Rustoni's Pizza in Sayreville - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Pizza is very good for New Jersey. Best tasting for that area. Just had meat stromboli IT WAS DELICIOUS

Rustino’s is the best pizza in town! Down from the food to their customer service. In the 3 years I’ve lived in Sayreville and discovered this pizzeria I’ve never ever experienced a bad time with them! The owner and his family are the best! I recommend anyone to come and taste their delicious pizza and lasagna oh and the wings!! Can’t forget their delicious wings omggg let me order my mouth is watering!! Guys don’t walk Runnnn and order yours today!!!!!!! Thanks Rustinos for the yummy food and the amazing service!

The pizza was good tasting, but toppings slid off the crust immediately. But my main complaint is the price. For what it is it isn't worth that high of a price. Our bill for 2 mediums and 1 drink was almost 50 bucks

Friendly town spot. Great customer service and excellent food! 100% recommend.

Ordered online, and they called to confirm address and what I ordered. The mozzarella sticks are fantastic and so are the meatballs. LOVE dipping bread in to the sauce! My delivery driver was very patient and understanding as I am in a new building and the address doesn’t always come up on GPS. Fast delivery to where I am, I will definitely be ordering again!!!

Sweet and mild pizza, buffalo pizza 10:/10

Had a large meatball Parm from them last week It was amazing!..Big tasty meatballs,lots of good sauce and tasty cheese made this a huge delicious sandwich Everything we get from Rustoni is excellent and fresh..Enjoy...

Amazing place. It was clean and had great food. Everyone was super nice and the service was awesome. Definitely coming back!

$7 for a plain slice and a soda... Worth every penny

Best pizzeria in this town. Great food and service!!

Great food, great people. Sweet and sour chicken pizza is unbelievable

The BEST grandma pizza pie around!! Living on the EB/ Milltown border I drive though two towns (EB& South River)& over the bridge into Sayreville past at least a dozen pizza joints. I even bought a Pizza Hut delivery insulated bag just to keep the pizza hot on the long drive back home.It’s worth it! The staff &owner are super nice & friendly (not fake) & know me by name. Then again, I’m the only dork walking in there with a Pizza Hut bag.😂We used to dine in too & the food was always excellent.easy 5 star

Kicked us out for having outside food in a bag that we weren’t touching. Rude staff

Best pizza in sayreville and probably a lot wider. I know during COVID I shut down the dining room to make space for more kitchen. It would be great if they had a dining room

Super friendly staff and the food is always great!

Best pizza around #1 love it don’t change anything please Rustoni’s 👍

Rustoni's is an awesome pizzeria! Their food is delicious! The staff and owners are very involved in the community & extremely friendly! Absolutely LOVE their homemade sweet balsamic dressing!

Great food, friendly staff, fast delivery. Catering options are awesome and the food is always great. Best pizza place in the area!

These guys make great food and for a good price. Very N.Y.C. quality. Sometimes I pick up and sometimes deliver. I'm going on 2 years now and have no complaints. Friendly staff also. Too bad they don't have a better place to sit and eat . Maybe 1 day down the road.

I just wanted to acknowledge Butch and his staff for their generosity in replacing my take out pizza that slid out of my cargo area onto the street, when the hatchback mysteriously opened as I left the parking lot. Butch replaced the pie (free of charge) and his wife gave me a free desert for me and my wife! I've been coming to Rustoni's Pizza since they opened, and their food is always exceptional, and the staff is always courteous and helpful. They are the best in town! Thanks again Butch.

Great food and an extremely nice staff!! Hopefully Umphrey's McGee plays at Starland again so we have a reason to go back!

Visited Rustoni's last night prior to going to a show at Starland. The vodka sauce with caramelized garlic slice was easily one of the best slices I've ever had. The staff and owner were hands down some of the friendliest staff I've had the pleasure of chatting with at a pizza joint. We got to sample some garlic knots, pepperoni bites, and a slice of pizza that I can't even remember what it was but it was AMAZING! The wing sauce sample on the garlic knots was delicious. Look forward to visiting Rustoni's again next time we're in Sayreville. :)

Best pizza around! They're closed on Sundays. Doesn't matter. Still, my number 1 pizza place hands down. I have never been disappointed with any dish I've gotten.

Excellent large pie half sausage half pepperoni great pie cooked perfect I would recommend

Love these guys, that sweet and mild chicken slice is to die for!

Ordered a large pie for delivery. The website said it would take an hour as it was busy. An hour passed and I had not received it, so I called them. They said they were busy and it would go out with the next delivery person. 20 minutes later I got an email that it was going out. It arrived over 20 minutes after that. The delivery guy made a big show of pulling my pizza out of the insulated carrying case and handed me a straight up cold pizza. When I commented that it took an hour and 40 minutes to get my pizza he shrugged and said “We were busy”. I had to heat the pizza up in my own oven to make it edible and it was one of the worst pizzas I ever ate. Threw half of it away. I contacted the store the next day and never received a call or email back. Not a restaurant I will be patronizing again.

I could say a lot of great things about this place. But THE BEST. And I mean the best cheese steak pizza I have ever had in my life.

Great local pizza I have been going there for years

Always a great choice for pizza and Italian take out!

Love there pizza, service and friendly atmosphere, will always be one of my favorites

Rustoni’s is impeding on my weight loss journey, but that’s a personal problem. Vodka pizza, double pepperoni somehow finds its way to our doorstep every weekend. So good, we can’t say no.

Well,I would've taken a photo of my pizza, but I ate it too fast! 😅 Very tasty, and nice crew! Definitely recommend

I am writing this review before I actually eat the food. I just went in to order and the service and attention to detail was amazing. I ordered off the menu and they accommodated what I want. Also, asked before I did how I wanted it: seperate with the red sauce or together with the dish sauce. I tried to tip extra because they were so warm. They wouldn't take it but I left it anyway. They are a real Italian restaurant feed you how you want! Can't wait to eat it!

All pizza in NJ is generally good, but Rustoni’s always delivers with some of the best I have had. I also enjoy the light seasoning on their calamari not too salty. Very on point!

So the food here is usually good, in fact very good. prices fair. when they are busy on weekends the quality of everything suffers. When there is a issue with a order, they seem hesitant (at best) to replace/refund. Requires approval/callbacks,etc.Even for long time customers. Otherwise a good choice.

Started ordering from Rustoni’s, maybe 3 months ago, and I’m convinced that this is the go to spot for pizza. Always fresh, full of flavor, most definitely satisfies the craving. Website is easy to navigate and Rustoni’s offers a 10% discount off of orders placed thru the website. Thanks for your consistency! 🙏🏽 (Traducido por Google) Comencé a ordenar de Rustoni's, tal vez hace 3 meses, y estoy convencido de que este es el lugar ideal para la pizza. Siempre fresco, lleno de sabor, definitivamente satisface el antojo. El sitio web es fácil de navegar y Rustoni ofrece un 10 % de descuento en los pedidos realizados a través del sitio web. ¡Gracias por tu constancia! 🙏🏽

Took a whole hour for them to prepare and deliver my order come on man 😭 (Traducido por Google) Les tomó una hora entera preparar y entregar mi pedido, vamos hombre 😭

Service is great and the staff are very friendly. (Traducido por Google) El servicio es excelente y el personal es muy amable.

Great local spot that has a lot of choices and good food to boot. Visited with my buddy recently for some pizza and it did not disappoint. Would be glad to order from them again when I'm in the area. (Traducido por Google) Gran lugar local que tiene muchas opciones y buena comida para arrancar. Visité a mi amigo recientemente para comer pizza y no me decepcionó. Estaría encantado de pedirles de nuevo cuando esté en la zona.

Nice pep/sausage pie! Really good sauce and crispy wings like I ordered. Didn’t know about the cash discount until after payment. I’ll be back. (Traducido por Google) Buen pastel de pep/salchicha! Muy buena salsa y alas crujientes como pedí. No sabía sobre el descuento en efectivo hasta después del pago. Vuelvo enseguida.

literally the best (Traducido por Google) literalmente el mejor

Don't even think just get food from here. (Traducido por Google) Ni siquiera pienses en conseguir comida de aquí.

Pizza is very good wings are amazing, the delivery time is good, everything about this place is good. This is definitely the number one pizza place in Sayreville. (Traducido por Google) La pizza es muy buena, las alitas son increíbles, el tiempo de entrega es bueno, todo sobre este lugar es bueno. Este es definitivamente el lugar de pizza número uno en Sayreville.

Really good pizza (Traducido por Google) muy buena pizza

Those WINGS!!!!!! The staff at Rustoni's is nice but those wings!!!! I order the wings every time I go. These are the Sweet & Mild wings. They were freshly cooked and hot! They aren't breaded but the skin is crisp an the entire dish is delicious. The pizza there is very good. My wife and I have gone there for years. I have recommended them for years because I believe they are one of the best places in the area. Their wings DOMINATE the local restaurants. Take my word for it and give them a try or suffer through the mediocrity of "Mid" wings from other establishments. Highly recommend. (Traducido por Google) Esas ALAS!!!!!! El personal de Rustoni's es agradable, ¡pero esas alas! Pido las alitas cada vez que voy. Estas son las alitas Sweet & Mild. ¡Estaban recién cocinados y calientes! No están empanados, pero la piel está crujiente y todo el plato es delicioso. La pizza allí es muy buena. Mi esposa y yo hemos ido allí durante años. Los he recomendado durante años porque creo que son uno de los mejores lugares de la zona. Sus alas DOMINAN los restaurantes locales. Confíe en mi palabra y pruébelos o sufra la mediocridad de las alas "medianas" de otros establecimientos. Altamente recomendado.

We order rustonis’s probably once a week, never ever disappointed us. Delivery is always speedy & customer service is great. Best food around!!! (Traducido por Google) Pedimos rustonis probablemente una vez a la semana, nunca nos decepcionó. La entrega siempre es rápida y el servicio al cliente es excelente. La mejor comida alrededor!!!

I've ordered from Rustons since the day they opened. The owner, his wife and staff are wonderful. I've dine in, take out and delivery. The food is great. The chicken used is quality food, as I'm a chicken connosour. I've never had a delivery issue with my food. The owner knows me when I come in. We've sent thank you letters to the owners to let them know we enjoyed their food. They have a small parking lot. (Traducido por Google) He ordenado de Rustons desde el día que abrieron. El dueño, su esposa y el personal son maravillosos. He cenado en casa, para llevar y a domicilio. La comida es genial. El pollo utilizado es comida de calidad, ya que soy un conocedor de pollo. Nunca he tenido un problema de entrega con mi comida. El propietario me conoce cuando entro. Hemos enviado cartas de agradecimiento a los propietarios para hacerles saber que disfrutamos de su comida. Tienen un pequeño estacionamiento.

Small counter to eat, no tables. Very good pizza. Girl behind counter was very nice. Brought us our food. (Traducido por Google) Pequeño mostrador para comer, sin mesas. muy buenas pizzas La chica detrás del mostrador fue muy agradable. Nos trajo nuestra comida.

Incredibly kind and considerate staff. Always top quality product. Easily the best in town, probably the state. Come through at least once or twice a week (Traducido por Google) Personal increíblemente amable y considerado. Siempre producto de primera calidad. Fácilmente el mejor de la ciudad, probablemente del estado. Ven al menos una o dos veces por semana.

The food here is always freshly made, and delicious. The best Pizzeria in the area. Their specialty pizza has always been amazing, either as a pie or slices from the case. The Eggplant Parm/Rollatini is amazing. The staff is always helpful and friendly as well! (Traducido por Google) La comida aquí siempre está recién hecha y es deliciosa. La mejor pizzería de la zona. Su pizza especial siempre ha sido increíble, ya sea como pastel o rebanadas de la caja. El Berenjena Parm/Rollatini es increíble. ¡El personal siempre es servicial y amable también!

Very good 👍 👏 (Traducido por Google) Muy bueno 👍 👏

This is the worst calzone I have ever had I am really surprised because usually food from Rustinos is pretty decent. The ham is lunch meat, the ricotta cheese is pretty awful its like cheese and water, and the mozzarella is barely there. When I cut it in half wet sloppy cheesy water oozed out, whoever was working in the kitchen today should be fired. Reply to Rustinos owner ... you may make a quality calzone some of the time that certainly wasn't the case this time and what did you do for me nothing. A little song and dance here about how quality of your food is in a link to a video. why don't you offer me a free calzone that's better than the one I had? I think that's what I would do if I was the business owner. (Traducido por Google) Este es el peor calzone que he probado. Estoy realmente sorprendido porque, por lo general, la comida de Rustinos es bastante decente. El jamón es carne de almuerzo, el queso ricotta es bastante horrible, es como queso y agua, y la mozzarella apenas está allí. Cuando lo corté por la mitad, salía agua con queso, y quienquiera que estuviera trabajando en la cocina hoy debería ser despedido. Responder al propietario de Rustinos ... puede que hagas un calzone de calidad algunas veces que ciertamente no fue el caso esta vez y qué hiciste por mí nada. Una pequeña canción y baile aquí sobre la calidad de su comida en un enlace a un video. ¿Por qué no me ofreces un calzone gratis mejor que el que tenía? Creo que eso es lo que haría si fuera el dueño del negocio.

Best pizzeria and the best food I ever had! Their food is delicious and the owners are amazing! (Traducido por Google) ¡La mejor pizzería y la mejor comida que he probado! ¡Su comida es deliciosa y los propietarios son increíbles!

Highly recommend their wings! All flavors are delicious. The wraps are also very good. And of course pizza is deliciojs. The pasta dishes are a little disappointing. Everyone is always so friendly. (Traducido por Google) Recomiendo encarecidamente sus alas! Todos los sabores son deliciosos. Los wraps también son muy buenos. Y, por supuesto, la pizza es deliciosa. Los platos de pasta son un poco decepcionantes. Todo el mundo es siempre tan amable.

Good spot in sayreville (Traducido por Google) Buen lugar en sayreville

No inside dining since covid , boo ! (Traducido por Google) No hay comedor interior desde covid, ¡buu!

Disappointed. Lunch special is a different price on the menu online. Never paying $13 for 4 pieces of ravioli again. (Traducido por Google) Decepcionado. El almuerzo especial tiene un precio diferente en el menú en línea. No volver a pagar $13 por 4 piezas de ravioli.

Great meatball sub. Nice container. (Traducido por Google) Gran sub de albóndigas. Bonito contenedor.

scammers will never buy anything from you again!!! I paid online when I came for pizza, you said that the payment is not made, you ordered to pay in cash. You took money from my card and also cash. no more burying in all the pizzerias !!! (Traducido por Google) ¡Los estafadores nunca más te comprarán nada! Pagué en línea cuando vine por pizza, usted dijo que el pago no se realiza, usted ordenó pagar en efectivo. Tomaste dinero de mi tarjeta y también efectivo. no mas enterrar en todas las pizzerias!!!

Tried to order from there and they wouldn't deliver to my address even though it's in the same town.... Not cool... (Traducido por Google) Intenté ordenar desde allí y no me enviaron a mi dirección a pesar de que está en la misma ciudad.... No es genial...

I was at work and I drive all day and stumbled upon this golden nugget, the pizza is the truth, and the homemade sauce OMG!!!! I have had the pleasure to taste it on the pizza with chicken my taste buds whent out of control so I went back into the store and brought a couple of bottles of the sauce I wish they would get the sauce into stores so everyone can have this great experience I live 47 min away from them so I will take the drive to vist or maybe I they can deliver the sauce to me I'll pay the delivery fee for the sauce I can't wait to be back in the area to try the rest of the food if they can make a great sauce I'm all in and well worth the time. And I want to thank the young lady who observed my interest in the sauce on the pizza she was very informative on what it was and thanks for the suggested sell they have a winner on their team. Definitely will be back, see you soon. (Traducido por Google) Estaba en el trabajo y conduje todo el día y me topé con esta pepita de oro, la pizza es la verdad, y la salsa casera ¡Dios mío! Tuve el placer de probarlo en la pizza con pollo, mis papilas gustativas estaban fuera de control, así que volví a la tienda y traje un par de botellas de la salsa. Me gustaría que llevaran la salsa a las tiendas para que todos puedan tenerla. Gran experiencia. Vivo a 47 minutos de ellos, así que conduciré para visitar o tal vez ellos puedan entregarme la salsa. Pagaré la tarifa de entrega de la salsa. No puedo esperar a volver a la zona para probar. el resto de la comida si pueden hacer una gran salsa, estoy de acuerdo y vale la pena el tiempo. Y quiero agradecer a la joven que observó mi interés en la salsa de la pizza, fue muy informativa sobre lo que era y gracias por la venta sugerida, tienen un ganador en su equipo. Definitivamente regresaré, nos vemos pronto.

I would give 6 stars if I could! Best food in town!! (Traducido por Google) ¡Le daría 6 estrellas si pudiera! La mejor comida de la ciudad!!

Must try 16" thin crust pie with fresh garlic, fresh jalapeno and onions. It was awesomely delicious. (Traducido por Google) Debe probar el pastel de masa delgada de 16 "con ajo fresco, jalapeño fresco y cebolla. Fue increíblemente delicioso.

I’ve been ordering from here for about 3 years now . They are always so friendly , helpful & food is always great . Happy to be a customer (Traducido por Google) He estado ordenando desde aquí durante unos 3 años. Siempre son muy amables, serviciales y la comida siempre es excelente. Feliz de ser un cliente

Good (Traducido por Google) Bien

Everything is always good!!! (Traducido por Google) Todo siempre es bueno!!!

Best pizza I've ever had (Traducido por Google) La mejor pizza que he probado

Great pizza, always order my pizza here! (Traducido por Google) Gran pizza, ¡siempre pide mi pizza aquí!

Great pizza, great service and staff. (Traducido por Google) Gran pizza, gran servicio y personal.

not gonna lie, after i asked for marinara sauce and blue cheddar, i was a bit disappointed when i heard that it couldn't be delievered to me. Their sauces are amazing but their delivery radius is too small. I have my food ready and everything, movie on, but with no sauce! free my number1 delviery boy DP (Traducido por Google) No voy a mentir, después de pedir salsa marinara y queso cheddar azul, me decepcionó un poco cuando escuché que no me lo podían entregar. Sus salsas son increíbles pero su radio de entrega es demasiado pequeño. ¡Tengo mi comida lista y todo, película encendida, pero sin salsa! gratis mi número 1 delviery chico dp

Pricey but worth every penny. If I had known about the 10% of for ordering online, I probably would have. Then it would have been just barely below $20 for a large pie with toppings only on one half. Either way, still worth it. (Traducido por Google) Caro pero vale cada centavo. Si hubiera sabido sobre el 10% de para ordenar en línea, probablemente lo habría hecho. Entonces habría sido apenas menos de $ 20 por un pastel grande con coberturas solo en la mitad. De cualquier manera, todavía vale la pena.

Food is always amazing and they’re beyond nice to their customers! Highly recommend (Traducido por Google) ¡La comida siempre es increíble y son más que amables con sus clientes! Altamente recomendado

Friendly staff, and good food (Traducido por Google) Personal amable y buena comida.

Pizza was good, staff friendly, nobody was wearing masks if you’re concerned about that kind of thing (Traducido por Google) La pizza era buena, el personal era amable, nadie usaba máscaras si te preocupa ese tipo de cosas

Great pizza (Traducido por Google) gran pizza

Chicken tenders and fries and pizza is amazing from them I order three times a week ✔️😎 (Traducido por Google) Las tiras de pollo y las papas fritas y la pizza son increíbles de ellos. Ordeno tres veces a la semana ✔️😎

food was great, had great service from the owner and his children! will be back in the future (Traducido por Google) la comida era genial, tenía un gran servicio del propietario y sus hijos. volveré en el futuro

Hands down my favorite pizzeria! Food is always fresh, consistent and most importantly delicious! Family owned business and always greeted with a smile. The sweet and mild wings are insane! Haven't stopped dreaming about them ever since!!! (Traducido por Google) Sin duda mi pizzería favorita! ¡La comida siempre es fresca, consistente y lo más importante, deliciosa! Negocio familiar y siempre recibido con una sonrisa. ¡Las alas dulces y suaves son una locura! ¡¡¡Desde entonces no he dejado de soñar con ellos!!!

Soup was very good (Traducido por Google) la sopa estaba muy buena

Great! (Traducido por Google) ¡Excelente!

Food is great (Traducido por Google) la comida es genial

There great (Traducido por Google) hay genial

Great food and great prices. Owner and staff very friendly. (Traducido por Google) Buena comida y buenos precios. Propietario y personal muy amable.

Not bad for New Jersey (Traducido por Google) No está mal para Nueva Jersey

Best plain pie in Sayreville (Traducido por Google) El mejor pastel sencillo en Sayreville

The food is amazing (Traducido por Google) la comida es increible

Awesome food (Traducido por Google) Comida asombrosa

They don't have anywhere to sit and eat comfortably. And they don't believe in ac. (Traducido por Google) No tienen ningún lugar para sentarse y comer cómodamente. Y no creen en ac.

Delicious food!!!! (Traducido por Google) ¡¡¡¡Comida deliciosa!!!!

Great staff, large selection of pre-made pies for slice options (Traducido por Google) Excelente personal, gran selección de pasteles prefabricados para opciones de rebanadas

Now that I'm pretty much a regular. I finally had the pleasure to meet the owner. Extremely kind and talented fellow. But let me tell you the staff here is extremely welcoming no matter what kind of day it is, always happy to serve. Now let's talk about the pie I can't shake... The vodka Sicilian here is by far one of the best recipes in NJ, the owner customized it to an even better height of flavor to satisfy the taste buds. (Adding sauteed garlic and rosemary sheesh🙏🏼) Not to mention the crust which has excellent consistency. Great work here guys will be coming here often. P.S I'm Henry 🤓 (Traducido por Google) Ahora que soy más o menos un habitual. Finalmente tuve el placer de conocer al propietario. Compañero extremadamente amable y talentoso. Pero déjame decirte que el personal aquí es extremadamente acogedor sin importar qué tipo de día sea, siempre dispuesto a servir. Ahora hablemos del pastel que no me puedo quitar... El vodka siciliano aquí es, con mucho, una de las mejores recetas en NJ, el propietario lo personalizó a una altura de sabor aún mejor para satisfacer las papilas gustativas. (Agregando ajo salteado y sheesh de romero🙏🏼) Sin mencionar la corteza que tiene una excelente consistencia. Gran trabajo aquí, los chicos vendrán aquí a menudo. PD: soy Henry 🤓

Great pizza, friendly staff. I love the Caesar salad here and the cheesecake is amazing! definitely recommend! (Traducido por Google) Gran pizza, personal amable. ¡Me encanta la ensalada César aquí y el pastel de queso es increíble! ¡Definitivamente lo recomiendo!

Love their pizza. Favorite Pizza place in town. Will order from them again and again (Traducido por Google) Me encanta su pizza. Pizzería favorita en la ciudad. Ordenaré de ellos una y otra vez.

Best pizza establishment in town. Walk in and it feels like Family! Try the cheesesteak roll. It's my favorite! (Traducido por Google) La mejor pizzería de la ciudad. ¡Entra y se siente como en familia! Prueba el rollo de bistec con queso. ¡Es mi favorito!

I had a great experience the food was amazing and it came earlier than expected, I would recommend Rustonis to everyone. (Traducido por Google) Tuve una gran experiencia, la comida fue increíble y llegó antes de lo esperado, recomendaría Rustonis a todos.

Great service and tasty food (Traducido por Google) Gran servicio y comida sabrosa.

Hidden gem in Sayreville. Great square pizza! (Traducido por Google) Joya escondida en Sayreville. Gran pizza cuadrada!

Best pizza (Traducido por Google) mejor pizza

My favorite spot. Very good food. Even better service. Highly recommend. (Traducido por Google) Mi lugar favorito. Muy buena comida. Aún mejor servicio. Altamente recomendado.

Went to this place to get a slice changed my mind got a Sicilian Best Sicilian slice ever had in New Jersey. Seems like someone took this Sicilian pie from Sicily brought to Jersey and sold it as their own.. Great employees the best Sicilian you could have crispy bottom gooey in the middle best gravy combination don’t forget the fresh basil. (Traducido por Google) Fui a este lugar para obtener una porción, cambié de opinión y obtuve una porción siciliana. La mejor porción siciliana que jamás haya tenido en Nueva Jersey. Parece que alguien tomó este pastel siciliano de Sicilia que trajo a Jersey y lo vendió como propio. Excelentes empleados, el mejor siciliano que podrías tener, fondo crujiente y pegajoso en la mejor combinación de salsa del medio, no olvides la albahaca fresca.