Antony's Pizzeria - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

As awesome as I remember it. So glad that they reopened.

One of my favorite places to grab a slice of cheese pizza! Just today stopped into grab one and it’s closed. I am sad and disappointed. I pray that those recipes make it to another oven and soon!

Can't believe the news today that Antony's was closing! Some of the better, more unique pizza in the area for 30+ years. Definitely a staple of Beaver County. I still remember the old location where Candy Express used to be.. many great memories! We really hope you are reopening at another location, Antony's! You've been too good for this dumpster fire of a mall for too long . . . Your business deserves better!

Not to many restaurants, let alone pizza joints, I give 5 stars. Mike's crew gives quality food in a timely manner. Consistency is important to me!

Sorry but they have the most delicious pizza my family is hooked, we drive many miles just to get it💓😋

My boyfriend and I go almost every other weekend and get a whole 17 inch pizza and they've never once made us feel weird for buying a whole pizza where as most people by it by the slice there. We've tried finding even similar pizza in different places but nothing is as good as theirs.

Vegetable pizza very very good nice and crispy no flop

Best pizza hands down anywhere! I could eat this everyday.

The Italian Hoagie meal was a staple of my diet when I worked at the mall 25 years ago. The owner is one of the nicest people you will ever meet and he always hires quality people. My wife and I were back in the area so we of course had to order from Anthony’s. 2 Italian hoagies that were just as good as I remembered. Thank you for the great food and the memories! It was so good to see the owner again after all these years.

I think it’s the best pizza in the county, I hope they stay in business when the mall inevitably closes

Always great food and service. This is always our go to place at the mall.

I've gone there for years. I've had a number of their items & I have always been pleased. The owner & his staff are always very nice. I'd recommend Anthony's to anyone.

Service was friendly, and pizza was well done. Would definitely recommend.

I ate here every time I went to the mall as a teen in the 90's. I was floored to see it was still there on a visit back to my old hometown. The same great taste and even the same man at the counter. That just doesn't happen much these days. I felt like a kid again. A++

Delicious! My husband was saying he didn’t want “mall pizza.” This is an amazingly delicious pizzeria that just happens to be in a mall! He has since changed his tune after trying it.

There are a lot of pizza shops in the Beaver Valley, but none as delicious as Antony's! Quality toppings, courteous fast service. Not greasy and piping hot. Ask for it crispy...

Best new York style pizza in western Pennsylvania. Stop by and grab a real slice. Really good bacon cheeseburger pizza. I love this place.

I can't say enough about this place, I just love ❤ 💕 ♥, love 💘 this place, Good People, Good Food, Exceptional Customer service 5 Stars 🌟🌟 ⭐🌟 ⭐

Love the location and staff prices are fair

Such a classic pizzeria. I have been eating their pizza for years! Never disappointed!

Hands down the best pizza in the state... fresh pepperoni pizza. Fast and friendly service.

We loved the pizza customer service was good price was responsible especially considering the food we got. Very big pizza

I’ve been coming here since i was 6. Awesome staff and easily the best pizza in beaver county.

Best pizza in the Pittsburgh area, by far.. ny/Philly style pie; make sure you get a fresh one!

Anthony's Pizza is a awesome pizza shop I'm going to this place ever since I was a little kid I remember it being on the other side of his Beaver Valley Mall right beside the arcade and across from Olan Mills.

Food is just ok but the service was pretty good

I absolutely love this place. Great food, fast and friendly service and all for a great price! I’ve gotten their #3 special (a huge Italian hoagie, a drink and chips for 5.99) 3 times this week!! This is the best place to eat in the entire mall and around it! The workers treat every single customer as a friend and the owner is there everyday!

Excellent pizza, Staff was very fast and kind

Fantastic pizza. Absolutely love it.

This place has been my favorite food spot ever since I was 5 years old. Such good hoagies, good pizza, and great service. I live out of state and used to live in Pennsylvania but every time I come into town it’s always a go too! This place is AMAZING!!

Delicious pizza. Very friendly staff. They even gave us a box for our leftovers. Definitely recommend. There drinks are good to.

Have been around for at least half a century and theres a reason for that, great food. You get what you pay for. Food cooked the old fashion way, in an oven not on a conveyor belt. Most of the time owner is on site. You have to give them a try!

We are very lucky to have this gem here. I can't belive they are inside the mall. The quality surpasses most pizza places with they're own establishment in the area. Easy to place an order over the phone and pick it up or get slices to eat there, if you enjoy good pizza, I think it's worth a try. The price is definetly right. They even were able to split our bill in half so that my girl and I could use on our own payment methods and didn't charge us extra. Very friendly people here! Here's a menu!

Absolutely my favorite pizza we call and take out a lot and they have more than just pizza , all great food and the price is spot on.

We drove for about an hour just to eat here.

Best pizza and calzones in the valley. Actually, just all around great Italian food served with a smile

Good pizza subs and good service

Great Pizza..really enjoyed having it at Christmas party

The pizza is excellent. I especially love their mushrooms. If you are just getting a couple slices, it can be pricey. It's best to buy a full pizza for the money. For those shopping at the Beaver Valley Mall, this is a great place to eat.

Good pizza, not the absolute best but certainly delicious. The prices are somewhat high but not super expensive.

Lived in that area for the first 20 years of my life and the pizza was awesome. Stopped back to Anthony's today because I was in the area for business and had two slices of the cheeseburger pie.. It is even better than I remembered. The guys that work there are the same people and are as awesome as they were decades ago. Will need to get back there more often.