Pizza Mania NJ in Garfield - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The best in town without a doubt no questions😀

I paid $20 for a large pizza that was half cheese and half veggies. It was cold my kids and wife didn't eat it. It's really disgusting.

great selection of food, staff is always happy to help.

Recently decided to try out Pizza Mania since I’ve never quite loved the other pizza stops in town (I work in Garfield) and I’m so glad I did! I ordered a large pie to take home (half cheese/half pepperoni) and it was DELICIOUS! The pie was thin and crispy cooked to perfection and the cheese and sauce had a perfect ratio and really great favor. My husband kids loved it too will definitely be ordering again!!!

We were traveling from Texas and found this place on Google with good reviews. We stopped in and ate. The pizza was AMAZING with a very nice staff and excellent prices! I definitely recommend Pizza Mania!

pizza mania is the absolute best..i was one of their 1st customers when they 1st opened..the owner is amazing..staff is always on point..delivery is awesome..their food is out of this world delicious..there isn't anything that i have tried that i did not like..

Just recently moved to NJ and this is a excellent pizzeria with so much variety of food. After living here for a few months this is my go to pizzeria for pretty much anything me or my wife is craving for lunch or dinner. During the day they have an excellent variety of slices on display and everything I have tried is delicious. The takeout picture is of a specialty salad and a penne alla vodka with grilled chicken. Whatever you are craving they cook and even if you are trying to eat healthy they have so many options including delicious wraps and salads and so much more! Calling the restaurant is always easy and efficient, Take out is always on point, delivery is fast (No delivery fee, but always take care of the driver delivering your food) and all staff have been great and friendly thus far.

Fantastic lunch specials. 10 or so daily choices ranging from wraps to salads to pizzas, most priced under $10.

I entered this establishment with my service pet 🐕 within seconds I was greeted aggressively "how can I help you" by this big tall guy behind the counter with his hands crossed in front of his chest and 4 other guys around him. This was very intimidating all looking at me like wolves and my dog and I were sheep. This was really weird and kind of scary. I proceeded to tell them I wanted to order something (obviously) then the leader of the pack says to me we'll bring it outside to you "we can't have dogs in here" I was so upset and confused I turned and walked out. I was also confused because there was no sign displayed in the window stating "No dogs allowed" or Service pets only or no service 🐕‍🦺 pets nothing. This was my first time there and the experience was so awful, awkward and frightening. I didn't bother to tell them he was a service dog due to my anxiety disorder. I just wanted to get out of there. I would never patronize this place.

Great food and customer service!

Long story short I’ve been ordering from Pizza mania for 4 years in a row consistently blown from the quality of food I receive on a weekly basis to much of my surprise I accidentally ordered a wrong pizza which turns out it had a specific ingredient I’m allergic to and when I call asking for a replacement or refund they put me on hold as I waited for 5 minutes the person on the phone said my manger said it’s your fault and not really our problem if you want a other pizza you need to pay it separately. Even though I respectfully explain my allergies to it they said it’s my fault. Even though it’s a big well known pizza store they refuse to help me and they have a very clunky website with a horrible interface.

Best wraps and salads you can get from a pizza restaurant. I have been addicted every since I tried their wraps me and my coworkers order from here almost everyday. The grilled chicken is very tasty and grilled to perfection. Any sandwich wrap or salad they make with it tastes amazing. Also prices are very reasonable.

Very good worker always careful 🧐 ❤️

Chicken Alfredo pizza is the best

Great service !! Employees were so nice and made sure me and my family were taken care of and food was amazing ! Definitely will come back again !

I will most likely never order again. I ordered today garlic knots. I asked for 6. They refused to give me 6 and told me. I can only order 5 I asked them. Why is that because that's all you have? And I was told no. There's 52 in order. I even told them charged me for 5 and charged me for one extra. So I can get 6. They refused to do it. Most likely not ordering again ever.

Pasta is becoming more and more dirty, careless, not fresh ingredients in salad, salad not properly clean. Will not order anymore chicken parmigiana with spaghetti. Needs quality control inside that kitchen. Worst order ever!

Hands down one of the best pizzerias. Their drunken grandma square pizza is the best I’ve had. Their drunken chicken parm over penne is worth every dollar. I always order the same things every place I go… this place is it… its #1.

Are go to pizza place. But don't forget to give it a try to the char-broiled burgers. Great job with sandwiches and pasta. Friendly owner. Great delivery

Buffalo wings are trash and salty everything else is ok

Sadly my kids enjoy the food here but they deliver to Passaic and Garfield but not Paterson.

Great Sicilian pizza, everything looks so appetizing. My first time there.

Wings were not wings they were drum sticks Chicken Marsala pizza was soggy and blah!!!!

My job is close by and we order from there often. Speciality salads are really good. Their breads make the sandwiches better. Pasta dishes are really good too.

My go to pizza place every time I come to Jersey from Miami. Highly recommend.

All I can say is Brooklyn pie baby. Get it you wont be disappointed

Mi lugar preferido para comprar pizza .. y la atencion es buenisima todos son muy amables ✌️✌️✌️

i usually order their wings because they always taste amazing. 10/10

Rude Delivery guy, knocked the door very aggressive, then wanna give attitude because he aint had the full $40 he had 39, i was trying to give the $3 for tips plus the etra dollar of payment he got mad and started getting loud. not first time either last time he was being rude then when i walked away he said something in his language idk what it was, ima be honest i did say something back in my language. so then he walked away saying all lotta stuff. never again rude staff!!

My Kids & I love the Penne Vodka with Chicken! after all the times we've tried the same dish at any other restaurant, it was actually horrible every time & Pizza Mania really makes it the best!!!

Excelente atenciones y buen sabor.

The pizza is good but the prices are a bit wild. Like just for 2 slices it almost 7 and with a drink almost 11. There's a reason why I barely go here and it's due to how expensive the place is

This was my first and last time the pizza was cold and no taste and the capresse salad omg firs the presentation says everything about the place. The tomato was old that said doesn’t go with lettuce is just tomato mozzarella cheese balsamic and basil that’s all plus it suppose to be in small pieces never in the way they serve it. Well it went straight to garbage and pizza only eat 1 slices 😔😔 the garlic rolls no flavor .

Rude delivery drivers. Food is good and I’ve been a loyal customer since they opened. Not the first time I answer the door to get my food and the driver says nothing or makes a rude face the whole time. He was waiting outside less than a minute when I opened the door. I always tip as well no need to be rude.

Best gourmet crazy different and delicious pizza varieties.

The pizza is really good! Customer service is nice. Pizza prices could be better but they're really good regardless.

The food used to be really good but now instead of French fries you get tortilla chips. The prices have gone way up and food seems to be rushed out the door now. You really are paying more for less and in these times that's insane. I won't eat here anymore due to the high cost for nothing.

Love the lasagna and pizza here.

I just wanna say the price on some items are ridiculous I ordered eggplant parm sandwich and coke to drink 14 dollars My friend order chicken parm same price that’s not why I’m pissed they charged almost 6 for beef patty that’s just rip off

Probably the best pizza in the area.

Food is great but parking lot sucks

Wonderful hometown experience ❤️ with people who definitely remember you!!

Was deeply disappointed... used to have the best gluten-free pizza in the area... Recently had some of the worst. Tasted like frozen pizza from the supermarket... also bought a regular plain pizza... Which was partially folded over... must have happened as it was put in the box... sure they noticed it... And just didn't care. Won't go back... very disappointed.

Love this place. Has great food and never disappoints!

Food and service os always great

Decided to get lunch from this restaurant. I ordered the chicken marsala and mussels. When I arrived I parked in the small lot. I walked in and was greeted. The food was ready, and I paid and left. When I dug in, the mussels were delicious! It was seasoned to perfection. I also liked the chicken marsala pasta. I definitely enjoyed it, and it was super affordable.

This is the place I miss the most when I moved out of Garfield. They are the BEST pizza and Italian food place I’ve been to in NJ. Their food delivery service is also amazing, drivers are extremely nice. If you are looking for a pizza place near you, this is it!

Wife liked the meatball parm. I thought the meatballs were bland, as well as not having a lot of substance. Chicken in the chicken parm sandwich was very dry and was cut into pieces. Both sandwiches had nice amounts of cheese, and bread was very good. Sandwiches were also nicely sized.

Great food and decent prices. The genovese focaccia was absolutely gorgeous with fresh and generous ingredients. Love their pizzas also.

Their specialty pizzas are the best! My fav is the Las Vegas, it contains Alfredo sauce, potatoes, cheese, and bacon 🥓. Must try!

Delicious penne vodka, chicken parm., wings and pizza!

I have been ordering from here since I moved into the neighborhood. However their delivery drivers have been rude and I have been charged extra for mistakes that their service team makes. FIX YOUR CUSTOMER SERVICE

i always stop in when in the area making deliveries. i get 2 slices and the fruit flavored san pelegrinos. Great piece of 🍕

Great spot for food in the garfield area. We get food here a few times a week. Never disappointed. Solid food, decent value, and good people.

The owners and workers are A 1, they also greet you and have a smile for each customer, good food. Calzones, eggplant the best, try one or two

Pizza is amazing! They offer a variety of different types of pizzas, salads, sandwiches, etc. Def recommend!

Hey if you want to get riped off and not get what you want come to this place i oreder 2 sandwiches a 7" and one 12" with small fries for $34 UNBELIEVABLE!! 2 rolls $1, pieces of chicken $5, sauce $.50, cheese.75 = $7.25 34-7.25=26.75 profit. I understand the inflation but come on!!! Last time I bought any thing from that scaming joint!

great place, great service, very delicious food

Delicious wing. Ham and corn pizza reminded me of my home country pizza.

Had to make a delivery next door waa treated to good food while I was waiting :D

That was my last order from this place. Screw in my portobello salad. Almost brake my tooth. That super unprofessional and dangerous!!!

The best of the best, love this place

Absolutely love the chicken parm sandwich from you guys, fair prices and great customer service. I try to pick up my order most of the time because I know you guys are really busy, and that's a good thing, but when I get my order delivered every now and then it takes really long. for sure will be back

Every order they always make wrong no matter how many time u repeat the order always is wrong

Hello everyone hope everyone is safe and healthy 1st off. 2ndly I just had ordered the chicken parm dinner with penne and 10 hot wings and meatballs and spaghetti and everything was soo delicious and fresh. My order was ready before the estimated time I was given online. The food was worth every penny and I suggest Pizza Mania to everyone even family that visit. Never have I been disappointed. #1 Pizzeria in Bergen County and Passaic County honestly. Keep up the good job and my tummy thanks you. God bless you and the whole staff of Pizza Mania.

The crinkle cut French Fries were different on my pizza, but good. Clean place

Crinkle cut French fries were different on my pizza

Good quality at reasonable prices,

Had a less then pleasant experience the other night ordering dinner. We ordered online which said it was 50 minutes for delivery. I get a call after 1 hour that my order was never received so they just saw it and were working on it now. It was delivered with a very uncaring “sorry about that”. I asked how long it would be as I had hungry kids waiting for dinner and they said 30. Another entire hour passes and the food finally gets here. No sorry, no anything. They just dropped my food off and left. Things happen, I understand. But they honestly seemed like they couldn’t careless that my family and I waited over 2 hours for food. It’s really sad cause this is a place we frequent often, but it seems the customer doesn’t matter to them.

One two hairs in my food . Had to trash it. One long one and one shorter one. Had to trash it.

The delivery is always very prompt, the food is always hot & fresh and they are GREAT at customizing orders.

Put more polite person taking orders on the phone.

Excelente pizzaria italiana em Garfield, New Jersey. Deliciosa pizza. Oferece cardápio enorme e variado e possui delivery próprio.

Muy rica la pizza, y una gran velocidad de entrega lo recomiendo mucho 👍🏻

My go to spot! Variety of options, and the delivery is always great!

Grandma pie is a must. Great wings. Everything from there is good. Good selection of slices readily available. Gelato is top notch.

Horrible inside, no one asks if they can help u. I just stood there eating thinking people ahead of me were waoting to be taken care of. Not friendly at all. No atmosphere.

Normally their food is great but maybe since it was a Monday nite and not a weekend there was a different cook because everything ordered was rather bland

I order from here pretty often and 8/10 times they’re good but what really made me want to write this review is last night I ordered food. I ordered a quesadilla and a chipotle chicken sandwich and the quesadilla was just a flat wrap sandwich. Wasn’t a real quesadilla the whole thing fell apart as soon as I picked it up. I was so aggravated I just threw it out. Didn’t even get to eat it. Now on to the next issue. My boyfriend goes to bite the sandwich and we both heard a crack and he’s like ummm wth was that. At first he thought he pulled out a huge bone from the sandwhich but when we looked closer it was actually a stale hard penne pasta.. not sure how that got in there but it chipped the front of his tooth..

Never disappoints. One of mine favorite pizzerias in the area.

I give 5 stars where it’s due. Always a good pie— i live close enough to renowned places and still choose pizza mania!

This place was amazing great pizza great everything and for a place called pizza mania it has an amazing selection in food and the best restaurant bathroom I’ve ever seen it smells amazing and they have good soap!

Saw many reviews and good rating, was optimistic. I don't know if there has been a change of owner or staff, but my order was subpar at best. • fries were soggy and clearly frozen not fresh • pizza was undercooked and soggy • overloaded with toppings, haphazardly thrown on there, that not all were fresh The only reason it is not a 1 star is delivery was quick (though order undercooked) and delivery guy was very polite and nice. Will not try again and will not recommend.

Pretty much our go to when we can't decide on anything else. They have a large menu that has something for everyone.

I’m not sure if it might have been a busy night or what the excuse is but I couldn’t even have my kids eat it. They sent another one but this was terrible.

Güzeldi muhammet abiyle tanıştım o dahada iyi oldu..pizzaları lezzetli

Coming from a pregnant girl and a first timer at this place the food is delicious. Well let me rephrase that lol… the salads are delicious!! I ordered a grilled chicken salad no croutons and extra onions, i must say everything was sooooo fresh down to the dressing! Lately I’ve been having some trouble with finding a place that serves fresh salads but this place won me over. And the delivery driver is fast and kind.

Pizza is great but the wings are trash flowered wings they got to go

They improved for sure they have a boss who cares about his bussines

My experience with this place has been good but last time I order some fries from them and it wasn’t even filled up like it’s supposed to. As u can see half of the fries are missing. This has happened multiple times. If you order fries just be prepared to only get half of your order. No disrespect to this place but this has happened so many times that I just had to take a picture and post it.

The pies behind the counter are beautiful works of art!!! And delicious too! Pricy, but well worth it.

Came in from Philadelphia to see my grandson play football so I decided to have a quick bite before the game I can't get pizza like this in Philadelphia best pizza ever

Great food, quick and friendly service!

Im a MAJOR foodie that's eaten all over Jersey and this place is 💥! The pizza is AMAZING! Its the sauce you'll see , not 2 mention their wraps,paninis, etc Staff is wonderful,very pleasant n delivery time ANYWHERE is ALWAYS on time NEVER late

Great sauce and a crispy crust with perfectly cooked toppings. This is some good pizza. Easily top 10 pizza spots in the tri-state.

Good pizza when its freshly made

If I could give pizza mania 10 stars I would. What a life saver they were yesterday and they probably don’t even know. It was my daughters 2nd birthday and we ordered some food from pizza mania, but most food from a Mexican restaurant. Pizza mania like always delivered on time, while the Mexican place left 30 of our guests high and dry after an hour and a half… finally we decided to give up and get a refund. With a house full of hungry guests we called pizza mania back and they delivered 3 trays of food a tray of bread and 2 pizzas in what seemed like 30 minutes !!!! Unbelievable, I can’t thank them enough. They saved the day. The food was so delicious my guests were raving about it, they were so fast and so kind. You truly saved my daughters birthday party.

The pizza is pretty good I recommend it with bacon and sausage.

Excellent selection on specialty pizzas, great sandwiches & food overall. Friendly staff, with very fast service even tho they are mostly always busy. Professional business, I would definitely recommend pizza mania to anyone.

The Popeye pizza is to die for...wow...place always busy...orders going out like crazy.