Black Magic Pizza in Orlando - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I come here at least 2-4 times a week and lemme tell you, easily some of the best Zaa in the Orlando area.. and in general!! The staff here is truly amazing and offers friendly vibes along with a beautiful orchestrated atmosphere. From the moment you place an order on the phone to the moment the pizza is in your hands, the journey to and from is ethereal to say the least. I would recommend this place to any person who enjoys a quality slice of pizza. The owner is a very hard working individual, with that being said I will always come back here and eat my favorite pizza. One of their specials they have from time to time is called the “Green Goblin” - I highly recommend. Not to mention their service is very quick and seamless for its customers. Thank you Black Magic Pizza for setting a standard in the pizza game

I ordered take out and the mozzarella sticks, buffalo wings and pepperoni pizza were fantastic!

First time coming and my experience was great and worth the wait. I’ve tried alot of pizza places in Orlando and this one is up there. Red sauce and crust are perfect!

The pizza was nice. They have interesting combinations. Their poutine wedge fries with cheese curds were our favorite, and we definitely recommend them. The staff is friendly. It is the definition of a hole in the wall restaurant, having only a pick-up window.

Black Magic is our favorite pizza place in Orlando! We've gotten something different each time and we're always blown away. When we ordered this past Saturday, the man at the window let us know that he didn't think our pizza looked the best when it came out of the oven, so he prioritized getting us a new one right away and then offered us drinks while we waited. We really appreciated the pride he had in his work and his dedication to giving us a quality product. We'll be back! :)

Best pizza in Orlando!! Always hits the spot when I’m craving pizza !!

Great pizza!! Dr. Pepperoni has been wonderful to work with.

Best pizza spot in all of Orlando, hands down. I would die for their garlic knots and I make all of my friends try them at any chance I can get, that’s how good they are. Staff has always been super friendly and service has always been super fast.

Every time I come to Orlando I have to stop here. Never have I had bad service, an issue with an order, or disliked the food. It's always amazing and quickly became a favorite must have. Highly recommend.

Food was great, really cool staff, and though it's carry-out only, there's a lot of local areas that share seating and have additional options to add to the experience. The pizza and knots we had were awesome, we will definitely be back!

The best pizza in Orlando! Tried the Dr. Pepperoni and you can tell a lot of love is put into each pie with super high quality ingredients. The entire staff is fantastic too. Can’t wait for more trips to Black Magic soon!

Highly recommend the hornets nest

Love coming here for my Wednesday special. The best deal in orlando tbh.

Easily the best pizza I have ever had. The garlic knots, the desserts, and the pizza were insanely tasty and we were smiling from ear to ear with every bite. I even had some of the vegan replacements and genuinely could not tell the difference. Everyone was very kind and the food came out very quickly for it being made-to-order. I simply could not recommend this place enough!!!

I don’t think I’ve ever had a more angelic experience than eating garlic knots from here.

the BEST pizza in orlando!! the flavor combos are so unique and they’re all delicious, and the people working there are awesome! also the garlic knots are a MUST

Amazing food, friendly staff and quick service! Some of the best pizza I’ve had ever.

Absolutely outstanding pizza. Amazing crust with a perfect cook. Sauce tasted fresh with a nice touch of garlic and it was the perfect amount of cheese. I just wanted more once it was gone. Some of the best pizza I've had in Florida. Will be back for sure next time we're in the area!

Best pizza in Orlando HANDS DOWN. The White Iverson is next level. Always friendliest service. I have seen my 4 year old eat an entire Cheezus on the car ride back from a pick up once. Fact.

10/10 experience. Little slice of heaven in our backyard. We didn’t know this place existed and will definitely be back! The pizza options are creative but not overly done. All the apps look amazing and the service was white glove 5 star! Definitely recommend.

Amazing pizza! Got the dr.pepperoni and it was crispy, and soft and spicy in all the right ways! Will definitely be back! (:

Great pizza! A bit slow, but they were super busy. Hooked it up with free knots on next visit as a comp though.

One of the best pizza’s I ever had, genuinely. Everyone here is super nice and their consistency’s been on point every time. I haven’t ever been disappointed! I’m addicted to the hornets nest. Please give this place a shot! 🫶🏻

best pizza ever! they never miss

the best pizza in orlando! the owners are so welcoming and friendly. super accommodating to allergies and preferences as well. sauce is perfectly balanced and the dough is incredible. love that they use sourdough, which makes the dough super pillowy soft yet light and crispy. it does get pretty pricey, but you truly are paying for quality and freshness. happy to see that they are getting the recognition and following they deserve.

I stopped by here mostly because I loved the name of this place and was absolutely delighted by the pizza here! We ordered the Dr. Pepperoni and the Tuscan Leather and both of the pizzas were delicious. There is 'dine in' seating available at their partnered establishments next door but mostly this is an order and take out kind of place. I'd recommend ordering ahead of time for pick up because that seems to be much easier. I will definitely be back here- this is probably some of the best pizza I've had since moving to Orlando and I am so glad to have finally found a place I love.

This is a must for anyone in Orlando! The customer service was unmatched, I got my pizza but dropped it accidentally when picking my first slice. The owner offered to remake it for me and I got to enjoy a delicious Dr.Pepperoni which definitely stood up to its name. This experience has made me a long term customer and I would recommend this pizza to anyone.

Blown away by this pizza. Must try if you're in the milk district.

Best pizza of its kind in FL bar none

My girlfriend and I were just blown away by this pizza, got the “Hornets Nest” and “Dr. Pepperoni” some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Got six wings that were pretty good too. New fav pizza spot for sure

Holy Canolli! Go get the strawberry canolli now if it’s available!! Delicious! Pizzas are light Neapolitano style pizza. Amazing pizzas!

If this is black magic, then Dominos must be voodoo. The only thing saving this from the other pizza place mentioned is dubious business practices. Support local businesses! But these were way overpriced for what I got. It was good pizza, and you can eat it at the bar which is a neat atmosphere, but for the price compared to the quality, it's clear Houdini is not the one in the kitchen.

My life would mean nothing without Black Magic Pizza giving me the fuel I need for success 💪🏼 Food: Everything that I've tried on the menu is phenomenal! My girlfriend & I typically only go on Wednesday's for half-priced wings, a side of garlic knots, and an order of poutine to bring to work the next day. My girlfriend will tell you that these are the BEST buffalo wings that she has ever had, and my garlic parmesan are so beyond consistent that I never have to worry about being disappointed. Garlic knots are killer, although if you don't have another to share with, I suggest you opt for the "leftovers tomorrow" route, something I struggle with. Four to six garlic knots and a full order of garlic parm wings tends to leave the tummy a bit upset, of course. The poutine is to die for as well, and the portion is massive. Speaking of portions, the wings are always more than enough to fill you up, the garlic knots are pretty large and come with six I think? The mozzarella sticks usually leave us beyond full, and the pizza itself is also perfect. I would say the pies are a little larger than a normal personal pizza which is perfect. We have only had the pizza two times, but loved every slice. As two young adults we try to save our money the best we can, so Wing Wednesday tends to take precedent over the pizza. Overall, I've never had a bad item on the menu. Service: Cool, nice people. Being a pick-up window, there isn't too much opportunity for conversation, but everyone we've talked to was super chill 👍🏼 Atmosphere: Again, as a pick-up window there isn't much immediate seating available so we used to just eat in our car. Now we typically go sit outside at the Milkhouse right next door. You could even grab a drink there (Foxtail Coffee is always a hit) or even some ice cream for dessert. I already liked the pick-up window for some reason (maybe I'm more antisocial than I always thought) but having the Milkhouse right next door is perfect for everyone involved. All the businesses in the district get more business by working together here, and it's great to see it work out so well. If you can't already tell, I couldn't recommend Black Magic enough and we don't intend on stopping our weekly visits anytime soon!

Went here tonight for a dinner and wow this pizza is amazing, very high quality ingredients. We got the Hornets Nest and the Dr. Pepperoni and we’re both outstanding. Some of the best pizza I’ve had in Orlando. I do recommend online ordering as placing an order in person took about 35 minutes. Highly recommend.

The sesame crust on the Iverson was amazing. Love the brand, the taste, the vibes and the location! Was a perfect pizza.

we come every wednesday for their wings, they’re heavenly, pizza is unique and tasty. my boyfriend has an unhealthy relationship with their poutine, you seriously can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. and all the staff is very kind!!!

When Gabby helps me the world is my oyster.

When it’s good, it’s good. Not much more to say.

The Boof pack and the motz sticks are my favorite, never disappoints! Super kind people too, love to support their buisness.

If you love ‘za you gotta try, it’s worth the price and the hype. We never have any leftovers and we usually order and extra pizza or two per person. They can burn my pizza anytime

I will say this YUM!! first the way they all work together is amazing and creates a fun environment Then comes the food You can tell its made with love of their product straight to you You can end the experience with a home made cannoli or if you're like me and do backwards meals start with one Holy Cannoli You gotta get one Or try all 3 Definitely recommend

Basically a walk up only pizza place. We were at Whiskey Lous & decided to try it. If you order & ask them to deliver it inside Lous they will. Pizza was good to have with a beer at Lou’s but I wouldn’t seek it out. Nothing special about it. Better option than the chicken place that used to be there. *** update 11/16 tried to go at 2 pm but they don’t open until 4 pm

new favorite pizza spot!! everything was so tasty & love how they do fun specials every month! we got the cheezus, mozzeralla sticks, and their special sub of the month “pub sub”. can’t wait to try more items!!

We ordered the garlic knots the mozzarella sticks the poutine the buffalo chicken pizza and the pepperoni pizza add sausage. The mozzarella sticks and garlic knots were our favorite. The garlic knots could have used more garlic or the garlic butter spread on the top of the garlic knots not just in a puddle underneath them. The poutine we requested extra crispy fries and they were pretty soggy but the flavors were decent. The pepperoni and sausage pizza was pretty basic. The buffalo chicken had a nice flavor but both pizzas were pretty Bland overall for $20 a piece each. Overall, we don't know that it was worth $75. Also, unfortunately the walk-up window is terrible when it's pouring rain and parking is so limited that you have to slug through ankle high water to get to and from the window.

Black magic pizza is top tier, the best pizza spot in Orlando!

Visiting from texas saw them on IG. Close to a friends house basically walking distance. Chick up front hot!! And nice gave me some stickers to take back To Texas. Gave them to my metal head doctor who loved them!!! Delicious pizza crust and mozz ooey gooey good. Marinara on point and got a mini show with homeboy tossing that dough up ! A definite win 🏆

We’ve been following them on Instagram for quite some time and finally got a chance to give it a try. The pizza was absolutely fantastic. The crust was slightly charred and thin, just how I like it. The toppings were fresh and obviously high quality. We’ll definitely be back.

1000000/10 top pizza in Orlando. We ordered 2 pizzas, one having pepperoni and the other having pepperoni mushrooms and some other things. Also ordered a hat and the blueberry lemon cannoli. Pizza was absolutely FIREEEE. I accidentally got the wrong cannoli (regular) but it was still fire so it’s totally okay. Lovely service and the staff is friendly and nice.

Friendly people, awesome neo-Neopolitan style pizza. Ordered online and was easy to pick up at their window in the corner of Whiskey Lou's. Only down side to ordering ahead is missing their awesome daily pizza and side specials. Vegan and vegetarian options. So glad these people are doing their thing.

It was ok. My italian genes cringed a little bit. The dough and sauce was good, but the cheese was very odd. It was almost rubbery and tasted like the cheep ones you can get at walmart. But I have to admit, it was definitely better then most pizza places in the USA.

This place is bitchin’. Had the Hornets Nest pizza and it was everything I hoped for and more. The flavors blended together so well and had nice crispy Neapolitan style crust. The cheese tasted like cheese and not just waxy white goo. But I guess that is to be expected. Delicious sauce and the realization that soppressata is wrongly overlooked as a pizza topping. I will be back again to try the other pizzas. But it will be hard not to simply reorder this every visit.

Best pizza place in town. This would be a better joke if they didn’t also have wings: the buffalo chicken pizza is so good that it probably counts as the 4th best wing place in town too.

Honestly this pizza never makes it out of the parking lot for me! Listen to me when I say this, you can’t name a better pizza in this city! I won’t eat pizza anywhere else!

This was absolutely the best pizza I've ever gotten the pleasure to have. "Burnt" pizza gang for life. This crew kills it.

Photo Credit to my wife Jessica. This place is great. The pizza is top notch. Nice an charred. Cup pepperoni perfectly crunch. Delicious flavor. All that said, it is overshadowed by another menu option: POUTINE. There are two places to get poutine in central Florida: 1. the cheese curds truck at Fringe that's here for only two weeks a year 2. BLACK MAGIC PIZZA It is the real deal. The brown gravy is *perfect*. The exact flavor you want on a poutine. The cheese curds are exceptional. The fries are crispy on the outside with a soft delicious interior. It's like Quebec came down and decided to stay for the summer too. The staff said it's a labor of love and it sure tastes like it. Perfection.

Awesome to see a great pizza pop-up open a spot. This trip we got the Cheezus and the DrPepperoni along with their mozz-stix. The Cheezus is a classic cheese pizza, their red sauce is great not sweet - a lot of fresh tomato flavor and the two kinds of cheese are a nice mix. The DrPepperoni has a perfect mix of sweet and salty with the spicy maple, it also adds a nice twist on the typical hot-honey. The mozz-stix are an item we haven’t had before : WOW, this is everything you want in a cheese stick, crispy and seasoned, stringy-stretchy cheese and their awesome red sauce to dip. Check them out if you haven’t!!!

Great experience and food. Great people and vibes too :)

This place has the best pizza in town. If you are ever in the Central Orlando area, do yourself a favor and grab a pie. They even have a Canadian staple poutine!

Amazing food and wonderful service. A friend and I just went and got some merch too and it was such a great surprise. Would definitely recommend the Hornets Nest pizza.

I’d followed them on social media for a long time but my schedule never allowed me a visit. Today - finally- was the day. 1000% worth the hype. Incredible pizza and the greatest staff ever. I will absolutely be back.

First visit at the window, both pizza’s were undercooked. We have never had this issue with the popups. We went out of our way to come here and we were starving, the pizza’s were so floppy and the dough was very soggy and soft. I hope this was a one off experience because this was our favorite pizza in Orlando before this visit. We are afraid to try it again if this is the new norm.

Black magic Pizza has Blessed This Town with their Pizza 🍕 my favorite is The White Iverson but you can not go wrong w anything that is served from their ovens. This is Pizza for Pizza people. Thanks for all your hardwork! Be back soon!!!

Pizza kind of small for the price tag. Feels like they’re exploiting the milk District demographic. Also tipping 30% on the app you order from as a default? Come on you’re going to lose customers that way just leave a tip jar out even wealthy people don’t wNt to pay a 25$ single person pie

Best pizza in town and it's not even close! Perfect crust and pepperoni cups! 🤌🤌

Hands down best pizza in Orlando . Perfectly toasted crust and delicious flavor plus excellent service ! I love it 🤤🤤❤️

Completely worth the hype. Better than the pictures. Poutine is amazing, glad there is a place in Orlando doing it, can’t wait for them to open with regular hours. pizza is unmatched in Orlando. Very nice staff, quick service, reasonable prices. Would reccomend to a friend, or any foodie looking for something truly unique in Orlando.

They burnt my pizza, 10/10 would return.

Best pizza in Orlando , they’re pizza and sides are to die forrrr , the staff is incredible!!