Stephano's Pizza in Winfield - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The food was great. Reasonably priced.

Enjoyed the sweeter sauce but got the thick crust to give it a shot and like an other review said, the pizza was under cooked and doughy still.

The sauce was grossly sweet and it was burnt. Just not good in any way, the breadsticks reminded me of the school cafeteria. Might have to go get a hot n ready to try to salvage the night.

These people really do care about the customers and are SO UNDERSTANDING. Not to mention, the pizza is beyond amazing! This brand deserves to expand and spread across the Midwest. Love the thickness of the pizza + the SAUCE. So dang good!

Ordered a pizza and it was still doughy in the center when I took it home to eat it. I had to actually put the pizza in my oven at home to finish cooking it. I do like my pizza more well done and I did not order my pizza well done this time however many other pizza places do not have this issue regardless of how you order it. The wings were decent. But I will likely not be returning.

My wife ask well for well done pizza and well done fries the fries look like soggy like soak in oil and the pizza cheese wasn't brown it didn't look cooked. To top it off I was got sick after I ate miss work.

Guess lansing, Lynwood area wasn't the place to market too anymore. Grew up on this pizza and loved it. Use to leave Heritage & T.F South just for the slices and fries

Best Pizza in LOFS area hands down!! WORKS,Tavern style thin crust well done absolutely delicious!

This is exactly like what I ate growing up in the Chicago suburbs and begging my mom to get on Friday nights after school. Definitely going to be my regular pizza spot in the area. My wife and I really love the sauce and amount of toppings!

Best place for pizza. Love the sauce and also offer a delicious gluten-free crust. Best in Winfield. A+.

Best pizza I’ve ive ever had and the sauce is just so good

I heard from a coworker to try this and it has become my new local favorite pizza place. They have a great variety of pizzas, sandwiches, pastas, salads and appetizers. The calzone was delicious. You could taste the fresh ingredients. We also tried the fried mushrooms and toasted raviolis. Everything was great. We will be back.

Very disorganized and messy inside. Just got there after a long hot day outside. Wanted to use a restroom while waiting for our pizza....no public bathroom! What?? Pizza was not good. Dough was close to raw in the center. Should of gone to our usual across the street..

New joint in Winfield. Just got a pizza from them to try it out, delicious stuff. Highly recommend.

Moved here from Chicago 5 months ago and have tried just about every pizza in NWI and I can safely say this is my favorite! This is the only thin crust that even comes close to all the good pizza we had in the city. It smells like heaven as soon as you walk in too. Sauce to cheese ratio is perfect. Edit - I may take away one star for this eventually but hours are posted until 9pm (every day except Fridays & Saturdays which is until 10) and I swear they never answer the phone after 7:50pm lol just tried again right now and it was only 8:01pm with multiple phone call attempts. This happened 4 other nights I tried calling in the last two weeks. We’re settling for Pizza Hut because it’s close but pretty disappointed :( Hopefully it doesn’t happen again.

The wings crispy and naked... delicious 😋

My family ordered Stephano's yesterday and it was AMAZING! So excited to have a new favorite pizza place in Crown Point :)

Hands down the pizza in Northwest IN!!!! I do not live there anymore but whenever I visit I make sure to stop at Stepanos at least once to get my fix. Nothing compares to it. I've even taken pizza back home on a flight with me because it's that good.

This was some awesome pizza. Owners are incredibly nice and welcoming. Cute pick up area.

Great pizza!! Delicious sauce. One of my favorite spots for some good za.

Pizza is amazing with fresh ingredients. Staff is very friendly.

The whole family loves this pizza. If you like cheese, get the deep-dish. It's not a thick crust just more toppings.

This place will surprise you. Some of the best pizza in town

One of my favorite pizzas in the area. The sauce is amazing and we’ve never had a bad pizza. For the people that gave a one star, they are the definition of Karen’s. Keep making amazing pizzas

Our favorite pizza place! The food is always hot and delicious. Jess, the owner is also amazing-great customer service!

Excellent food at great price, pleasant staff, 10/10

Great pizza, great customer service

The Works pizza is our favorite. Order well done for a crispy crust.

This is the best pizza in north west indiana. If you're a cheese lover the deep dish is perfect. If you like thin crust theirs can't be beat. Chicago pizza without the drive.

Always a great pie ,my daughters favorite

Great pizza and great staff. They offer contactless pickup as well.

The pizza and toasted ravioli were awesome!

Delicious fresh to order pizza! Medium pizza with italian sausage, mushrooms was upgraded to large due to a promotion that week. Service was kind and excellent! We'll definitely be back when we visit again.

First off Stephano’s has the best sauce in all of Northwest Indiana the Chicago suburbs! It is the perfect combo of oregano and Italian herbs to a lightly sugared sweet, savory goodness that will keep you coming back for more because you can’t find any taste quite like it! Last night was my first time trying Stephano’s Italian beef pizza with tomatoes and I was incredibly shocked by how tasty this combo was! One, I’m not a meat lover when it comes to pizza. I prefer veggies. Two, I do not really eat Italian beef in the first place, but someone else suggested I try this combo, and WOW! The sweetness of the tomatoes mixed with Stephano’s amazing sauce to the savory salted beef was like when you make the perfect charcuterie board combination! An explosion of flavor! Every flavor is present all working at the same time to create a new taste and flavor you never had! Plus, i couldn’t even tell I was eating meat on a pizza! You have to try Italian beef and tomatoes at Stephanos! I highly doubt you will be disappointed in your choice to venture out and try this combo! And besides, no matter what your choice of toppings may be, at Stephano’s it’s guaranteed to be satisfyingly delicious!

The double decker is my family's favorite pizza.

The pizza and wings are AMAZING

Love this pizza place! Definitely would recommend for a friend

We hadn't ordered personally from Stephanos pizzeria, I have with friends its amazing pizza. We had ordered a deep dish with and a small sausage for our boys. We had received the pizza on time and hot still. Unfortunately the deep dish was tilted and a huge mess! I had called, and spoke to Annmarie a super sweet young lady who right away took care of our issue. With no issues and she was very kind and not rude the owner Honored us a pizza On our next order or if we wanted one today but we chose to do on our next order. Regardless it's still amazing pizza and great people. This isn't ment to be a complaint just a thank you!

Best pizza in town... The phone remembers your name and what you ordered last time.. So I can just say "the usual" and whatever size. Steve is usually there tu o greet you and bring out your pie. Ready in less than 15 minutes. Great family one of pizzeria!

I usually get the double decker, but went with the regular thin crust and still excellent

Pizza ok, prices little high!

I have had stephano pizza before and love it. However today while at my daughters in LOFS I called to order a pizza and was told 35 minutes. After 15 minutes I left to pick it up and came straight home to a cold pizza. That's never happened and I have to wonder why. Disappointed this time🙄

Great food selections for the whole family. My husband gets their Mango Habenero wings, I usually get the Chicken Alfredo, and the kids get the pizza! Also, they always have had a friendly crew in the 5 years I’ve been coming, I think a lot of these 1 star reviews are either fake or probably very greedy people that didn’t get free food. Support your local business!

Delicious pizza with a great crust. I get delivery every week on my lazy day. Never had a problem with anyone and the drivers are very nice.

This pizza is amazing. Closest to My Hometown Pizza in Chicago it's truly good.

Good good but wait times are not great.

Of the pizza places in Winfield this one tastes the best! They're good about getting food ready on time and the price is reasonable. I ordered food on Superbowl Sunday and it was ready within a couple minutes. All together I think this is a pizza place worth trying!

Delicious pizza! The sauce is amazing and the owner is very friendly. If you are ever in the area, order pizza from Stephano's, you won't regret it.

Good pizza. Sausage is Chicago style.

Great pizza that's probably the most important part! The staff was also very friendly with fast delivery services. I've tried many different things off the menu & can't think of one thing that I haven't liked. The prices are also reasonable, highly recommended by me.

The deep dish is THE BEST PIZZA ON THE PLANET!

Good semisweet sauce. Crust is also good

Es allí, en la lista de la mejor pizza que he probado: ingredientes frescos, corteza perfectamente horneado, gran sabor, los precios son razonables. Estaremos pidiendo a menudo!

I would say one of the best pizzas in Northwest Indiana Great sauce order the pizza the way you like it very accommodating A++++

It's always a delight to eat here. Never disappointed. Nothing about it stands out, but it's still a good safe place to grab a pizza! Great local friendly staff.

Hay pizza es un knock out, el mejor que he tenido en cualquier parte lejos indiana el salsa es increíble y el personal es estupendo y la entrega siempre es una buena cosa.

Best sweet tomato sauce around! Never disappointed with the taste or texture! Always fresh tasting ingredients. The owner is friendly, and always asks if theres anything else she could do to make your experience better!

My niece has a cheese allergy and the owner has gone above and beyond to accommodate us. She is such a sweetheart and very nice to us even when she is busy!! Great food, definitely recommend

Great experience! After reading the reviews I see why this is a beloved pizza place. I definitely recommend the food there! Support your local businesses rather than trash them over a sandwich children!

Absolutely amazing food! The pizza is the best I have ever had. The chicken sandwiches are delicious. The staff is friendly and polite. Love their willingness to please the customer.

If your going to post something at least post the truth. Jessica is a hard working kind owner. If you have a complaint about not liking something it gives you no right to call scream, yell, cuss or be belittling to anyone. You don't like something use class, manners and speak like an adult. I listened yesterday as a woman called about her sandwich that she didn't like. Jessica apologized several times that you didn't like it and you continued to yell at her. She kindly said "ma'am I don't have to listen to you speak to me like this" and hung up. You also forgot to mention that you sent your husband to come yell at a woman over a $6 sandwich. Your going to post at least post the truth.

Best pizza in the Winfield/Crown Point area. The owner is very professional and kind to all of her customers.

Love this place. Something about the cheese here makes it stand apart from he other local pizzerias. Always fast and friendly service.

The pizza was great! I really enjoyed it and the friendly staff. What prevents this from being a 5 were the wings. The sauces were tasty but the wings were super tiny. Can't win them all but next time I'm in IN, I'll get more pizza.

He probado la pizza varias veces a lo largo de los últimos años y siempre ha sido muy bueno! Normalmente entrega y nunca he tenido ningún problema. Pizza es siempre bueno. Prueba la coliflor, cheddar frito ... es delicioso, demasiado. Sin duda os mantendremos pidiendo a ellos.

We have been ordering a take out pizza at Stephano's for several years on a once a week basis. Have eaten pizza all over Chicago and Northwest Indiana and think Stephano's is the best. We usually order a pie with sausage on one half and pepperoni and jalapeños on other half. Pizza is to die for.

Great pizza - love green pepper and diced tomatoes.

Love pizza all kinds, but this by far is awesome. Go with the thin crust!

Ok, I'm not fat BUT this place makes me want to be fat... I love the pizza here... Fantastically wonderful, to say the least...