Barnside Creamery - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

They have the best ice cream I’ve ever had. They also have a good amount of amazing food from which to choose; I do recommend trying their Coney dog. I enjoy their Candy Land Sundae! I highly recommend checking this place out!! FYI: This place only accepts cash.

We went for some waffle cones and saw the foot ling chili dags..... let me say. They are amazing. My new gold standard on chili dogs

This place is very good. From the flavor of the ice cream to the portion sizes to the friendliness of the staff. I highly recommend them.

Ordered a sundae and it was one of the best sundaes I have had in a long time. It was a speciality one but well worth the additional cost. My sundae was also good size. Disappointedly, they do not take cards. They are a cash only establishment.

We always stop when we're near... We especially love the apple dumpling they offer in late summer. To die for!

1st time trying ice cream nachos... they were soooooooo yummy!!!!!!!!! Definitely recommend. I didn't even think to take pictures I was too busy smashing. I'll be back though and I'll add pictures!

This is a terrific place to get ice cream. They have everything you could ever imagine. And then some and the ice cream is absolutely fabulous. It doesn't matter if you want a slush ice cream flurries. Maltz, anything you can ever imagine. This place has they're fast, courteous and kind, and everything is made fresh. To order. So it's not real quick, but it's well worth the wait. Also, the biggest point to remember is this place is cash. Only they do not take credit cards or checks or anything of that nature.So you need to be prepared with cash

Delicious treats , great atmosphere.

This is about a 30 minute drive for us, but well worth it!! The service was fast and very friendly. And the food was so delicious!

I just love their Dole ice cream made with juice not milk. Fabulous flavors. Mango right now. Pomegranate before this and pineapple before that. I am hoping for strawberry or raspberry next flavor change. Enjoying the mango while it lasts. Very good !

Great little stop on the way to/from the Erie shores! Highly recommend stopping for ice cream, Dole whip, hot dogs, or even a hot chicken sandwich. Just remember, CASH ONLY!

Shredded chicken sandwiches are really good

Perfect stop after a trip to White Star Quarry.

Daily special? GOOD Ice cream? GOOD CONEY DOG?! GOOOOOD

Nice treats and friendly staff! Expect to pay tourists prices!

They serve Tofts ice cream always fresh and creamy. Great staff every year!

Great food It's pretty close to the road, so it's kinda loud when ordering. Little walk and they have sweet covers tables to eat your snacks Big parking lot will fit a simi

Best ice cream and best service ever!!! It’s our tradition to visit Barnside Creamery every time we drive here for birding.

Lovely little drive-through with several outdoor tables for dining. I highly recommend the ice-cream nachos (picture attached). The sundaes, flurries, and cones are also delicious. The staff are friendly and the service is fast for a small business. 10 STARS

Really just wanted to leave a review on our most recent experience. I know they just opened for the season, but retraining needs to be done. Waited in drive thru line for 30 minutes. Then when it was our turn we witnessed them take 6 walk up window orders before walking over to the drive thru window to take our order. I believe it should be equal as drive thru needs to move more quickly than the walk up

Yummy Yummy and cute names of items on their menu

Apple dumpling was good. Soft serve is OK. Cash only!

Great food , buckeye sundae was awesome, the caramel was good but felt to like the caramel flavorings over powered it some , the chicken salad sandwich and potato salad was good , but only a 4 star due to not having a bathroom , a Porta potty would be fine. Will definitely be back though

we have been stopping here for an ice cream for 3 years on our trips to Maine from Michigan. your chicken sandwich and potato salad have also never disappointed. it's too bad your employee (yes, only 1) doesn't know the menu and is rude enough to convince us never to come back. PS, Starry is on the menu, AND it is also a Pepsi product. next time don't argue with your customers.

Ice cream is so delicious like homemade! Worth the drive!

Ice cream shops are getting crazy expensive.

OMG delicious. The banana split in a cup was epic! In size and taste. Great value for the price also.

Huge menu with something for everyone. Generous portions.

We stopped for ice cream on a whim, and I enjoyed their limited time orange sherbet cone. I chose the vanilla twist bc I love the dreamcicle flavor from my childhood. It was sooo good! It did not disappoint. The service was excellent as well. So glad we stopped.

Great place to stop for a treat after a day at Cedar Point! Delicious ice cream and service with a smile!

Very nice place to stop along route 2 for a bite to eat or some ice cream. Please note, you will need cash

All I can say is "yum!" Worth the stop every time!

Love this place and close to home

Great ice cream , unique flavor will return

I absolutely love stopping at the Dairy Barn as often as possible. Everything is so very good.

Great ice cream and service as always!

Love this place. Ther have quick service, great prices and the portions.

Great place to grab a quick sandwich or tasty ice cream treat.

Wonderful stop for some great ice-cream! Prices are reasonable since the portion sizes are very generous. A ton of flavors and toppings to choose from. The staff were friendly and service was quick. It's an easy place to stop and enjoy a tasty treat. No bathroom and cash only. I ordered everything small and it was more than enough for us!

Friendly staff. Cash only. No public restroom. Couple large picnic tables. Also has a drive thru. Pictured are small cones chocolate & watermelon

I really enjoy going here. They have the best ice cream that I know of! They also have amazing Coney Dogs! The only sad part is that they only accept case and not credit. Other than that, I highly recommend giving this place a try! 🍦

Stop for the dole whip, whenever we go to our boat

Definitely worth stopping at. Tons of sundae options.

Raspberry sherbet ice cream 🍦 😋

Best footlong Coney I've ever had this place just knocks it out of the park great service great place overall

Always friendly service in great ice cream

Had the ice cream nachos with peanut butter and strawberries! Highly recommend for those of us who love peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. The young lady taking the orders, Maddie, is an absolute joy! So helpful and always has a smiling face!

A nice place to stop for a refreshing cone. Portions are generous, especially for a hot summer day .

These servings are huge! They have 2 open silos with tables in them to eat. What cool farm themed idea. Plenty of parking, quick service, drive-thru and can handle high volume of people. Lots of room for kids to run around and be kids. Set far enough back that the route 2 traffic isn't too noisy or dangerous.

Definitely stop if you're going to pass it by

Excellent as always !! Great service ! Still very friendly people ! And big portions..

Fun place to stop for hot dogs and ice cream! They have picnic tables near the building but also covered tables in the back. No public toilets available.

ATM one minute away, just east and across the road at MaGee East Marina for those that forget their cash. Fabulous ice cream choices & service.

We come here every season, love it!!!!

Nice little area to walk or sit. Delicious food, ice cream and they have only8!! Also nice employees!

Their icecream is amazing. Glad I made it out before they close for the season. PS. Theyre cash only so make sure you have some on you.

If you ever go to oakharbor or you take state route 2 to cedar point you HAVE to stop there (bring the puppies too) they are so good they have great selection reasonable prices and great staff they normally close for the season around late September so hurry up and head out there

Amazing place if you want ice cream and you are in the area

Love this place. Always stop when I pass by.

Ice cream scoop was HUGE so get a small unless you want a bunch 💙 the chicken sandwich was soooo good too.

Stopped by after a volleyball game for a treat. Everybody ordered a different flavor sundae & they were huge! The grasshopper sundae & buckeye one were the favorites.

Love this place best malts ever

Dolewhip all day long! Only place around you can find it

Ice cream is great. HUGE servings for what you pay. Sherbet by the way, is blue for anyone curious.

Great ice cream always has a good amount of toppings.

The best soft serve around. It was worth the drive. Just make sure you have cash. No credit cards here.

This is the best ice cream place around. Lots of great choices. This is a summertime treat for me and the family.

Always good, cash only. It's our favorite ice cream place to stop at.

Favorite local place to get ice cream!

Good food, delicious treats, even our fur baby gat her own ice cream 🍦

Nice little place along route 2 excellent banana split boat have to stop again recommend this to anybody nice friendly people

Excellent service and portions are unbelievable! My family and I loved this place!

They are cash only. Hands down best ice cream ever. And GREAT specials! Love this place.

Great place make sure you have cash.

I would have given 5 stars but there was no restrooms.

I would like to give it 5 stars, but just can't due to it being "cash only". Menu was pretty diverse & everything sounded good. I just rarely carry cash anymore so I was unable to try anything.

My favorite ice cream stop in the area. Must get a doggie treat for your puppy, and the cloud maker is amazing

I would give five stars but my Chocolate milkshake was did not have a lot of chocolate )flavor and it wasn’t super Thick it was more on runny side so not my fav milkshake by far!However everything my husband and kids ordered was excellent , they all had sundaes and flurries, not much seating outside and no shade ! Definitely needs some awnings or sun shade and more seating, we had to eat in car

It’s excellent- they only take cash though. Drive through moves quicker than you may expect.

This is a quaint little place in the middle of a county road. The ice cream is good and they are VERY generous with their toppings. I recommend just ordering a small, it’s a lot! The only downside here is that this place is cash only. So come prepared!

The line is always long, so it must be good right? The best part of going to this place is the scenery on the way there and back. I love going at sunset and watching the sun set on the lake after getting my dessert!

Ice cream is good, need to advertise MUCH better that they are cash only. Not just a tiny sign on the widow where you order.

Have always had a great experience here. Food is always good .... And the ice cream is delicious!!! Pleasant staff.

Cash only but if you're prepared they have tons of awesome delicious food. Always stop here when we're in the area.

Best ice cream we have had in a very long time! Real ice cream!

Not a fan of soft serve with limited flavors. Plenty of mix ins and great service. Cash only.

Delicious ice cream & great prices!

Small ice cream cone is nearly too much to eat. Get your cone as cone cup.

Best ice cream ever! Our kids love going here & wish they were open all year long. 🙂

Good ice cream. Generous servings.

DELICIOUS!! As always! Lewie loved it, too! ❤🐾😊

Awesome 👌. The apple dumpling was delicious.

Nice quick stop for some food & drink while riding. Covered outdoor seating area!

The chocolate malt was very good.

The apple dumpling was very good

Apple dumpling was amazing... and my daughter had the pineapple ice cream it was delicious! One thing to know is they are cash only here .

The ice cream cone was HUGE and delicious!

Medium swirl cone, super big and they have the best ice cream. Dont change a thing. Yummy.

Holy buckets of ice cream. Bring your appetite because they give you way too much

Great ice cream and good prices.