The New York Cheesecake Company - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I ordered the Peach Cobbler Cheesecake and it was absolutely delicious!!! Highly recommend!! Great customer service!!

The plain cheesecake was the best we have ever had! We also tried the sampler which included 4 flavors and loved the chocolate chip cookie dough and the tiramisu cheesecake. Pricey but well worth the expense.

I have a newly wheat allergic family member and we were traveling to Destin Florida. All that person wanted for their 22nd birthday was a chocolate cheesecake that was gluten and nut free. I ordered the 6 inch gluten free death by chocolate. I didn't get a picture and it didn't last. It was fantastic! It was shipped with dry ice so even arriving in July in Florida it was perfectly cold. Thank you for the fantastic cake!

Ordered a cheese cake for my wives birthday. It came within a couple days, just in time for her birthday party! It did come frozen but we were able to thaw it out just in time for the party.

I ordered two sampler 4 packs, all gluten free. They arrived quickly and were delicious, you would never know they were gluten free. I will definitely be buying more in the future!

I always bake a cheesecake for Easter, and my guests look forward to it. This year I bought one from The New York Cheesecake Company for the first time. It was outstanding, and everyone agreed it was the best one I ever "made"! Am I a bad person if I threw away the box and claimed it as my own??? Fantastic cheesecake!!! Who made it will remain our secret....

I ordered 2 gluten free cheesecakes and gluten free cheesecake bites at this place and boy were they delicious. They were so good that I doubted they were gluten free, so much so that my family and I monitored ourselves for the entire week to see if we’d be symptomatic (ie bloating, muscle aches and pain) but we had no issues. Additionally, the delivery was perfectly on time and the cakes well packaged and remained frozen as they promised. I highly recommend this place for delicious gluten free baked goods. I wish I could give more than 5 stars.

Some of the best cheesecake I've ever had! Purchased 2 for a birthday party and everyone needed to know where I got it!

Shipping was right on time, packed well, price is what others should be, and the cheesecake was very good, don't hesitate to try these guys, I will be ordering again soon.

Update (original post below) I had a special order made up for gifts because I could not decide on a single cheesecake (they are ALL so good!). They did my special request and make 4 different cakes (cinnamon roll, Lemon Zest, Vanilla Latte and the new Chocolate Raspberry) and did a quarter of each to make a full cheesecake. My friends LOVED it!. Best cheesecake ever, made with all pure and natural ingredients and made to order. Original Post: We had a 90th birthday party for my mom and ordered 3 different varieties of cheesecakes from this company: Lemon Delight, Cinnamon Fusion, and Vanilla Latte. The crowd was wowed! The lemon was very popular and reminded me of a Key Lime flavor. I loved the cinnamon as it was like having a Cinnabon treat. If you like coffee flavor, the Vanilla Latte was excellent too. Now, if they could only make these without calories I could eat them every day!

Great company We were very happy with The New York Cheesecake Company. First, they have gluten free cheesecakes - which is great. Plus, when we ordered, for some reason the software didn't ask for a delivery date. Figured it would get there in a few days. But someone from the company actually called me to ask when we wanted it delivered. Great customer service! We will use them again.

Had the opportunity to try both the lemon delight and the cinnamon fusion cheesecakes and they were delicious! The cinnamon fusion had cinnamon buns for the crust and a whipped icing and it was fantastic! Would absolutely order from here again!

I ordered the banana cheesecake for my daughter’s birthday. It was so so good! Not just a hint of banana but full flavored banana. Will definitely order again in the future!

Incredible cheesecake, you can taste the difference!! My favorite so far is the lemon, it’s such a light and refreshing flavor. I’m looking forward to trying more!

This was the best cheesecake ever. I don't like cheesecake but my friend said I had to try it. It was the original flavor and the taste was amazing I actually had a 2nd piece. It was so creamy and velvety. We also got the cookies and cream cheesecake and that went quickly should've gotten 2. Our friends said it was amazing. The flavor and texture was perfect. I highly recommend cheesecake from here. It's a home based business and from the ordering, to pick up everything was so smooth. When I picked up the cheesecakes I was welcomed inside and given instructions on how to best serve and how long before it could be eaten.

To quote my parents, "that cheesecake was aaaahhhmazing!" They said it reminded them of a banana flambe. Hard to beat! Shipping was right on time too. I will be back again soon :)

Tried it for the first time, it was fabulous. I will diffently order again

Great cheesecake! We had the pudgies sampler pack with four different types: Death by Chocolate, Vanilla Latte, Berry and Plain. They were all fantastic! I truly could not decide which was my favorite. Will definitely be ordering again and looking forward to trying more flavors! If you are looking for great cheesecake, give it a try, you won’t be sorry!! We will attach the 'verified buyer' badge because this review results directly from one of our review requests.

They are very nice people and they make outstanding Cheese Cakes!

We absolutely love Grateful for you and your cheesecake Larry

Talk about THE best cheesecake anywhere..they are FABULOUS! The Death by Chocolate was beyond imagination!! And the Key Lime was soooo refreshing!!! Shipped to Florida with no problems, and arrived frozen and ready to defrost and enjoy!! Will definitely be ordering again!!!!

Not only have I tasted 3 different kinds of cheesecakes, I have seen the operation and it is amazing. Larry has done a wonderful job with this business and the cheesecakes are delicious!!!

I ordered a New York style cheesecake for a friend's birthday. I called on Thursday to have it delivered Friday. I wasn't sure if they could even make it happen on such short notice. But I spoke to Larry, who was extremely nice and he talked me through the process to order online and made it happen for the next day. He even contacted me on Friday to see what time she would be home for the best delivery time instead of contacting her ( which I did leave her number in case there was an issue) knowing it was a surprise. My friend contacted me after receiving it and was thrilled! I asked how it was and she said it was phenomenal!! I highly recommend and will definitely order from them again!

The Cinnamon Fusion Cheesecake was delicious! Would absolutely order again.

Our daughter celebrated her birthday last week. This Choc/choc/choc cheesecake blew her away. She shared it is the very best desert she has ever tasted. The Shipping Director called me the day after I placed the order to assure our request was accurate as well as if the delivery date was acceptable. NEVER had this happen before. Highly recommend this team to exceed expectations.

Fantastic Cheesecakes....I am 4 for 4 on flavors to highly recommend - Plain, Lemon, Vanilla Latte and Smores....they are all great.

I recently ordered the orange creamsicle cheesecake for my moms bday and OMG! So rich and creamy! It had just the right amount of orange and I also added the cream cheese frosting which was a perfect match! The crust was moist and firm not dry nor crumbly! It is homemade and not a factory made cheesecake, worth every penny! The owner is awesome, professional and so nice to work with! I will definitely be ordering again in the future!

I received the NY Cheesecake Co.'s lemon cheesecake for a birthday gift. It arrived in picture-perfect shape. The cheesecake itself was outstanding; indeed the best I have had (and I've eaten a lot of cheesecake over the years!). Solidly creamy, just enough lemon to balance the sweetness, an uncommonly perfect crumb crust (with a hint of ginger?!). The candied lemon peel truly "took the cake." Hands-down a memorable (most) tasty treat. I will gift others going forward (and selfishly re-order for my family)! Thank you for such a wonderful product!

BEST cheesecake I’ve ever had in my LIFE. No joke. I absolutely love this cheesecake. I like to think I’m a bit of a connoisseur because I’ve eaten a lot of cheesecakes in my life. I’ve never had better than this. 100%

I've been a loyal customer of The New York Cheesecake Cake Company since Day 1. Every step in the cheesecake making process is official. My family has purchased multiple cheesecakes and the quality is always the same... OUTSTANDING! The New York Cheesecake Cake Company creates cheesecakes with no fluff. I'm eating cheesecakes full of natural ingredients and no additives! Cheesecake is supposed to fill you, not leave you wishing you had more. Order from the New York Cheesecake Cake Company for all your family events, everyone will be pleased!!!

Everyone at a recent family gathering commented on the quality of the cheesecake. The product is every bit as good as the cheesecakes we experienced in New York City. Mitchell A. - Leesburg, VA

Outrageously Scrumptious, Creamy and Done to PERFECTION! Down right yummy! Living in Florida, I was afraid our Cheesecake was going to melt, prior to getting to us. NOT THE CASE! Packaging was still frozen when it got here. Thank you New York Cheesecake Company for the best dessert we've had in a very long time!

We purchased 6 dozen Bitty Bites in 3 different flavors to offer at my nephew's wedding. They were delicious and everyone seemed to like them. Easy to transport and plate, too. I would buy them again! Enjoy!

Helped me order for a local delivery. Communication was excellent. and replies were prompt. Will order again.

I driving to the place looking for a Bakery. This is a home base business not a Bakery store. The owner was very nice. They have several delivery options. The cheesecake are good quality and perfect sweetness’s.

We ordered the lemon, latte, oreo, and regular cakes and LOVED all of them. Great flavor! We got the cheesecakes shipped and they arrived still frozen and the cheesecakes were perfect. Also love that the cream cheese is made from scratch, you can definitely taste the quality. Also, the website provided great instructions on how to keep / freeze the leftovers.

Wow! Received my order 2 days ago via FedEx. The taste and the quality was beyond all expectations. I am addicted! Great job NY Cheesecake!

Excellent customer service, reasonably priced products, on-time delivery AND the best darn cheesecake you'll ever have! I ordered the lemon and it was soooo good! I highly recommend this company!

Seriously, the best cheesecake I've ever had! I ordered the cinnamon roll cheesecake and it was delivered to my door in Miami looking amazing. It tasted even better. I will be ordering more for upcoming events and family gatherings. Can't recommend this enough!!!