Prop's Inn - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Good fish fry and sides. Typical bar atmosphere. Overall it was worth the stop. Server was super and attentive.

Food is great, friendly waitress. 😋

This was my first time here, and it didn't disappoint. It was a cool place. I liked the pictures on the wall explaining the history of the place. The food was good and the service was as well. I will definitely visit this place again.

Very nice local tavern. Food is very good and service is excellent as well. More of a bar menu, but the daily specials make up for that. Worth a try to see if your pallet agrees. Very fair prices that add value.

Great food and service, happy bar atmosphere!

A friend and I stopped for wine after pickleball! The service was fast and friendly! We weren't hungry but the food looked good! We will return for food and drink!

The food was amazing. Our waitress was the sweetest little blonde who was so nice. I am non verbal, she took her time to make sure I had what I needed and wanted. The atmosphere will take you back in time . So cool. Very clean. We will be back for sure .

Loved this place. Great food, pleasant and friendly service. Great neighborhood bar. Next time in New Hartford I'll be stopping in again.

Best meatballs and sauce around!

Great interactive staff ~ upbeat & friendly & the food delish!

Haven't been there in over 15 years. Came with my family and had such a wonderful experience. The food was amazing, service top notch and friendly and the price was just right. We will be making this a regular stop for a family bite out.

The fried string beans are so yummy! Their meatball sub has homemade meatballs and they are great as well!

Awesome time with awesome staff and atmosphere.

Great little tavern that's been around since Moses was walking the earth, very nice people to socialize with, food is 👍 prices are awesome 👌

Awesome fish. Best I've had in awhile. Hot and delicious. As good as ever!!

Have gone here a couple of times on a Tuesday night when they have the fresh made pierogis. Always delicious 😋

Best fish fries, pierogi, cheddar broccoli soup and special's!! Incredible food every single time!!

Just a great, friendly"home town" pub.

Excellant customer service and food!!

Love Props!!! Food is always on point!!

THEE BEST DIVE BAR IN AMERICA! Just my opinion...don't let the new floor and new stools fool you...it's still the same old wonderful gin mill! Great drinks, bangin food and the best bartenders on the planet!

This is a great secret place that has been around for years. If you check it out you will see why. We frequent Props almost weekly since we discovered it.

The friendliest bar in the area.

I've been going to Props for so many years. It brings back memories.

Great food home style cooking friendly

Excellent food, service from Erin, and the place was very clean & cozy! We had been wanting to come here for years & finally had the chance & we're so glad we did!

Cold beer and excellent service.

This cozy place is beyond wonderful Have dined here many times and always great. Service is amazing and food is fabulous. Thanks to jane for everything. We will be back Fish fry was delicious

Prop Burger was HUGE! Hubby loves the tater tots! Pulled Pork outstanding. My favorite, along with the coleslaw!

Lady on the phone was very pleasant.

Good food at a local dive bar. Very small but good service and good prices.

Just had a great fish fry for takeout. Very fast service and a very pleasant experience. Will be returning for sure!

Waitress was very funny and polite! The food was delicious, and cooked well. All together great place!

Best cheeseburger and tater tots