Sadie Baby Sweets in Columbus - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Quick turnaround excellent flavor beautiful designs!

I love this store and all the people that work there. They always have my nuts in stop, and so polite.

We use Sadie Sweets for all of our events. Best in Columbus!

Had an absolutely fantastic first experience ordering custom cookies from Sadie Baby Sweets! They made the highest quality cookies that were a big hit at our corporate event. Everyone LOVED them! Will definitely order again.

They are always amazing ! They have done so many events for me and never disappoint .They are patient and so helpful.

Sadie baby sweets setup a dessert table at my Bridal shower and every detail was done to perfection and taste delicious

Such an easy experience to order and the cake pops I ordered were so beautifully decorated and absolutely delicious!

Recently had a bee themed birthday party for our daughter who turned 1. We ordered cake pops, mini and regular cupcakes, custom cookies, mini rice crispy treats and chocolate covered pretzel rods. Pick up was super smooth and quick. Everything was delicious and so cute! Rachel was very responsive and helpful when finalizing the order. 10/10

Sweets were so beautiful we didn’t want to eat. But we did and they were delicious! Would highly recommend.

The BEST! They took my inspo pics and created the most beautiful cookies!

Everything was fantastic! I ordered custom cookies for a special event and they were both gorgeous and delicious!! Ordering and pickup were quick and easy! I’ll definitely be a repeat customer!

The details in their products are amazing. They taste great, and make a wonderful presentation at any event!

I ordered 1 dozen cupcakes for my sister’s bachelorette weekend & they turned out so great! I spoke with Madison & she got me together with these beautiful Taylor Swift Eras themed cupcakes. Thank you so much to everyone at Sadie Baby 💕✨🧁

Sadie Baby can take any inspiration photo and match the beauty and design perfect but what’s more incredible is the taste! Their treats are amazing!!

I had royal iced cookies made for my son’s Baptism and they were beautiful! Exactly what I asked for and tasted great. Everyone loved them!

Ordered a sweetheart cake for November 2023 wedding. Absolutely delicious red velvet cake and the design we asked for was replicated PERFECTLY, such a beautiful cake. We also had some last minute schedule changes for cake pick up and we did not have any issues updating the pick up time- we so appreciated the flexibility! Our only comment is that it would be nice to have an actual cake slice tasting instead of trying cake balls because it was a little bit different texture.

Everyone loved the Baby Shark cookies! They were beautifully done, tasted delicious, & were the hit of my 2 y/o grandson’s birthday party! I would highly recommend Sadie Baby Sweets!!!

Sadie Baby did our wedding dessert table and we’ve gone back for every anniversary, most birthdays and special events. Everything tastes as wonderful as it looks, the presentation is always flawless and the service is spectacular.

Beautiful, delicious treats! I’ve ordered for multiple events and my guests have always been impressed. Sadie Baby has high quality desserts and excellent service at a reasonable price point. I highly recommend!

We ordered Sesame Street themed cupcakes for my son’s 2nd birthday and they turned out beautiful and tasted great! They were a huge hit with both the kids and adults. We will definitely be ordering from Sadie Baby Sweets again soon.

Sadie Baby Sweets produces high quality product that not only look amazing but taste delicious as well. The chocolate covered Oreos and caramel pretzel rods are my favorite but the Rice Krispie treats are also a hit. The staff are also very friendly and easy to work with even on some last minute requests I’ve had to throw at them. I highly recommend for any special event or occasion.

Great service and delicious treats! Everything looked beautiful, fit perfectly with our theme, and were a huge hit at my mom's birthday party! I wish I had taken a pic before everything was gobbled up! I will definitely order from Sadie Babie Sweets again!

The team is great! They got back to me quickly and professionally. For someone who is indecisive they helped with design. Everything looks beautiful! 12/10

Cake was delicious and very beautiful. They also made cookies exact copy that I asked for. Everyone was happy

We have gotten custom cookies several times and they've been beautiful and delicious every time. We also love the cake pops! So grateful to have a reliable source for custom treats for our family's special occasions.

We've ordered from here twice now for a baby shower and a bridal shower and they always do a fantastic job. Beautiful presentation and delicious as well! Thank you!

They were very professional and able to fit me in at the last minute. My family absolutely love the cake pops!

The cake I order was great and delicious! I will definitely buy more cakes with them!

The caramel wrapped pretzel rods were absolutely delicious for my daughter’s bridal shower. Guests loved them and what a nice addition to our dessert bar!

The cake pops were great. The staff was professional and they delivered their product timely.

I have been a customer of Sadie Baby Sweets since 2016! The ideas, color combinations and whimsical creations are always met. The treats not only look good but taste so good! Excellent service and quality!

Amazing! Everyone at our graduation party asked where we got the amazing sweet treat. Definitely recommend!

Great experience. I had a last minute request and they were able to accommodate me. Cake was perfect, exactly what I envisioned and my daughter loved her first sweet experience!

Wonderful cake, amazing taste and exactly what I was expecting as far as design. So many compliments!!!

Sadie’s macarons are very tasty. The shells are light with the crunch you expect and the fillings have just the right consistency and flavor. Favorite was key lime and raspberry but I’m sure all their flavors are good. I used the macarons for a baby shower and would highly recommend for any event.

Cookies are delicious! And the customer service is amazing as well. Highly recommend for your orders!

The family was sooo pleased with our Valentine charcuterie. Both visually stunning and very yummy.

Sadie Baby sweets made my baby gender reveal dreams come true! Teddy bear themed cake pops to match our “we can bearly wait” themed baby shower and they were perfect! Not only were they beautiful, but also delicious! Would definitely recommend 🤗

Love this place! I drive 40mins to get their goods because it’s worth it!

Amazing bakery! Used Sadie baby sweets for my baby shower and childs first birthday. Fantastic customer service and beautiful delectable desserts!

My sweets table was an amazing addition to my wedding. It was exactly as I had ordered and set up so I didn’t have to worry about it. Would highly recommend.

A nice little place. Like most similar places target 2 weeks ahead of time for planning purposes especially around relevant holidays (Valentines, etc). Parking can be a bit tricky but there is parking along the adjacent side street that's only a 50 foot or so walk. Can do custom orders not found on their website.

Sadie Baby Sweets staff delivers great customer service, beautiful designs and great tasting food! Don’t stop - GO and order some now!

Wonderful service. Friendly staff and very professional.. I ordered cupcakes, cake pops and pretzels for my son’s Senior night for swimming..everything was a big hit especially the pretzels. I am still getting compliments even weeks after the event. Thank you! I will use them again for my son’s graduation!

Rachel and the Sadie Baby team are outstanding! I have ordered cookies for both personal and business events. Each time the team has been quick to respond, accommodating, and professional. They know how to bring your idea to life with gorgeous designs. And the best part, their cookies are delicious. The cookies are always a hit; I cannot wait to use Sadie Baby again in the future!

Sadie Baby Sweets is my go to for all my sweet treat needs when it comes to gifts for friends and family! No matter how big or small the occasion, I had them for my wedding and continue to use them for all my treat needs, they are always a big hit!

Sadie Baby Sweets is amazing! Their sweets are delicious, and we are excited that they will be putting together a sweets table for our wedding. The experience has been wonderful!

The piecaken was amazing! The perfect dessert to celebrate a birthday around thanksgiving!

Always a perfect and professional cake. Attention to detail on the exterior of the cake is high quality and the taste is by far the best around.

Got exactly what we wanted! Great with communication and great product! Will be using again!

Amazing display and everything tastes delicious!

Everyone LOVED the cake pops. I was hoping to have some leftovers but nope. Huge hit and decorated beautifully! Highly recommend and can’t wait to order more for my sons Spider-Man birthday party!

I went to Sadie Baby Sweets to provide birthday desserts for my 60th birthday party. I would definitely go to them again. They were very easy to work with. Their prices are reasonable and Sadie Baby Sweets worked with me to create beautiful and delicious dessert options that met the theme of my event, and in the event’s color scheme. Plus, they were very friendly and provided excellent customer service. Sadie Baby Sweets is an excellent resource when you want unique, delicious, confections tailored to your special event.

I needed a Toy Story birthday cake pretty last minute. They were able to accommodate me and exceed my expectations. The cake tasted delicious, was ready on time, and fit perfectly with a Reach Four the Sky themed birthday.

I loved finding Sadie Baby Sweets. What a gem!!! We visited Columbus from out of town and needed a hostess gift for an engagement. I ordered individually wrapped diamond rings for the party. Sadie Baby exceeded my expectations. They were ready and waiting for me when I picked them up. What a charming bakery. Loved it and will use them when we are there visiting.

Sadie Baby sweets is an amazing company! They’re so easy to work with and have a great attention to detail. The treats I ordered for my party were beyond perfect!! They were beautiful and matched my theme perfectly! The treats were also tasty and were the talk of the party!!

Such an amazing bakery! They designed the cookies just like the examples and better. They also taste delicious! Highly recommend

The cookies we ordered for my daughters baby shower were beautifully done. It’s not often you find a cookie that tastes great and looks beautiful too. We got just what we were hoping for. Thank you for helping to make this special occasion a beautiful memory. The Fletchers Worthington, Ohio

Amazing! Delicious! Beautiful! They helped me with orders that I thought would be too late to place. Cake, cake pops, cake push ups were all perfect! So many compliments at my parties😊

Sadie Baby Sweets did an amazing job with our cookie table for our wedding last year! We loved their treats so much that we're bringing them to Pittsburgh for my sister's upcoming wedding! I highly recommend Sadie Baby for any big family events!

They made the cake exactly like the picture. They blew my mind away. It was perfect. Thank you so much. Mucho gracias 🥰😘

Excellent and highly recommend. Had for bridal shower everyone love it, deserts gone immediately..so get extras!!! Love the people,easy to email with order and quick to respond!!

I can always count on Rachel and her team for my dessert needs no matter what the occasion is!

Got cookies from here for my sisters gender reveal party & they not only looked sooo amazing but tasted great too!!!

WOW! The cake pops I ordered from Sadie Baby Sweets were a winner! I ordered 4 dozen (football, basketball, golf, and pink girly) for a couples’ shower. They were so incredibly cute that I used the cardboard holder from Sadie Baby and mixed them up. Then I used each holder as a centerpiece on the tables—ADORABLE! Service is excellent and the flavors are yummy!

So delicious! Ordered for an event. Received so many compliments. Easy to order and pick up.

Sadie Baby Sweets made custom treats (cakes and cake pops) for my son’s first AND second birthday parties, and we could not have been more impressed. Not only did they make beautiful custom designs for each of our themes (Mr. One-Derful and Two Wild), but the cakes and cake pops also tasted amazing. All of our guests raved about the designs and flavors. Communication, payment and pickup were also easy and seamless. We will no doubt be back for his third birthday 🥳

Very friendly and fast response when I emailed my request to order for a baby shower. Everything turned out beautifully, I couldn’t have asked for anything better. I had so many guests compliment all of the sweets, but especially the cookies!

This is just a house. I don't know if someone is running a business out of the house, but there are no signs, and I didn't feel comfortable just walking in.

Rachel came up with a creative design for our theme and really exceeded my expectations! And the cookies were delicious!

I’ve ordered from Sadie Baby Sweets for holiday occasions and have been so impressed with everything! Not only do the treats taste delicious, but they are also adorable. They have made personalized elf cookies that I took to a Christmas party and they were a hit with both the kiddos and the adults. Their customer service is also amazing. Will definitely be ordering from them again!

I found this place while working at a wedding. I fell in love with there cookies. I have used them for every event I throw. There work is magnificent and I enjoy the customer service I receive every time I inquire/order.

I love what they do. I love decorating sweet tables on my family's birthdays and they always achieve what I have in mind, besides being delicious. Thank you!!

Amazing! Everything was so beautiful and most importantly so delicious! I purchased chocolate covered Oreos, chocolate covered caramel pretzels, chocolate covered strawberries and cake pops and all my guest loved them all! I highly recommend Sadie Baby Sweets for all your chocolate needs!

I highly recommend this bakery! They make custom cake pops for our gender reveal party. Communication was great and they were easy to work with. Not only did the look good, they were delicious. We ordered the carrying cases which were very sturdy and made it easy to transport! We will definitely be back!

I’ve ordered custom cookies from Sadie Baby multiple times. Rachel is always friendly and super communicative. The cookies are beautiful and delicious. Both times I have shared inspo pics and the cookie decorator has done an amazing job creation exactly what I wanted. The shop itself is so cute and has easy street parking. Would highly recommend Sadie Baby for any events or dessert needs!

I love this bakery. The owner is professional and the employees are friendly and easy to work with. The sweets are delectable and unique. They think out of the box and will add that special touch to your large or small event.

I have ordered “decorate-it-yourself” treats from Sadie Babies a number of times and they never disappoint. Your DIY cake or cookie kits include all the ingredients for a fun gift that kids (of all ages) can appreciate. I have given these kits instead of “stuff” as gifts, and the recipients (and their parents) have loved creating their own designs with delicious icing and embellishments.

My go to for all special treats. I’ve never had a bead experience and the Carmel pretzels are the best!

We ordered chocolate dipped Oreos with our church’s logo. Ordering was quick and easy, and the cookies were SO good and pretty! We will definitely use them again.

Sadie Baby Sweets always delivers a quality and beautiful product. I have used them numerous times and will continue to use them in the future. Great and easy communication as well.

I planned my Mom's 80th Birthday from out of state and Rachel was so incredibly helpful. She was so responsive and provided recommendations based on her expertise. Everyone loved the desserts, especially the Buckeyes and Banana Pudding Parfaits. Thank you, Rachel, for help making my Mom's party a success.

Highly recommend Rachel for all your dessert needs! We also hired her to design and set up our dessert table. We got to taste a number of items from her shop before we made decisions, which was great! Rachel was easy to work with and very responsive! Everyone loved all the desserts and the table was beautiful and more than I could have imagined!

They have the cutest little shop, the staff was very friendly, and they have the cutest treats. I loveeeed their macarons the most

They have cute Valentines themed sweets right now with a variety of flavors. I also felt completely safe with all the covid measures they are taking.

A cute little shop with handmade treats—I highly recommend their pretzel sticks and hot chocolate bombs if you can get them before they sell out!

I'm sure its a secret, but, your candied pecans are off the hook! Normally, candied nuts are somewhat "soggy", but, these are fresh, crisp and decadently delicious!

Vue Columbus, the downtown Brewery District wedding venue, loves working with the amazing team at Sadie Baby Sweets! Rachel and her team have such a passion for their exquisite, fun desserts and will deliver nothing less than perfection for every event. No couple can go wrong when choosing Sadie Baby for their celebration. Rachel has gone above and beyond for Vue, gifting treats for our team just to provide a deeper vendor to vendor connection. Vue will continue recommending Sadie Baby Sweets to all of our couples, and we look forward to many more shared, successful events in the future!

Rachel has always been wonderful to work with and always delivers on the best products! She created the best bachelorette cookies for a recent Vegas Bachelorette Party! Thank you!!

Phenomenal sweets. Delightful and rich! Super creative as well!

Sadie baby was amazing! Rachel and her crew were so helpful throughout the entire process and really took the time to make our event special. Their cakes are AMAZING! I will definitely be recommending them to everyone in the future.

Rachel and her staff were amazing to work with. The dessert table looked stunning. The desserts were so good that we had no left overs and everyone raved about them. Thank you Sadie Baby!

This is a wonderful place when you want something special that not only looks amazing but taste wonderful.

The best spot in Columbus to supply desserts for weddings. Everything they make looks wonderful and tastes great!

Tastes as good as it looks! The attention to detail is unmatched. Sadie Baby Sweets is my go for treats at every event.

Sadie Baby Sweets is absolutely amazing! From the stunning first impression to the delicious taste, you will keep going back for more! The hard work and dedication is evident. Rachel is always professional. Every time I am in Columbus it is a must have! And even an occasional delivery to SF! SO worth it!

These are delicious. The detail she puts into these is incredible

Cream of the crop for events and holiday parties! I have had their cake pops or other treats at farmers markets and at a weeding as well as the shop and it is consistently good every time. Highly recommended

I've been getting desserts from Sadie Baby Sweets for 3 years now. They get shipped to my house in Northeast Ohio. She has done numerous themes for me. We have 8 birthdays a year and every birthday I order from Sadie Baby Sweets. Very easy to order, adorably creative, and they taste amazing. No one compares that's why I order only from Rachel. She's experienced, talented, creative, and professional. Thanks so much for making every birthday a memorable one!

Everything is beautiful and tastes even better than it looks! If you want to make an impact at a party or event, believe me Sadie Baby Sweets will impress! It's amazing what they can do.