Bagful O' Bagels - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Employees always friendly n helpful

A simple order..got a terrible hard as a rock bagel,with lettuce that was dripping water, 1 slice of Swiss? And a heaping amount of tomato? Very disappointing 😞 I think I dislocated my jaw...awful

Good bagels, crispy on outside chewy on the inside but a little on the smaller side. Only bagel place I've been to that charges as much for a butted bagel as a bagel with cream cheese.

BEST BAGELS. The staff are always smiling and very courteous, polite and very friendly. God bless

The food is always good whatever you get... ONE OF THE BEST COLESLAWS 👌 👍

Good bagels, however $11 for 2 bagels and a chocolate milk will keep me from returning.

Pretty good bagels. My only complaint is their coffee cups!!! I should know by now not to order coffee with my bagel. They leak along the seam. So, get the bagels but coffee elsewhere

Such good eagles and coffee. But oh! The special treats for Valentine's Day... outstanding! Thanks guys!

Always quick and friendly. Food is always good

BFB is a great place, always quick courteous service and the bagels and sandwiches are overloaded with quality meats and cheeses. Have breakfast & lunch there every week.

Coming from baguette capital of the world 🇫🇷 France. I was seeking out the best baked taste of the American Bagel. And this is by far one of the very best In this small town of Jersey made right on site. The Jalepeno Cream Cheese has also the right kick 👌. Their rolls are also hand made here. 2 Hard working impressionable guys working the store. Just love this spot you can only catch this treat up till 2pm though. So make sure you make it there before then!

Got a ham, egg and cheese. There was a ton of ham, very yummy.

Disappointed I always stop there on our way to PA never have been Disappointed until today I ordered 6 bagels to go,I opened my bag and 3 were burnt,very upset that they were put in my bag

Great local place for bagels and sandwiches. Bagels made daily on site and are very good. Workers are friendly and efficient.

Excellent variety of bagels...perfectly toasted everything bagel w cream cheese..😊

These guys are so friendly and all their food is extremely consistent. I go out of my way to stop here because I've never been disappointed. Keep it up guys. You're great!

always the cleanest place . greatest bagels and sandwiches . fast and friendly service . make it a pleasure to stop at this family owned and run deli

After all these years the bagels are the best in Sussex County. Service is always good. Thank you for my yummy breakfast.

Very nice people,food delicious Keep up the good work!!!

Hands down the BEST everything bagel around & the breakfast sandwiches are completely on point!

I love this place. Food is always excellent. The staff is always kind. The bagels are excellent with the most interesting flavors (like the bacon egg and cheese bagel and French toast bagel), as well as the other baked goods like the coffee cake.

They are amazing every time very cheep also I stop here once a week because they are so good if you haven't been here I would try it

It is great to go and get great food and they know you by name!!!

After an unpleasant experience at a bagel shop up the road (I won't name names, but it's exactly 1.8 miles south of here), I stumbled upon Bagful O Bagels. I should be thanking that other rude shop for doing me a favor! Bagful O Bagels has a great atmosphere, friendly employees and best of all - quality bagels! Much appreciated! I'll be back next time I'm in the area

Great food love their sandwiches

We love this place. Great for all kinds of bagels, omelettes, and many other items. The prices are very reasonable and the staff is terrific. Very friendly and service oriented. Highly recommended!

Another great bagel place real bagels not bagels cooked on convection ovens real bagels and you get a bag full 15 great people own it to

Small bagel and not much cream cheese

Great local bagel place. Super friendly staff with great bagels.

HOT BAGELS MADE THE OLD FASION WAY !! Family Run & Excellent Customer Service !! PHONE IN ORDERS & PICK UP !!

Best around... Prices, people, and especially THE FOOD

Just spent 15 dollars here today. All the bagels that I asked to be toasted were burnt! My two children couldn't even eat them they were so hard. I called up and not even a apology. As you can tell they were burnt. The girl should have discarded them qnd made them again.

This place was the best! The owners were so friendly and the breakfast was wonderful. Toasted bagel and muffins - perfection. The chocolate/caramel/pretzel bark was an added treat.

Really small bagels yet no cheaper than any other bagel shop. Stopped in the other day during work in the morning for an untoasted cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese. The bottom of the bagel was so burnt and hard that I could only eat the top and when the bagel isn't much bigger than a frozen lenders bagel I was still pretty hungry afterwards. So many other better choices around the area unfortunately. The kids working in there are friendly but I'm not at a bagel shop to make friends I'm there to get breakfast.

Always love stopping at Bagful when I can. Specials are always reasonable,coffee is great and everyone is always very friendly.

Best bagel in new jersey and great Taylor ham egg and cheese!!!

Love their breakfast sandwiches!

love this place, great bagels and everything I've sampled from the menu has been awesome.

Great breakfast and great homestyle food from a family business!

Awesome people behind the counter and the best bagel I’ve ever had!

Without a doubt their bagels are far superior to any other throughout Sussex County. Being from NY and trying several bagel stores in Sussex County you can trust me. They're made the old fashioned way with the best ingredients. The salads are all homemade recipes and not like some other places where one day it is good and the next it taste different. All the workers use the same recipes produced by one of the lovely ladies who is also owner with her husband. The workers are extremely nice and very helpful! ade

The food was good and the workers were very respectful

I give the store five stars, I like shopping here. I always have the products I need on sale. And the prices are reasonable.

Good sandwich and not light on the meat.

Cute little place with a pleasant staff and some darn fine bagels. I've had an egg and cheese bagel sandwich here several times and it's always been delicious. A handful of small tables to sit and enjoy your food and/or coffee in a nice clean setting if you are not on the go. Prices are fair so a trip here won't break the bank.

This is one of my favorite places to stop. Never long lines and the staff is always very friendly. Highly recommend for all your bagel needs.

Good selection and food was good

Sunday breakfast after hiking/camping all weekend. The staff was extremely friendly and kind. I was exhausted and the girl behind the counter heard me say I needed coffee, she turned around and voila...coffee... she then continued with taking the order and didn't skip a beat. The food was delicious and tasty. Don't miss the opportunity to visit this gem. I had the mouthful and it certainly was...a delicious mouthful. Coffee...Delicious. The menu covered everything you could want. I was so busy reading it that I didn't see the iced cinnamon roll in the case by the counter (next time it's mine lol).

I'm from NJ but live in WV and never fail to stop and grab a dozen bagels when I'm up for a visit and heading home. Excellent baking and cheerful staff makes the stop even better. Easily the best bagels in NJ.

This is my first time that but I'll be back again breakfast was fantastic

Best bagels, food, and staff anyone could ever ask for. Such a unique place as well. One of a kind. Breakfast sandwiches are #1 in the county will always be going to bagful. And you should too!

Good food , very good service and plenty of choices to choose from.

Alright, we have plenty of bagel shop options in this area, no question. BUT, bagels here are not even just generally better than the surrounding options, but with the love and care put into these bagels has made getting bagels from other shops akin to buying grocery store bagels. Yeah, you might have a place closer to you, but when you want an amazing bagel? Now you know the place to go, it's Bagful. Amazing service, and good taste in music (I liked the System of a Down playing this morning). Based on another review I was also curious about the smoked jalapeño cream cheese, and I was allowed to try it. Let me tell you, TRY IT. I know I will be trying other flavors for sure. Great job to the staff, and the owners who created such an amazing place.

Best Bagels love the employees all so friendly caring

Friendly thoroug service, great food. We had bagel with lox and the tomatoes and onions were so fresh it was delicious!

Great place to get some breakfast sandwiches and coffee with a great selection of pastries too. Family run business with a cozy atmosphere. Great.

First time there! Lovely, warm atmosphere, great service and delicious homemade sandwiches and baked goods.♡

Lovely breakfast spot with seating inside and out.

LOVE this place. The family that runs it is so pleasant And kind. They know everyone by name and the bagels are the BEST!

Great food and the staff is really nice!!!

Good bagels! Great sandwiches! Plenty of seating! Ample parking. I always stop here for breakfast or lunch when I’m in the area.

Good bagel breakfast sandwich, not great coffee, nice people.

I haven't been there in 15 years, but it's on my list of places to go when I come out next month. I used to stop just about every morning on my way to work in Dover from Dingmans Ferry and got the BEST bagels ever. Can't wait!

Eggselent breakfast sandwiches!

Great service with decent selection. Tasty bagels and fair portions for a good price. Very colorful environment. Highly recommend!

Wow. This is one of the best bagel sandwiches in the state. Turkey with tomato on an everything bagel. Can't beat it. And this is a guy who worked in Brooklyn for 18 years. I've eaten a lot of good bagels and this one of them.

Love this charming place. Always go there when visiting my son in Wantage

Top notch. Excellent food. The best bagels in sussex county. Excellent staff and service.

I'd say best place to get bagels!! They are absolutely delicious and have a great variety!!

Love this place! The bagels are always made fresh and taste amazing. Will always continue to come here!

Amazing bagels. Great coffee. Fresh cream cheese and more importantly great customer service

Fresh bagels all the time. The smoked jalapeño cheddar cream cheese is amazing. Quick service and excellent staff.

Nice selection of breakfast and lunch. Friendly staff and good quick service. The best bagels in Jersey.

Fast service fresh food good prices

Always Great, best bagels & Overstuffed sandwiches @ very reasonable prices ! Super Friendly Staff.

Great bagels, family business with a friendly environment. Breakfast or lunch, just aquick call and it's ready when you walk in.

Fast service. Baked goods and pastries. Hot and cold sandwiches. Variety of cream cheeses and bagels available. Fair pricing. I would have given it five stars, but personally I like my bagels a little softer. Also have fresh salads.

Friendly staff.... awesome bagels!!!

These are the best bagels I have had in a long time

Delicious food and great staff! I eat hear about 2 times a month and love it every time!

Best breakfast sandwich around! Wonderful family run business! Everyone that comes in is treated like family.

Friendly staff. Very good bagels

Great bagels!!!!!!! Also great sandwich!!!!

Go here for breakfast and get yourself a "Mouthful"!!! You won't regret it. Friendly service, clean space and best breakfast sando around.

Food was really good and dessert better

Best customer service from dedicated people

I never ate here. But I had a panic attack right outside. My daughter was on the phone with 911 and brought it to their staff. They talked to the 911 and walked 2 troopers on target. One of the troopers was a marine combat vet and knew what I was going through. So to make a short story long, BO'B provided me with food, water and shelter - along providing overwatch on my kids, dog and me. A friend picked me up. I moved on. Moral of the story... you don't have to eat here to know there's love in the world and it's wonderful.

Bagels are fresh and delicious! Their pastries, muffins, and especially their crumb cake are out of this world. Worth the stop for breakfast or lunch. Many choices for sandwiches are available.

Their bagels and breakfast products are phenomenal sandwiches are very good and great coffee and the staff is extremely friendly family run... A great place to get a good meal to eat....

Delicious bagel with cream cheese.

Their bagels aren't doughy and their selection of food is really good. And prices are very reasonable...go enjoy!!

Great food and service as always.

Good bagels. Friendly staff. Lots of options.

Best bagels! Best taylor ham egg and cheese! Tater tots are delicious! Pastries are delicious! Family owned and very friendly.

Great hot dog bagel...Fast service. Friendly people.

best dang sausage, egg and cheese bagels in the tri- state area

Quick service, real good breakfast sandwiches and I like their Tuna Fish too

Our favorite bagel place around! My fiance always split a "mouthful" and it's so good!

This family that owns and runs this bagel shop are absolutely the nicest people you can meet. What a great place to grab a bagel.

Loved it. Awesome staff awesome food.