Authentic New York Pizza Inc in Orlovista - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Real NY Pizza place with amazing food. Run down on the inside, broken tables, dirty bathroom, angry looking but nice man at the register Just like home. Wouldn’t want it any other way

Been coming here since 2010, and will still come here.

Great prices 🍕 was really good crust too

Good food, good service. Tastes just like home. Bathroom is gross and dirty. Seats are all busted and all table tops were gross. To go only. I could see them cool which is why I ate the food. Might go elsewhere with friends/fam cause it will not

Love this place....Greek salad, garlic knots, lasagna, pizza, calzone, philly cheese steak.....they have the best Italian made food ever

This place is the best when it come to real NY Italian food. Calzones, lasagna, subs, salads and much much more. They treat you like family and I wouldn’t have it any other way. Down to earth, excellent cooks and never a complaint. If you are looking for a NY feeling with Italian taste look no further!!!! Once you check it out you will definitely know what I’m talking about!

Grumpy old man at the register and excellent food. I am not a true pizza eater but have tried many in 50 years and the pizza is my top choice I'm sure he is a nice guy so I just treat him like the soup kitchen naz##### from Seinfeld show, place my order don't make eye contact and move along.

My boss loves this pizza place, and I see why. Service is great. The gentleman at the front taking orders and cooking are all super nice. The pizza is delicious and super fresh. I'm definitely not disappointed in that aspect. But.....what I didn't like was the number of teenagers allowed in the establishment that are not consuming anything and just sitting around taking up seats, being rude and disrespectful amongst themselves and with customers! The owners need to control that crowd in their establishment, or it's gonna run off their clientele.

Amazing pizza, friendly staff, great price

I have tried every pizza place in my area, and I do mean every place, not commercial, and hands down the best. Hot subs are good. The owner seems grumpy but I can work with that, since he does not come with the food. I myself am not a big pizza eater but I will get down on pizza from this place.

Authentic style NY Pizza cooked to order while you wait or you can call and order it your choice foods excellent give them a try I guarantee you want regret it.

Always good food and friendly service ☺️

The only authentic NY pizza in Orlando. I love this place. Hands down the stuff cheese pizza is a vibe.

Food was not really good to be as expected. Cheese slices a bit pricy.

This used to be my favorite pizza place I’m not sure if they changed chefs/cooks but the last couple times I’ve ordered the pizza is not properly cooked through and falls apart. Very disappointing

Place has great customer service . Food is excellent for the price..

Really good food and service. Great “hole in the wall” location

Phenomenal pizza subs all of it pretty good eat there as much as I pass

Upon arrival, the cashier gives off a vibe that he'd rather be anywhere else but there. But, its also the first pizza place I've been to that actually brings you your pizza. The pizza was really good, but the wings were subpar. Wings are decent size but dry. Buffalo sauce tastes like flavored vinegar and not spicy at all. The service was redeemed by the rest of the staff I'll admit. I can't say I'll be happy to be a frequent customer, but I've had worse service and food from the well-known chain pizza restaurants.

The pizza is not cooked in a traditional oven. It’s cooked on a screen (you could see the screen pattern indentation on the bottom of the crust) which would NEVER happen in a real NY pizzeria. Not cooking the pizza in a pizza oven makes the crust soft and, let’s face it, NY pizza is all about the crust. NY pizza this is not. However, the sauce was very good and there was a generous amount cheese.

We love the pizza here. The best pizza in Orlando. Makes me feel like I'm in NY Prices are awesome

Their food has always been so good and I've never had a bad experience

Been coming to this pizza place since I was 10 years old. Amazing pizza !! The wings are amazing ! Definitely recommend ! Same owner same people. Love the environment.

They always change the prices but never update the menu.Poor management.

Pizza is amazing. The crust is crunchy and so yummy.

Best Pizza Around, We only order here native NYers. If your missing home and looked for some good pizza and great service, This is it!

The food is pretty good but def room for improvement.

It's one of those amazing " mom & pop" pizza joints. A very good energy there. You can dine in with your family and friends or take out. I highly recommend you visit.

Great food and the owner and staff are welcoming to crews taking lunch! Very fast service.

Great customer service. Pizza is the best in the area! I'm definitely a regular.

One of my favorites..never tasted actual "New York Pizza" but if I had to guess it would taste like this pizza👍

The best pizza and Subs in Orlando. We ordered pizza and Chicken Parm sandwich and it was very delicious. Definitely my spot in Orlando. The owner and staff was very attentive and made us feel like family. Hands down the best! Thank you all for having us.

Ótima pizza, massa crocante e saborosa. Espaço estruturado para ayender preferencialmente por delivery, portanto descuidado na arrumação e decoração.

Family owned carry out and dine in, all foods are made to order

The crust is one of the we've have in very long time. Service was very friendly and helpful.

This is THEE spot for NY Pizza, I am a Kings County native and this the best pizza I've had in Florida.

Food was pretty good and service was great. Otherwise, the restaurant is very dirty, and It was incredibly difficult to eat my Calzone with a flimsy plastic fork. I will not be back.

Usually go to the same pizza places in the area so wanted to try something different. I was pleased with the food and the prices were decent. It was $23.99 for a large one topping pizza. 10 wings and Garlic knots. Also got a small fire. No complaints on the food all was very good. Wings were nice and crispy just the way I like them. I gave 4 stars because the place did not look well kept and could use a deep cleaning. There was also a man sleeping in the booth with half his body hanging on the floor. A worker came over and kept kicking him telling him to wake up. Very odd. If I had children I would think twice to leave them in the car if picking up food.

One of best pizza place in Orlando. I'm from Massachusetts and I haven't had good pizza until I when here.

Top notch pie and the closest to NYC pie ever

Ordered through Uber tonight. Absolutely horrible. I requested less mozzarella and more ricotta. Of course they didn’t follow the instructions. The 2 calzones were so chewy and the dough sour that it was inedible. They charged a fortune for a large cannoli and sent the smallest cannoli I’ve ever seen. When the food is good, it’s very good, but unfortunately that’s a hit or miss. Never ordering again.

Scrummy pizza and other dishes as well.

Literally they have the best garlic knots 🤤and they are always fresh !!!

Great pizza! Calzones are incredible.

My son and I really enjoyed the Stromboli

Super delicious, fresh ,just how I wanted it,👍❤️🫶 just like NY pizza 🍕😋

Best New York style pizza in the area

My order was delivery, it arrived piping hot, tightly sealed...no complaints there. I ordered eggplant rollatini. Everywhere I've had it, there was marinara sauce on it. This had more of a light brown sauce. Maybe a NY recipe? The garlic knots were also burnt on the bottom.

GYRO, Pizza traditional NY style. Receipts and cooking style reminiscence of Bronxs style.

Best pizza ever! I love they open up so early!!

This place is very good. The staff is so friendly and courteous. I had to try the garlic knots after reading so many reviews and I am very pleased. You get a free can of soda or water if you order one of the daily specials. I ordered the three ingredients Stromboli. Everything tastes so fresh and delicious. I highly recommend this restaurant!

If you come here get the Calpine it's amazing 👏

Love this place everything is so good , pizza & wings are the best ! Probs one of the only pizza joints I trust in Orlando honestly

Food is always hot and delicious! I'll be back!

I find myself trying to compare other pizza joints to this and the truth is i simply cant! This is easily my favorite pizza spot in orlando❤️ The cheese is perfect, very light tomato sauce, the PERFECT crust(if garlic butter is added) and very reasonably priced! Love this place, wont eat any other pizza in orlando

No se si cambiaron la receta de la pizza o la salsa pero no es igual antes era una verdadera pizza de ny ahora no tiene sabor he ido 3 veces a ver y nada así q cambiaré de pizzeria

Just like NYC Beef Patties With cheeses. Pizza is Yummy and they have Cannolli's. Great Service!

I was treated rudely and was rushed to order and got my food burnt and dry……..as I waited for my order for a very long period of time the cook was watching tv as my food was burning……and gave it to me as is and the fries were burnt as well at the sub I recommend you go to gyros they treat customers better and serve non burnt food and there was HAIR IN MY FOOD THE COOK HAD NO HAIR NET This is a better restaurant called gyros here’s there adress 5507 W Colonial Dr Orlando, FL 32808 United States

This is my spot when I want a good pizza for a good price

Awesome service and great pizza. Everyone working here is so friendly. Also the prices are really good. This is my go to pizza spot.

First time here. This place is surprisingly tastey. I should have known when the old guy in a wifebeater and massive arm hair handed me my pizza that it was going to be real deal italian pizza. These guys know whats up here.

I love this place. The food is fresh and sooo good and served hot. The staff is so friendly and helpful, as well. I always get the veggie stromboli with garlic knots. Try it. You will not be dissapointled.

Great food the best pizza ever and nice staff

Love the food here it is great friendly atmosphere

Pizza by the slice, two pepperoni slices and a coke for less than $7. This place is insane, nowhere can I get a deal like this. I’m not talking about tiny little Cesar slices, NY slices which are hella big. This place is an institution.

Their pizza is always on point! My go to every time!!

Best cheesesteak in metro west. Love the lunch deals. My dad's been going for years as a regular. Good guys, great food.

Don't waste your time trying other places for good pizza. If your from the big cities of the northeast and you want a good pie, you have to go to "I Love NY Pizza and Subs". The people who work there are great people, very family oriented.

Surprised by the quality. Better than the top 3 chains. Price is reasonable also. I will be a regular.

Llevo 3 años visitando este lugar, Nunca me decepcionan Siempre la misma Calidad, Me encanta la Pizzaa, Sin duda la Mejor que he comido..

Great clean new York style pizza 🍕

I love the service is very good and fast

The Pizza I got was excellent wow. I’m from Jersey and wanted some good pizza I heard pizza wasn’t to good down in Florida like it is up here. I wanted something good for lunch so I opened the Uber eats app looked for something good down in Orlando and said let me try this place and see what it’s about. My first bite I was surprised how good it was. Can’t wait to get it again and try other things there.

All I have to say is I tried to Pizza and I am a pizza Guru they really were in the top five in the whole Orlando area number one still held by Tony's New York Pizza on New York Ave DeLand Florida

Excelente pedido de variedades de piza.

Absolutely loved this pizza that I got from Ubereats! My pizza was still hot when it came and it was so delicious! So happy that me and my family found such a good pizza place.

Always love this place to go to. They have great customer service, specials and the pizza is always on point. My go to dish is pizza and fries.

The pizza is off the chain delish the slides are huge n tasty I've been going here for years my whole family loves it n the crew are great. Indiah

Always amazing service and delicious food. Fresh always

Only place I eat pizza. Every time I go the food is great. I love the stromboli. The owner is very friendly and remembers us. He is very gracious for our business. Any one who has not tried them they should. There prices are fare.

I wanted to try a different pizza place and this one always comes up on my search engine. I've been hesitant to try but finally did and they did not disappoint. I ordered through Uber Eats and the food was still piping hot even when it arrived at my house 35 mins later! The meat calzone was amazingggg. The flavor it had was great. The pizza sauce they use has a different taste from most which really made me love it here. Will definitely be back to try more menu items!

I am a DOORDASH DRIVER AND I LOVE NEWYORK PIZZA

I was craving a couple of slices of NY style pizza and found this hidden jem. They have a special for $4.99 that comes with 2 slices of cheese pizza and a free can of soda. I opted to upgrade to the Deluxe pizza at it was only $1 more for $6.00! The crust was crispy and the cheese was very flavorful and warm with just the perfect amount of oiliness that you expect from NY style pizza. I would definitely recommend this restaurant and would come back here the next tome I’m in this part of town!

Have for many years loved that Pizza shop.

Staff friendly. Food was mehhh pizza was not too good and wings were literally just sprinked with hotsauce

The best pizza, chicken wings Ever!!

This is my second day ordering and oh my goodness I don’t know how people can write bad review about this place there food is so so delicious and was very hot

Well I got a beefpayty with cheese they didnt have coco bread no wasn't ny at all Also the pizza looks small this noo ny at all but the beef patty was well done and delicious

Good pizza with crunchy crust. 2 slices and a can of soda for $4.99 is a good deal.

Food good and free can soda when you buy to slices of pizza s

Great pizza. Reminds me of what real NY pizza is

The Food is A 1 & the service is top notch, I recommend you eat there,take the family 👍

Love the pizza here good special offers

Pizza was ok but lacked in flavor. A New York style place but not New York taste. Wings were good not too bad. I don't think I will return as there much better pizza places in Orlando.

I love the wings my boys love there pizza

Nice small business. They even remember my family!

My grandkids love this place. Food is great. Love those cheese patties.

BEST PIZZA IN ORLANDO!!! Highly recommend!

Best pizza in Orlando!!!! Their marinara sauce is amazing!!!! The pizza was as authentic as getting an actual NY slice of pizza!!!

Been there too many, I order different stuff every time, always good and friendly staff and my kids love their pizza.. Love NY pizza!!