Pizza Suprema in Land O' Lakes - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Pizza is okay. Not a fan of employees or owners talking politics while I'm eating lunch. Will not go back.

This is my FAVORITE pizza place. I don't know how they make the crust or what they use for ingredients, but I have no problems eating it as I'm allergic to white flour yet I have no problems with their pizza crust. Their pizza is absolutely delicious. My whole family loves them and they are always so welcoming when you enter their store.

I've been coming here for 20 years now and the pizza has always been perfect 👌 Family owned, the staff is always friendly and fun to talk to while my order cooks in the oven. I feel like there's all these new Novelty pizza shops opening up everywhere and in my experience, they're usually overpriced, lack any soul and typically don't last very long before being replaced by some other niche eatery. Pizza Suprema has been here for over 20 years, same small dining room, same great staff, same delicious pizza. I love this place!

Awesome place. The best pizza, period! I've been coming here for over 25 to 30 years now. Original as ever!!!

Frank and Joe were outstanding. I ordered a pizza close to closing time and they stayed open a little later to cook my pizza. I can't say that i've ever had a better pizza in my life. I mean john cena eats here on the regular! Great customer service and great-quality pizza. Bravo!

N.Y. style family owned pizza and casual Italian restaurant. One of the best in Lutz/Land O Lakes area

This place puts out a delicious pizza, the best I have ever had. And I've had a lot of pizza. Also people there are always friendly even when they are crazy busy. LOVE their pizza!

They are AMAZING!! Very good service and excellent delicious food. I had a huge order to take to my large family of 9 and they were very accommodating and gave my son cannolis for his birthday! Highly recommend ‼️‼️‼️

I am using not a big pizza person due to having it alot and we were near the area and my dad decided to take me to this pizza place they have been to before. And omg we got a half cheese half pepperoni pizza with garlic kont and it was the most amazing food I have ever had I'm my life. Like I would fight someone for it. And the garlic knots-mmmmmm. The perfect amount of garlic and butter.

As others have said, the place is mostly designed for takeout with only around 6 tables. It was nice to find a place that actually had Sicilian Slices available since so many places now only offer it as a whole pie. Sicilian pizza was good, but heavier on sauce and lighter on cheese than I prefer. Garlic knots were just ok and would probably say skip them. They needed more time in the oven and were a bit more dense than I prefer. One disappointment was lack of fountain soda. They have one but guessing it doesn't work since they direct you to the cooler to grab a bottle even if dining in. They do offer bottle drinks, but with limited Pepsi products.

Great place to get pizza and best of all great customer service

Love pizza suprema, we've become regulars basically & everytime we go in there, the customer service is awesome. Such a cool environment. I'm from up North so I know a good pizza when I get one. Flordia pizza does not compare. HOWEVER!!!!! This place has the best pizza I've had in the 10 years I've been in flordia! Great work, thank u guys for being so awesome!

I’ve been eating here for years. Great food and a great bunch of guys.

Delicious!! We drove almost an hour to visit after reading other reviews and it did not disappoint!! Pizza was authentic and reminded me of back home in NY. Garlic knots were just okay. Dense and lacking flavor. The dining room had 5 or so tables, so it doesn’t have a restaurant feel if that’s what you’re looking for. But if you’re in the area, or an hour away and are looking for outstanding pizza, this is the place!!

Just went in for the first time today!!! The two gentlemen making my food and cashing out were absolutely awesome!!! Great conversation and great professionalism!!! Oh and this pizza (from an Italian girl review) OUTSTANDING …..soooo good and I ordered the cold caprese sub…..Delish!!!!! Highly recommend and I’ll be back 🙏🏽😊

This is a traditional NY pizza joint. Very good pizza. BUT what puts them over the top is they are truly a small family owned business with customer service that will truly make you feel at home.They aren’t afraid to throw something in your order on the house just to be nice, which is more than I’d ever ask for. They have a touch that is truly missing with most of the big cookie cutter chains that surround this area.

I have been going to this place since I was in my teens. I love their antipasta salad. Their pizzas are great along with their sandwiches.

Pizza crust was burnt. Ate cheese and threw the rest away. Second time over the last 3 years. Will not buy again other times we're good

What a pleasant surprise! This place is a gem. I secretly believe it's a witness protection program front run by some former wise guys. Don't believe come have a look for yourself

Language was marine barracks level

Great pizza Family owned are Always the Best They put their heart into it.

One thing to say they don’t clean their hands been there and have seen the pizza maker go to 7/11 and gotten coffee comes back smoking a sig and go straight to making pizza that’s sad for being in business for so long that should be automatic to wash up just by stepping out and going to another place pizza is good but that not so good

The canolis were fantastic! The pizza was really good.

They have a few tables to dine in. Small restaurant. The pizza was ok. The salads were very good. Probably wouldn't go back.

i’ve been going here with my family for 20 years. the pizza is always amazing and everyone is always so nice.

Great customer service and delicious pizza

Best pizza out here .especially if you from new york city

This is the best pizza in Land O Lakes and Tampa. The white pizza is the best. Our favorite pizza place!

It would be perfect if they don’t burn the pizza.

I love this place! Great pizza and feels like home!

I can’t remember having a better slice. The ingredients, dough, and seasoning were on point.

Love it here truly, prices are great and always friendly faces!

One of the best Pizza in this area!

I love their Pizza 2 pieces and a small drink for $7.00

The best pizza I’ve ever had! We had the Mediterranean and garlic knots. Super small restaurant but really big taste!!

The Best pizza I've had in the whole Tampa area. Frequent customer. Always great service, super friendly and personable. Small, quality family business.

The very definition of a hole in the wall spot that hits way above its weight with the quality of its food. Reminds me of an old school Staten Island pizza shop. The specialty slices as well as the plain punch way above their weight. The personnel are always friendly. Never had a bad experience here.

Discovered this place by accident and SURE am Glad I Did. One of The BEST "REAL" NYC Style Pizza!!! Came back a few days later, with My Family and We Had Excellent Garlic Knots and Several Different Styles of Pizza (Pepperoni, Cheese, Spinach) and the Flavor was Worth The Drive (from Brandon, Florida!!). They Are NOT Open on Mondays and I Found Out the Hard Way 🤣😂🤣, but Tuesday's 2nd Trip There was Well Worth It!!

Pizza is absolutely Suprema!!!!

Great owner, unfortunately the son and his GF are druggies and couldnt care less about the business. The whole staff are degenerates.

Puedes consumir en el lugar, porque tienen las condiciones o comprar para llevarte las excelentes pizzas a tú casa, tú trabajo, etc y compartir con tú gente, estás pizzas son muy buenas, los felicito y te invito a visitarles, gracias

I've been going to Suprema since I moved to Land O'Lakes in 1999. As good a slice as you'll find in NY. The family is from the Bronx and still own the place. Typical NY pizza place with a couple of tables and chairs. Mostly takeout but I still enjoy their 2skice special for a quick lunch.

We just ordered pizza from here and i am not sure what has happeneded to this place. They used to have good pizza but the pizza we had tonight tasted like the dough was made a week ago. Red Baron has 5 stars compared to what we had. Garlic knots were the same. If you want better pizza based on what we spent over $40 on go to Little Cesars! As a follow up we ordered takeout on Haloween and the pizza was fantastic. Not sure what happened last time but this time it was as we remembered

Hands down best local pizza shop. Blows any chain out the water and family business style and ethics is the core.

Always amazing service and pizza!!

Great pizza. Large variety of pizza. Can buy by the slice

The team at Pizza Suprema is incredible, great food - family vibes and great prices! I was introduced by Tony who is a regular at my place of work, who is now a friend! Glad the universe led me here!

Just went in here for the first time and the pizza is amazing! This is our new favorite spot! Very authentically New York pizza!!!

The Best pizza on the area! Very tasty!! Pizza by slide the best

Always a treat, still the best pizza around but cannot get it all the time since they do not currently have delivery drivers that want to work and not on door dash/uber eats. Certianly worth picking up if you live close enough!! Don't forget the homemade garlic knots and excellent Salads, every one of them!

Everything you order is delicious and fresh best pizza around!

True NY style pizza and so delicious! Highly recommend. Love this place

I've gotten pizza here for a long time. It's always great. Today for some reason it was even more delicious than usual. Even the crust was fantastic.

Best pizza, Calzones and subs around here. Always fresh and hot!

Best pizza in the area. Veggie supreme and garlic knots are my staple when I want pizza. Tony was very kind and answered questions I had. Will definitely only come here for pizza.

Authentic & delicious! All made fresh to order and when you pay in cash get yourself some free cannolis. The people working here are entertaining and super cool. Worth the wait !

Joe, Anthony and the crew were amazing!!!!! Best pizza in town! Awesome cannolis, garlic knots, pizza, everything is great here! Will recommend this pizza place all day hands down!

So delicious and amazing service! They are so awesome, and the pizza is to die for!

Delicious pizza, please update your phone number though, it doesn’t work.

Been coming here for 15 years I've traveled a lot and this is still probably the best pizza I've ever had. Never disappoints and thankgoodness because most places around here are pretty disappointing/inconsistent.

amazing pizza & great salad with service to match! thanks for being welcoming to me & my mom <33

Not a better pizza place in the area. Better than Eddie and Sam's. Been going here for years. Whenever I bring their pizza to my Italian grandparents they rave about how amazing it is.

Excellent... Wonderful food.... Solid staff... Treat strangers like family....please support this local business!

Best pizza in the area! This is the real deal if you looking for NY style pie.

Pizza Suprema is always excellent!

Messed up a Stromboli and manager told me off because it wasn't what I ordered.

Have been eating here for years!

First time in I ordered out, pretty great pizza, and awesome garlic knots! With an even better price! Can't beat quality food, fast service, and great prices will be coming back!

I got a Sicilian pizza. It was not what I expected to pay for was stale and as hard as a rock. When I gave the crust to my dog we thought she was chewing on a bone my wife and I started laughing I don’t think my dog expected that either . That was a waste of money.

Great pizza recommend you try it out

I ordered the Philly pizza and lost my mind with flavor and love. This is my new pizza joint! Gentlemen taking my order and at pickup was extremely polite and well mannered. Highly recommend this place!!!

Amazing place great people serving you/ making your food.. Came all the way from saint Petersburg

My FAV in Westley Chapel pizza and family! Thanks again fam 💯

After settling down to eat I found a finger nail in my calamari, the service wasn’t bad just didn’t have it ready by the time I came which in this case is cool why not have a hot pizza pie other than that Great.

Unfamiliar with the area I Google searched local pizza, I've come back here three times this month. Pizza melts in your mouth, and leaves you full and satisfied. And as a guy who normally leaves the crust behind.. you'd be missing out if you did. Best of all it is easy on the wallet. I would recommend it to anyone who wants to grab a slice and get back to work.

We've ordered from Pizza Suprema several times now for pick-up, and the pizza is always consistent. The crust is fluffy enough with a slight crunch, good ratio of sauce and cheese, and they don't skimp on the toppings. You can tell the owner cares about his business and the staff is friendly. This is our pizza spot from now on!

This place rocks! The eggplant and chicken parm are very good, and so are their pizza’s. Nice staff.

All of the guys that work there have a great sense of humor.

Food was good. Messed up the order, but fixed it and made up by discounting food and free drinks. Cannolis were very good.

Their lunch special is a great deal. Yummy pizza and kind service. Had a good time.

Love this place, so friendly and the pizza is perfect every time!

This is a great NY style pizza restaurant. Huge thin slices just like up north. They also offer XL pizzas as well which comes in handy! The staff are all great and had our pizza done within the time promised. This is my go to NY pizza spot in my area.

Second time ordering pizza and it's the best pizza for us. Definitely we will keep coming back. And they are very friendly and nice people.

The nicest people and the best pizza! My dad is from NY and says it's the most authentic he's had down here. The cannoli was delicious!! We will be back!

Really good pizza, even better people. wouldn’t want to give my business to anyone else.

This place is literally the best pizza around nobody can compete. The staff and the cooks are always super friendly go give this place a try you will not be disappointed.

Great pizza place. If you’re looking for good pizza not from a pizza chain store, this is the place. Reasonable prices and very friendly staff.

This place has huge pizzas for cheap and they are really good

The calzone that we got was good, but the outside edge was tough in some areas. Other than that it was delicious.

The staff is friendly, most of the time. When they get in the weeds they can be short with you at checkout. Never outright rude, but I have felt like I was a bother to them during those times. The dining room leaves a lot of room for improvement there are only about 5 tables for dine-in customers and most of the time 2 or 3 are loaded down with overstock items. Not a very inviting look when you walk in the front door. Having said that, the pizza is outstanding! The reseaon we keep coming back.

You know you're going to get real pizza when you see an oven like this one!!

They have the best stromboli around! Great food at reasonable prices

Always awesome food and better service

We’ve been enjoying the pizza here for a long time. The past 2-3 times in the last 2+ months the pizza has been very undercooked. Basically dough, and the fries have been stale and mush. I know they’re understaffed, but we’re still paying good money. I’ll give it a while before we check back and see if things improve.

Food is good and close to NY style. The menu posted online has incorrect prices and was upset to pick up an order of two sides of meatballs to make heros when I got home and the charge was $5 more per order than the online menu states. Would have been way cheaper to just get the hero’s but we had bread so I figured…. Was about $5 per meatball. Was not happy. Update your online prices. 👍🏻

Best pizza in the area, very friendly people and Supreme service.

Anthony is a great young man if I had a son I would like to be him 💙. I am blessed with 2 great daughters and a great wife 💙!

We love this place and the people. Awesome job

Had a large pepperoni and 20 wings with some mozzarella sticks. It’s was pretty legit . Definitely coming back.

Super busy but order was in time. Great pizza for Florida visiting customers