Russell's Pizza in Wagener - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I get the same thing everytime I show up l. Double cheese burger no mustard. Lettuce ketchup tomato and mayo. But almost every single time they add the mustard. And mustard makes me sick I wonder tossed it out and they gave me a new one. But the other times I just tossed it out and counted as a loss. And even tip them.. I refuses to call them.and tell.them they messed uo because they gave me dirty looks and tried to.make it seem.like I was lieing. Need better people to work there

This is almost the best pizza I've had since I've moved to the South definitely my go-to for pizza living in Sally

Just went here for lunch. Checked the reviews before going, and I'm not sure why a lot of comments were complaining about the pizza being "too greasy". I thought it was very good, id definitely eat here over Pizza hut or Domino's. 10/10

I was quoted 20 minutes, my lady gave them 30 minutes. She arrived and our food wasn't even made, nobody knows what's happen!

The service is great, it's usually a bunch of young kids who are very respectful and pleasant. The food, that's another story. The pizza is always greasy, there is hardly anything on the sandwiches, the wedges barely have anything in them, and the Stromboli are small! When I order a sandwich I want more than bread!! Overpriced for bleh food. If your in Wagener than it's an ok place to eat, but I certainly wouldn't be making a special trip. If you want a sandwich your better off going to the Subway in Circle K.

Paparoni's left Pelion. Figured we would give this place a try. Called in an order for a large pizza "the works". The pizza did not disappoint. Toppings are generous. We will definitely be back for more. The place was clean and the staff consisted of mostly young folks that were very nice and respectful.

The pizza was amazing (it was dripping with grease though). But the thing I want to talk about is the "Philly cheese steak sub". I was splitting one with my aunt but she doesn't like the vegetables, so we asked for them to not be on there. I figured it would be fine since there would still be plenty of meat and cheese.... Or so I thought. There was barely any meat on it at all, it was dry, and they only used half of a slice of provolone for each half of the sub. It's supposed to be filled with sliced juicy beef and mozzarella but I got chunks of dry beef with half a slice of provolone. It was also $8. Also, I forgot to mention, that the Sprite tasted like mildew, the floor needed mopping, the trash can is just a big outdoor one that's sitting inside of a little shack looking thing. I don't even know what to call it but it was covered in the remains of old food. The tables were clean at least

Salads this is what I get here.

Pizza was great, service not so much.

Great pizza omg I can't even start on how good the calzones are. Yum yummy.

The sandwiches at this place are off the chain!

Worst I ever had supposed to have extra cheese couldn't hardly find anything on Supreme ingredients never go back terrible

Sometimes, the best food comes from simple, no frills, hole-in-the-wall, places. We were in town for an event, and asked about good pizza. We were sent here. Thankfully. Great ingredients make great food... this a perfect example. Fluffy, crispy, flavorful crust. Not too thick, not to thin. Just-right amount of Sweet and tangy sauce. Piled on with fresh, real cheese. Covered in quality meats and toppings. Yum. Sort of an odd ordering experience, and simple (but clean) interior.

Small town's secret. Greatest hamburgers too. Cauliflower pizzas Hey! Perfect.

Takes too long to get your food so call ahead! Food was very good. The floor was filthy in the dining room.

Very tasty pizza , good crust and sauce , plenty of toppings ( the works ) The folks working there, courteous , and efficient

I love Russell’s pizza the chicken wedge is great!

I'm originally from NY, and this has been the best pizza I've had since moving to SC

slowest place i’ve been too in my life

Visit frequently to enjoy steak and chicken wedges and garden salad. Wedges are a delicious combination of quality ingredients including homemade pizza dough. Casual relaxed rural atmosphere.

There Calzone is off the chain,I love this place.

This last trip, we had the lasagna and plain chicken wings. We usually get their pepperoni pizza. Wagener SC doesn't have many choices for restaurants, but what they have is great.

Ordered lasagna, it was fresh made as we waited (about 20 Minutes). Very cheesy and tasty. I would like to try a pizza next time and would order the lasagna again. Small place, but we ate inside and a very friendly staff.

Very nice selection of food and very very tasty 😋 Anijah was very nice and friendly and we didn't wait to long...

Calzone is affordable pizza is over priced.

The Russell’s Pizza in Williston is always on point. Pick it up Wagener!

General small town feel in the diner, but holy cow is the pizza good. That felt like classic pizza, make you wanna come back for dinner pizza. We came from Virginia Beach visiting family and stopped on through after Eudora. I wish we could find pizza that good back in Hampton Roads. Russell's in my #1 pick right now.

First time visit. Took my niece's and their friend to eat after ball practice. Pizza was good. Nice little place.

To me, pizza is all about the crust. It needs to be thin and crispy. I tell them to go easy on the Marinara. Tò much, and the pie gets soggy. The same goes for toppings. Easy does it. Russell's appears to be a local franchise. I have been to several of their stores. They are all different from each other in their ability to produce a decent pizza. Most fall short. This one in Wagoner SC. Is worth a try.

You just don't answer the phone saying hello and when ask what's the special for today's for lunch you reply its the same everyday..I dnt call every da

During the day the pizza is very good but at night, not so much. Iris would get 5 stars when she makes the pizza

Staff is awesome and the place is clean and foods great.

Awesome pizza!!! One of the few pizza places we enjoy being from NY it's been hard to find good Pizza well Russell's has never disappointed. Great selection and friendly staff.

We got into town last night and I ordered the Italian Sub. It tasted like the meat was spoiled and stunk so I took it off and tried eating more of the sub but ended up throwing it away. There was barely any meat on it to begin with. I should have went to Subway for a sub.

To begin the service was absolutely excellent it was a overall amazing experience the food was great as well I highly recommend!!!

Remind's me of the pizzas, I had in the 70's.. upstate NY 🙂

Doesn't seem to be that busy when we go there but it takes a long time to get your food...an older gentleman was sitting across from us and he'd been there before us and he got served his food after us...not a lot of food either...he didn't complain or anything. They could be a little faster....but I guess they get a lot of phone orders for pickup.

Local place to get good food like pizza, salad or even a loaded baked potato.

Had the Stromboli Anna my friend had the lasagna, excellent food and fast service, top notch ingredients.

Went in and sat down. Waited for about 20 minutes with no acknowledgements from the 2 people that saw us come in. Finally left and went somewhere else. No wonder they aren't busy.

Friendly staff. Good food for the area.

we was told 7 minute wait 10 minutes ago, 10 minutes go past 5 minute wait, what sense does that make

No need to explain great food great place

Salad had old lettuce and very few condiments-- Horrible deal for the price.

Russell's use to be a good place but the quality has went way down. 4 teens making the food (while eating) in the kitchen. All employees seemed more interested in socializing Service is extremely slow and unprofessional.

Real good pizza you won't be disappointed.

Excellent food and friendly at all locations

I was in Wagener SC today at dinner hour and needed a place to eat. I am glad to stop in at Russell’s pizza. The service was quick and all items were fresh and made to order. I had a pepperoni and sausage Stromboli although it was made like a calzone instead of a Stromboli. It was very tasty and the presentation was nice.

Very friendly and clean. I love trying out little mom and pop places when I go to new towns. I will definitely stop again if I am in town.

Russell's used to be great. When you got a large the works pie you could barely hold the slice. Now it's like they cut back on the sauce, cheese, and toppings. I was very unsatisfied with my pie as was my husband. Guess I will be looking for a new pizza joint!!!!

For a small franchise pizza joint, Russel's does well. The food is a comfort and always hits the spot when you need it. The staff always knows the town and when you visit, it doesn't feel like a business, more like a community hangout.

My daughter loves the large chocolate cookies.

The people are nice the place is clean could be the place to eat tonight

Just visited Russell's with my grandsons after a very long drive. This is the best pizza we've enjoyed in a while, so please support this local business.

Great local pizza joint!! Excellent pizza and service.

Excellent pizza! I love the crisp crust!

Their food is great with great employees and excellent service

The was awesome the did good job getting the food perfect

Great food and super friendly service!

Nice to have this place in a small town. It helps out many people that live rurally. Food and pricing are a 6-7 on my taste scale. Like I said, it's a godsend for a rural small town.

The wait time was really bad but the food was good

Good Ny style pizza and nice family friendly atmosphere

Delicious pizza at a delicious price

Best ingredients. I’ll stop here before going to a bigger chain pizza place.

Prices are good and food is delicious.

Best pizza lasagna and spaghetti in town wonderful service very little wait time very clean Brother Jerry D Goldman Salley South Carolina

Great food fast service.. Great customer service

Really good pizza and well made

Great deals great service and good food

The chicken wedges are wonderful

Stumbled upon this gem on the way to Eudora farms, it was delicious 😋

It was alright except for the biscuits for the biscuits and gravy were burnt.

We stopped in after visiting Eudora Farms, and I am so glad we did! The pizza was delicious, and we had a large crowd full of toddlers and other children. The staff was so friendly and accommodating! We will definitely be back anytime we are in the area!

Great pizza! But their chicken wedges are THE BEST!!!!

Great service,food and atmosphere.

Great pizza, good price! Friendly staff. Just need to be patient. Will visit again.

I live Russell's Pizza! They work hard, make the best Stromboli and cheese sticks! I still call it the Pizza stop!! Prices are the best and food is always hot. Highly recommend this little home town pizza place.

I love this place... the chocolate chip cookies are delicious along with the rest of the food!

Had my daughter's birthday party there. The staff was very accommodating and helped with extra supplies we needed. No reservations needed for my event.

AWESOME AWESOME AWESOME!!!! Very delightful and dedicated crew!

BBQ Wings are awesome and the cauliflower crust pizza is so delicious

Great food, friendly service. Number 1 recommendation would be the wedges.

Great prompt service as usual always a great experience

Food was pretty good, and the staff is really nice. Tried the stromboli and I feel another pit stop coming soon already.

Cheese bread was the best I've had from a pizza place.

Best pizza ever! People are always so friendly service is great

A good way to show off Italian food the stromboli is the best

Great little pizza shop in a small town. Can't beat it especially when the dough is hand tossed! Absolutely zero complaints and will most definitely visit again!

Great little place with pizza that is delicious. The ladies there provide wonderful service. Highly recommended.

One of thw best pizzas around! I recommend ordering "The Works" pizza. 👍

Had not eaten at Russell's in quite some time but placed an order for a medium pepperoni pizza and a large salad. Both were delicious. Our order was ready in 15 minutes as promised and pizza was hot when we arrived home. The salad was fresh and made two meals it was so big. They did not skimp on the pepperoni, the pizza was covered with it.

The food is good & the employees are nice

Good pizza, friendly staff, quick service

Russell's pizza has the best bread sticks ever and you get so much! Their pizza is also pretty amazing. It's one of those hidden gems where the place looks kind of sketchy and old but serves one of a kind taste.

Running late so stopped in for a pizza but saw them serving another customer and his plate looked good. I asked what he was eating and the lady taking my order said it was a chicken wedge. I tried it and it was really good. Now I don’t have to grab a pizza each time I go.

Some of the best pizza you will find anywhere.

Decent pizza but nothing special.

THE BEST PIZZA I EVER ATE, GREAT SERVICE, AWESOME STAFF, KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK!!!

Great Pizza and friendly atmosphere... Majority of the time when we are in Salley and Wagner, we have to have their pizza.... Yummmm

My family and I have eaten here over a dozen times and have never been disappointed. Their pizza is amazing!!