The best restaurants in Edgartown

The butcher here is not only tradesman but an artist - he knows more about his craft than many chefs, can get you rare pieces, and only keeps quality in his shop. So lucky to have him here!

$17 dollars for a tiny panini that doesn't even have real grill marks and melted cheese is disappointing. Especially since the coffee and atmosphere are great.

Peanut Butter Pie ice cream is my favorite!

Absolutely delicious! 10/10 would recommend I was in a group of 9, we all loved our food! Didn’t have to wait long and service was exceptional

Sadly, not a bakery, just a local storefront for a location off island. The croissants and bread were average quality and they’re unable to slice any of it.

What a difference a year makes. Yikes. This place was so good last year too. Such a shame

Great food!! The breakfast sandwich and veggie burger were fantastic.

I would give The Covington more than 5 stars if I could! The decor is simple and elegant, but the food is out of this world. We shared the fish special (meant for 2-3 people) and it was perfect for tw

We celebrated our second wedding anniversary at the Terrace. Everything from the food to the service was exceptional! We are so glad that the Charlotte Inn restaurant is back in all it's glory! Spec

This independent family-run business has been one of my regular stops at least once every time I am visiting Martha's Vineyard. The food is nourishing and tasty, the service friendly and fast. Every t

I loved this restaurant! Great place for a date night or a girls night out. The outdoor tent area is stunning. Great ambiance and service. Every aspect of our dining experience was exceptional. The e

Nice to have a dq gift card on the house table. Huge, large dipped cone. Dillybars!

Short rib grilled cheese sandwich with tomato bisque soup. I was so surprised at how fabulous it was!!