Procolino Pizza in Chestertown - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Great pizza! The place is a lot bigger inside than it looks—we are glad we stopped. The fried mushrooms were fresh made, with light, crispy batter. We had the thick crust pizza with pepperoni and sausage—it was great! My wife couldn’t finish one slice, though. There are plenty of options ready if you’re just looking for a slice or three. Mix and match. There is a beer and wine menu, but we don’t partake. We plan to go back.

Passing through and found this place for lunch. The real deal y’all. Pizza spectacular

Ordered the chicken Alfredo. Just threw right in the trash, not worth The money.

The food was awesome, and there was no skimping on the portions. Nice, quiet Itialian atmosphere. You order your food and then decide where you want to sit, booth or table. When you are done, you take your dishes, scrape off what you didn't want, and put your trash trash to the containers provided. Nice place.

Great for pizza and subs. Friendly service. Good food

Wonderfully deceiving for a strip mall spot..so many choices for whatever you're craving whether its pizza, cheesesteak or Italian favorite dinners

Absolutely the best on the shore...period.

The chicken Alfredo was great. Taste great!!! Owner and staff friendly. Interested if food was good Had more than enough. . Had enough for my evening meal

My pizza has a ton of BBQ chicken on top. No skimping here. Delicious.

Absolutely love Procolino’s! I’ve been going there for years. I moved to Chestertown in 2004 and have eaten there ever since. I moved over an hour away in 2016, but I still come back to Chestertown to see my doctor once a month. Every time I come over for a doctors appointment, I stop in to Procs and get barbecue, chicken, pizza, taco pizza, ziti, pizza, chicken, cheesesteaks, and more to take home to my family for dinner that evening. I could seriously eat broccoli Enos every single day… Headed there right now to get my chicken cheesesteak 🙌🏼

Good good, not very expensive, friendly service

Love every meal from here! The food is great!

Delicious! NY Style! Great Price!

Procolino’s Pizza offers a vast array of pizzas, subs, steak rolls, and more. Feeding the volleyball team, we indulged in their diverse selection, finding each dish delicious and satisfying.

I thought that this place had an amazing cheesesteak, and being from Philly, this is a big win. The only problem was that the pizza crust was kind of hard due to it being reheated. The workers were nice, and our food came out really fast. The place is very big so if you’re looking to host a party here, then you should be good. And it is pretty clean. Overall 4.4/5 stars.

Food was good, very busy place.

This was the best pizza I have ever eaten.

Pizza by a nice family who immigrated years ago. Lots of varieties of pies, and non pizza options. Pizza by the slice is available. Efficient and friendly staff. Good crust. I normally get one of the veggie options and they are delicious. Kids got pepperoni and cheese pizzas which they were happy with. Onion rings and cheese steak subs were also good. Not a fancy place, but they have what you need for a good price for the quality and quantity. A cheerful front dining room where you see the wall of pizza ovens and a back dining room. Very, very good considering Chestertown is below the pizza belt, and on the Shore.

Great fun and food. We had a nice time. The regular pizza was really delicious but the gluten-free pizza was disappointing.

This is the best pizza in Maryland! My favorite is the sausage and mushroom. The sausage is perfectly crumbled and evenly distributed throughout the pizza. My girlfriend and I drive an hour and a half to go here.

Many years been coming here for great food

Love. Staff so friendly & FAST - WOW!!! Delicious. TY.

Procs is a local favorite. You can't go wrong going there! The pizza by the slice is huge.

I ordered (1)Sicilian 3-topping pizza, and(2)Procolino’s Special Sub. Both were tasty. My wife thought the sub was loaded. It was a hefty sandwich, they don’t skimp on meat or toppings… Same with the double-crust Sicilian; I ordered with olives, bacon, and sausage. Hefty, cheesy, loaded with the toppings selected. One slice is a main dish!

I am from Pennsylvania and I had the Honor of Eating at Procolino's Pizza. You Simply WILL LOVE Procolino's. Try it, You Will Not Regret it. Excellent Food and Choices. I Reccomend Cheesesteaks and Any Pizza. Do Not Miss Your Chance to Eat at Procolino's Pizza.

My husband and I were in Chestertown for the Downrigging Festival and ALL THE RESTAURANTS we tried were booked. Then we discovered Procolinos in the shopping center right next to the Comfort Inn. This place was great! It is not fancy. You order and pick up your food at the counter. When we were there Procolino's was crowded with young people dressed for Homecoming. The line moved quickly. The pizza's were all on display, making it easy to choose. I ordered a slice of vegetarian pizza, a Greek salad and a glass of cabernet. My husband ordered a cheese steak and beer. We got our food quickly and it was delicious! The Greek salad had plenty of olives, feta and peppercinos. The slice of pizza I ordered was covered with vegetables and cheese -- they definitely don't skimp on the good ingredients. We sat at a booth in the back. The room was comfortable, but definitely not elegant -- I could see into the closet where cleaning supplies were stored-- but, whatever. I appreciated that the food was served on real plates with real silverware -- not disposable plastic. All the staff members were so friendly and helpful since we didn't know the drill and they had to explain their system. Just a great, hometown place for a quick and delicious meal.

Not impressed with the garlic knots we heard raves about, but the PIZZA! Excellent and worth the trip to go there!

Long time customer for 20 years, still my number choice for getting a slice of pizza in the Delmarva region! Their New York style pizza has an balance of bread cheese and tomato and their garlic are super doughy and tasty. Also a good place to grab a quick slice for when you're on the go!

I love my hometown spot. Customer service is always great. The food is so delicious and flavorful you will not be disappointed!!!

These guys know what they're doing! Good food fast.

Always a winner! Been a go to of mine for over 20 years now.

The food is delicious. The service is excellent. All family members can eat here. When they get busy it still nice and peaceful.

A deluxe cheese steak (fried onions,peppers, mushrooms) was loaded! Bet you couldn't eat the whole thing at one setting! Delicious!!

Love this place, u will tooooo!

This pizza place has been the best in town (and it's not the only in town) since the 80’s. It is invariably the best. Good pizza by the slice. Parking is easy. The staff is friendly, but don't be prepared for making the selection. The line moved along fast. Their menu is diverse but trust me-pizza is why you are here.

Rapidez y buena atención. Recomendado para las prisas. Y que decir la comida es buena.

For MD- this pizza is awesome. Lots of pre- cooked options in the case for grab and go.

Unfortunately the quality has gone down over the last few years. Some pizzas have sauce, but unripe diced tomatoes with zero taste. 2 different types of slices were tasteless. A gluten free pie and a ziti slice had sauce that was watery, anemic and, again, with no regard as to taste. I've been only disappointed in all the times I've been there, especially in the last year at least.

Great, low key, classic Chestertown pizza place.

Great service and food that makes you want to come back time after time.

Best Pizza in 100 miles! I'm not a local but I have been here six times. Each time exceeds my expectations.

Really enjoyed all our pizza, salad, and tiramisu. We had pizza by the slice: pepperoni pizza, veggie pizza, and Caesar salad. The fellas at the counter were really funny and helpful, and the service was fast. Prices are very affordable.

As close to New York pizza you are going to get to the eastern shore. Great family atmosphere.

Best pizza for the area. They serve beer and wine. Full line of food not just pizza.

Always inviting and kind employees and owner. Food is amazing everytime I visit home I have to stop and eat there. Love this restaurant..

Had a wonderful slice of mushroom spinach pizza, hub had pepperoni and friend had Buffalo chicken. One slice is so huge it's all you need to fill up! Staff is friendly, service prompt. Typical pizza joint atmosphere. Have been coming here off and on for 40 years and never disappointed.

Always a great neyork style pizza, they put the love in the food, and it shows!

High quality dough…Low quality cheese…. NY style….. Not even close…. Very friendly staff.

I think it's a wonderful place to eat I try to go when I have the time right after I go to church I go to church at Hope fellowship which is right down the street and a lot of our church members go there after church as well it's very reasonable prices the people that work there or really nice and I'm a big man and I can only eat one and a half pieces of pizza so the pizza is around $5 or slice but most people can't even eat one slice and if you can eat one slice then you're not going to usually get another one down their Philly cheesesteaks are wonderful their chicken cheesesteaks are even better and I just really enjoy going to proccolinos and I think I will continue to go there a lot longer I hope this was a help to your making your decisions and please try them out I don't think you will regret it have a blessed day everyone

Great pizza! I've had the garden vegetable several times, and it never disappoints. I'll definitely be trying more items on the menu. It's been added to one of my top pizza shops.

Ordered a steak sub 😋 super moist and chewy highly recommended with cheese.

You want good pizza, this is the place. Delicious! Will definitely return.

Always fantastic food, great service and good prices!

Pure Italian Men...Know what they're doing

Although it is not a high-end pizza place, it is the kind of place where you are comfortable, food taste good, it is consistent in their menu and flavors, and employees pay attention.

Proc's, is our favorite pizza place.

They make the best ziti! Vincent ur the best

It was really good and the portions were great.

One of my favorite place to eat love there food and never had any problems with my food and every one is nice

Always my favorite stop for lunch in Chestertown!

Best cheesesteaks sub I’ve had in a long time and they didn’t skip out on the meat

Delicious manicotti. Sometimes it gets crowded.

World class pizza establishment. A must visit when in C'town.

Had pizza ,it was really good. Second visit has buffalo chicken philly sub. It was awesome. Highly recommended.

Was in here a few times and each visit was not a disappointment in any manner. Food and service awesome, reception when coming in and the sincere welcome is well remembered.

Their pizza is amazing. The ordering/paying process is a little overwhelming.

Super friendly and absolutely wonderful food! Very large pizza slices and a huge Italian menu

Some of the best pizza I have ever had out side of NYC. The crust was just the right texture, alone with the spices it was top notch. Would definitely recommend it.

Wilted soggy Caesar salad probably left from lunch crowd. Asked for Margherita pizza which is tomato and basil with little or no cheese. Pretty sure I got left over cheese pizza with chopped tomatoes and more cheese added on top. Most of it slid off the pizza into the box in route home. Cant anyone in MD make Italian food! Don't recommend.👎

Very nice employees and good food/service! Love the inside restaurant… and the tiramisu 💜

No waiter, run of the mill pizza place

One of the best pizzas I have ever had. I can not wait to eat there again. We tried cheese pizza. Their sauce is very good.

This place has been around forever and they still taste the same.

As someone from Brooklyn NYC I give the stamp of approval for good pizza

The worst pizza ever! Too greasy...and wilted salad was drenched in too much dressing. (But staff was friendly).

Clean and cheese steaks were very good

Pizza and garlic knots were hard, couldn't eat it at all and it left a bad aftertaste.

I'm from Jersey, their cheese steak was really good. Haven't had their pizza, but I've heard that it's worth trying, maybe next time

The pizza is amazing, so much to choose from & the service is great!

Delicious Italian food. Good for dining in or take out.

I wish I can put more than five stars on this place. I used to live in Maryland and the last time I was in proccolino's it was about 26 years ago. The food still taste so amazing you can't top it anywhere I have been! I took several family members with me that agreed with me of that place being the most Tasty Pizza in the area. The only thing I did not see which I don't know if they still do it but I did not see no one tossing the dough in the air and the first pizza I had gotten that was not cut Sicilian Style which they did a lot 26 years ago if not more. I did go for a second time and ask them to cut it that way and even though they don't do it anymore they still did it for us. Now that's customer service

Great service and pizza. Great folks

Haven’t been here in years but it’s still fantastic. Try the ziti pizza!

$10.20 for 2 slices is a lot but you have to realize that one slice is really 2 “normal” slices. Excellent crust

I'm a Philly transplant. I've had the best and worst pizzas that Philly and the Jersey shore can offer. Nothing beats Procs.

Lovely pizza with great customer service and amazing food My gosh that food is to die for

My favorite pizza in the whole world! Vinny and his team are still serving the best pizza period!

Best pizza in town if I could I would give it more stars. Got a 12in meatlovers fantastic plenty of meat and cheese. pippin hott. 🤤

What can I say? This place is a gem, not so hidden. Great pizza. Fast service.

Good selection. Hot and ready fast.

Absolutely the best pizza & stromboli anywhere. I’ve brought quite a few friends here that have never heard of it or tried it. They all agree! It’ll knock your socks off! Service is always friendly and you just can’t beat their food. Give it a shot! You won’t be disappointed. It’s worth the drive. It’s 40 miles from where I used to live and a 45 minute drive. Only place we go for pizza. Now live out of state, but must make this a stop whenever I visit!

I would give you a 5 for the food. But the orders get mixed up when you are busy. That needs to improve

Just got back from my first visit to Procolino's. I am very impressed. Had a large pizza and it was LARGE. The toppings were ample and it was very filling. The owner and staff were all very friendly and the service was fast. The pizza? Amazing. I will be back.

The food is fantastic and staff is very friendly!

Best pizza anywhere, friendly staff

Everything on the menu is great,with exceptional quick service

Excellent pizza. I’m a pizza guy. This is that GOOD STUFF BABY.

They were slammed busy but I was impressed with how quickly they served us customers. Plus the food is great.

Delicious food, wonderful and friendly staff. Was a welcoming atmosphere to walk into.

I loved the pepperoni pizza, not so much the cheese steak. The wings are breaded but have a good souce. Cheese fries are ok