Bro Man’s Sammiches - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Gas station doesn’t take EBT like most, the restaurant makes you get the drinks from the gas station if they are out. Very good food and fast made

I tried the new location on Glenwood Park Ave. I’ve been addicted to Bromans since their food truck days. Their birria is my fav. We also tried their fries which were 🔥 I have to shout out their staff and how amazing they are. Everyone we encountered was so polite and friendly. We didn’t realize they closed at 8 and noticed they appeared to be closing up for the night. We asked when they closed and then apologized for still being there. The employees were so gracious and kind. Food is incredible, and the staff is top notch. This is my fav place to eat in Erie hands down.

Absolutely delicious. Highly recommend!

You walk into the gas station and immediately smell the grills doing their work. I instantly knew just looking at the menu that this was gonna be good, and it didn’t disappoint. They were out of soft drinks in their supply, no worries, we just bought a bottled drink from the store. I’m fine with it if it means there’s an alternative and the strive for good food is there. I got the “big smash”, and I was immediately blown away with how good it was. These are those paper thin smash burgers you see all over the internet these days, and I can easily say it met the hype. Burger was juicy in the center, and the crispy edges added to it. The smash sauce was great and the other toppings were distributed right. I would have to narrow it down, but it’s at least in contention for the best burger I’ve had. The dipper fries were interesting, but a great twist over normal fries. Think of them like a cross between potato wedges and chips. The edges were crispy, while the inside was potatoey like a normal fry. They were seasoned perfectly and something I could probably eat by themselves, then the comeback sauce dip was a great add on to it. So would I recommend this? Absolutely!

I've ate at bro man's about 5 times and it was so good everytime go it keeps me coming back I usually get the Buffalo chicken tacos super good this time I got the jerk chicken tacos trying it for the first time and i have to say I Don know which is better the cook has been blessed by God Also I've tried a few places in erie and this place has the best food I've tried since I've been here If you're in the area give bro man's a try u won't regret it

Two bites in I knew it was top tier. Everyone should try at least once.

The lady at the register was very nice. The food was awesome just wish there was more of the "fries" ☺ not a bad place considering it's in a gas station.

Used to LOVE the ability to choose between tots and fries. Now, all you can get are these dippers? They're awkward and soggy (I get loaded fries/tots, maybe they're fine without being in a loaded dish with sauce on it?). They're just really awkward and worse than both the fries and tots. It's not a deal breaker. Still got some of the best burgers I've ever had. And it's still potato... But it worries me, they're apparently looking for cheaper substitutes....

Gross and greasy. Was not impressed for a place so highly rated.

Absolutely, positively, the best sandwiches in town. My opinion! Unfortunately no photos. I ate it all too fast.

If you’re from out of town, these burgers and Birria tacos will take you out of this world. Try them!!!

Bro Man’s is truly a culinary culture staple in Erie. The burger I tried (Shroom Burger), fries, and dipping sauces were absolutely delicious. and when speaking with the owner, you could truly tell the quality ingredients and love they put into of the food. The prices were actually very reasonable, which surprised me at first, especially as I learned they had to raise their prices about a week before I stopped in. The atmosphere and vibe were incredible when checking out their new location. Absolutely recommend stopping in and checking it out in person! Very happy to have found another amazing Erie food location.

Excellent service, very friendly and helpful and the food was incredible! Food was fresh, hot and sooo tasty! If you're nearby definitely stop in, you'll be glad you did!

If you're into a feel of Sunday funday and want the comfort of home visit bro's Mans. You will leave happy and full !

Wanted to go to a local place and not a chain on our visit. Found this place and the pics looked good. Went there after our day and ordered. OMG. Absolutely the right decision to try this place. Don’t let it being in a gas station turn you off. The burgers were amazing. 2nd best burger I ever had in my life ( pre covid bison burger from Burgatory in Pittsburgh #1). Great price for the quality. This will be a must go to place whenever we are in Erie. Keep up the good work guys.

Love the new restaurant! Great food and the service was excellent. Will be going back to try new things.

Saw it on Google maps but didn't realize it was inside the Gulf station. Great place for a pop-up biz like this.

Very clean restrooms for a gas station, we were very surprised. Lots of goodies in stock. Very polite workers

We ordered the Shroom Burger & Smash Burger tonight as takeout. The Sammich was the best burger I've ever had! A slight crunch to it on the outside, tender on the inside and deliciously full of flavor. Absolutely amazing!

It's in the gas station!! But oh man best burgers we have had. I did just meat and cheese, and the spices in the meat were balanced great! Wife did the jalapeño popper burger... enjoyed every bite.

Several of us at Boneyard Barbecue wanted to make a trip out to Bro Man's Birria N' Burger Joint and give them a try! Let me tell you, they did not disappoint! If you want a delicious and massive cheesesteak, the cooper cheesesteak is the way to go. Best I’ve ever had! Extremely cheesy, and full of delicious, juicy meat. Also tried the new Bro Tato Dippers with the popper berry sauce as well. Game. Changer. Such a unique cut of fries, perfect for dipping into the berry sauce. Absolutely incredible flavor! The quesabirria tacos were super flavorful and the texture was to die for! Love that they were served with bits of lime to squeeze onto the tacos! Really intensifies the flavor. Can’t wait to try the other styles next visit! I don’t know another local place around to get smash burgers which are my favorite! The meat portion was great as it was slightly bigger than the edge of the large bun on all sides. Yum! This is not a negative by any means, but there was a little confusion regarding the menu combos when ordering.The quesabirria tacos and cooper steak were ordered and we asked for them to be combos like the menu stated. Either it wasn’t an option to make those specific things combos or we were just charged separately for fries and a drink. Perhaps you can only make the burgers into combos and we just misunderstood? But also hoped the girls at the register would have stated that when we asked for combos. Once again, not a negative, but perhaps could be made more clear on the menu. Still happy to pay for the quality food we received. We had PLENTY to take home! You can tell these are all fresh, amazing ingredients being used. The quality of the food is outstanding. It really is. That place is slammed and packed with customers consistently for a reason. Excellent. We were so pleased and cannot wait to come back! If you haven’t tried this place yet, you’re missing out!

Very friendly folks and delicious food!

Can't wait for you guys to open your own place.

The Gulf Gas station restaurant is really fast and the staff is very kind and friendly and helpful. The food is AMAZING!! IF YOU HAVE NOT TRIED IT I RECOMMEND TRYING IT!!

I came here with my girl for the first time we both loved every bite they were super friendly fast and the food was amazing we love supporting local places and we will continue to support this place 10/10 would go back!!!

Ordered an impossible burger online. It was so good 10/10 . Very big burger , It almost taste like a Big mac but way better being that it was plant based!

Best burger in town and very reasonable pricing. Skip any of the fast food and go here!

OUTSTANDING food. Their Grand Opening at 2614 Glenwood Park Avenue, Erie was hopping with folks happy to get their favorite sandwiches at a new spot. But, the people headed to the original spot were not disappointed because Jeremy at the Gulf Station was certain to make sure every person got the address of the new spot. We headed over for burgers and tacos and shared the tale. The proprietor sent us back with Jeremy's favorite burger, the Pop'r Berry. Solid folks, excellent food and kindness to share. Go there, today.

This location is shared with the Gulf station, but the food and service are awesome! And they offer a military discount!!

This is not the type of place you’d expect to find vegetarian food, but they’ve got it. We tried the vegetarian tacos and Philly cheesesteak. They were bursting with flavor and the cheesesteak reminded me of my pre-vegetarian days, eating hamburger helper for dinner. Fries were plentiful. My sister got the real meat double smash burger with bacon…. It looked phenomenal. Don’t come here if you’re hoping for healthy food, because that’s not what you’ll find.

Hands down the best burger in Erie. This place just hits different. And do not get me started on the tacos. They have the big smash with the smash sauce. Smash sauce needs to be patented. It’s like Big Mac sauce on steroids. Only thing I’m pissed at is that they are not open everyday. I warn you though, they are addictive.

I was skeptical, but damn it was good. I liked the vibe, delicious food. We will be back.

1st visit was a huge success. The smash burger is amazing and absolutely delicious. Nice to see a local vendor thriving! Keep up the good work!

Some of the best food in Erie. The barria is great. Their fries and tots are great. It's all pretty great. Except the gas station setting 😂. They do have a new restaurant location further in town though, if you're able to drive a little further.

This was one of the best burgers I've ever had anywhere. Hands down the best burger joint in Erie.

Steak hoagie was great. Birria beef was also great.

I had the sooner burger and it was messy but soooo delicious. The cheese fries were good too and I dipped them in honey mustard chipotle 🔥

They're jerk chicken tacos and jerk chicken fries are to die for! I need to try their other items but I'm so hooked on the tacos it's hard 😅

Friendly workers. Burger 9/10. Buffalo tacos 8.5/10. I will definitely be back.

Great food! Definitely worth a stop!

Don't let the gas station look fool you. The food is DELICIOUS here. Highly recommend the tacos!

We tried the new location on 26th and Glenwood Park Avenue tonight. My husband and I had the cooper steak and my daughter had the chicken. They were amazing and the atmosphere and staff were awesome. My husband is a huge Raiders fan and I can’t wait for him to come with me next time to see the inside he will love it. We will definitely be back.

Bro Man's newest restaurant is in the old George's restaurant at 26th and State Street. The food was so good the staff and owners are great people. Do yourself a favor and get their chip fries with queso cheese dip you will not regret it.

BroMan's was a great experience. The menu selections are unique & different from most burger/taco places in the area. The staff is friendly & helpful with any menu questions you may have. You get a hefty amount of food for a very reasonable price! They also offer $1 off value if you upgrade to a combo meal, which is fantastic. They also have their own tasty house sodas they offer. Highly recommend stopping to check it out!

Had the cheese steak, really good. Wouldn't hesitate to recommend others giving it a shot.

Amazing food. We’ve been eating here regularly since they opened. Everything I’ve tried is delicious. I love all of the tacos they offer and the burgers. The customer service is even better than the food. I highly recommend them if you want flavorful food.

Their buggers are the absolute best

Stopped in for the soft opening today at the newest location. So glad to have a great place to grab lunch so close to my shop.

Very limited menu due to the absence of ingredients. Friendly service. Just didn't live up to the hype. Food was edible. Nothing special. UPDATE: As per owners request. We could not receive any sandwiches that contained chicken or Cole slaw. This very much limited our choices to some other items we had to settle for. The biria torte was a bit overcooked( crispy stew meat) and a bit sloppy even without dipping. The cooper sharp cheese steak had the taste of meatloaf. My guess would be from a heavy cheese filler to meat ratio. We had high hopes for some sandwiches to take along for a picnic lunch. Unfortunately those we had set our sights on were unavailable. I fully understand that due to the events of the past week, demand for certain items might of been high or ill prepared for such volume. Hey we gave it a shot.

An awesome unique lunch experience! I most recently had the Nashville hot chicken sandwich, it was most excellent.

Wow, glad we stopped on our way out of Erie. Smashburger was really tasty, tacos were straight fire 🔥 Fries on point, perfectly seasoned. Yummo, would recommend.

Big Raiders fan, like myself!! Great food and atmosphere!

Awesome food! You won't find anything on the menu that disappoints.

Is it in a gas station? Yes. Do I care cause it's the best food in Erie? No.

A must stop when I'm in Erie! These guys are awesome!

Definitely the best food we had on our trip. My daughter even loved the chicken nuggets. The smash burgers were probably the best burger I've had and the tater tots were pretty delicious. We decided we will stop here every time we go to Splash Lagoon. Food does take awhile so plan accordingly.

food was amazing! Best gas station food I ever had lol! The Birria tacos were delicious. highly recommend it and the sooner burger was also very good! Mom Loved it as well!

Bro mans is an easy 5 star all day long. I've come to love bro mans food. I come here quiet often with my family but the quality of this food from our last visit wasn't up to par. My birria tacos were smashed into and under sized container and they looked quiet burnt. My wife's chicken sammich looked like it had been fried in tar it was so black. My daughters food however looked banging. I'm sure it was just an off day but just wanted to let ya know.

The Popper berry burger was excellent. Will be back

Middle of the road... Staff was very friendly, location sux and food is ok just very greasy . They are adding another location I'm told, with the extra room and updated equipment I will give it a shot. No negative feedback from here.

The sandwiches here are phenomenal! Walked right up the cashier recommended their most popular sandwich (torta) and it was delicious! Food came out super fast and their Bro Man’s cream soda was yummy as well! Highly recommend checking this place out!

If you want a real taste of Erie, this is the place to go. Honestly, I can't decide if the burgers or tacos are better, but they are both a 10/10. Don't forget to try the tots and fries.

Amazing food. Good people and good music. Can’t complain

Wow!! Erie has needed a place like this for a long time. The burgers we had were not just a burger, but an experience. We ordered the Big Bro burger and a Diablo type burger(can't remember the name 😔 sorry). We also had the cheese fries as well. Omg, please don't ever change what you're doing, we can't wait to return again in the future, highly recommend this place.

A solid burger you really cannot go wrong doing here

Ordered a burger. Presentation was under par. The burger patty was falling apart just picking it up. Not a healthy choice write the grease ray puddles. Seasoned fries was the highlight of the meal. If your alright with greasy messy burgers the flavor was above average. Prices I would have expected a gourmet burger. Atmosphere. Gas station. Tables next to service desk so everyone who shops can watch you eat.

Not a great vibe and too expensive for what you get.

Had the cheesesteak and it was excellent. Service was good and the prices were very reasonable. Large sandwich also. You get your monies worth.

Another great local eatery. It's made fresh to order.

Fantastic burgers and fries/tots. Heard great things about the tacos as well Lots of different menu options to suit your palate. Easily the best burger I've had in Erie and well worth the 20-ish min wait. Owner checked in on us, which was very nice. Only downside is minimal seating- it was very busy when we went and others had to wait standing

Reasonably priced, never had we visited and the cashier was very patient and helpful with our order Thank u

This is my new favorite place to eat on upper Peach Street. Everything on the menu is delicious. Last night I had the Big Smash, which is a WAY better version of a well-known sandwich at McD’s.

The very best burgers in Erie, hands down.

As good as it gets. I love the tacos, burgers and fries. If you have any apprehension about the location, there was a 30 min wait for burgers inside a gas station because of the line up (I would have waited an hour for this food, it's that good). Don't change a thing, you guys are doing it right!

If I could give Bro Man's 10 stars, I would. From the first bite to the last, the food was absolutely phenomenal. Like close your eyes in ecstasy phenomenal. Recommendations from the staff were good, we went with some birria tacos, the big smash, a kid's burger meal and finally the blast off. Also grabbed some queso fries. The big smash was so good, but the winner for sure was the blast off. O.M.G. I wanted to hug every person working, the food was so good. Too bad we live 3 hours away, we would be regulars. 🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤

Food is always delicious and it's my official weekly dinner place

Was worth every cent! Delicious

You had one of the biggest best chicken sandwiches in all of Pennsylvania now its a small lifeless patty with less bredding and taste why the change???😥

Fantastic sandwich! Dont let the gas station fool you, you will not be disappointed!

The character of a business is in the heart of its employees. I walked in at 11 on the dot. The employees all treated me with a smile and pleasant conversation and walked me through some of the most popular and favorite items. The cashier was awesome. Sweet smile and happy to work where she works. Ordered tacos, burgers, and grabbed a couple homemade sodas, all of which are absolutely divine. The flavors are soooooo fresh and clean and authentic. You cannot find any other experience like this probably anywhere. You truly are a diamond in the rough. 50/5 stars and thank you for you kindness and grace. If you haven’t try Bro Mans…well Bro Man, you better get to it. Fire. Fast and Fresh. Great Prices and super good vibes. God Bless all of you and your journey to becoming Erie’s best restaurant. And please don’t worry about where you are located ever. We all start somewhere. We all have a story. Yours will truly shine above the rest. God bless and thank you for your time, patience, and outstanding food

Absolutely some of the best burgers you'll ever have!! Life is entirely too short for people to NOT try here !

Had the Birria tacos today and man were they good. Have to check out the torta next time.

Just had the Reggie burger special for Erie Restaurant week. So good I think we'll have it again tomorrow!!

It's definitely one of the best places for something a little different. Unbelievable flavor, and the service is always spot on.

Love Sicilian Square pizza with cup n char pepperoni. Can't wait til they open up new location.

Vegetarian and vegan offerings weren't. The plant based items are cooked where meat is. Hard shell taco shells cooked in meat fat.

As they say, fast food isn't fast!

The best food in town made by great people... In a run down, out of the way gas station. They desperately need their own location. And an awkward "social club" with a door you need to be buzzed into isn't it... You make seriously great food. Get serious about the location.... Even a nice food truck would be tremendous for you. My one complaint is that the spit fire is gone from your menu. I've not ordered twice now because it's my favorite thing and its just gone. Not even an item with crazy ingredients, I don't understand why it left. Please bring it back. But regardless, I can't stay away for long. I'll be back and it will be glorious. Response to the reply: The website order form begs to differ on the spitfire burger...

Fantastic sammich, but gas station atmosphere. Excellent value.

Best affordable food in Erie the perfect place to relax and enjoy some amazing food

Best sandwiches in Erie, hands down. Such variety and flavors.

Amazing food best place on peach street.

Always great! Brother was visiting from New Orleans, definitely a hit with him.

I got a fantastic cheesesteak in an Erie gas station, you should too!

Got take out today and it was delicious! I can't wait to try everything! Great burger and great chicken sandwich. Looking forward to trying pizza and tacos. So impressed. Fresh and unique! Love it!

Got the pastrami and kicking mac and cheese. Both very good. My only suggestion is to grill the bread on the pastrami

This place was recommended to me and boy was it good! My cheese steak was absolutely out of this world! Definitely recommend!

Best food I have had in Erie for a very reasonable price. The staff is friendly and helpful.

Best burger ever!!! Will be back 😀

Pleasantly surprised by how unique and delicious the food was here....I'm hooked! Amazingly diverse menu options really sets this place apart