Prospect Pizzeria in Oakland Park - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The pizza was so amazing and made us feel like we were back in italy, we can't wait to come back

Great family owned pizza spot! Must try the Nutella pizza!

Outstanding food and service. This place is the real deal - quality ingredients, experienced chef-owner, great environment and friendly service. Give this place a try, you'll be happy you did.

This is a little gem Off Prospect Rd. in Oakland Park. Small place full of flavor and family atmosphere. Pieces always fresh and make sure you get dessert because they are fabulous!

The best pizza in town! Family owned spot with the most welcoming atmosphere ever, I would recommend this spot 100 times over!

Margarita Pizza was fresh and delicious!

Tried a couple of times, it wasn’t bad but certainly not very good and pizza was forgettable. South Florida doesn’t have very many great pizza options unfortunately.

This little place happens to be close to the office and I could not be happier! From the moment you walk in it's comfortable. The pizza is 1st class all the way. One Bite, everyone knows the rules. Excellent crisp crunch on the bottom and the cheese is perfectly balanced over the pie. To top it off they sprinkle parmigiana/regiano when it comes out. All around this is a hidden gem here in Oakland Park. If you like pizza come visit these folks. Portnoy would agree!

Spectacular place I recommend one hundred percent. I love the service, the food is excellent, the prices and the attention are great.

It is a HIDDEN TREASURE!!! It looks mysterious, but delicious!! Unique attention, great food, abundant portions. Really low prices. Don't hesitate to come. It's worth it!!

Went for a pizza. Staff were very friendly. Atmosphere is fine... it's a local pizza place. Clean and comfortable. Pizza is outstanding. Has to be some of the best in the Oakland Park area. Will definitely go back.

I go there every week for my pizza . Love it ! Best pizza around ! The folks there are extremely friendly it really doesn't get any better.

Heard so much about this place Tryed it Friday Was very disappointed. Nothing special about this place. Lg Pepperoni extra chez. Really it's a No for me Just sayn that's ay

This one of my favorite pizza places to go.

I don't understand why there isn't a line around the block! The customer service is amazing,the food was amazing there was no line minimum waiting everything was perfect I love this place I'll see you guys again very soon

Excellent service first class pizza. Great place for take out or dine in. Family owned and operated. We always feel like home here and the family and staff treat us with warmth and professionalism. Definitely a pizzeria worth visiting and supporting.

The pizza here is delicious reminds me of New York pizza. Crust is thin and crispy slices are huge sauce is on point. Staff is super friendly service is fast.

Great food, service, and atmosphere!

I highly recommend you check out Prospect Pizza. The new owners are very welcoming and provide friendly service. The pizzas and sandwiches are delicious and made with top quality ingredients and care. This neighborhood pizza parlor reminds me of local places in NYC!

The food and the service is excellent.Please come by and visit

I placed an order for pick up, they kindly adjusted the kids menu to provide what my daughter wanted to eat. The lady that works there and handed the order was very nice as well as the guys that answered the phone.

We had a group of 70 people travel from NYC to Ft Lauderdale for a soccer tournament. I found this hidden gem! It’s tough to feed 70 people with only a few hours notice but Prospect Pizza came through! The food was amazing! We ordered garlic knots, chicken wings, 10 pizzas, salads and several trays of pasta. The restaurant stayed in touch with order updates and accommodated some additional requests. What an experience! THANK YOU to the entire Prospect pizza team for true Florida hospitality!! Our entire crew of 70 truly loved the food.

The BEST pizza around!! Seriously, stop what you’re doing and order right now!!

In this little corner, you eat very well. The pizzas and pastas are delicious!

My boyfriend and I stumbled across this wonderful little eatery tucked away in a strip shopping center. But don't let its non-prime location fool you. It is a hidden gem! Family owned, the pizza is the best we've found in South Florida. We asked why and one of the family members said it's the quality ingredients. Just thinking about our 12" pie with its savory cheese, light garlic, and crispy and airy crust makes my mouth water! We've eaten there a few times (including ordering their delicious Caesar salad and pasta), and can say that the food and service are consistent. We can't wait to return.

Had a great experience here with great food and amazing service. 10/10

Really good pizza. Light airy dough nice homemade sauce and great cheese for a great price for lunch, full pizza and a soda for $13. Staff were super nice and will definitely be back to try the homemade pasta.

Perfect place to eat and order your pizza! My pizza was delicious, loved it and recommend

Great place for great pizza and pasta! My husband and I really enjoy their food. We live close by and it’s so convenient for either dine in or take out. Oh and their Alfredo sauce is amazing!

Ive ordered from here twice, the service was just OK there's definitely a bit of a language barrier, but also both times I ordered- my pizza was very much undercooked like inedible undercooked. I had to put it in my own oven. And it's just average.

Excellent food and service, authentic flavors and everything very affordable. I CONGRATULATE YOU.

Capriccio d sophia pizza. Incredible.

Excellent pizza, awesome staff too !!!

Ever since I started coming here. Never a miss

My family and I stopped by for a pizza night and I can say that we were impressed with the quality of the pizza. I was born and raised in Italy so when it comes to pizza my standards are pretty high. I really enjoyed the pizza here! Recommended!

A must visit new pizza place in town! Do yourself a favor and get the 16" the smaller one wont stand a chance. This is a place we need to have Dave Portnoy and Barstool Sports to visit.

I just pick up and we've finished our pizza and it was amazing! We've had pizza in Naples, Italy and this came very close to the one we had there!

Never asked for refund , never threatened a bad review as I have txt to proof. 40 minute wait not 10. And burned product. And then received a disrespectful message with defamation. As to what my review was.

We stopped for a slice of pizza last week. The restaurant is cozy and clean. The owners are so friendly and accommodating. We have since returned two more times because the food is delicious. Mostly everything is homemade, from the sauce to the meatballs, sandwich rolls and salad dressing. Needless to say, they now have some faithful customers. The cheesesteaks are the best we have had since moving from Pennsylvania, and we know cheesesteaks!

New owners took over about 4 months ago and wow what an upgrade! It's a great little family-owned restaurant with in-house baked sub rolls, great pizza and great prices!! It is quickly becoming our Friday night spot to meet friends and family. They don't serve any alcohol yet, but you can bring your own. I highly recommend you check it out.

Honestly This Comment I’m About To Make Is Coming From An Italian American From NY Say No More. Prospect Pizzeria In Oakland Park Florida Is The Best Tasting Pizza In The State Of Florida. It Actually Matches The High End Pizzeria’s In The 5 Boro’s & Long Island.

I want to start by saying the service here is some of the best. We were met with warmth and kindness and my family felt so welcomed. We ordered the tomato and avocado bruschetta and WOW was it amazing. Great flavor and the bread (which is homemade in house) was to die for. We also got the pepperoni pie and it was cooked to perfection. The dough and marinara are also made in house. It is some of the best pizza I’ve had. Look no further for great food.

The pizza was delicious! I had the bbq Chicken with added bacon and mushrooms. The amount of toppings was fair and they all tasted fresh. Over all top notch!

Best restaurant ever!!! The pizza is AMAZING. The staff are Awesome. You can feel that the food is making with love!

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Prospect Pizzeria, and let me tell you, it was an absolute delight from start to finish! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warmth and friendliness by the owners, who made me feel like part of the family. The customer service at Prospect Pizzeria is truly top-notch. The owners went above and beyond to ensure that my dining experience was nothing short of perfect. They were attentive, friendly, and genuinely seemed to care about every customer. It's not every day that you encounter such a welcoming atmosphere, and it really added to the overall enjoyment of the meal. Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza! The quality of the food at Prospect Pizzeria is exceptional. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the cheese was gooey and delicious. Each bite was a heavenly combination of flavors that left me craving more. What sets Prospect Pizzeria apart is not just the delicious food but the passion and dedication of the owners to provide an unforgettable dining experience. They take pride in what they do, and it truly shows in every aspect of their restaurant. I can confidently say that Prospect Pizzeria is now at the top of my list for favorite pizza places. If you're looking for a place with mouthwatering pizza, a cozy atmosphere, and owners who genuinely care about their customers, then Prospect Pizzeria is the place to be. I can't wait for my next visit to indulge in more of their delectable offerings and experience that warm hospitality once again!

FYI - THIS IS A NEW OWNER. Opened about 4 months ago. 10/10 for freshest of ingredients that have flavor. The beautiful pizza sauce - not sweet nor does he use marinara, just a simple, flavorful pizza sauce. Big pieces of sausage, again with really good flavor. The Mushrooms - big, fresh, delicious. We've never had better mushrooms. What a delicious surprise. The crust - Oh My Goodness : perfectly cooked, crust crispy and tender. Customer Setvice - made me welcome with no need to hurry. Seems like a good place for kids too. Pablo is the owner and chef and he can he cook!

Consistently the best , every time. Right spot between thin and chewy. Tastey pepperoni and sausage for me.

Best pizza I ever had in South Florida !!

Chicken avocado sandwich was awesome with the fried youca

Great food ,great service ,family owners

The lobster ravioli is to die for!! Great service and food.

First time here and amazing! The ordered the pepperoni pizza and a side of meat balls! The flavor of the sauce was very good, the pizza was very good and not super greasy. I spoke to the owner and had a great conversation very nice people!! As a reviewer, I would give 5 stars for the quality of food and the most important the FLAVOR! Thanks you!

What an amazing hidden jam! Food was out of this world if I am allowed to talk like that about a pizzeria… Chef welcomed us and explained his menu, even found my name there on one of the options! I love the modern feel and smell of this place! Thank you for the awesome prosciutto pleasure pizza, we will order delivery soon!

Exquisite pizzas and pasta ufff how delicious 20 points

Excellent service and very delicious pizzas, the people are very friendly and helpful!!!

Love this place, great service, delicious pizza fair prices. Definitely recommend!

The pizza is VERY DELICIOUS and also the garlic rolls. I made an online order and I went to the Prospect Pizzeria a bit earlier than I scheduled the pickup. The owner was so nice, I finished my order before the schedule time so I didn't need to wait. Very nice, very clean the place. Definitely I will come again. The Pizza is DELICIOUS and so are the garlic rolls. I placed an order online and it arrived before the time I placed the order. The owner, super friendly, finished my order before the scheduled time so I didn't have to wait. The place is very nice and clean. I will definitely come back to this place to eat pizza.

Very nice experience, family own with a home feeling, great service and really good food! Garlic rolls were excellent, they made me something off the menu cause it’s what i felt like having & even tho they did not have it on their menu, they did it for me, and it was fantastic! My friends ordered meat lovers and boy that was good! I will be back for sure & bring even more friends next time.

Best pizza in town! You can tell that all the ingredients they use are fresh. The owners and all the workers there are very sweet and make you feel welcomed. I would recommend this pizzeria to everybody.

Absolute hidden gem! Love this place awesome pizza and amazing staff.

I'm giving 3 stars. The food is great. Not complaining. However, I ordered a $17 stromboli and was given just a 2oz. souffle cup of marinara sauce. The sauce isn't homemade, it's from a can. I think they can be a little more generous on the sauce portion, imo. -chef @ Woodfield cc

Thos place sells Only smalls 16" pizzas. No ideal for large parties

Excellente pizza croûte sauce tomate vraiment un vrai délice comme chez nous au Québec

What can I say? Best Pizza that I’ve had in a while. Family owned and the inside is fixed up very nicely. Friendly staff and plenty of good stuff to order. If ya like some good Itialian food. I highly suggest you go check them out. You won’t be disappointed. 👍👍

I love it, you must try the capricho di Sofía Chill place :)

Today is 10/29/23. Ordered a pizza and appetizer meatballs. Meatballs are awesome. Soft yet firm but with a great taste without overwhelming additions. Love them! Pizza was a Supreme that was obviously made fresh. Very good. And the people inside, who I assume are the owners, were very nice and pleasant. I have no need to go anywhere else. Great job, Prospect Pizza!

As someone who eats pizza regularly- this is gem to find! The food is AMAZING as well as the owners. I would highly recommend for all pizza lovers!

Had the Star pizza and was not disappointed

Star pizza is a winner. Wonderful little spot

We are new to Oakland Park ... this place is close, friendly, affordable AND very good ! Tried it out because of the location ... NOW ... our new pizza place ! YAY !

Perfect local pizzeria 👌. I ordered a classic cheese star which had a dollop of ricotta at the end of a delicious slice of cheese pizza. The restaurant is very cozy inside as well. Thank you!

1st time I visited and we live just blocks away. We ordered a cheese calzone and it was delishes as well as right out of the oven. The garlic rolls were 5 per order large fresh rolls. The best garlic rolls I have ever had! We ordered a Greek salad thinking that the calzone may not be enough for the 2 of us. I was wrong! We have enough left for dinner tomorrow as well and the calzone came with a side of arugula salad too! Service by both the chef and the young woman who waited on me was exceptional! I can't wait to try the fig, bacon, apple, and gorgonzola pizza. Won't be trying any other pizza/sub/Italian place again!

Great Pizza and the Bruschetta was amazing 👏

We came in for their grand opening today. We ordered a pizza and it was absolutely delicious. The owners were very friendly and use high quality ingredients. Check them out Edit: we went again and it looks like they changed their recipe a bit—they now use the pepperoni that curl, which are saltier and dough tasted different. Not consistent with our first visit, unfortunately

I had seen some pizza pictures in a Facebook group and decided I wanted to try this place. I got a large pizza, meatballs, and gnocchi. They were all amazing. Owner and staff were very friendly. I highly recommend you try this place!

The best pizza if you want to enjoy a family atmosphere with a delicious pizza, highly recommended

My New Favorite Pizzeria. Try it, you’ll love it.

I purchase 2 pies 1 cheese and the other was pepperoni, the meat is very good not salty but the cheese is very very salty not good for my family I personally will not be returning.

Really good takeout pizza and garlic rolls. Great little family owned spot. Super friendly staff. Will definately go back and dine in too

Their pizzas are to die for! Excellent service and super friendly staff. We will be coming back for sure.

Lo mejor en pizza y comida!! Delicioso todo

The best pizza and Italian food

Dined here at their grand opening and Chef Pablo is amazing; the Capricho D’ Sophia is my all time favorite and their bread pudding is to die for. Friendly atmosphere and a local family business!!

Great food and such an amazing atmosphere!

This place is a great pizza place. Pizza was delicious and I would highly recommend this place. They also serve sandwiches, pastas, and good appetizers. The price is very fair and when I tried the wings and chicken Alfredo pizza, it was very delicious.

AMAZING!!! They completely turned this location around!!!

Really nice place, family owned, food and service excellent, very friendly, 👏👏👏👏

Update hours to say closed Mondays please. Drove here and y’all are closed.