the Chicken Mafiosa.

Good food. Good prices. Wish they had beer, buy... This place is off the main highway from Artesia to Ros we all, but it is worth a detour.

We enjoyed the food, was delicious and great service...will definitely drive down to Hagerman to eat again instead of artesia...

May be a small place to dine, but so far one of the best in this area!

Wooow me encanto, la comida, el servicio, el lugar tranquilo para disfrutar una rica comida y una buena platica!👌😘

Good food, cheap, good ole out in the country place to relax!

Eating there at least once a week!

Live the food, service and atmosphere

Very good! I love the Real Meaty Delight pizza.

Simply amazing, great food, great taste, good friendly service. Will be eating again when in the area.

Great food, friendly staff. Worth the drive from Roswell, but get here early for lunch. Fettuccini Alfredo. Yum!

Okay for a small town, but I don't think I'll go back...