The Cakehole in New Palestine - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

10/10 experience with the cakehole! I had a cake emergency and they were able to make me the most perfect spiderman cake for my 3 year old! Super friendly staff who were very responsive and SO accommodating! I’ll never go anywhere else for a cake ever again!

Jovanna was awesome to work with! Our cake looked amazing and tasted great. We will definitely be back!

I delivered a instacart order to this business & they are very professional and polite! There facility is very clean and smells amazing! They even offered me a cupcake & I had the cookies and cream one and it was very very good ! Taste is amazing and it’s not to much sugar ! I definitely will be back to buy more and do more business here ! Thank you so much! Keep doing your thing !! Also prices are very very reasonable!

Got a custom birthday cake made for my girl. Taste was excellent also the decorations were terrific. Worth the money.

A cake was sent to the celebration of Life service for my partner. We had an after service dessert bar. The two tier cake from your bakery was a big hit. It was delicious and beautifully decorated. I have found my new Cake Decorater.

Jovanna did a fantastic job. we had great options for flavors and she was able to do everything we asked! Super easy to work with and very imaginative! would absolutely recommend again!

I'm absolutely grateful for ordering my husband's birthday cake from here. Such intricate talent and great tasting cake that deserves much more that 5 stars. I am definitely a regular customer now for all my celebrating occasions. Highly recommend!!!

Absolutely amazing experience with The Cakehole. I had been searching all around for a bakery in the Indianapolis area to make my son's Wednesday Addams themed birthday cake. It's become a family tradition to have over-the-top birthday cakes, but I was striking out everywhere for weeks as it's May and therefore wedding season has begun. I wanted black buttercream frosting with minimal food coloring icing a red velvet cake, which means using black cocoa in it. Desperate, I posted to a Facebook group for suggestions, and the owner was tagged in the comments. I sent her a message and she worked some kind of magic to get me squeezed in last minute. The price was reasonable for what I was asking for, and I was happy to drive out to New Pal to pick it up. Not only was the order completed on time, but it is GORGEOUS, and it is exactly what my 8 year old had envisioned as he was describing what he wanted. I swear to you, I will make the drive every year for another one of her masterpieces and for her amazing and timely service. I'll just call her FIRST from now on. Thank you for making a little boy's cake dreams come true.

Only cup cake place Indiana that served moist n melt in mouth cake

Beautiful cake and delicious! Thank you so much for making my daughter’s day special!

As always, the most delicious cupcakes ever! Jovanna always outdoes herself with the most delicious flavors! Love this place, it’s a New Palestine treasure!

Pictures coming they are making a beautiful chanel birthday cake

The best cupcakes in the world! 🌍 One of the biggest hits of our wedding was our cuocakes. Tip: Try the Black Bottom cupcakes (they're to die for).

From the samples to the big day, the Cakehole was amazing! Our wedding cake was beautiful AND delicious!

We used The Cakehole for our wedding cake and she did not disappoint! The cake was amazing and beautiful, I can't stop staring at it!

Best cupcakes and cakes on the east side of Indianapolis. We are always buying for birthdays and special occasions.

Amazingly cakes!! No need to go elsewhere!

I had a Cake and cup cakes made for my Boyfriends Birthday! She did an amazing job! And everything tasted sooooo yummy! :)

Wonderful place to get all your cake needs ! Very decent prices! Will be back for all my cake needs ! Thanks again!

Ordered a two tiered cake for 50 people to celebrate a 50th Anniversary party. Cake was delicious. Thank you! I was happy with our experience.

Great experience here! Inquired about cupcakes by email the prior day and they were boxed up and ready when I arrived the next day. Quick and easy transaction! Unfortunately these cupcakes were a gift but I will definitely be back for some for myself.

Made our wedding cake, it was awesome!

The Cakehole was always my go to “treat my self” place. My favorite part wasn’t even the cupcakes (which are always delicious), but the people who work at the shop. The Cakehole is a great addition to the community.

Just a little slice of heaven. When I arrived yesterday everyone in the place was buzzing. I looked at the head cake designer and her face had a light dusting of glitter. She was working on a cake that had a light blue glitter path along the top. Their cupcakes are scrumptious although Like many of today's shops the style is to have lots and lots of icing on top of the cupcakes. I prefer little less and they will do that. Get orders in early.

Jovana did a great job making my wife a Gluten Sensitive Cake it was better than GiGis Cupcake. It was soooo delicious. Highly recommend

This review is long overdue. Jovanna made the most beautiful cake for my daughter's unicorn-themed birthday party, after literally no guidance from me. I asked for a unicorn cake, and I received something out of a magazine. Every single person commented on how beautiful the cake was, and one person even said something along the lines of, "I've only ever seen a cake like this on Instagram :-). Another seemed perplexed that it actually tasted amazing, as if a cake so beautiful couldn't possibly taste delicious too. But it was, and it did! Once you find something good, you stick with it, and I will be headed back to The Cakehole for all of my cake needs! Thanks again, Jovanna!

We had our wedding cake made along with cupcakes and everything was perfect!

I ordered a custom cake for my grandma's 80th birthday and was amazed with the level of detail. I sent an idea and they went above and beyond. Everyone loved the cake especially the birthday girl! I would highly recommend The Cakehole and have already placed an order for my daughter's upcoming birthday!

I had my wedding cakes done from here and they were wonderful! We had the centerpieces for our tables that were different flavored cakes, a grooms cake, and our wedding cake. Everyone kept complimenting how beautiful the cakes were and how delicious they were. Jovanna was so nice and was accommodating to anything that I asked for. I was nervous about how much it was going to be for all of the cake we needed and everything we ordered came in way under budget. I would recommend The Cakehole to everyone and I'm just trying to come up with an excuse where I'll need cake so I can order from here again!

Jovana was so great! And her cake was even better! She took some of our inspiration pictures and made a beautiful cake that fit our theme perfectly. It was soooo delicious!! Highly recommend!

A great place for cake commissions

The Cakehole did the wedding cake/cupcakes for our wedding. In terms of vendors, they were clearly the best part of the night. By far. I've been to plenty of weddings and did some tastings while planning ours - most wedding cakes are overpriced and, in the end, not great. Not the case for ours. We did a few flavors of cupcakes, and they were amazing. The guests raved. And yes, we were on a tight budget. We were not one of those couples who spent $30,000 or even $20,000 on their wedding. They offered the best value in terms of cost vs. serving your guests something was not just OK or acceptable, but terrific.